Dead Air
Pairing: Batfam x Batsis!Reader
Summary: You passed in your father's arms. and no one will forget how you looked when you died. And after months of rotting grief, why are you standing there?
CW: ANGST, mentions of death, grieving, swearing, violence, injuries, travelling dimensions,
WC: 11k idk (this one is my longest fic to date)
NOTE: There is multi-universal travel in this fic, itsv type shit. On another Earth, Bruce dies instead of Batsis!Reader. Letting you know just for clarity's sake.
READ PART 1 - READ PART 2.5
The night is supposed to start like any other.
The cave is aliveâscreens glowing, engines humming, the familiar low thrum of readiness vibrating through bone and steel.
Everyoneâs half-geared, muscle memory kicking in.
Ready for patrol.
Routine.
Something solid to hold onto.
You should be here.
Your suit remains in the cylindrical glass vault on the wallâNightingaleâs armour pristine, untouched. The matte black plating catches the cave lights in dull glints, the bat emblem symbolic on your chest, pink highlights and accents decorating your suit.
It's neat. Too neat.
Like itâs waiting.
Waiting for it's wearer to come back and put it on. Dick notices it first. His gaze snags on the suit and lingers half a second too long before he looks away Jason clocks it next. His jaw tightens, nostrils flaring, like heâs bracing for a hit he knows is coming. Damian doesnât look at it at all.
Bruce steps forward.
âNo patrol tonight.â
The words echo strangely against the stone.
Everyone freezes.
âWhat?â Steph says immediately, boots halfway on. âYouâre joking.â
Bruce doesnât blink. âIâm not.â
Tim swivels in his chair, confusion flashing to irritation in a heartbeat. âBruce, weâre already running behindâOracle flagged three hotspotsââ
âI know,â Bruce says.
Jason lets out a sharp laugh. âSo what, Gothamâs just on its own now?â
Bruceâs mouth tightens. âYouâre benched. All of you.â
The cave feels smaller.
Tighter.
âFor how long?â Dick asks carefully.
âTonight,â Bruce replies.
Then, quieter, firmer: âTomorrow too.â
Damian finally looks up. âThat is unacceptable.â
Bruce turns to him. âYouâre staying.â
"And if any of you try anything, I'll stretch that time to indefinitely."
The finality in his voice shuts everyone down.
Even Jason doesnât push. Not when Bruce looks like thatâtired in a way no sleep fixes, grief stitched into every line of his face. He looks like he's aged years in the past few weeks
âSuit down,â Bruce orders.
Reluctantly, one by one, they comply.
The walk back up to the manor is silent.
Boots echo against stone. Gloves are pulled off and shoved into pockets. Helmets are clipped uselessly at belts. No one says what theyâre all thinking: that patrol wouldâve helped. That punching something wouldâve been easier than sitting with the ache.
They pass your suit again on the way out.
Cassâs fingers twitch like she wants to reach for it.
Damian pauses for a fraction of a secondâso brief itâs almost invisibleâbut his shoulders tense, breath hitching before he schools himself and keeps walking.
The elevator doors close.
The cave disappears.
They reconvene an hour later in Timâs room, still dressed half-for-battle, irritation buzzing under the grief like static.
Timâs sitting on the edge of his bed, elbows on knees, staring at the floor. Jasonâs leaning against the desk, arms crossed, foot tapping. Steph paces, restless energy with nowhere to go. Cass sits cross-legged near the window on a bean bag, watching the city lights like she might memorise them. Dukeâs slouched in a chair, hoodie pulled up, jaw clenched.
Dick stands near the door, arms folded, tryingâand failingâto keep the peace.
âThis is bullshit,â Jason mutters finally. âBenched. On a random ass Tuesday night.â
âItâs not random,â Tim snaps, far sharper than intended.
Silence.
Steph exhales solemnly. âIt's 'cuz tomorrowâs her birthday.â
No one answers. How could they refute that?
Elizabeth Taylor Wayne, your pet Cavalier, pads into the room then, tiny paws soft against the carpet of Tim's carpet, who's room she frequented after your passing. Sheâs wearing one of her little pink sweatersâslightly crooked, like someone rushed putting it on. She pauses in the doorway, head tilting, tail wagging uncertainly before she beelines straight for Damian. (YO I LOVE DOGS OMFG)
Of course she does.
Damian stiffens as she noses at his boots, then sighs and crouches, scooping her up with practiced care. She settles immediately, licking his chin like sheâs claiming him.
âSheâs anxious,â he mutters, more observation than complaint.
Jason snorts quietly. âYeah. Wonder why.â
Dick rubs a hand over his face. âBruce thinks keeping us here helps.â
âHelps who?â Steph asks.
Yet again, no one has an answer.
Tim finally speaks, voice low. âHe couldnât even look at her suit.â
That does it.
The room goes heavy.
Dense.
Like the air itself is grieving.
Elizabeth squirms, then wriggles out of Damianâs arms and hops onto Timâs bed, curling up atop one of your old hoodies like itâs instinct. Like she knows.
Damian watches her with an expression he doesnât have words for.
âShe was supposed to wake me up tomorrow,â he says suddenly.
Everyone looks at him.
âShe always does,â Damian continues, staring at nothing. âShe said birthdays should start early. That they deserve⊠ceremony.â
Steph presses her lips together.
Dick swallows. âWeâll stillââ He stops.
Tries again. âWeâll get through tomorrow. Together.â
Jason scoffs, but thereâs no bite to it. âYeah. Sure.â
Outside, Gotham hums on, uncaring.
Inside Timâs room, surrounded by half-packed gear, borrowed hoodies, and the soft breathing of a dog who misses you in a way she canât explain, your siblings sit with the weight of being benchedânot just from patrol, but from the one thing they all want most.
To outrun the day thatâs coming.
The house knows before anyone says it out loud.
Wayne Manor is quiet in a way that feels intentional, like itâs learned how to mourn without making noise. The kind of silence that presses against the ears, that fills every corner until itâs hard to breathe.
Damian wakes first.
He always does.
Training drilled into muscle memory. For a brief, treacherous moment, his body moves on instinct aloneâfeet hitting the floor, posture straightening, already turning toward your room with irritation half-formed on his tongue. He expects to see your door open, light spilling out, you already awake and doing something infuriatingly normal.
Instead, the hallway is still. Your door is closed.
The realisation hits him in stages. Not like a blade, but like pressureâslow, crushing, unavoidable. He stands there longer than he should, staring at the door like if he waits long enough, you might open it yourself and give him a kiss on the cheek.
Elizabeth Taylor trots up beside him, soft and warm, tail brushing against his calf. She presses her head into his leg, grounding him. Damian exhales shakily and kneels, burying his fingers into her fur.
Her pink velvet dog bed isnât in your room anymore.
It migrated.
Quietly. Over several days.
It sits in Damianâs room now, tucked beside his bed, next to Titus'.
No one commented on it. No one questioned it.
She sleeps there every night, curled close to him like sheâs guarding whatâs left.
Everyone has been taking care of her.
They take turns bathing her, brushing her coat, changing her outfits with the kind of careful attention usually reserved for something fragile and irreplaceable.
Jason complains the loudest but never skips his turn. Steph hums softly while she buttons tiny sweaters. Alfred puts her in a pink stroller and takes her to your grave every now and then. Cass watches her like sheâs memorising her existence, Dick brings Haley over more often, for Elizabeth to have a girl companion. Damian's taken up replenishing her doggy bowl and upkeeping her insanely expensive diet you sponsored.
After all, she is the last living thing that loved you without knowing what death was.
Downstairs, Alfred sets the table.
