Thoughts about the Paper Kingdom leak;
I have to admit that I fully understand why this didn’t see the light of day. You can feel that the well of creativity for the band had run dry at this point in their career. The strain after a decade of touring and work is fully evident.
At 15, yes, FIFTEEN TRACKS over an hour long it feels laborious to get through.
The guitar work, lyrics, and song compositions for some songs feel uninspired and something I never thought I’d say about MCR…just boring and predictable. They are emulating the sounds of other better songs by classic bands a lot here, more so than they did on The Black Parade. There is a song on this that is just a worse version of Tonight Tonight by Smashing Pumpkins and of course Gerard emulates Bowie in a few tracks. You can feel how this is a precursor to Hesitant Alien.
That isn’t to say all of them have been bad! Fake Your Death, Witch, Bike Thief, Paper Swords, Dive and High Hopes are decent. But obviously need work (Fake Your Death getting a better studio recording and actually being released is not surprising considering the rest)
None of these songs have been as memorable as anything on any of the rest of their officially released work, some of which is not even half as long as this album. It’s cool to get to listen to their behind the scenes process here but it falls victim to the same things stuff like Be Here Now by Oasis did; songs are too long, the choruses aren’t entirely memorable, and the album itself is overly long with not enough tonal shifts to have a diverse enough palette of songs to feel like unique tracks. They even have a fucking horn section in one of these that sounds like Be Here Now lmaoooo.
Love MCR and cannot wait for MCR5, but I can’t say I’ll be revisiting much of any of TPK any time soon. I understand why a majority of this stayed as demos and it doesn’t feel like a very cohesive concept at all. As a fan having listened to the fellas for over two decades now and having been witness to every iteration of the band I feel I can safely say that and not feel bad. The kid in me is excited to have finally heard this, the adult that I now am understands that even our faves are human and also swing and miss sometimes.
Also anyone that is genuinely upset at people listening to this need to touch some grass. The band will be fine, they’re still selling out shows and having fun. Relax and stop being so parasocial about grown men that don’t even know you.
















