Connor saw her before she saw him.
That was usually how it went.
He could pretend he didn’t look for Kassandra when he walked into a room, but the lie had started to feel insulting even to himself. It was automatic now, some traitorous little part of him scanning every crowd for her face, her shoulders, the particular way she carried herself like she did not need the room to notice her in order to know exactly who she was. She moved differently than most people. Not loud. Not desperate. Not performing for attention. She just existed with this grounded, dangerous sort of grace, and Connor, who was used to being the loudest warmth in any given space, had no idea what to do with someone who could quiet him by simply being nearby.
So, naturally, he had been staring.
More in a deeply embarrassing, very obvious, someone please send help before my entire personality leaves my body sort of way.
“You planning on talking to her,” Mason asked from beside him, voice dry as dust, “or are we all just gonna watch you admire her from the wildlife preserve?” Connor’s shoulders stiffened. “I’m not admiring.” Theo glanced over the rim of his drink. “Your pulse changed.” Connor turned slowly. “I know you think saying stuff like that makes you sound mysterious, but mostly it makes me want to throw a breadstick at you.” Theo only smiled faintly. “You also stopped blinking for eight seconds.” “That’s normal,” Connor said too quickly. “It is absolutely not normal,” Jake said, leaning in with a grin so bright it was practically illegal. “Big Man’s malfunctioning.” “I am not malfunctioning.” Christian, who had been minding his own business until he apparently decided peace was overrated, gave Connor a once-over and said, “Your ears are red.” Connor immediately reached up like he could physically hide them. “It’s hot in here.” “It’s February,” Theo said. “Inside, man. Inside heat exists.”
Rowan, who had been quiet until then, took a slow sip from his drink and looked across the room with the lazy precision of a man who had read the defense before the snap and already knew exactly where the ball was going.
“No,” he said. “That’s not heat. That’s fear.” Connor turned on him. “Quarterback privilege does not extend to emotional commentary.” Rowan’s mouth twitched. “It does when my fullback starts looking like he forgot his own playbook because a woman walked in.” Mason snorted.
“So does courage.” Connor shot him a wounded look. “I have courage. I run into linebackers for a living.” “Yeah,” Jake said, “but apparently one rugby player in a red dress has you looking like you need a permission slip.”
Rowan leaned slightly forward, eyes still on Kassandra. “To be fair, she looks like she could make a linebacker apologize.” Connor opened his mouth to respond, something sharp and clever ready on instinct, but then the crowd shifted.
Red satin.
Loose hair.
Strong legs.
That smile.
Connor’s entire brain went quiet for one fatal second.
The guys saw it happen in real time. Of course they did. Because his life was cruel and full of witnesses.
“Oh, he’s gone,” Jake said with immediate delight. “Not gone,” Mason corrected. “Reduced.” Theo nodded solemnly. “Emotionally composted.” Rowan studied Connor for a beat, then said, “I’ve seen cleaner collapses under blitz pressure.” Connor blinked. “Can everyone please stop narrating my death?”
Then Kassandra’s voice cut through the music.
Not subtly. Not smoothly. Not in any way that could be mistaken for dignified.
He froze like someone had pulled his plug.
There was no other word for it. The sound that came out of them was immediate and viciously joyful, a chorus of laughter, whistles, slapped shoulders, and someone, probably Jake, saying, “Pretty boy! Oh, we are never letting that go.” Rowan’s grin appeared slowly, sharp at the edges. “Pretty boy,” he repeated, as if testing the nickname for future tactical use. “That’s going on the call sheet.” Connor turned toward her, already feeling heat crawl up his neck.
Truly the kind of verbal performance that made men legends.
Rowan lifted his glass slightly. “Electric opening. Really controlled the pocket there.” Connor shot him a look that begged for silence and threatened violence at the same time.
Kassandra slid into the space beside him like she had always belonged there, her hand settling lightly on his arm. Connor looked down at that hand before he could stop himself, and every single thought in his head tripped over itself, fell down a flight of stairs, and landed in a heap.
Her fingers were on his arm.
Her fingers were on his arm and she was smiling up at him and calling him pretty boy in front of his entire team, and Connor had the sudden, terrible realization that he would rather take a helmet to the ribs than survive the next thirty seconds with grace.
“Were you hiding from me,” she asked, warm and teasing, “or just waiting for me to find you?”
Connor inhaled. Then forgot what breathing was for.