He does it the same way he always hasâmeasured, precise, unyielding in ritual. The grand dining room feels cavernous this morning, its long table too long, the ceiling too high. Sunlight filters through the tall windows and lands across the polished surface like it doesnât know what itâs illuminating.
Your place is set.
The chair between Duke and Damian is pulled out, napkin folded neatly, cutlery aligned just so. Alfred adjusts it twice before heâs satisfied. He doesnât look at the chair for long. One by one, they drift in.
Dick checks his phone as he walks, then stops dead when he sees the date. He doesnât sit right away. Just stands there, thumb hovering uselessly over the screen.
Jason takes the seat across from yours without realising it, then stiffens when his gaze flicks up and lands on the empty space opposite him. Tim arrives last. Hoodie sleeves swallowed over his hands. Eyes shadowed. He hasnât been sleeping well. None of them have.
Bruce doesnât come down.
Alfred pours tea.
He comments on the weather. Mentions a meeting at Wayne Enterprises that Lucius has postponed. His voice is steady, clipped, perfectly composed. He asks about training schedules that no longer exist. About patrols that arenât happening. They answer him because itâs easier than saying anything else.
Forks scrape against porcelain. Cups clink. Damian doesnât touch his food. Elizabeth sits at his feet, chin resting on his shoe, eyes tracking every movement like sheâs afraid someone might disappear if she looks away.
The chair stays empty.
Itâs Tim who finally breaks.
His voice is barely above a whisper.
âItâs her birthday.â
No one responds immediately.
The words donât echo. They sink.
Stephâs hand freezes mid-reach. Duke swallows hard, eyes fixed on the table. Dick closes his eyes like heâs been punched. Jasonâs jaw tightens, teeth grinding audibly.
Alfred stills.
Just for a breath.
âYes,â he says softly. âI believe it is.â
No one wishes you happy birthday.
After breakfast, no one knows what to do.
They hover in that awful in-betweenâtoo restless to sit, too exhausted to move. Bruce still hasnât come down. The manor feels wrong without him, like the absence of both father and daughter has knocked something structural loose.
Thatâs when they see the package.
Bruce stands near the base of the staircase, motionless, a medium-sized box clutched in his hands like it weighs more than it should.
Your name is printed on the label in clean, unmistakable letters. Ordered weeks ago. Scheduled. Planned.
For today.
No one speaks.
Bruce doesnât look up. His grip tightens slowly, knuckles whitening. The box crinkles faintly under the pressure.
Alfred approaches quietly, like heâs walking up to something wounded.
âMaster Bruce,â he says gently. âPerhaps⊠a game might be of use. The children could use the distraction.â
Bruce doesnât answer.
He doesnât move.
But he doesnât object either.
So they play cards.
Uno, of all things. They gather in the sitting room, sunlight slanting through the windows, dust motes floating lazily in the air like nothing has changed.
Steph volunteers to deal.
She shuffles once. Twice.
Disperses the cards, makes sure everyone has the standard deck of seven.
Everyone has one. Yet there's one extra deck remaining.
One meant for you.
âOh,â Steph breathes.
Her hands shake. She almost drops them.
No one tells her to stop.
She reshuffles, and deals again like muscle memory can carry her through what her heart canât.
They play.
They argue about rules. Jason accuses Dick of cheating. Damian snaps at Tim for not paying attention. Alfred comments dryly from the armchair, pretending not to notice the way conversation falters every time someone laughs too hard.
Timâs phone buzzes.
A TikTok.
Itâs stupid. Genuinely stupid. A video that wouldâve made you laugh. Without thinking, without pausing, he hits share.
Your name pops up automatically.
Sent.
The realisation lands a second later.
He stares at the screen, breath leaving him in a sharp, broken sound. The phone slips from his hands. He curls in on himself, shoulders shaking as Cassâ hand finds his sleeve and Dick shifts closer, anchoring him.
Laterâafter cards, after silence, after everyone drifts awayâBruce stands alone in the hallway.
He holds the package.
He doesnât open it.
He stares at it like it might start breathing.
âI was supposed to give this to you,â he whispers, voice breaking completely. âI was supposed to be here.â
The manor listens.
And for the first time that day, it lets him cry.
After your funeral, it felt like there was a hole Dinah and Ollie harboured that they couldn't fill up. The penthouse is too quiet when they come back from your funeral.
Itâs the kind of quiet that only exists after something enormousâafter crowds, speeches, the weight of hundreds of eyes and condolences and hands on shoulders. The doors shut behind Dinah and Ollie with a soft click, and suddenly thereâs nowhere for the grief to hide.
Dinah slips her heels off by the door without bending down, toes nudging them aside.
Her feet ache. Her shoulders ache. Her chest feels hollowed out, like something vital has been scooped cleanly away.
Ollie sets the keys down too hard on the counter. The sound echoes.
He winces like heâs broken something.
âWell,â he mutters, forcing air into his lungs, âhome sweetââ
He stops himself.
Dinah doesnât answer. Sheâs standing in the middle of the living room, still in black, still stiff, still holding herself like if she lets go sheâll collapse straight through the floor. Thereâs a strange exhaustion that follows events like this. Not the kind sleep fixes. The kind that makes your bones feel heavy, your thoughts slow and sludgy, your body lag a half-second behind your mind. Dinah feels it settle into her joints as she walks further inside, fingers brushing the back of the couch.
She can still hear voices.
âIâm so sorry for your loss.â âShe was such a beautiful soul.â âShe loved you both so much.â
Dinah sinks down onto the couch and stares at nothing. Ollie hovers for a moment, unsure, then sits beside her. He reaches for her hand, squeezes once.
Solid. Real.
âShe shouldnât be dead,â Dinah says suddenly.
Ollieâs jaw tightens. âNo.â
âShe was supposed to come over,â Dinah continues, voice flat, distant. âTo get back her airpods, and she wanted to borrow a dress. She said sheâd already planned the outfit but wanted my opinion.â
Ollie exhales through his nose. âShe always wanted your opinion.â
âShe never listened to it,â Dinah says.
A pause.
âBut she wanted it.â
The penthouse smells faintly like flowersâsympathy arrangements that arrived before they left, before they could stop them.
Dinah hates it.
It feels invasive. Wrong.
She stands abruptly. âI need to change.â
Ollie watches her walk away, shoulders squared, movements precise like sheâs holding herself together through sheer discipline. He doesnât follow.
Dinah goes to the closet.
Sheâs halfway through unzipping her dress when she sees them.
The handbags.
Lined up neatly.
Exactly as you left them.
Her hands still.
For a moment, her brain refuses to connect the dots.
Theyâre just bags.
Leather. Fabric. Accessories.
Normal things in the closet of a woman who happens to have a billionaire for a husband.
And then the memory hits her sideways.
You, perched on the bench, swinging your legs. âDinah, why do you have so many black bags?â âBecause black goes with everything sweetheart, your father knows that of all things..â âThatâs boring. This one though?â Youâd picked up the ridiculous beaded clutch, grinning. âThis one has personality.â
Dinahâs throat tightens.
She slowly, carefully zips the dress back up and steps out of the closet.
Thatâs when the days start to blur.
The quiet mornings. The untouched handbags. The way Ollie stops cracking jokes when he realizes no oneâs laughing.
And eventuallyâweeks to months laterâitâs the department store.
Dinah hasnât moved the handbags.
Theyâre still where you left themâlined up along the back of the walk-in closet in their shared penthouse, pristine and untouched.
Chanel, YSL, the ridiculous beaded clutch you insisted she needed because âDinah, itâs cute.â Dinah passes them every morning and every night and does not touch a single one.
She tells herself itâs because she doesnât need them.
Thatâs a lie.
Ollie notices first.
He notices everything lately.
Dinah feels both blessed and cursed to have such an observant husband.
