California AG Leads Pushback Against Trump Attack on Transgender Healthcare
California Attorney General Rob Bonta has joined a coalition of 18 attorneys general urging a federal court to dismiss the Trump administrationâs lawsuit against the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), warning that the case threatens both transgender healthcare and medical freedom more broadly.
Attorney General Bonta (photo) and the coalition argue that:
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) seeks to undermine statesâ right under the Tenth Amendment of the Constitution to maximize the health and well-being of their residents by enacting laws and policies surrounding the practice of medicine.
The FTCâs efforts could damage the development of healthcare guidelines and policies beyond transgender healthcare and across multiple medical fields.
WPATH defends trans people
WPATH is an international professional organization whose Standards of Care provide evidence-based recommendations for healthcare for transgender and gender-diverse people. Its current Standards of Care 8 were published in 2022 and have become an important reference for clinicians, health systems and policymakers.
WPATH represents the views of practically all serious scientists and medical experts in the field of gender variance and transgender identities.
WPATH argues that transgender and gender-diverse identities are part of normal human diversity, rather than mental disorders in themselves.
The fact that they are fully accepting transgender identities (i.e. not seeing gender diversity as a mental illness) and are supporting the needs of trans people seeking medical health, undermines the Republican "gender ideology" narrative, where being trans is seen as some kind of deceit.
Ironically the transphobes argues that the views of the scientists on gender variance are unscientific, as it collides with the false and unscientific dogma of a strict binary "biological sex". They need to give the impression that science is on their side, and since it isn't, they have to silence the real experts.
Note also (as WPATH points out) that the U.S. Federal Trade Commission is not a medical provider and "has no place interfering with the process of individualized medical decision-making."
The Republican attack on free and fact-based research
The conflict began in January, when the Federal Trade Commission demanded extensive internal WPATH documents concerning the development of its guidelines.
WPATH challenged the investigation, and a federal court then blocked enforcement of the demand. After this the FTC joined Republican-led Alaska, Iowa, Nebraska and Texas in filing a new lawsuit on June 17, alleging that WPATH made misleading or insufficiently supported claims about gender-affirming healthcare for young people. This is nonsense.
This attack on free and fact based science is just one of many by the MAGA regime, all of them aimed at stopping universities, research institutions and medical service providers from (1) helping trans people with guidance and - if needed - medicines, surgery and other treatments, and (2) doing research that tells the true story about gender variance, gender incongruence and trans lives.
(A truly grotesque example of this is the way Texas has forced the Texas Childrenâs Hospital in Houston to pay US$10 million to the state and create a âdetransition clinic.â The crime? Providing science based health care for trans people.)
The Trump-regime wants to stop researchers from presenting the facts regarding gender variance, and in this way making it much harder to discuss this topic and defend trans people in public. The Trump-regime does not care about facts. These people only care about ideology and power.
It is good to see that these attorneys general understand the problem and are doing something about it.
Press release: Attorney General Bonta Opposes Trump Administrationâs Attempt to Suppress Healthcare Recommendations from Major Medical Organization
WPATH Statement on the U.S. Federal Trade Commission, Statesâs Announcement of New Complaint
USPATH & WPATH Condemn Decision in U.S. v Skrmetti Allowing States to Ban Access to Healthcare for Transgender Youth