“I was, uh.” He cleared his throat, forcing one hand into his pocket like that might make him look casual instead of doomed. “I wasn’t hiding. I don’t hide. I mean, I can hide. Physically. If the situation calls for it. I’m big, but I’m surprisingly stealthy for a man who has been compared to structural damage.”
Behind him, Mason muttered, “Lord help him.”
Rowan nodded solemnly. “Strong start. Terrible middle. Unsure about the finish.”
Connor closed his eyes for half a second.
Pull it together, Graves.
When he opened them again, Kassandra was still watching him with that sparkling look in her eyes, and somehow that made it worse. Better. Worse-better. A horrible, beautiful ambush.
He gave her a crooked smile, trying to recover some fraction of the charm people insisted he possessed.
“What I meant,” he said, voice smoothing just a little, “is that I was waiting for you to find me because clearly you enjoy the thrill of the chase.”
“Ooh,” Jake said, far too loudly. “There he is.”
Rowan tipped his chin in mild approval. “Better. Little shaky on delivery, but he found the route.”
Connor pointed backward without looking away from Kassandra. “Ignore him. He thinks because he throws a ball for a living, he gets to narrate everyone else’s choices.”
Rowan’s brows lifted. “I throw very important balls.”
Christian coughed into his drink.
Connor turned his head sharply. “Nope. Not today. We are not doing phrasing today.”
Kassandra mentioned his game, and Connor’s smile warmed instantly, his embarrassment softening beneath something earnest. Praise from her hit differently. The crowd could roar, commentators could talk, coaches could slap him on the helmet, but Kassandra noticing him? Kassandra watching his play closely enough to catch a borrowed move?
That landed somewhere deep.
“Good game, pretty boy,” she said.
Connor’s grin twitched wider despite himself. “You keep calling me that and I’m gonna start answering to it in public.”
“You already did!” Jake called.
Rowan nodded. “Twice, actually. Once verbally, once spiritually.”
Connor turned his head slightly, expression warning. “I swear on every protein shake in that locker room, I will put you through a refreshment table.”
Rowan looked at the nearby table, then back at him. “You’d miss. Hands are shaking.”
Kassandra’s hand gave his arm a gentle squeeze, and Connor’s threat died immediately.
Beautiful woman. Hand on arm. Focus.
“You used my signature move,” she said, playful accusation glowing in her voice. “I saw it. Don’t even try to deny it.”
Connor’s brows lifted, and for one precious second, he managed something close to suave. He leaned back just enough to look down at her with mock offense, one hand pressing to his chest like she had wounded him personally.
“Stole?” he asked. “Kassandra, I am shocked. Hurt, even. Maybe a little betrayed.”
“You did steal it,” Christian said.
Connor snapped his fingers toward him. “You don’t have proof.”
“There’s film,” Theo said.
“It’s literally footage,” Mason said.
Rowan hummed, enjoying himself too much. “I remember the play. He came back to the huddle trying to look casual.”
Connor’s eyes widened. “Do not.”
Rowan continued, merciless. “Then he said, ‘You think Kassandra saw that?’”
The entire group made a noise.
Connor stared at him like he had just been stabbed by his own commander on the battlefield.
Rowan spread one hand. “Accuracy matters.”
Connor’s face went volcanic. “I said that because she understands the technique.”
“Sure,” Rowan said. “That was definitely the tone.”
Kassandra looked far too pleased with all of this, and Connor, despite the humiliation crawling red-hot up his throat, felt something dangerously fond bloom in his chest. Because she fit there, somehow. Not in the soft, polished way people sometimes tried to fit around athletes and their noise, but easily. She did not shrink from the teasing. She did not seem startled by the chaos. She stood in the middle of their noise with her hand on his arm and that amused little smile on her face like she had decided she could survive them.
Worse, the team had noticed too.
The way Mason’s teasing had warmed into approval. The way Jake was grinning like he had already started designing wedding hashtags in his head. The way Christian watched Kassandra with the assessing calm of someone deciding she had enough spine to run with their particular pack of emotionally damaged, overgrown golden retrievers. The way Theo, cryptic menace that he was, had gone quiet in that way that usually meant he had seen enough to know something before Connor did.
And Rowan, damn him, looked almost satisfied.
Not loud about it. Not soft in any obvious way. Just standing there with that captain’s stillness, watching Kassandra hold her own among them, watching Connor turn into a blush-red mess beside her, and apparently deciding something had clicked into place.