The way Dinahâs fingers hover, the way she inhales like sheâs bracing herself, the way her shoulders tense when she catches sight of something that still smells faintly like youâyour perfume, your shampoo, your presence.
âYou gonna rotate your bags or keep âem in museum formation?â he asks one morning, light, careful.
Dinah doesnât look at him. âTheyâre fine.â
Ollie nods. Lets it go.
Heâs learned when not to push. He feels your absence as well.
Queen Industries feels wrong without you. Ollieâs office used to be a revolving door whenever you were in town. Youâd show up unannounced, feet kicked up on his desk, stealing his coffee, complaining about Bruce, asking if Roy was around, asking if Dinah had eaten yet.
You made the place loud. Lived-in. Human.
Now itâs just⊠quiet.
Too clean.
Ollie catches himself glancing at the door some afternoons, half-expecting you to barrel in with a grin and a complaint and some overpriced desserts you bought from that viral pastry place downtown.
But yet, it never happens.
The door stays closed. The silence settles.
He hates it.
Thatâs why he suggests the department store.
âDinah,â he says one afternoon, keys in hand, âyou havenât bought anything frivolous in weeks. Thatâs not like you.â
She arches a brow. âI donât need frivolous.â
âOkay, but want?â he counters. âCome on. Smell some expensive nonsense. Yell at me about notes and undertones.â
She hesitates. Then sighs. âFine.â
The store is bright and glossy and painfully normal.
Dinah moves through it on autopilotâpast makeup counters, past mirrors, past smiling employees who donât know her world has ended. Ollie trails behind her, hands in his pockets, watching the way she moves slower than usual, like sheâs underwater.
They reach the perfume section.
Rows and rows of glass bottles. Gold caps. Elegant labels. Too many choices.
Dinah reaches for one without thinking.
She freezes.
Her fingers close around the bottle.
She doesnât spray it.
Doesnât need to.
She already knows.
Ollie sees it immediatelyâthe way her breath stutters, the way her grip tightens, the way her eyes go distant.
âBabe?â he says softly. âWhatâs wrong?â
Dinah swallows.
Her voice comes out quiet. Fragile.
âY/N used to wear this.â
Ollie steps closer, his usual bravado evaporating. âYeah?â
Dinah lifts the bottle, finally spraying it onto the tester strip. The scent blooms into the airâwarm, familiar, unmistakably you.
Sweet without being childish. Sharp without being harsh. Confident.
Alive.
Dinah closes her eyes.
And suddenly youâre back.
Youâre sprawled across her couch, kicking off your shoes, telling her about a gala you went to with your father and sister that bored you out of your mind. Youâre hugging her hello, cheek pressed to hers, that exact scent clinging to your skin. Youâre laughing, loud and bright, asking if she wants to gossip because oh my god you will not believe what Dick and Jason did.
Dinahâs chest caves in.
She makes a broken sound before she can stop herself.
Ollieâs arms are around her instantly.
âHey,â he murmurs, pressing his forehead to hers. âIâve got you.â
âShe smelled like this,â Dinah whispers, fingers trembling as she clutches the strip. âEvery time she came over. Every time she hugged me. I didnât even realize how much I associated it with her untilââ
Her voice cracks.
Ollie tightens his hold. âShe had good taste,â he says hoarsely. âObviously.â
Dinah lets out a shaky laugh that dissolves into a sob. âShe was our kid,â she says. âShe just⊠showed up one day and never really left.â
âI know,â Ollie replies.
His own voice wavers now. âI miss her stealing my office chair.â
âShe stole everything,â Dinah says.
âMy clothes. My makeup. My time.â
Ollie exhales. âMy peace.â
They stand there like thatâin the middle of a luxury department store, surrounded by strangers and polished glass and music that feels inappropriateâholding each other while grief quietly wrecks them.
Dinah pulls back first, wiping her eyes. She looks at the bottle again.
âI canât buy it,â she says. âNot yet.â
Ollie nods immediately. âYeah. Yeah, thatâs okay.â
She puts it back carefully, like it might shatter.
As they walk away, Ollie glances back once, then mutters, âSheâd be mad we didnât buy anything.â
Dinah huffs weakly. âSheâd tell you to stop being dramatic.â
âYeah,â Ollie says. âAnd then sheâd hug us both and say we were doing our best.â
Dinah presses her lips together, nodding. They leave the store empty-handed.
The scent lingers anyway.
Just like the memory of you.
ON ANOTHER EARTH, IN A SEPARATE UNIVERSE.
You remember the night your father died.
23 days before your birthday
On another Earth, the night your father dies does not end when his heart stops.
It stretches.
It coils around your spine and stays there.
You remember the sound firstânot the explosion, not the chaos, but the quiet after. The way Gotham goes eerily still when something sacred has been taken from it. Rain clings to your lashes. Your gloves are slick with blood that will never come off, no matter how hard you scrub later.
Batman is not dead.
But Bruce Wayne is.
You donât scream. That comes later. Right now, youâre too busy counting breaths that arenât happening, hands shaking as you press down, as if pressure alone could undo destiny.
âDad,â you whisper, uselessly. âPlease.â
His cowl is cracked, his face pale beneath it. His eyes are still open, unfocused but somehow still kind.
Thatâs what destroys you â the kindness. Even now.
Someone pulls you back. Dickâs voice cracks your name like itâs breaking glass. Damian is shouting, furious and terrified and far too young to be watching this. Tim's gotten nauseous, you can't decipher what Babs is saying over your comms.
You donât remember leaving the alley. You donât remember the ride back. You only remember that Gotham keeps breathing even when Bruce Wayne doesnât.
The cover story is decided before the blood dries.
You are not in the room when they say it, but you hear it anyway â whispered through walls, through Alfredâs careful silences, through the way everyone avoids your eyes.
A drug overdose. Suspected suicide.
The words feel obscene.
Bruce Wayne, philanthropist. Bruce Wayne, troubled billionaire. Bruce Wayne, fallen icon. Bruce Wayne, a father, who is now dead.
The media eats it alive.
They speculate. They pity. They dissect his life like it belongs to them.
You sit at the long dining table and stare at the empty chair at the head.
He died in an alley protecting his city.
And the world thinks he gave up.
Parallel lines you donât yet have the words for twist tight in your chest.
The funeral is public.
Of course it fucking is.
Bruce Wayne deserves marble steps and black umbrellas and a sea of faces pretending they understand loss and better yet, pretending they knew who he was.
You're holding your dog, and Ace and standing beside Dick, who hasnât slept. Damian is rigid on your other side, small hand fisted in the fabric of your coat like he might fall apart if he lets go. Tim looks hollow. Cass watches everything with eyes too sharp. Steph cries quietly. Jason doesnât look at the coffin at all.
They speak of Bruce Wayneâs achievements. They speak of his generosity. His legacy. His struggles.
They do not speak of Batman. They do not speak of the man who taught you how to breathe through pain.
When the casket is lowered, something inside you follows it.
Later, when the cameras are gone and the world finally leaves you alone, you break.
Not loudly. Not dramatically.
You fold in on yourself in a hallway at Wayne Manor, hands pressed to your mouth to keep the sound in. Your knees hit the floor. Alfred finds you there and doesnât say a word.
He just kneels, dignified even in grief, and holds you like you are still a child who scraped her knee.
âI am so very sorry, Miss,â he murmurs.
You nod because if you speak, you will drown.
The days after blur into responsibility.
Someone has to take over Wayne Enterprises.
That someone is you.
Board members test you at first â subtle, patronising, polite. You shut it down quickly. You wear black like armour. You speak carefully.
You do not cry in meetings. Tim's by your side more often then not.
