One Year Later. A Light in the Dark.
I’ve written and deleted the opening line to this post four times because I don’t think there’s any good or right way to start it. I shouldn’t be writing it. I shouldn’t have to. I’m still working on accepting the fact that what I’m writing is real.
A year ago this weekend we were in Folly Beach, SC, celebrating my bachelor party and my upcoming wedding when a drunk driver named Andrew Robert Lanzaro swerved off the road and hit two of my friends. My friend Ryan was seriously injured and my friend Justin Plumlee was killed.
Man, I miss him. I don’t talk about him on social media much because I can’t bring myself to put those kinds of feelings out there with the other stuff we cloud our feeds up with every day. This is so much more important than any of that and so much bigger. But I think about him every day. All the time.
The feelings that come from missing him aren’t what I would have expected them to be. You expect to cry. Sometimes it doesn’t happen. And sometimes it catches you out of NOWHERE, like when you hear a song or you start to laugh over an old story and your laughter turns to sobs, or you do something as simple as open your phone and TimeHop reminds you that two years ago you were hanging out with Plumlee.
Sometimes I go on autopilot. It’s the worst. It’s not fair to my family or my friends or Amanda. My body becomes a shell and I float off into the distance without realizing it until way later. Sometimes days. It’s like when you drive your car and you realize that you haven’t thought about the action of driving in hours and you wonder how you even got to your destination, but hey, you’re there, right?
I tell stories about Justin whenever I can. People that knew him love it. People that didn’t know him or that don’t know how to react to someone telling a story about someone that tragically passed get uncomfortable. But I keep telling them.
Justin was living laughter. I try to live my life in a way that asks “what would Justin do here” or “what would Justin think of this?” There have been moments in the last year where I’ve been disappointed in myself because I feel as if I’ve made decisions that wouldn’t have checked out with him. A self-loathing vibe that I’ve never experienced and that I know is exaggerated in my head and my heart.
I’m really, really good at putting on a face. Those of you that know me know that I’m a positive guy. I try to preach the half-full life and I try to go into situations with an easygoing, open heart. I can get away with this most of the time, but honestly, I’m crushed. I’m fucked up. I’m heartbroken. I’m in repair.
Ryan called me out about this in February. Words can’t explain how thankful I am that Ryan is OK.
It was the first time we’d seen each other since my wedding day, and THAT day, of course, was beautiful and lovely and the brightest spot in the past year. I’m the luckiest guy on the planet to be married to someone as amazing and supportive as Amanda, and I’ll talk more to that later.
We got dinner with Ryan and Kellie and Kevin and caught up on life, recovery, everything. I was on autopilot without realizing it. Ryan called me out a few days later. He told me to go talk to a therapist.
I told him I would.
I didn’t.
He kept bugging me about it. I told him I would. I Googled people and support groups.
I didn’t.
My family told me to look into it. Amanda told me I should. I caught up with my friend Daniel in early April and he asked me if I was OK.
“I’m good, mannnnn. I’m good.”
“No, really. Are you OK?”
I thought I was a good bullshitter, but the people that know me best can see right through it.
On April 11, Quaker Lake Camp held a day of service for Justin called “Paths for Plumlee.” It was beautiful and nostalgic and you could feel him there with us, in the place where we first met, a place that was so important to him where he touched countless lives.
On April 16 I went to my first therapy session.
Ryan, thank you.
I’ve been going once a week since. Sometimes it’s awesome. Sometimes I don’t feel anything. Sometimes I tell stories and jokes the whole time because I like to talk and it’s a defense mechanism.
Sometimes we have breakthroughs and I cry my face off.
I’ve been finding ways to cope with the pain the last year. Sometimes I drink too much. Sometimes I find other distractions that are just as harmful. It’s stupid and I know it is. I get mad at myself. The self-loathing comes back.
I read a To Write Love On Her Arms blog a while back that talked about the BEFORE and AFTER that you experience through trauma. You become someone else. The BEFORE is gone and the AFTER is who you will be for the rest of your life.
The thing I’ve been fighting the hardest is accepting the fact that I’m living life as an AFTER now.
The BEFORE version of me was on top of the world. I’d just started a new job at my alma mater, I was on a trip with my best friends, my BROTHERS, and I was about to marry the most beautiful girl in the world.
Then the accident happened. It sent a shockwave through SO MANY PEOPLES’ LIVES. I think about and look at how it’s affected all of us. We all heal differently. We all handle things differently. None of it should have happened.
