Star✨

(these will be in order from most to least with some honorable mentions!)

Cassandra - I posted something about why I think this is about her

Down Bad - I mean… come on.

loml - “you’re the loss of my life” SHES ACHING FOR HER

Fresh Out The Slammer - she’s saying she did her time for loving Karlie (the public’s hate/heat)

imgonnagetyouback - self explanatory really

Robin - “long may you roar at your dinosaurs” Karlies kids were dressed up as dinosaurs for Halloween… shes mourning but wanting Karlie to be happy with what she has, even if it’s without her.

How Did It End? - no one really knows what went down between them for it to end but everyone wants to know. their friends are the only ones who really do know but do they? because even she doesn’t really understand it

I Look in People’s Windows -

Florida!!! - I don’t really have an explanation for this one but…

~~ honorable mentions ~~

The Black Dog -

Fortnight -

So High School - (100% not about Tr*vis)

But Daddy I Love Him - It’s so obviously gay either way you put it but I think this is about her parents/family/whoever disapproval of her and Karlie and well you can hear the rest. The ending though, I believe is what she wished happened. I don’t have a good explanation for the baby part though-

Many see her as bisexual and that's absolutely fine! She could be but I personally see her as a lesbian (and that's coming from someone who's bi) because from what I've seen of all her male relationships it just seems... off? I can't exactly put my finger on it but the way she acts with Travis for example is more of a "hey look how happy I am with a man! I can be happy with a man!" instead of genuine happiness. If it is genuine then that's absolutely incredible and I'm happy for her but that's just the vibes I get from it all.

While with women it's pure, ecstatic joy and happiness all over. She glowed when she was with Karlie, her smile was brighter, her eyes shined more. You could feel the warmth they gave each other.

There's so many songs to reference about her being with/loving a woman (i.e. dress, ivy, maroon, etc)

I'm sure I don't have to point out all the sapphic lyrics in her songs but I did want to point out in her new album, TTPD a lot of songs are sort of like "I'm straight, see?" while simultaneously having queer undertones or outright not making sense unless they were gay.

Big example is But Daddy I love Him & Guilty as Sin? These two reference religion repercussions of being in a forbidden/not socially accepted relationship which if you're familiar with the queer community and religion trauma you'll know exactly that would be code for. Honestly it isn't even code.

Back to why I don't believe she's bisexual though. Aside from how she acts with men, she often refers to them as "Ken's" (Ken in the Barbie world is often seen as just an accessory to Barbie, not important or relevant as she is) or something that isn't personal. Every time someone's mentioned that's personal and loved it's almost always non gendered pronouns. She's never spoke of a man the way she has a woman.

Please bare with me if any of this doesn’t make sense or isn’t accurate. I’m sort of newer to the Kaylor stuff and don’t know everything 100% but I think Cassandra is absolutely about Karlie.

“So they [the public] killed Cassandra first ‘cause she feared the worst [possibly being outed] and tried to tell the town [come out]”

“So they filled my cell with snakes, I regret to say, Do you believe me now?” Her telling Karlie she knew telling people would ruin everything and she didn’t want to at least not right now.

I know some think Taylor wanted to come out and Karlie didn’t but I think it could go either way.

In this song I think Taylor knew that fans (and family) were catching on “They knew, they knew, they knew the whole time” And she didn’t feel safe enough because of her family, “The family, the pure greed, The Christian chorus line” and “Blood’s thick but nothin’ like payroll”

We all know her dad really only cares if she’s making money and he feared if she came out the money would stop.

Feel free to add on anything if you please!