At night, you sit in Bruceâs study with the lights off, listening to the house settle.
You donât touch anything. It feels like trespassing.
Dick becomes Batman because Gotham doesnât wait for grief.
You watch him leave the cave the first night, cape settling over his shoulders in a way that makes your chest ache.
He pauses at the steps.
âYou donât have to do this alone,â he says quietly.
âI know,â you reply.
But you do it anyway.
Damian stops sleeping through the night.
He ends up in your room more often than not, curled tight and furious with the world, he holds you like you'll disappear as well. You brush his hair back like Bruce used to. You never mention it.
You become the constant in all their lives.
Joining the PTA for Duke regardless of how much you hate Margie and all the other middle-aged women. Showing up to Cass' ballet recitals. Taking Damian to piano classes and his swimming lessons. Helping Jason on the occasional mission, and the occasional hangover.
And it costs you more than you let on.
You and Dick ramp up your presence at the Watchtower.
Initiating meetings, scheduling timetables, emails with the UN.
Even though the two of you are heavily respected, all your league members look at you the same.
Two kids who lost their dad.
And now they're paying the price for his absence.
Dinah and Ollie are the ones who notice first.
Because of course they are.
They show up without warning, no fanfare, just familiar noise cutting through the manorâs oppressive quiet.
Ollie complains about the driveway. Dinah hugs you hard enough that your breath stutters.
They donât ask you to be strong. They donât ask you to talk. They just stay.
Something you took for granted quite frankly.
You end up in Star City more often than you expect â weekends at first, then longer stretches. Dinah teaches you how to breathe again, slow and deliberate. Ollie distracts Damian with archery and loud jokes and the kind of fatherly affection that doesnât demand anything back.
You sit on their couch one night, exhausted, head tipped back, and Dinah drapes a blanket over you without comment.
âYouâre allowed to rest sweetie,â she says softly.
You donât answer.
But you stay.
They become your anchors â not because they fix anything, but because they donât try to.
Because they remember Bruce without making him a ghost.
Because they look at you and still see you, not just the weight youâre carrying.
When you laugh â really laugh â for the first time in weeks, it startles you.
Ollie grins like heâs won something.
âThere she is,â he says
This past weekend, you've been staying with Dinah and Ollie, it was the perfect opportunity as Dick's on a solo mission with the Titans, Tim and Damian are with the Kents, Jason's with the Outlaws and Steph and Cass are preoccupied with Babs on girls night, they were gutted you couldn't come with, but they weren't gonna stop you from being with Ollie and Dinah. They knew how much you relied on them.
Star City feels wrong before you ever see it.
Itâs subtle at first.
The way the air hums just a fraction too loud, like the city itself is vibrating under your skin. The sky is clear, but it feels watched.
You stand on the balcony of Ollieâs penthouse, coffee cooling untouched in your hand, and you canât shake the sense that something is leaning toward you.
Waiting.
Dinah notices because Dinah always notices.
âYouâre doing that thing,â she says, leaning against the doorframe. Her voice is gentle, but her eyes are sharp.
You glance back. âWhat thing?â
âThe staring-into-the-middle-distance-like-the-universe-is-about-to-punch-you thing.â
You huff a weak laugh. âDidnât know I was that obvious.â
âTo me? Always.â She steps closer, her shoulder brushing yours. âYou been sleeping?â
You hesitate. Thatâs answer enough.
Below, Star City moves like nothing is wrong.
Cars. People. Normalcy.
It makes your teeth ache.
âI donât like this,â you say finally.
Dinah doesnât ask what this is.
âNeither do I,â she replies.
Inside, Ollieâs on the phone, voice low, humour stripped clean. When he sees your expression, he ends the call immediately.
âWhat,â he asks. Not joking. Not loud.
Just what.
âThereâs something in the Glades,â Dinah says before you can. âI can feel it.â
Ollie exhales through his nose. âMerlyn.â
The name lands like a bruise.
You straighten instinctively. âYouâre sure?â
âNo,â Ollie admits. âBut Iâm never wrong when it matters.â
The lights flicker.
Once.
Twice.
You all freeze.
That hum you felt earlier deepens, crawling into your bones, vibrating behind your eyes.
Somewhere far awayâtoo far to pinpointâmetal screams.
You donât say it.
But youâre already reaching for your gear.
The facility isnât marked on any public map.
It sits half-buried in concrete and steel, a scar stitched into the cityâs underbelly. The closer you get, the louder the sound becomes â not noise exactly, but pressure. Like reality being squeezed through a needleâs eye.
Your comm crackles.
âEnergy readings are off the charts,â Dinah says, voice tight. âThis isnât just tech.â
âNo,â you murmur. âItâs worse.â
The entrance yawns open, heat rolling out in waves. Inside, the air shimmers, bending light in ways your brain doesnât like. Your head throbs. Your teeth buzz.
Ollie draws an arrow anyway.
âGuess Merlyn decided subtlety was overrated,â he mutters.
You move ahead of them without thinking, instincts honed sharp by too much loss, too much responsibility. Nightingale moves like second nature â quieter than fear, faster than doubt.
The core chamber is massive.
Circular.
Wrong.
Spanning hundreds of metres in distance.
A machine dominates the centre, towering, spiralling rings rotating at different speeds, glowing with a violent, sickly light. Energy arcs between them, snapping like lightning with no thunder.
The air smells burnt, metallic, alive.
You gaze up at the machine
You hear Dinah swear softly. âThatâs a supercollider.â
"It's a particle accelerator. Merlyn failed with the last two, this one's gonna succeed." You say.
Ollie goes still. âYouâve gotta be kidding me.â
âI wish I was.â
At the far end of the platform, Merlyn waits.
He looks pleased.
âYouâre late,â he calls out, voice echoing unnaturally. âI was beginning to think grief had dulled your reflexes.â
Your hands curl into fists.
âYouâre going to shut it down,â you say coldly. âNow.â
Merlyn laughs.
âOh, child,â he says. âThis is the shutdown. Of everything.â
The machine pulses.
Harder.
Your knees buckle for half a second before you catch yourself.
Dinah grabs your arm. âYou okay?â
You nod, even though your vision is fracturing at the edges.
âSplit up,â Ollie says. âWe disable the outer rings.â
You donât argue.
You should.
But something in your chest is pulling you forward, toward the heart of the machine, toward the light that feels like it knows your name.
The closer you get, the worse it becomes.
Gravity wobbles.
Time hiccups.
Your footsteps echo twice, then not at all.
You swear you see movement in the light â shadows that donât belong to anything solid.
Your comm screeches.
âNightingaleâ!â Dinahâs voice cuts in and out. âSomethingâsâwrongââ
âI know,â you gasp.
Your head pounds. Images flash behind your eyes â Bruceâs smile. Damian asleep on your shoulder. Dickâs hand on your back. A coffin lowering into the earth. Another one. Parallel grief folding in on itself.
Merlyn steps into your path.
Up close, his eyes are fever-bright.
âDo you feel it?â he asks eagerly.
âThe strain? The walls between worlds thinning?â
You raise your guard despite the vertigo. âYouâre insane.â
âYes,â he agrees cheerfully. âBut Iâm also right.â
He gestures, and the machine surges.
You scream.
Not from pain â from everything. From the sensation of being pulled apart at a molecular level, of existing in too many places at once. Your knees hit the platform. You claw at the metal, gloves smoking where they touch.
Dinah shouts your name.
Ollie fires an incendiary arrow that disintegrates midair.
Merlynâs grin widens.
âYouâve been holding the universe together with grief and duct tape,â he says softly.
âYou were always going to snap.â
He grabs you.
For a split second, you think of your father.
Then he throws you.
You donât fall.
You are taken.
