The Logic of the Knight in the Dark World
kinda a part 2 to my last post, but you don't need to read that one to understand this one. its here if you wanna read it tho.
I'm going over the logic of how the knight operates in both the light and dark worlds. basically the rules it follows, since it kinda follows its own rules. this post is about its general logic, as well as how it works in the dark world
I think the knight might be a bit physically unstable, in the same way the amalgamates in undertale are.
the knight is seen shapeshifting constantly. the knight from we usually see them in is probably their natural form (tho I have seen it argued that it could instead be the ball form), and we see them shift into the ball form, and the bird. their visor moves around their head constantly, acting as both their moth and eyes. when they roar, they're chest and face split open. the roar they do at the start of their battle looks almost like something trying to rise out of tar, the way the string of black run across their mouth as they open it. they're also seen crying or drooling or dripping at the very beginning of their encounter too. the knight is also always followed by this aura or distortion. basically, their physical form is an ever-shifting mess.
it also looks visually similar to the titan and titan spawn. they're all back and white, and they get staticy whenever they are hit. the knight does seem to get significantly more staticy tho, as its form destabilizes more than the titan's does at the end of its fight.
so what am I saying? I think the knight is, physically at least, in some kind of in-between state. it has properties similar to the titan, in that it looks like the titan and responds the same way when hit. but its a much more unstable version of the titan, as its form constantly shifts and there's a distortion following it around.
what does this mean? I have no fucking clue. the only thing I can think of as a plausible explanation is that the knight is some kind of fusion or something.
no, I don't believe in the kriselle amalgam knight theory to be true. but I think the knight might follow a similar type of logic, and that's why its so unstable. I've said before I'm a dess-knighter, so maybe dess got corrupted by darkness or fused with darkness or something, and that's how she became the knight?
its kind of impossible to say. we just dont know enough about how the knight was made to be able to say anything definitively. literally any idea we could come up with can be plausible if we stretch it enough. we just dont have enough information to say for sure rn.
the only thing I can say for sure is I think the knight is in some sort of in between state of being a titan an being a lightner. they're not a regular darker by any means, and that's why they behave so differently. they're some third category of thing we have yet to see
to add on to that, they're able to ignore stats for some reason? like, flowery's fake stats they're able to flat out ignore.
side note: I dont think they're actually changing the amount of damage flowery is doing to them, I think they're calling his bluff. like, if someone pulls out gun in rock paper scissors, if you accept it as happening it counts as a loss. you allow the other person to insert something outside of the rules that allows them to win. but if you call out the other player and say that there's no gun in rock paper scissors, the gun has no effect. you dont allow. it to work because you dont allow it to defy the rules of the game. I think the knight slashing the numbers is basically a shorthand for calling out flowerys fake stats following this same kind of logic
so for some reason, the knight can call out flowery's bluff. his fake stats are acknowledged by ralsei, for example, but its not like ralsei can outright ignore the damage flowery deals when fighting him. unless he can and just chooses not to. i dont wanna think about that tho. the knight however, can and does.
so the knight can tell when stats are being faked, and is able to ignore that fake stat. whether its a skill unique to the knight or not is hard to say. but its the only one we see actively ignoring them at least.
the knight also has really high defense when fighting it. I dont think this is manipulating/ignoring stats tho as much as it is just having a high defense stat in general. it's just something interesting at least.
they are the only one who can swoon the party. I have. no idea what to say to that except. they're fucking strong. like, stronger than the titan, cause the titan doesn't swoon the party. idk what to do with this information than say "well, more evidence the knights some weird third thing"
so what do we know of the knight? like I outlined earlier, the knight seems the be physically unstable, like how the amalgamates were in undertale. its similar to the titan, but a more unstable version, like its some kind of combination of a titan-like entity and something else. it knows of flowery's fake stats, and its able to call him out on them by straight up ignoring them. we dont know if its the only one able to do this, but its the only one willing to. it is strong enough to swoon the party, seemingly stronger than the titan bc of this. and obviously it has sword and star magic like we see it use constantly
I think the only conclusion I can really draw from this is that the knight doesn't fit cleanly into an established category. they're not a regular darker bc they can go to the light work (see part 1 for more info), they're not exactly a titan bc they're both stronger than one but at the same time are less physically stable. they're certainly not a lightner in the traditional sense, because their logic breaks every single example of a lightner going into a dark world that we have.
they're some weird, fucked up combination of the three. one that we can't fully know the how or why behind them until after we know more about their origin. which isn't going to happen for awhile, at least...