Do you know what is interesting? Palpatine and Obi-wan have the same opponents. They are both fighting using two lightsabers. We almost get a comparison of their skills. Almost. One is still Sith and the other is Jedi.
In reference to this post.Â
Okay, I love jarâkai. And I love lightsaber combat styles. Fair warning, though, I am not a fencing practitioner in real life, so I am working directly off of Wookieepedia and headcanons, and not any practical application in actual dueling. (Although one dayâŚone dayâŚ)
âAlthough the full extent of Sidiousâs mastery of each form of lightsaber combat have [sic] not been displayed, he had enough competence with the forms of Juyo, Makashi, Niman and also apparently Shien or Soresu to teach them to his apprentice Maul. At times, Sidious displayed considerable proficiency in applying Force attacks into his lightsaber combat, which can be attributed to his superb skills in Niman. He also used a Form V opening stance when up against Mace Windu and at times has displayed reasonable skills in deflection, apparently due to his mastery of Shien.â (x)
So basically, Palpatine is well-versed in almost all the lightsaber forms and incorporates them into his jarâkai with an astounding amount of fluidity, most likely drawing off the very same Juyo he had taught Darth Maul.Â
We all know that Obi-wan is the Soresu practitioner. And that he, originally, learned Ataru from Qui-gon but abandoned the form after Qui-gonâs death. But if one goes trolling through the Wookieepedia black hole, a few interesting snippets appear.
âObi-Wan Kenobi studied Niman during his apprenticeship under Qui-Gon Jinn, attempting to learn how to apply the Force while in the midst of combat, a practice he commented as being difficult but eventually mastered enough to seamlessly Force Push droids.â (x)
âDuring the Invasion of Naboo, Obi-Wan Kenobi showed a basic knowledge of Shien, utilizing it in conjunction with the rare reverse grip to skillfully deflect blaster bolts, overcoming Ataruâs weakness against blaster-wielding opponents, as he had yet to learn Soresu.â (x)
âObi-Wan Kenobi commented Form I was wild, raw, and deadly, requiring much emotional heat, and Kit Fisto noted how hard it was to control the pull of Form I, disabling opponents rather than killing them. However, Kenobi was nevertheless versed to a degree in Shii-Cho, able to infuse elements of the Form into his swordplay, including the rematch with Count Dooku onboard the Invisible Hand.â (x)
âFor his part, Drallig refused to allow Anakin Skywalker to study Juyo, while Obi-Wan Kenobi was likewise forbidden to learn Vaapad by Qui-Gon Jinn.â (x)
Now, I actually did look up the forms our other jarâkai practitioners were versed in. And I ended up with this:
Anakin Skywalker â> Djem-So, Ataru
Barriss Offee â> Soresu
Ahsoka Tano â> Shien, Ataru, Djem-So
Asajj Ventress â> Makashi, Ky Narecâs style (not identified)
Darth Maul â> Juyo, Niman, Soresu, Shien, Makashi
Jarâkai is not necessarily a separate fighting style, but rather a fighting style that incorporates elements from the seven base lightsaber combat forms using two blades. And so it makes sense that Maul is on the top of this list and is able to go head to head with Sidious, considering he is trained in and has mastered a wide variety of styles.Â
What is even more interesting, is that Obi-wan has mastered an equal number of styles, albeit slightly different ones. And that the only areas in which he is seemingly lacking in comparison to the Sith are in Makashi and Juyo/Vapaad. And Obi-wan wanted to learn Vapaad in his youth, and you canât tell me that he didnât some research behind Qui-gonâs back.Â
Now, probably all Jedi are at least given rudimentary instruction in most of the forms, but none are mentioned as having capabilities in so many varieties of forms as much as Obi-wan and Yoda. (And interestingly enough, Vader, later on.)
Now, the Niman form is a gateway to jarâkai, and also relies heavily on Force manipulation during combat. And you can see this with Sidious in the duel with Maul and Savage. Any time Sidious is at a disadvantage, he uses the Force to turn it into an advantage, like when Maul kicks him off a wall and Sidious just pulls the two Zabrack with him to fall to the ground. And this would explain Sidiousâs ridiculous skills.
For Obi-wan, Ataru training often used two blades, and you can see in his duel with Maul and Savage that he is a bit more acrobatic, twirling and doing that little kick-up from the ground (which is the best thing ever :o) And this would explain his style of jarâkai, which is so fluid, but less reliant on Force manipulation, and more on acrobatics and blade work.Â
But! Both Sidious and Obi-wan can fall back on a variety of forms in their jarâkai, which is why they (and Maul) look so damn good at what they do. And Obi-wanâs devotion to Soresu (both the form and the philosophy of the form) -Â âThe core tenets of Soresu encouraged duelists to place themselves âwithin the eye of the stormâ: to maintain a calm center, undistracted and undisturbed by the conflict around them.â (x) - is perfect for him. And I would posit that even a dark!Obi-wan would keep to this philosophy, because a dark!Obi-wan would take that anger, chain it, and make it his own - cold, and icy and controlled.Â
At least, until it wasnât.Â