The world detonates into colour and sound and screaming light.
Your body is weightless, then impossibly heavy.
You canât tell where you end and the energy begins. The supercollider howls, rings spinning faster, fasterâ
Your thoughts fracture.
Is this how he felt?Is this how I die?Is this how I leave them?
Your mouth opens but no sound comes out.
Space folds.
Time screams.
You're shot into a myriad of electric webs, seas of blue with sparkling rope.
You see cities that arenât yours.
Skies wrong shades of blue.
Your atoms stretch.
Your soul lurches.
The last thing you feel before everything tearsâ
âis your name being ripped out of the universe like it was never meant to stay.
And thenâ
nothing holds you anymore.
You wake up on concrete.
Cold seeps through your suit firstâthrough the plating, through the kevlar, through whatever adrenaline is still clinging to your bloodstream like it knows itâs about to be evicted. Your vision swims. Light fractures overhead, neon signs bleeding into each other, letters doubling, then tripling, then snapping back into place.
Star City.
You know it instinctively. The smellâsalt, oil, rain. The hum of traffic a few streets over. The particular way the wind curls through alleyways like itâs learned the cityâs bones by heart.
But somethingâs wrong.
Your ears ring, a high, thin whine, like feedback after an explosion. You push yourself up on your elbows and the world tilts violently to the left.
Your stomach lurches. You swallow hard, breathing through it.
âNo,â you murmur. Your voice sounds wrong here. Too loud. Too real.
Your head throbs where it hitâwhen did it hit? The last thing you remember is light. Pressure. The feeling of being pulled apart and stitched back together incorrectly.
You sit up slowly.
The alley is narrow.
Brick walls on either side, damp with last nightâs rain. A flickering security light buzzes overhead. Thereâs a dumpster to your right, graffiti you donât recognize sprayed in angry red strokes.
You look down at yourself.
Nightingaleâs suit is scorched.
Hairline fractures spiderweb across the chest plate. Your gloves are blackened at the fingertips like you tried to grab the sun and lost. Your mask is still onâthank goodnessâbut the edge is cracked near your temple.
Your comm is dead.
Of course it is.
You try to stand.
Your ears ring as you push yourself upright, palms scraping against the ground.
Your hands stutter.
Not shaking. Stuttering.
Your fingers leave faint echoes behind them when you move, like afterimages burned into the air. You watch, horrified, as your wrist phases a fraction of an inch out of sync with the rest of you, snapping back with a sharp, nauseating jolt.
âOhâno,â you whisper. Your voice sounds like itâs coming from underwater. âNo, no, noââ
You stagger to your feet, back slamming against the wall as another wave of distortion rolls through you. It feels like pins and needles under your skin, like your atoms are being politely but firmly told they donât belong here.
Wrong Star City.
You squeeze your eyes shut and try to breathe through it.
In. Out. Slow. The way Bruce taught you. The way Dinah insisted on when your hands shook too badly to string an arrow.
Dinah.
Your eyes snap open.
They were just with you. Both of them. You can still hear Dinah shouting over the rising whine of the collider, still see Ollieâs hand gripping your shoulder, too tight, too scared.
You turn in a slow, unsteady circle, scanning the street beyond the alley mouth.
Pain explodes up your spine and you gasp, stumbling back against the wall. Your breath comes fast, shallow. Your heart is hammering, too loud in your ears.
âOkay,â you whisper to yourself. âOkay. Thatâs fine. Thatâsâfine.â
You squeeze your eyes shut.
Where are Ollie and Dinah?
They were just there. You can still hear Dinahâs voice in your head, tight with warning. Ollieâs hand on your shoulder, solid, grounding.
You open your eyes again and the alley is still empty.
No Green Arrow. No Black Canary. No humming supercollider tearing reality open behind you.
Just Star City.
But not your Star City.
You think of your family, of Dick, Damian, your siblings back home, you wonder if Dinah and Ollie notified them of you disappearance. The panic the two of them might be feeling, are probably experiencing.
But your thoughts return to your surroundings.
Of a different Star City.
You donât realise how deeply wrong it is until you hear footsteps.
Theyâre halfway down the block, arms full of nothing, the shopping bags long since abandoned back at the department store counter.
Dinah is mid-sentence, voice warm with something dangerously close to nostalgia, when Ollie stops so suddenly she almost runs straight into him.
âOllieâ?â
He doesnât answer.
Heâs staring down the alley.
Dinah follows his gaze, annoyance melting into something colder, sharper, the instant she sees the movement there. A figure braced against the brick, head bowed, armor catching the flickering streetlight in jagged flashes.
The air feels wrong.
Not tense. Not hostile.
Off.
âDo you see that,â Ollie says quietly.
Dinahâs fingers curl around his wrist without her thinking about it. âYeah,â she murmurs. âI do.â
The figure movesâand glitches.
For a split second there are two of them, offset by a fraction of space, before snapping violently back into one. Dinahâs breath catches hard in her throat.
ââŠThatâs not funny,â she whispers. âThatâs notââ
Theyâre already moving.
Not as Green Arrow and Black Canary. Not with masks and weapons and mission parameters.
Just as themselves.
Because whatever is happening in that alley, it feels personal in a way that makes Dinahâs chest ache.
You hear them before you see them properly. Footsteps approaching, voices cutting off mid-conversation.
You spin, adrenaline flaring sharp and hot, muscles screaming as you drop instinctively into a defensive stance. The world lurches again at the sudden movement, your balance wobbling as static skitters across your skin.
Two figures stand at the mouth of the alley.
Civilian clothes.
Dinahâs scarf. Ollieâs jacket.
The exact way Ollie stands when heâs relaxed but ready, weight shifted just so, hands loose at his sides.
Your heart slams into your ribs so hard it hurts.
ââUncle Ollie?â The words slip out before you can stop them.
Both of them freeze.
Dinahâs eyes widen, just a fraction. Ollieâs shoulders go rigid, like someoneâs just drawn a bowstring through his spine.
You take a step toward them.
The world breaks.
Your vision fractures into overlapping images, the alley stretching and folding in on itself as your body lags behind your intent. You gasp, clutching at your side as your outline shimmers violently, air cracking around you like displaced electricity.
âHey!â Ollie snaps, all instinct now. âDonât move.â
âWoahâwoah,â you say quickly, panic rising, hands lifting placatingly even as they leave ghostly trails behind them. âItâs me, itâs me, I swearââ
You rip your mask off.
For one awful, suspended second, no one moves.
Dinah feels like the ground has dropped out from under her.
Itâs you.
Itâs your face.
The same person sheâs scolded and laughed with , the same cheeks she's pressed kisses to when the world got too heavy. The same jawline, the same scar near your temple she remembers patching up herself.
But your eyesâ
Goodness.
Your eyes look like theyâve seen too much.
Not older, exactly.
Just⊠exhausted in a way sheâs never seen on you before.
Like sleep hasnât touched you properly in years.
Like grief has taken up permanent residence behind them.
There are fine lines of tension around your mouth that shouldnât be there yet.
Scars she doesnât recognise.
A weight to the way you hold yourself that makes her chest ache.
You look at them like youâre drowning and theyâre the only solid thing left in the world.
Ollie swallows hard.
ââŠKid,â he says, voice low, careful, like one wrong syllable might shatter you. âThatâs not possible.â
âI just saw you,â you say, breath hitching. âYou were there. Both of you. The colliderâDinah, you were yelling at Merlyn, and Ollie you told me to get back andââ
Your body spasms.
A violent ripple tears through you, your form blurring and splitting before snapping back with a sound like a gunshot. You cry out, dropping to one knee, nausea flooding your throat.
Dinah moves without thinking.
Ollie catches her wrist.
