⋮ ⌗ ┆You and Michael do best friends better than anyone.
╰┈➤ warnings/tags: unprotected, p in v, sub reader, soft dom Michael, dirty talk, spit play, nut facial, sexual nickname usage, pet names, angst, hurt but comfort, happy ending but a little of a open ending, kissing
Tags: @wisejudgedragonhairdo @michaelsfayvourite @kisscoqueen @t-o-pswifey @strawbevrri @onlyrebloggingprincess @swavydadon @vonxxivi @delicate-ray-of-sunshine @effervescentdeityofchaos @whyxo @megsnotokay
A/N: I wanted to take the time and thank everyone for supporting this blog and reaching 500+ in the span of a week, and we’re still growing! Y’all are very supportive of my work and I’m very very grateful. I love you guys so enjoy this filler post while I work on y’all request!
𝜗ৎ Bsf Michael and reader who are overly touchy with each-other and shameless about it. ⋆˚࿔
╰┈➤ The living room was quiet, bathed in the soft, flickering glow of the television screen. You were sprawled out across the couch, but instead of taking up your own space, you were draped comfortably over Michael’s chest, your legs tangled with his. The arrangement was intimate, toeing a line that felt far too blurred for "just best friends."
What made the setup undeniably provocative was where his hands had naturally settled—dug firmly into the soft curve of your ass. Whenever a tense scene flashed on the screen, his fingers would flex, using you as a literal stress ball to ease his nerves. When something was funny, he’d give you a light, playful smack before bursting into his signature giggles. He didn't have to touch you like this, but he did anyway, relying on his gentle, innocent persona to keep you from questioning his shameless motives.
Fortunately for him, you weren't complaining. Every time you felt his warm palm begin to drift away or loosen its grip, you’d let out a soft, needy whine.
"Keep it right there, Mikey," you’d murmur, sinking back against his warmth.
He’d let out a low, satisfied hum, his fingers instantly tightening back around you, stroking and squeezing as if it were the most natural thing in the world.
When the front door clicked open and his brothers strolled into the room mid-conversation, the chatter instantly died. The room went dead silent as they took in the sight of you practically fused to Michael’s upper body while his hands remained unabashedly planted on your backside. Marlon opened his mouth to say something, but before a single word could escape, Tito delivered a swift, brutal gut-punch to his midsection, folding Marlon over in pain.
Tito didn't even look back as he dragged his brother away, muttering under his breath, "Leave it alone, man. It’s not worth it."
𝜗ৎ Bsf Michael where he spoils the SHIT out of you⋆˚࿔
╰┈➤ Michael was a giver by nature—there was no denying that. Seeing a smile break across your face released a hit of dopamine in him that no award or applause could ever match. You were his favorite person, which meant you were the primary recipient of his endless generosity. Spontaneous shopping sprees, custom jewelry, rare finds—he lavished it all on you without a second thought.
At first, the sheer scale of his gift-giving made your stomach twist with guilt.
"Mikey, stop," you had protested one afternoon, staring down at a pair of red bottoms he’d casually bought you just because it was a Tuesday. Your lower lip pouted slightly as you looked up at him. "I feel like a leech. I’m mooching off you."
Michael had just laughed, stepping into your personal space and cupping your face in his warm palms. He pressed a soft, lingering kiss to your cheek, his breath warm against your skin.
"Baby, drop it," he murmured softly, his dark eyes shining with pure fondness. "I’m spoiling my girl, and you deserve nothing less than the best. Let me take care of you."
The sincerity in his voice dissolved your worry every single time, leaving you feeling cherished in a way no one else could ever manage.
𝜗ৎ Bsf Michael and reader who kisses often ⋆˚࿔
╰┈➤ It was common knowledge that Michael wasn't shy about physical affection. He was constantly kissing cheeks, throwing his arms around people, and planting peck after peck on friends at award shows or meet-and-greets.
You, however, got a completely different side of him. You got the heavy, unfiltered, one-hundred-percent version of his mouth.
That was usually how you ended up tangled in his bed late at night. Michael would hover over you, his knees nudging their way between your thighs, pinning you to the mattress as his mouth devoured yours. His tongue would slide against yours in a slow, possessive rhythm, tasting you deep and thorough.
When he needed to catch his breath, his lips would trail down your jawline to the sensitive dip of your neck. Open-mouthed kisses turned into heavy sucking, leaving hot, dark marks against your skin as his tongue licked a feverish path down your collarbone.
