Not my typical kind of reblog, but I feel this probably deserves something more in-depth than a comment. I hope it's helpful! There is a LOT, sorry in advance...
A good place to start would be blinkie collection websites! There are many NeoCities websites dedicated to collecting blinkies they've found, and typically just going to the NeoCities' home page and searching for websites tagged with blinkies will show you many options!
If you'd like to broaden your horizons, I believe some SpaceHey users also have blinkie collections, but I'm not as familiar with that website...at the very least, if you can't find what you're looking for, looking up "blinkie collections" in your search engine of choice is amateur, but it's probably how most people got their start.
In terms of specific websites, the most extensive collection I've seen is Adrian's Blinkie Collection; they're all sorted by color, but unless you're going in with a color in mind, it might be a little difficult to find something specific. But it's definitely fun to look through, I feel like I see a new one every time I look!
There are also three websites that I know of that act as blinkie search engines or repositories; blinkie.world by (which is still in progress, but typically updates on a weekly basis, and has different pages to sort blinkies by color, theme, subject, etc.), blinkie.wiki (which takes a little bit to load, unless they've patched that, but had options to search by subject and transcript), and GifCities (which lets you search very broad, general keywords, but it's not exclusively for blinkies).
Now, while this isn't necessarily what you asked for, there are also blinkie making websites where you can put text onto a template to make your own blinkies! My favorites are blinkie.cafe, gerudovalley.net, PixelWave Studio, and MyBlinkie!
Finally, here are a bunch of creators I've found while hoarding blinkies myself! Some websites linked have sections for blinkies they've collected, so that might be a good place to start too! I hope this helps!
Arkm's World | The Blinkie Hoard | Andrew's Blinkie Swap | aprillily | Bacon Spider | Becca Blinkies | @berrybi-archived | @biohazardousgeodez | @blinkees (creator of gerudovalley.net) | Blinkie Autism | @blinkieopolis | blinkie-net | Blinkie Madness | Blinkie Obsession | @bluelagoonz | @bside-mispress | Buflod | CaitSith | Cathie's Crazie Creations (AFAIK, the creator of the blinkie you posted in the original post, so you might like some of their other stuff!) | @cheriisoda | CombatBaby | @corbingraphics | CubeRoot's Web Graphics | CyberDaydream | ekate23 | Michael Murder | @fanclubgraphics | Feary Glitter | gayvillain | @gifdog | Glamour Goblin | @glittergroovy | Grossion5z | @graphic--horde | GREAZYGUTS | @radiotrophicfungi / @hyprmobile (same person, different accounts) | Ice Shadow Dolls | Ix-C-999 / @blinkie-rat | Jack Dawlia | Jan Suta (this links to their creations, but the whole page is a collection!) | Kimber | @k1yosh1k1tsun3 | konnamono | Kotatsu | @kuiperror | Lockheart Love | @lonely-coconut / it's website (creator of blinkie.world) | Lupinus | m00nsrequest | moonpixels | @neeetr | OMFG | @pawpr1nc3 | @pearlieprincess | Rachel Pinku | Pinky Blinkies | @pixelsgarage | plasticdino | @pretties-by-io | @qiekz | Roobit | @roomwithavoid | SaltyTangerine | @scungledfiles | Shishka | Silly Blinkies | Splitathon | svnhrtz | @sweetsatellite-tv | To Love An Angel | @twinkfrottage | @velvetcompendium | vesselvindicate / their collection / their own list of blinkie pages | Vinny Vistazo | WebMewMew | WickedMimiArtz | Wynn's Wonderful Pixel Paradise
(If any Tumblr account mentioned wants their name removed, I understand, and I apologize for the tag! And if any other blinkie creators not mentioned want to advertise their own page, feel free!)
andulkaphoto
kianamaiart
ellievsbear
blakekathryn
