lowkey itβs becoming more unenjoyable being on twitter as doppu now. The pst 2 years these loud dy hard stan accs are making dy even more unlikable to people outside of the fandoms esp to other nct members solo stans. And it even makes me, a hardcore dy fan to consider geting out of the fandom. Itβs starting to become more prominent during dy solos and seeing how well dy did with his solo work, these people cant help becoming more big-headed. What i cant stand the most is them using the excuse of dy being βthe butt of the jokeβ to justify their action but are you blind? Cant you see the underlying dynamic? In the early years sure they played it up a bit but these fans are not even fans back then? Lol. Way to hold a grudge. And oh the most favourite mantra βevery nctzen hates dyβ. What are u? Fkn child?
Why are they so reactive? Like i dont understand? Sometimes a discourse on twitter starts without even mentioning dy and suddenly, the moment dy is mentioned these ppl doesnt hesistate to blow it out of proprtion. Itβs embarassing honestly. And iβm just glad big, older accs are not engaging directly in any of it. But if they do, it might be my last straw in the fandom. And i really dont like the words best vocalist. Itβs too absolute and i cant sit very well with that knowing how much work he puts on, how his condition fluctuates sometimes. I know fans want to praise him but do it outside of fandom war please. Itβs just distasteful at this point. Cant they just ignore? Thing is i can really count how just a handful of ppl who are reactive to these fan wars but now theyβre making other doppus to become βbraverβ to talk shit to other ppl. Canβt believe there were days that our fandom is very very at peace. Like we were just happy with whatever content we have of dy and itβs like weβre having the same mindset as him to just work hard and be consistent. Now, the pedestal is becoming more higher and the ppl in fandom is trying to make him as untouchable.
i know itβs just impossible to have everyone behaves online but honestly theyβre making it veryy hard for international fans to get into dy. Itβs as if they dont want ppl outside of korea to get into him. βItβs fine dy is big in korea and japanβ yes itβs not false (i think heβs just barely breaking out of that kpop circle into other genre like musical and variety so itβs very fragile still) but shouldnt it be natural that we as fans promotes and makes outside ppl engage with him? Like is it hard to be kind so ppl would find it easier to explore the fandom? As a fan, itβs not like i want him to be famous all around the world but i just want outside ppl to at least have nice interaction or encounter with dy or extension of him (fans).
Will be dropping some dy edits soon βπΌ
I feel you, anon. I have to supress myself and not drag the topic here, only sometimes allowing myself snide shady comments.
The development is very unfortunate, I agree with you that such behaviour not only worsens the climate in the fandom itself, it alienates potential Doyoung fans.
The situation is not unique. I see this conduct in relation to every neo and almost every group. The posts about Doyoung just appear before you and me more because of our search history. There are more solo stans and there are more fanwars that need fodder to be invented. An unrelated to singing example is clothes. My bias is mistreated because he/she wore a duller dress/long pants. Your group is a copycat of mine because your bias wore a similar dress to mine.
You know how kids in school pick out a trait of a child and use it to bully him/her? Anything: height, freckles, stutter, absence of a parent, eligability for a free lunch, etc. "The best singer" is the same idea but in reverse. Taeyong's solo stans look down on anyone who doesn't write their own songs (singing is not important, producing is). For Yuta's fans others can't sing rock, so are no match for him. Of course, charting is "a talent". And, depending on a situation, a chart is selected to answer one's needs (Billboard 100, Spotify, Melon, music show wins, etc).
So yeah, in short, the situation is not unique to Doyoung. He just "became of notice" and started to attract people who like to use idols for squabbles. And, as you said, these people look for posts to react to, invent a reason, go extra mile and search OP's history for "damaging information".
What can be done to turn the tide? For real Do's fans to not be swayed by this wave, for them to not become like the perpetuators? The only solution is to offer an alternative. In other words, create a wave/movement of your own. Write and support Doyoung positive and Doyoung "welcoming" twits. Spread edits that highlight him as a singer, visual, kind friend paired with non-confrontational annotations. "This is such a beautiful song" or "His voice helps me go through the day" instead of "the only idol who can sing". Do not antagonise a potential passerby, lure with safety to their pre-established opinions.
Involve Doyoung in more discussions/lists of good vocalists in k-pop. He really progressed only in recent years, so is not widely known, he is still judged by his older performances. Think of how Ten is universally known as a good dancer, so noone questions his skills in the NCT fandom even when people have differing preferences (Jisung, Mark, Taeyong). Unfortunately, it is a lost battle to argue with fans online about vocal skills of idols. Many will say utmost rubbish with absolute conviction in them being right. It is a bias of false easiness of the topic, of sorts? People don't argue with scientists about quantum physics, but they will about the shape of the Earth or the human evolution. Hence "my bias sounds pleasant to me = he is a great vocalist".
Another issue is that people in general became less tolerant of other people's personal opinions. They are taught to react to any inconvenience, any perceived hurt and slight. It is expected that Doyoung won't be as attractive as an idol in comparison to others for many Westerners, especially from US. Be it his looks, his mannerism, his sassy nature, or his solo songs and genres he prefers. The language barrier is an obstacle, the type of the melody barrier is as well. Yeah, people are being dumb in the way they reply ("ballads are boring"), but it is reflective of their insufficient level of education/maturity, not of Doyoung. It's like a person on the Internet saying that classical music is boring. Is there a need to prove the classical music is way more advanced art than a simple pop-tune? No.
As for staying in a fandom. Switching to the official content really helps, lol (+lives, fancams). By its nature X is not the best place for practicing the fandom life. Tumblr is better for it, so are dedicated forums/boards or closed communities. There were always troublemakers and affinity to misbehave, it was just fought off by a forum's rules and moderators. A once issued ban freed everyone from a negativity spreading user, on X every person has to ban individually. Which allows uncontrolled spread of malpractices.