Otherkin vs Gender Identity
I know that itâs probably been said a thousand times before, but the new plant/animal/object pronouns are very problematic and hurtful to the trans community.
Before I begin, Iâd like to state that even though I greatly dislike the new pronoun system, if a person told me that they wanted to be called by a certain pronoun, Iâd call them by it. I donât want people to feel bad about their pronoun choices, but at the same time I hope you realize the damage that is being done. Additionally, I believe that being otherkin is valid, however it has NOTHING TO DO WITH GENDER.*****
Life is hard enough as-is for non-binary people. People STILL donât consider nb to be a valid identity. How does this affect me? My boyfriend (he prefers I call him my boyfriend) is genderfluid, and every time I explain that to someone they bitch and whine about it, while at the same time I can tell the same person Iâm a transman and theyâre 100% okay with it because they see it as valid.
The problem with the new pronouns is based off expectations. When I say Iâm male, people expect I have a certain anatomical makeup. Because I donât yet, I have been verbally abused, discriminated against, and generally harassed. Trans women have the same exact problems, and sometimes itâs even worse because of transmisogany and sexism.
When you use plants, animals, or objects for your pronouns, nobody is going to give you a hard time for looking a certain way. Nobody is going to tell you that you canât use a certain bathroom. Nobody is going to beat you up.
And before you say Iâm an idiot because saying that the new pronoun system is nb erasure, let me explain a thing about being non-binary. As ironic as it seems, in order for nb to exist, there must first be a binary to base it off of. Those binaries are male and female. When a person says that they identify as agender, that means they donât identify as male or female. When a person says that they identify as genderfluid, that means that they identify as male sometimes, and female sometimes. See the pattern? Saying you identify as a plant/animal/object has nothing to do with gender at all. If people identified as animals, then there wouldnât even be an issue. But saying that identity is the same as a gender identity is wrong, because gender is a social construct based on sexual attributes, and your actual being is different then your gender.
Alternately, animals are gendered too.
And before I get some sort of message saying âyou hate furries!â or âyou just donât understandâ! Let me explain a few things.
One: I donât hate furries. I occasionally draw furry porn on e621. I started there because it seemed like a safe outlet where I could express my sexuality and physical appearance safely and comfortably. I also know that not everyone who identifies as a furry draws nsfw things, and that not everyone who draws anthro art is a furry.
Two: I understand that some of this has NOTHING to do with furries, however it appears that the person who started this is a furry.
Three: I completely understand not wanting to be human. I get that. When I was little, I used to wish I wasnât ALL the time. I understand someone saying âbut on the inside Iâm a wolfâ. Okay. Thatâs fine. Just donât make it about gender. Because saying you wish you were an animal has nothing to do with gender. At all.
The new pronouns would be less of a big deal if it wasnât for cis people. I literally wouldnât give a crap at all if you wanted to be called an animal/plant/object as your pronoun, but because itâs hard enough to be taken seriously when I say something as simple as âI identify as maleâ, thereâs no way in HELL cis people are gonna take the new system seriously. Hell, they canât even wrap their minds around BINARY trans people! They often donât even think being non-binary is valid. There are TRANS people who donât think being non-binary is valid! Trying to make new pronouns that actually have NOTHING to do with gender at all makes it even EASIER for cis people to say shit like âYou donât identify as male or female? Whatâs next, youâre gonna tell me youâre a plant or something like those other freaks?â and treat us like shit because they have more leverage now.
Then people started using the new pronouns because they though they were âcuteâ
A pronoun is not an accessory. Itâs not a fashion statement. It is something I have fought for, and something I could easily be killed for. Nobody is gonna kill you because you think youâre a rabbit. Who cares? Itâs not like that affects what bathroom or changing room you use, or how people are gonna treat you when you enter it. It changes nothing and makes the rest of us seem like idiots for trying so hard. Gender is NOT something thatâs taken lightly in our society, unfortunately.
****In writing this, my goal was NOT to say something like âeveryone who uses the new pronouns are scumâ or âI want then to dieâ because that is so far from my goal I could ship it a package and it wouldnât arrive until a year later. What I wanted to outline is WHY these new pronouns are problematic and how they cause issues that could easily be avoided if they didnât exist. I wanted to do it in a way that is (hopefully) readable and not aimed at telling people theyâre wrong. I just want to educated people about why trans people feel the way they do about all this, and why itâs damaging. Please, at least consider what youâre doing when you start using these.