âDinah,â he says quietly. âOur kid is dead.â
The words sit there.
Heavy. Final.
You look up at him.
Something flickers across your faceâpain, old and sharpâbut it settles into something quieter, sadder.
ââŠNot on my Earth,â you whisper.
Silence.
Then Dinah steps forward anyway.
She stops just short of touching you, hands hovering inches from your shoulders, like sheâs afraid youâll glitch apart if she makes contact.
âSay that again,â she says softly. âSlowly.â
You explain.
Not cleanly. Not all at once.
Fragments spill out between breaths.
You come from a different Earth.
Different choices.
Bruce died instead of you.
Surviving things you werenât supposed to.
Merlyn. The collider. The moment everything went wrong.
Ollie listens without interrupting.
Thatâs how Dinah knowsâknowsâhe believes you.
Because with Ollie, disbelief wouldâve come loud. Defensive. Angry.
Your body glitches again, smaller this time but relentless, a constant shimmer at your edges like the universe is tugging at you, trying to pull you loose.
Dinahâs eyes fill with tears she doesnât bother to hide.
Ollie exhales slowly through his nose. âOkay,â he says. âOkay.â
She reaches for you.
Stops.
Looks at Ollie.
He nods.
Dinah pulls you into her arms.
The contact grounds you instantlyâand breaks something wide open inside your chest. You cling to her like sheâs gravity itself, fingers digging into her coat as another wave of distortion rolls through you. Dinah buries her face in your neck, inhaling the same smell that went with you everywhere.
Ollie joins a second later, wrapping both of you up, pressing his forehead briefly to yours.
âWeâve got you,â he murmurs, fierce and unsteady. âWeâve got you.â
For the first time since the collider, the world holds.
They donât ask where to take you.
Ollie doesnât even consider anything public.
The penthouse doors slide shut behind you, sealing out the city, and the quiet hits you like a wave.
Without the noise to anchor you, the wrongness comes roaring back.
The penthouse is different.
The kitchen and the living room have been swapped. Dinah and Ollie's wedding portrait looks different. Huh.
It's all a bit uncanny really.
It's the same house, same people, but there differences everywhere.
You think that's probably what they thought when they laid eyes upon you.
Your reflection in the glass windows flickers, lagging a half-second behind your movements. You sway, knees buckling as the room seems to tilt.
Dinah catches you before you hit the floor.
âEasy,â she murmurs, guiding you down onto the couch. âIâve got you.â
Your glitching worsens under the stillness. Your outline shimmers constantly now, like a bad signal. Ollie watches it with a tight jaw, arms crossed, eyes never leaving you.
âYouâre decaying,â he says.
You huff out a weak, breathless laugh. âYeah. That happens when youâre not supposed to exist somewhere.â
Dinah shoots him a look.
âWhat,â he says. âThatâs my way of panicking.â
She kneels in front of you, cupping your face gently, thumbs brushing beneath your eyes.
âWeâre going to fix this,â she says, voice steady despite the tears shining there. âYou hear me? We didnât survive losing you once just to do it again.â
Your throat tightens.
âStill bossy across universes,â you murmur smirking.
Her smile breaksâand she pulls you into another hug, holding you like sheâs afraid the universe might steal you back if she lets go.
She hugs you so tightly, it's so comforting.
You can tell she's been through a lot.
She still scratches your scalp the same way she always did, puts a hand behind your neck.
Some things never change, you guess.
The city outside keeps moving.
And for nowâ
Youâre still here.
Ollie doesnât pace when he dials.
He stands at the window of the penthouse, one hand braced against the glass, the other holding the phone like it might detonate. Star City glows belowâalive, oblivious, cruel in its normalcy. Dinah sits behind you on the couch, her arm draped around your shoulders, thumb tracing slow, grounding circles like sheâs afraid youâll slip out of existence if she lets go.
The call connects on the third ring.
âBruce,â Ollie says.
Thereâs a beat.
Then Bruce's voice, low, tired, restrained to the breaking point. âOliver.â
Ollie exhales through his nose. âI need you to listen. And I need you to stay calm.â
That alone is enough to make Bruceâs spine go rigid on the other end of the line.
âWhatâs happened?â Bruce asks. âIs this about Gotham?â
âItâs about your daughter.â
Silence.
Not the empty kind.
The dangerous kind.
The kind that means Bruce has gone very, very still.
ââŠWhich one,â Bruce says quietly. Asking even though he knows the answer.
Dinah closes her eyes.
âY/N,â Ollie answers.
The name hangs between continents.
Bruceâs voice drops. âThatâs not funny.â
âI know.â
âOliver.â
âIâm not joking.â
Another pause.
Longer.
He can hear Bruce breathing now.
Controlled. Measured. Like heâs already bracing for impact.
âSheâs dead,â Bruce says.
It isnât an accusation.
Itâs a statement. A fact carved into his bones.
âI buried her.â
Ollie swallows. âI know you did.â
âThen donât say her name like this,â Bruce snaps. âDonâtââ
âSheâs sitting on my couch,â Ollie says, cutting in. âSheâs alive. Sheâs hurt. And sheâs not from this universe.â
The words land wrong. Like broken glass in the mouth.
âYouâre going to explain,â Bruce says, voice razor-thin, âright now.â
âShe looks like her,â Ollie continues, slower now, choosing every word. âBut older. Tired. Like griefâs been living in her bones for a long time. She knows things she shouldnât. She called me uncle. She called Dinah aunt. Sheââ
âStop,â Bruce breathes.
âNo,â Ollie says. âYou need to hear this. Because she thinks you are dead.â
Bruceâs hand tightens around his phone so hard it creaks.
âIn her world,â Ollie says, âyou died on the same mission. Same explosion. They ruled it a suicide. Covered it up. Just likeââ
Bruce closes his eyes.
ââŠJust like we did with her,â he finishes hoarsely.
Dinah opens her eyes again, tears streaking silently down her face.
âSheâs decaying,â Ollie adds. âShe got into an incident with Merlyn and got shot into this universe, I think it's because this universe doesn't have Y/n in it. But it's like she doesnât belong here. Barry might be able to help, but right nowâright now she needs you.â
A long, broken breath on the other end.
ââŠIâm coming,â Bruce says.
âCome alone,â Ollie replies gently. âAs Bruce.â
The call ends.
He doesnât go to the cave.
He doesnât touch the Batmobile, doesnât pull on armour, doesnât look at the memorial wall. He takes the stairs instead of the lift, every step echoing too loudly through the manor.
The living room is full.
Theyâre supposed to be gearing up.
Half-suited, half-armed, irritation crackling through the air because patrol was delayed again.
But they're not. 'Cuz they're benched.
Damian is on the floor with Elizabeth Taylor curled against his thigh, pink bed dragged in like a quiet rebellion. Dick is mid-sentence, Steph sprawled across the arm of a chair, Tim cross-legged with a tablet, Jason leaning against the wall, Cass and Duke close together.
Bruce passes through them like a ghost.
âBruce?â Dick says, confused. âYou good?â
Bruce doesnât answer.
Jason straightens. âHey. Where are you going?â
Bruce stops at the door.
âI need to step out,â he says.
Damian frowns immediately. âFor what purpose?â
Bruce turns then.
His eyes land on each of them in turn, like heâs committing their faces to memory.
âItâs about your sister,â he says.
The room detonates.
âWhat?â Steph blurts.
Timâs tablet slips from his hands and hits the floor with a sharp crack. âBruceâ?â
Dick is already moving. âIs sheâdid somethingâ?â
âYou benched us, then you say that?â Jason snaps. âYou donât get to justââ
âEnough,â Bruce cuts in, sharper than intended.
Silence slams down.
