On the topic of Spindlehorse's newly-rolled out policy on studio employees selling art online:
To be totally honest...I'm surprised it took them this long crack down.
When I first got into this fandom it was very surprising to me that so many artists employed by the studio had merch shops. I know this change has left a rotten taste in everyone's mouth because it feels so disingenuous on their part, and it also left a lot of artists in the lurch with merch to sell and no venue to sell them at other than conventions. That really, really sucks, and I'm so sorry to those affected. The sudden change was unfair, there should have been more warning and lead time to help artists move their product before the policy was enacted.
It might seem sudden but this was likely months in the making, probably predating the announcement of Spindlehorse's extended partnership with Warren James back in April. They're well within their rights to crack down on anything that infringes on copyrights and removes conflicts if interest. The deal was probably made with this explicit agreement a long time ago.
It's a bummer that they're no longer indie, but this is the way it just goes once something gets big enough. The lines were very blurry when it came to official merch and independent merch made by the same people, why wouldn't Amazon or Warren James insist that their investment be protected and set clear boundaries?
Now, before you start writing your angry response to me...
I think there's a massive difference between small-scale art products like stickers, standees and little trinkets like that and say...
...A monetized music video created in part by studio artists that kept referring to itself as the "Official Music Video"?
...using Crowdfunding to move mass-produced unofficial merch?
Large-scale attempts to profit off someone else's intellectual property should be stopped. It's unfortunate that in order to catch the big fish, they had to cast such a wide net that lots of little fish were caught too.
I propose that there be some amendments to the current policy that is more lenient on small-scale merch sales from employees, or more opportunities for collaboration that benefit them directly. Artists need to be supported and they're asking for opportunities to work.
I really think there is a middle ground that can work for studio artists and help prevent large-scale misappropriation of IP.
In the meantime, two things are important:
1. Sign the petition linked below if you don't agree with SH's current policy.
2.Consider writing a note in there suggesting that small-scale online merch sales be re-evaluated.