Mangiato Vivo

She kind of looks like a cookie... I wish I had a cookie right now...

No idea what this girl is doing in the Dark Forest. Honestly, if any of Mapleshade's enemies would be to go there, it should have been Oakstar. He exiled helpless kits from his clan, which would be a direct breaking of the warrior code. Protecting all the kittens is an important part of it, after all. Some people argue that Frecklewish broke it as well, since she saw Mapleshade's kits falling into the river and didn't help... But... Realistically, what was she supposed to do? RiverClan warriors were the most likely to actually successfully rescue the kits, and they were already there! Frecklewish wouldn't be able to help at all, and if she tried, she probably would just end up having to be rescued as well.

I seriously can't think of any good reason why she would be sent to hell... Maybe StarClan just needed to blame someone, and Frecklewish had the weakest alibi? Or maybe she, out of guilt, deemed herself to the Dark Forest on her own? Or maybe she was tricked by Mapleshade somehow? Seriously, no idea. It's weird.