Everyone’s AFTER is different than the BEFORES of August 30, 2014.
I’m working on accepting mine. I’m working to be more like who I was BEFORE. I recently asked my Mom if I seemed different than I was BEFORE. I told her to be blunt. She was.
“You’re cynical now. You have something snarky to say about everything.”
I asked for it and I knew what she was going to say, but I needed to hear it. That’s what Moms are for. Moms, Dads, wives, husbands, siblings, good friends, they call us out for the stupid shit we sometimes don’t even realize we’re guilty of.
Mom, thank you.
Amanda’s had to deal with my AFTER more than anyone. She’s been on the front lines with me since the accident. I told her not to drive down to Folly Beach after it happened. She didn’t listen.
Seeing her that day was like seeing a sunset after a storm. She was the best sight I’ve ever seen. Shoot, though. Her on our wedding day. When I get really sad or start to see the mental pictures of the violent images from the accident in my head, I close my eyes.
I close my eyes and I SEE her at the end of the aisle. I see my boys to my left and our families in front of us and the walkway. I see the sun shining behind her and I SWEAR to you there’s an AURA of LIGHT around her. Golden rays from Heaven or somewhere like it. Maybe from her heart. That keeps me going. That light in the dark.
There’s always a light in the dark, I promise.
Amanda is my brightest light.
Our first year of marriage hasn’t been easy. No one said it would be. I check out sometimes and it’s selfish and I don’t realize it but I’ll coast and all the sudden it’s a new month. Amanda has been a lighthouse through all of this. She’s stood strong and been there and helped me find my way. Even though it’s damn hard, she understands that healing takes time and she’s been my ROCK.
Amanda, thank you.
I still look at pictures of Plumlee all the time. I listen to old voicemails that I have.
“Hey, man. Wanted to see what you were doing for the game tonight…” is one of them. It’s from 2012. I don’t delete things, and I guess I’m glad for that.
I watch old videos.
I wear a University of Florida hat that was his. His parents gave it to me with a collection of his stuff. I don’t even like UF, but it’s one of my most prized possessions. I made sure to wear it on our honeymoon.
Besides going to therapy, I try to find light in other things. Jamie Tworkowski’s book If You Feel Too Much couldn’t have come out at a better time. I’ve never smiled and cried so hard to a book before. He talks about love and loss and hope and it’s so relatable. I encourage you to read it if you’re feeling down or lost about anything in life. It’s another light.
He talks about coping and he talks about second chances and finding your way again. He reminds you that you are not alone. One of the most powerful passages came in the end of the book, originally from a blog post he wrote. Here are a few of the points that, in my mind, were written in bold, all caps, and a really large font.
If this world is too painful, stop and rest.
It’s okay to stop and rest.
This life – it’s not a contest, not a race, not a performance, not a thing that you win.
It’s okay to slow down.
You are here for more than getting by.
You don’t have to fake it.
You do not have to fake it.
Other people feel this way too.
If your heart is broken, it’s okay to say your heart is broken.
If you feel stuck, it’s okay to say you feel stuck.
If you can’t let go, it’s okay to say you can’t let go.
You are not alone in these places.
It’s okay – whatever you need and however long it takes – it’s okay.
My book is bent and highlighted and underlined and stained with sand and saltwater from the beach and my tears. You can borrow my copy if you’d like. You’ll see “Plumlee” in so, so many of my notes among the stories.
Plumlee is everywhere and it makes me smile through the tears. Ryan is alive and recovering that makes me smile through the tears. I know that we’ll talk about all of this when we’re old and in rocking chairs and we’ll tell our kids and grandkids about Justin and we’ll ALWAYS raise a toast to Plumlee.
To Plumlee, forever.
I wanted to get through the year anniversary of this. I know that there’s not an on/off switch for our grief or our recovery. I know that this will affect us for the rest of our lives.
But I also know that the first day after the anniversary is actually the second time that we’ve lived that day after the accident. And we’re doing our best to move forward and embrace our AFTERS.
I know I can’t be the person I was BEFORE. I’m an AFTER and I can’t change it. So I’ll keep working on this embracing the AFTER thing.
Thank you all for your support. Thank you for your love. Thank you for putting up with this new guy and for knowing that I’m still in there somewhere.
There’s always a light in the dark. Plumlee’s lives on in our smiles and our laughs.
There is always a light in the dark.
Peace to you and yours.
D