âI will explain,â Bruce says, forcing steadiness into his voice. âLater. Alfred will stay with you.â
Damian rises to his feet, Elizabethâs leash still looped around his wrist. âFather. You are withholding critical information.â
Bruce meets his gaze.
It softens considerably.
He kneels to meet Damian.
âSon, I need you to trust me,â he says.
Damianâs jaw tightens.
He nods once.
Bruce leaves.
The front door closes behind him with a quiet finality that feels like another loss.
You donât mean to open the news.
You really donât.
But the penthouse is too quiet, and Dinahâs thumb has stilled on your shoulder, and Ollieâs gone tense in that way he gets when heâs bracing for bad timing. A tablet is in your hands before youâve fully registered it.
Your name is trending. It's been trending for weeks.
You stare at it, blankly, like your brain refuses to translate.
You tap.
Your face fills the screen.
Y/N WAYNE, DAUGHTER OF BRUCE WAYNE, DEAD.
Another headline.
Another photo.
A gala smile.
A candid shot with Damian scowling beside you.
Death ruled a suicide.
Your throat closes.
âOh,â you whisper.
Dinah notices instantly. âHeyâhey, sweetheart, what did you see?â
You tilt the phone toward her.
She sucks in a sharp breath.
You scroll numbly.
Edits. Tributes. Candle emojis.
She wouldâve been another year older today.
People arguing in comment sections about whether you were happy.
Whether you were lonely.
Whether you were âtoo gentle for this world.â
Your hands start to shake.
âIâm dead,â you say, distantly. âHere, I mean.â
Dinah pulls you fully into her chest now, arms locking tight. âI know.â
Your eyes burn. âThey said I killed myself.â
Ollieâs voice is rough. âThey didnât want questions.â
You nod slowly. âSame thing they did to my dad.â
The realisation settles like ash.
âThis isnât my universe,â you murmur. âI knew that. I justâI didnât think it would hurt like this.â
Your vision blurs. The glitching starts again, a faint stutter at the edges of your hands, like static crawling up your skin.
Dinah presses her forehead to yours. âYouâre okay. Youâre here.â
âAm I allowed to be?â you ask quietly.
Footsteps sound behind you.
The door opens.
Bruce Wayne, your father, stands in the threshold.
He looks smaller without the suit.
Older.
His eyes find you instantlyâand stop.
Time folds in on itself.
You look up.
Every breath has left your lungs.
Dinah and Ollie's gazes remain transfixed on you and Bruce staring at each other.
âDaddy?â you say, small and uncertain, like a child testing the edge of a nightmare. You stand, slowly.
Bruce crosses the room in three strides and pulls you into him, arms crushing, desperate, breath shuddering against your hair.
âOh my goodness, baby, youâre here,â he whispers. âYouâre real.â
You cling to him, fingers digging into his coat. âDaddy I missed you.â
He lets out a sound that might be a sob.
When he pulls back, his hands stay on your shoulders, grounding, trembling.
âYou shouldn't be here. My daughter is dead,â he says, voice breaking. âHere.â
You nod.
âI know. I saw.â
âAnd in your world,â he continues, forcing the words out, âI died.â
âYes.â
The symmetry is unbearable.
âThey said you overdosed,â you add softly. âSuicide. They couldnât tell the truth.â
Bruce closes his eyes. âWe did the same to her.â
Your chest aches.
âI buried you. I took over the company. Dick became Batman. Damianâhe needed someone. I stayed Nightingale. I just⊠hardened.â
Bruce cups your face gently. Smiling, even though the pain he's feeling is the worst he has ever felt, like stitches being ripped open again.
âYou shouldnât have had to.â
Your glitching worsens suddenly, static crawling up your arms.
Bruce notices immediately. His jaw sets.
âYouâre destabilising,â he says. âBarry can help. He understands this kind of physics.â
You nod, trusting.
Exhausted.
âI donât belong here,â you whisper.
Bruce pulls you into him again, softer this time.
âMaybe not,â he says. âBut youâre not alone. I promise sweetheart.â
You wrap your arms around his waist, feeling like he'll disappear at any second, but you savour this moment.
The moment lingers longer than it should.
Bruceâs hands are still on your shoulders, like if he lets go youâll flicker out completely. You can feel itâthe strange, itchy wrongness under your skin, the way the air doesnât quite agree with you.
Dinah watches it happen with a tight mouth. Ollie clocks it immediately.
âYouâre destabilising again,â Bruce murmurs, more to himself than anyone else.
You nod faintly. âIt gets worse when I think too hard.â
Bruce exhales, then straightens. The Batman slides back into placeânot the armor, not the voice, but the decisiveness.
âIâve already called Barry,â he says. âAnd I notified the Watchtower. Select members only.â
Ollie lifts an eyebrow. âYou trust them with this kind of stuff?â
âI trust them with her,â Bruce replies without hesitation.
That lands heavier than anything else.
Dinah squeezes your hand. âAlright. Then we move.â
She stands, already reaching for the hidden panel near the hallway. âWe suit up.â
You blink. âNow?â
Ollie gives you a soft, crooked smile. âKid, if youâre gonna glitch out of existence, youâre doing it somewhere with the best minds in the universe.â
Dinah disappears briefly and returns with something folded carefully over her arm.
Your breath catches.
Itâs a suitâbut not yours.
Not Nightingale as you knew her.
The silhouette is familiar, but refined.
Reinforced seams. Subtle gold threading worked into the black. A faint canary insignia worked into the inside lining, near the collar.
Dinah holds it out. âTemporary. Modified to stabilise your vitals. Barryâll do the real work, but thisâll help .â
You take it with trembling fingers. âYou didnât have toââ
âWe did,â Ollie says gently.
As you change, the penthouse hums with quiet urgency. Dinah and Ollie suit up too, muscle memory guiding them. When you step back out, fully masked, Bruce stops breathing for half a second.
Youâre Nightingale.
But older. Sharper. Tired in a way this worldâs Nightingale never had the chance to be.
Bruce approaches you slowly, like you might spook.
âYou ready?â he asks.
You hesitateâthen lean forward and hug him.
He makes a small, broken sound as his arms wrap around you, pressing his forehead to yours.
âI should go home first,â he says quietly. âI need to tell them, the kids deserve to know.â
You nod. âI know.â
You pull back just long enough to press a kiss to his cheek. He does the same to your hair, lingering.
âBe careful,â he whispers.
âYou too, daddy.â
He watches you go with Dinah and Ollie, something in his chest ripping open all over again.
Bruce drives home in silence.
The city lights blur past, reflections ghosting across the windows. His hands are steady on the wheel, but his thoughts are anything but.
Alive. Not his. Dead here. Alive somewhere else.
The manor looms ahead like a mausoleum.
Inside, the lights are on.
Alfred opens the door, welcoming him.
He walks ahead, trying to figure out a way to break the news to his children.
Too many of them. Voices carry faintly from the living roomâirritated, confused, restless.
He steps inside and all of them turn at once.
Cass's head perks up first, she nudges Duke who stops talking
âBruce?â Dick says immediately. âWhat the hell is going on?â
Jason pushes off the wall. âYou disappear and drop that line about Y/N like itâs nothingââ
Steph and Tim are already standing, eyes sharp, scanning Bruceâs face. âIs this about the Watchtower alert?â
Bruce turns his head because how did he have Watchtower alerts?
Damian is quiet.
Elizabeth Taylor sits at his feet, tail thumping nervously, like she knows what's up. âFather,â he says. âExplain.â
Bruce closes the door behind him.
He doesnât take off his coat.
He walks to the couch and sits.
That alone shuts them up.
âI need you all to listen,â Bruce says. âAnd not interrupt.â
That earns him a few looks, but no one speaks.