Jake lifted his glass toward her. “For the record, Kassandra, you’re welcome here anytime.” “Anytime,” Mason agreed. “You make him quiet. That’s a public service.” “I am not quiet,” Connor protested. “You said hi and then forgot nouns,” Christian said. Theo studied Kassandra with thoughtful approval. “Also, his blood pressure is doing something fascinating.” Connor groaned. “Please stop giving her medical updates.” Rowan lifted his drink slightly toward Kassandra. “You walked into this chaos and didn’t flinch. That counts for something around here.” Connor glanced over, suspicious. “Was that sincere?” Rowan looked at him. “Don’t make it weird.” “I didn’t make it weird. You were nice. That’s suspicious.” “I can be nice.” Mason made a doubtful noise. Jake shook his head. “Debatable.”
Rowan ignored them and looked back at Kassandra, his expression dry but not unkind. “What I’m saying is, if you ever need backup, bad advice, or someone to drag Connor out of his own head by the ankles, congratulations. You’ve got all of us now.”
Connor’s heart did something stupid.
Kassandra’s grin widened, and the team, rather than backing off, seemed to brighten around her presence like someone had officially opened a window in the room. It was not mean. Not really. There was too much warmth in it for that. Too much immediate acceptance. They were teasing Connor because they loved him, and because Kassandra had apparently walked in and found the one lever capable of turning their resident battering ram into a stammering disaster.
Jake leaned slightly toward Kassandra, not even trying to hide his grin. “You know, he’s been trying to talk to you for weeks.”
Connor’s soul left his body.
“Months,” Theo corrected.
Connor turned on him. “Et tu, weird oracle?”
Mason nodded. “He had openers.”
“You had several,” Christian said. “One involved complimenting her footwork.”
Connor’s face went hotter. “Because her footwork is good!”
Rowan took another sip. “He said it with reverence.”
Connor pointed at him. “You are supposed to be my quarterback.”
“I am,” Rowan said. “That’s why I’m reading the field.”
“You’re sweating like it is.”
“Another involved asking about recovery routines,” Mason added.
“That is a normal athlete question.”
“Another,” Jake said, barely holding himself together, “was, and I quote, ‘Do you think she likes coffee, or is that too forward?’”
The betrayal was biblical.
Rowan’s mouth curved. “My favorite was when he asked if saying ‘good match’ sounded too basic.”
Connor dragged a hand down his face. “I hate all of you.”
“No, you don’t,” Rowan said.
Connor looked at Kassandra, then back at Rowan. “I am considering starting.”
Kassandra’s hand was still on his arm, and Connor could feel every ounce of himself becoming more and more ridiculous under her gaze.
“I was workshopping,” he said, dignity limping behind him with a flat tire.
Then Kassandra leaned closer, her voice dipping into something softer, more dangerous.
“Or,” she said, “you could thank me properly.”
The room seemed to take one collective inhale.
His eyes flicked to hers, then to her mouth for half a second, then back up so quickly it might as well have come with a guilty sound effect. His smile faltered, not disappearing, just changing. Less performance. Less defense. More honest. More stunned that she was standing there, that she was teasing him, that maybe, somehow, she had crossed the room for him.
The word came out lower than before.
Behind him, Jake whispered, “Be cool.”
Connor did not look away from Kassandra. “I was cool before you said that.”
“No, you weren’t,” Mason said.
Rowan added, “You were nearby.”
Connor lifted one finger. “I was cool adjacent.”
Kassandra’s eyes glittered.
Connor swallowed, then gave her the best grin he could manage, crooked and warm and still a little wrecked at the edges.
“Okay,” he said, nodding once as if accepting an extremely serious athletic challenge. “Proper thank you. I can do that. I’m very good at gratitude. Huge fan of appreciation. Big believer in credit where credit is due.”
“Absolutely stalling,” Christian agreed.
Rowan clicked his tongue softly. “Clock’s running, Graves.”
Connor ignored them again, though the blush creeping up his neck made the effort less convincing.
He shifted a little closer to Kassandra, careful not to crowd her, but close enough that the teasing from the others blurred into the background. His hand came up, hesitated for one nervous second, then settled gently over hers where it rested on his arm.
But he did not pull away.
“Thank you,” Connor said, and despite the heat in his face, despite the team hovering like a council of badly behaved cupids, his voice turned sincere. “For the move. For noticing. For coming over here and making me look like I’ve never spoken to a woman before.”
