Ayla

“Wait…” he squints at the screen, then looks at you with wide eyes. “You… were a fan?”

You freeze like a deer in headlights, trying to laugh it off. “Uh… maybe?”

Heeseung grins, the corners of his mouth twitching into that teasing smile.

“Ohhh, this explains why you knew I hated cucumbers before I even told you.” He nudges you with his shoulder. “So, what was I? Your bias?”

When you nod shyly, he absolutely melts, leaning back and running a hand through his hair.

“This is crazy. My own girlfriend was my fan? That’s… kind of the sweetest thing ever.” He pulls you into his arms, still laughing. “Guess I’m lucky you upgraded from fan to girlfriend.”

➽──────────────❥

★ Jay

You two were cleaning the apartment together when Jay found a box tucked away under your bed. Curiosity got the better of him, and when he opened it, he saw old Enhypen albums, photocards, and banners from concerts.

He raised an eyebrow, holding one of his own photocards between his fingers.

“Babe… is this… me?”

You instantly panic. “Okay, in my defense—”

But he just smirks, biting back a laugh. “So you were a fan. All this time, and you didn’t tell me?”

You groan, covering your face. “I didn’t want you to think I was weird.”

Jay chuckles, setting the photocard down and walking over to wrap his arms around your waist.

“Weird? I think it’s adorable. You supported me before you even knew me personally. That means a lot, you know?”

He kisses your forehead before whispering with a teasing grin, “So… how many photocards of me do you have? Be honest.”

➽──────────────❥

★ Jake

It came out during a random conversation with one of your friends. She casually mentioned how you used to attend Enhypen’s fansigns “back in the day,” and Jake’s head whipped around so fast you thought he’d get whiplash.

“You… what?”

You try to explain, but Jake is already grinning ear to ear.

“Wait, wait, wait — my girlfriend stood in line just to meet me before we were even dating? This is gold.”

For the rest of the night, he’s relentless with playful teasing.

“So technically… I’ve known you longer than I thought. I just didn’t realize you were that pretty fan I smiled at during the fansign.”

Later, when you’re cuddled up watching TV, he suddenly turns serious for a moment.

“It’s actually kind of amazing… you were cheering me on even before you knew me personally. Makes me feel really lucky.”

➽──────────────❥

★ Sunghoon

You were showing Sunghoon your camera roll when he noticed an old picture of you at one of his concerts, holding a lightstick and wearing merch.

“…Is that… my tour shirt?” He blinks, then smirks.

You try to quickly scroll past, but he grabs your phone, looking at the picture closely.

“You were a fan?!” His eyes widen before narrowing playfully. “So all this time… you’ve been hiding it from me.”

You mumble something about not wanting to be embarrassed, but Sunghoon just shakes his head with a small smile.

“Embarrassed? Babe, that’s actually really sweet.”

Of course, he can’t resist teasing you a little.

“Guess I must’ve made a pretty strong impression if you went from cheering for me in the crowd to dating me now.”

➽──────────────❥

★ Sunoo

Sunoo found out completely by accident when you were cleaning your closet together. He spotted an old Enhypen fan slogan with his name on it and gasped so loudly you jumped.

“YOU WERE A FAN?!”

You cover your face in embarrassment, but Sunoo just bursts into giggles, clutching the banner to his chest.

“This is the cutest thing ever. My girlfriend was waving this for me?!”

For the rest of the day, he keeps pretending to “thank his #1 fan” in exaggerated ways — offering to sign your forehead, posing for “selfies with a fan,” and even asking if you want his autograph.

But later, when the teasing calms down, he looks at you with that soft, genuine smile.

“I’m really glad you were there supporting me back then… and I’m even more glad you’re here now.”

➽──────────────❥

★ Jungwon

It slipped out when you were talking about how long you’ve been listening to their music. You mentioned the exact date of Enhypen’s debut without hesitation, and Jungwon’s eyes narrowed suspiciously.

“…How do you know that so well?”

You try to play it off, but he just stares at you until you finally admit it.

“Okay fine! I was a fan before we dated.”

Jungwon’s expression shifts into the cutest smile. “Really? That’s… actually so nice to hear.”

He sits beside you, looking thoughtful. “It’s a little weird, though. Like… the person who used to cheer for me from far away is now the person I come home to.”

It’s a rare, sentimental Jungwon moment — but then he smirks.

“Guess I must’ve been your favorite, huh?”

➽──────────────❥

★ Ni-ki

You and Ni-ki were watching an old Enhypen performance on YouTube when he caught you singing along — with perfect fan chant timing.

He pauses the video. “…Wait. How do you know the fan chants that well?”

You hesitate, but his eyebrows are already rising. “Don’t tell me…”

When you confess you used to be a fan, Ni-ki’s jaw drops before he bursts out laughing.

“My girlfriend was a fangirl? This is hilarious!”

For the next week, he calls you “fan-chan” just to annoy you, but secretly, he’s touched.