He swallows.
âY/N is alive.â
The room explodes.
âWhat?â Steph blurts.
Tim stumbles forward a step. âThatâs notâdonât do that.â
Jason laughs once, sharp and disbelieving. âThatâs sick, man.â
Damianâs breath hitches. âFatherââ
Bruce raises a hand. âShe is alive. But not our Y/N.â
Dead silence.
Dickâs voice is barely audible. ââŠWhat?â
Bruce exhales. âSheâs from another universe. In her world, I died. Same mission. Same explosion. They covered it up as a suicide.â
Tim pales. âLike we did to her here.â
âYes.â
Cass steps closer to Steph instinctively. Dukeâs hands curl into fists.
âSo she justâwhatâshows up?â Jason demands. âWearing her face?â
Bruceâs voice breaks despite himself. âShe called me dad.â
Damianâs composure fractures. âYou saw her?â
âYes.â
âWhere is she?â Damian asks immediately.
âThey're on their way to the Watchtower, her, Dinah and Ollie. They were the ones who found her.â Bruce says. âSheâs unstable. Barryâs working on something to stop the dimensional decay.â
Dick runs a hand through his hair, pacing now. âYou didnât bring her here.â
âItâs not safe yet.â
âFor who?â Jason snaps.
Bruce looks at all of them. âFor her. And for all of you.â
No one has an answer to that.
Only Elizabeth, who whines softly.
"Can we see her?" Duke asks,
"Eventually, I promise, let them get to the Watchtower, then we'll go." Bruce replies.
The Zeta-tube opens with a sound like the universe holding its breath.
Cold hits you first.
Not windâthereâs no air moving like thatâbut the kind of sterile, metallic chill that seeps straight through bone and settles behind your eyes.
The Watchtower always felt distant, even when you belonged here. Now it feels⊠vast. Hollow. Like a cathedral built for gods who forgot how to pray.
Below the transparent curve of the station, Earth hangs in silence.
Blue. Whole. Untouched by the fact that you died on it.
You take a step forward and your boots echo too loudly. Ollieâs already scanning the corridor, hand loose near his bow. Dinah walks just ahead of you, deliberate, protective without being obvious.
âYou good?â Ollie asks, glancing back.
You nod, even though the static under your skin prickles in warning.
âYeah,â you say. âJust⊠colder than I remember.â
Dinah hums. âItâs always like that your first time back.â
Back. You swallow.
The corridor stretches long and white and impossibly clean. As you walk, doors slide open. Heads turn.
John Stewartâfreezes mid-conversation, eyes widening as they land on you.
Hal stares like heâs seen a ghost. Because he has.
Zatannaâs hand flies to her mouth.
Shayera stiffens, her wings twitching.
Martian Manhunterâs gaze sharpens instantly, unreadable but heavy with recognition.
You catch Victor Stoneâs reflection in the glassâCyborgâs systems visibly lag for half a second as he recalibrates what heâs seeing. Even Aquaman, regal and unshakable, pauses.
Every step forward feels like walking through your own funeral. Whispers ripple behind you.
âThatâsââ âDidn't Bruce's kid pass?â âWait what-.â âIs this some kind ofââ
Ollie clears his throat loudly. âEyes forward, folks. Multiverse emergency. Nothing to see here except your own business.â
That gets a few embarrassed looks, but the staring doesnât stop.
You donât really blame them.
At the end of the hall, the doors to the Flashâs lab slide open.
Barryâs voice spills out first. ââtelling you, the math doesnât lie, if she destabilises againââ
He stops mid-sentence. Clark turns. Diana looks up.
For half a second, none of them move.
Clark is the first to break.
He tries. You can tell he tries.
His shoulders square. His expression smooths into something neutral, professional. Justice League Superman.
âNightingale. Y/N,â he says carefully. âItâs⊠great to see you.â
"Hi Uncle Clark" You reply softly
You barely have time to smile before he fails spectacularly.
In two strides heâs in front of you, pulling you into a hug so careful it almost hurts more than if heâd crushed you.
âOh,â he breathes, voice breaking. âOh, kid.â
Your arms come up automatically, pressing into his chest.
He smells the same. Sun-warm and familiar and devastating.
âJonathan really misses you,â he says softly into your hair. âHe keeps asking how your doing, forgetting that your uh-.â
Your throat closes, you cut him off. âI miss him too.â
Diana steps forward next, hands gentle as she cups your face, searching you with ancient eyes.
âYou are weary,â she says quietly. âMore than you should be.â
You let out a shaky laugh. âYeah. That tracks, thanks Aunt Di.â
Barry doesnât even pretend to be calm. He darts in, hugging you quick and tight, then pulling back just as fast, hands already hovering like you might fall apart if he blinks.
âOkay,â he says, voice wobbling. âWow. You lookâwow.â
âBad wow?â you ask.
âTired wow,â he corrects immediately. âLike youâve been carrying grief in a backpack with no straps.â
That hits harder than anything else.
Clark frowns. âSheâs dimmer.â
You blink. âDimmer?â
Barry nods. âNot in a bad way. Just⊠less light. Our Y/N wasââ He gestures vaguely. âSharper. Louder. You feel like⊠aftermath.â
You smile thinly. âYeah no shit. I watched my dad die.â
That does it.
The static spikes.
It starts in your fingersâwhite noise crawling up your hands, your vision stuttering like a corrupted video file. The floor feels too far away, then too close.
Dinah swears. âSheâs glitching.â
Your body flickers. Once. Twice.
âHeyâheyâhey,â Barry says quickly, hands on your shoulders. âStay with me. Donât fight it.â
You try to breathe and fail spectacularly as the world fractures.
Your arm phases through itself.
You gasp.
Clarkâs hands hover uselessly. Dianaâs jaw tightens.
âI need time,â Barry says sharply. âI can build something, but I need her stable now.â
âIâm trying,â you choke, and then your knees buckle.
The room dissolves into static
When sensation comes back, itâs softer.
Thereâs a band around your wristâwarm, humming faintly, like itâs alive. The static is still there, but muted. Padded.
Barry sits in front of you, goggles pushed up into his hair, eyes red-rimmed but bright with relief.
âParticle stabiliser,â he says proudly. âTemporary, but itâll hold you together.â
You flex your fingers. They stay solid.
âOh,â you whisper. âThatâs⊠better.â
He grins, exhausted. âYeah. Thought youâd like that.â
Dinah squeezes your shoulder. Ollie lets out a breath heâs clearly been holding for a while.
Across space, a notification lights up on Batman's display.
GLITCHING STABILISED. SUBJECT SAFE.
His hands tremble.
Wayne Manor is silent in the way only grief makes things silent. Bruce stands in the Cave, staring at the message like it might disappear if he looks away.
âSheâs stable,â he says finally.
Every head snaps up.
Dickâs breath catches. Tim and Cass are already moving. Jason swears under his breath. Damian looks at Duke and Steph, his eyes shine with something dangerous and hopeful.
âWeâre going,â Bruce says, voice ironed flat. âSuit up.â
And somewhere, kilometres away, your laughter rings down a Watchtower corridorâ
and the silence that follows it is so loud it hurts.
A/N: Praying that this doesn't flop (it probably will ngl) , it def needs a part 3 sorry guys, i was actually gonna include a scene where AU!Batsis meets the batfam of this universe, but i couldn't be bothered i was cracked out while writing this. also does anybody want a fic of batsis with uncle ollie and aunt dinah, also ik this shit is so ass but I'm so proud of myself for conjuring up 10000 words
Hope you all enjoyed this! Likes, comments, reblogs and requests are highly appreciated! Requests are open!
Dividers from @cafekitsune


