“You haven’t,” Jake said.
Connor’s jaw tightened. “I’m choosing peace.”
Rowan nodded once. “Growth.”
Then Connor looked back at Kassandra, and the softness returned.
“And for the record,” he continued, “I did give you credit. Maybe not out loud, because I was busy trying not to get folded in half, but in here?” He tapped his temple, then immediately winced. “Wow. No. That looked less smooth than it felt.”
Kassandra laughed, and Connor’s whole face brightened.
That was worse than the dress, somehow. The laugh. Because he had made her do that. Because it did something to him, something stupid and hopeful and bright.
He tried again, a little quieter.
“I saw you use it first,” he admitted. “And I remembered because you move like you already know exactly where the hit is going before it happens. It’s not just power with you. It’s timing. Leverage. Nerve.” His thumb brushed once, barely there, over the side of her hand. “So yeah, I borrowed it. Maybe because it worked. Maybe because I wanted to carry a little bit of you onto my field.”
The team quieted just enough for the shift to be noticeable.
Connor realized what he had said a second too late.
“I mean, not in a weird way,” he rushed out. “Not like a shrine thing. I don’t have candles. Or photos. Or, God, please don’t let that be the sentence you remember.”
The laughter came back, but softer this time.
Jake pressed a hand over his heart. “He’s growing.”
Mason nodded. “Painful, but beautiful.”
Christian lifted his glass. “To Connor’s first complete thought.”
Rowan’s voice came in, low and dry. “Mark the date. We’ll put it in the team newsletter.”
“Okay, all of you are being traded to Cleveland,” Connor said.
Rowan didn’t miss a beat. “You can’t trade me. I throw the very important balls.”
Connor closed his eyes. “I regret teaching you sarcasm.”
“You didn’t,” Rowan said. “I came like this.”
Then, because Kassandra was still there, still smiling, still touching him like she had no intention of running from the disaster zone that was his dignity, Connor let himself be brave.
“So,” he said, voice lowering again, warm and nervous and trying very hard to be smooth, “if proper thanks are on the table, pretty girl, I’d like to start with buying you a drink.”
“And then maybe you can tell me exactly how much credit I owe you.”
Another beat, softer this time.
“And after that,” he added, cheeks still flushed but eyes steady on hers, “maybe I can finally stop pretending I haven’t been trying to work up the nerve to talk to you since the first time I saw you play.”
The team made a collective sound behind him.
Something more like delighted approval.
Jake leaned toward Kassandra, stage-whispering, “We like you, by the way. Officially. Unanimous vote.”
“You don’t get a say,” Connor muttered.
“Oh, we absolutely get a say,” Mason replied. “You’re emotionally unsupervised.”
Theo gave Kassandra a small nod. “Welcome to the fold.”
Christian’s mouth curved. “Good luck with him.”
Rowan raised his glass one more time, eyes flicking between Kassandra and Connor with that sharp, quiet captain’s approval he rarely bothered to soften.
“He’s an idiot,” Rowan said. “But he’s ours. And he’s good where it counts.”
Connor looked at him, caught somewhere between touched and horrified.
Rowan looked unmoved. “Don’t get needy.”
Jake laughed. “Too late.”
Connor looked at Kassandra, helplessly embarrassed, painfully fond, and somehow still trying to stand tall through it. “They’re terrible,” he said.
He glanced briefly over his shoulder at the men still grinning behind him before looking back down at her.
“And, uh…” His voice caught for half a second, the stammer slipping in despite his best effort. “You don’t have to be, obviously. No pressure. That sounded intense. I just mean…” He huffed a laugh, rubbing at the back of his neck with his free hand. “You’re welcome here. With us. With me.”
The last two words came quieter.
His cheeks went red all over again, but this time he didn’t retreat behind a joke fast enough to hide it.
Rowan, thankfully, did not make fun of that part.
He only shifted beside the others, giving Connor the room to stand in the truth he had finally managed to say.
“So,” Connor said, squeezing her hand gently beneath his, “what’s it gonna be, Kass? Drink first, lecture about proper credit second, or do I have to earn forgiveness for athletic theft some other way?”
Behind him, Rowan added mildly, “Choose carefully. He’ll overthink whatever answer you give him for six to eight business days.”
Connor sighed without looking away from Kassandra.
“Quarterbacks,” he muttered, “are a plague.”