If the current circumstances weren't based on the incredibly painful experience of losing the love of her life, then Rory might've felt her ego grow at the understanding that she could still make Emily Clarke stutter. And that would be before all of the eye contact they apparently couldn't stop partaking in, which only made Rory finally avert her eyes down the court to where she had just been standing minutes ago and had no idea Emily was within yards of her. "Okay, good." She could only nod at the next part, not that it really mattered who Emily was there with or why she was. She was there to play tennis and clearly ruin Rory's Sunday and maybe her entire summer. "I'm sure he's happy you're back."
"You wouldn't have a reason to know, would you?" She began with a shrug. Emily was the one who ultimately moved away, after all. "Just for fun," The brunette said slowly, thankful that there was something familiar they could talk about. "I took over as the girls' team head coach at school a few years ago, so I always have to know what I'm talking about. I give lessons in the summer. Thankfully that gossipy bunch of 12-year-old girls this morning didn't have to witness this conversation." It was said with an attempt of a smile and then it was gone again so she could catch her breath. It felt like she had to keep talking, anything to evade the awkward looks and confusing silence that she was sure would take over if neither of them spoke. She'd never had that with the taller woman, and she sure wasn't ready for it now. Pressing her lips together, she scanned her mind for anything to say. "So New York, huh?" With a tilt of her head, she continued. Small talk was safe, even if she wanted nothing more than to walk away. Her legs felt like they were stuck in their spot right by the serving line, even if her brain clearly wasn't. "Fits you, I suppose." A moment of realization, widening eyes, and she couldn't help the self-deprecating chuckle that left her lips. "Let's pretend I didn't just say that and I don't know where you've been these past few years because I looked at your Instagram a few times?" A few times was an understatement.
Happy you're back. Emily raised her eyebrows, offering a simple nod. Dean had been happy she'd come back, but Emily's mind instantly went elsewhere. Was Rory happy she was back? She already knew the answer was no - and she couldn't blame her - but a small, infinitesimal part of her wished that she was. Not that that would've made any logical sense - why on Earth would Rory ever be happy to see her after their relationship ended the way it did? After it felt like their hearts had been wrenched from their chest by the other.
Rory's voice wasn't malicious when she pointed out that Emily didn't have a reason to know whether or not she still played tennis, and for that, Emily was grateful. Rory could've been going about this interaction in a completely different way, but they'd both evidently decided to opt for polite conversation instead of cutting remarks (of which Emily knew there was probably no shortage of). She found herself nodding along to Rory's explanation of her coaching, absorbing new facts about the woman she'd once loved, new things about someone who she'd once known better than anyone else in the world. It was a strange sort of grief, to realize that the version of Rory she'd once loved no longer existed, just like the Emily of back then had been changed by the years that had passed since she'd been gone.
She was pulled out of her thoughts when the topic of conversation shifted to her and her life, or former life in New York. It didn't even occur to her that it was strange that Rory knew that until Rory caught herself, Emily catching on half a beat later. Had they really been so cut from each other's lives that she'd never told Rory she was going to New York? That they hadn't even had a single conversation in all the years that had gone by? With Rory standing right in front of her, it felt like time was warping around the two of them - her life on Marshall Island seemed so recent, so fresh in her mind, but, she knew, she'd built an entire separate life in a separate city, a million moments crammed into the years that separated her life in Marshall Island from the life she had now.
"It's okay," She blurted, laughing partially out of politeness but partially because the way Rory babbled when she was embarrassed was always endearing and funny to her, "We never blocked each other," Emily pointed out, as if that was an accomplishment on their part. Break ups could be ugly - but at least they never blocked each other, and Emily had never even deleted the photos off her Instagram - she'd left things exactly as they'd been. It was also a backhanded admission, because she was just as guilty as Rory of perusing the other's social media pages, keeping tabs when curiosity got the best of her. "I guess I was just trying to find a place that fits me as well as Marshall Island fits you," She shrugged, "But I guess it wasn't New York."