"Mmm, Mikey..." Your fingers dug into his broad shoulders, arching your back into his chest as heat pooled low in your stomach. The soft, helpless whimpers slipping from your throat acted like an intoxicating drug to him, driving him to press harder, lick deeper, and drag another moan out of you.
When he finally broke the seal of your neck from his lips to gasp for air, he refused to put any distance between you. He rested his forehead directly against yours, his hot, shallow breaths fanning over your flushed cheeks. His dark eyes scanned your face—taking in your disheveled hair, your swollen, bitten lips, and the needy haze in your eyes.
A low growl rumbled in his chest before he dove right back in for another round.
𝜗ৎ Bsf Michael and reader who refuses to talk about their feelings and actually confront the consistent issue of “what are we?” ⋆˚࿔
╰┈➤ As incredible as it felt to be worshiped by him, Michael’s behavior was completely messing with your head. The lines between a "best friendship" and an actual, exclusive relationship had been thoroughly erased, yet neither of you had ever put a label on what you were doing.
Naturally, you assumed that meant you were both technically single. So, when a handsome guy asked you out on a date, you decided to take him up on it.
Michael, predictably, lost his mind—even if he refused to admit it out loud. The idea of you speaking to another man, let alone letting someone else take you out, felt like a personal betrayal. He treated you better than any man ever could, so why couldn't you just see that you were his?
The inevitable clash happened on a late Thursday night. Fresh off your date, you drove over to the Hayvenhurst house, having already agreed to head to his place afterward per his request. You kicked off your heels at the entrance, carrying the designer red-bottom heels Michael had gifted you, and made your way down the quiet hallway to his bedroom.
You knocked softly, and the door swung open almost instantly with unnecessary force.
"Hi, baby. Come in," Michael said. He gave you a bright, tight smile that didn't reach his eyes.
You walked in and placed your belongings in the dedicated corner of his room—a space he had insisted you have since you were practically living there anyway. You sat at his vanity, unclasping your jewelry and letting the silence stretch between you until Michael finally cracked.
"Where were you tonight?" his voice cut through the air. It wasn't explicitly mean, but it was blunt, cold, and demanding.
"I was out on a date," you replied simply, looking at him through the mirror.
Michael rolled his eyes, crossing his arms over his chest. "Well, obviously. But with who?"
"Just a guy I met during one of my work shifts."
A low, dramatic whine escaped Michael’s throat. He hated that job—mostly because he had told you a dozen times that you didn't need it, constantly offering to pay your bills so you wouldn't have to spend time away from him.
"He was actually really sweet at first," you continued, intentionally keeping your tone light as you took off your earrings. "We went to this lovely Italian spot about ten minutes away, and he even got me these beautiful flowers..."
"Yeah, okay, I don't care," Michael snapped, cutting you off. "Why would you even go on a date in the first place?"
Your eyebrows pulled together as you turned around in your chair. "I didn't think going on a date was an issue? Why are you acting like this?"
"Like... this," you gestured vaguely between the two of you. "Whatever this mood is."
He rolled his eyes again, turning his back to you. "I’m not 'acting' like anything, thank you. At least I'm not keeping secrets from the people I love."
"What the—Michael, I literally just went on a single date!"
"I know, we’ve established that about twenty times already—"
"Jesus Christ, Michael! You do this every single time!"
The spark lit the powder keg, and the argument exploded into a full-blown screaming match. Hurtful words were hurled back and forth, fueled by months of unsaid feelings, confusion, and unspoken boundaries. After what felt like an eternity of trying to make him see reason, your voice finally gave out. You sank onto the edge of the bed, utterly exhausted—physically, mentally, and emotionally.
Walking the tightrope of your relationship with Michael was draining. You loved him fiercely, but trying to navigate his possessive hot-and-cold nature was becoming impossible.
"Michael, we’ve been going in circles for an hour," you breathed out, your voice dropping into a tired, raspy whisper. "This is so stupid. You’re acting like a spoiled brat."
Michael’s eyes widened in shock. He stepped toward the bed, towering over you and pointing an accusing finger down at your face.
"If anyone’s a selfish brat here, it’s you!" he yelled, his voice cracking with emotion. "I make sure you’re loved! I take care of you! I run myself ragged just to see a smile on your face—a smile you barely even wear half the time!"
That was the last straw. The exhaustion vanished, replaced by a surge of pure, unfiltered rage. You stood up, stepping right into his personal space, your face inches from his.
"You are the most childish, emotionally immature person I have ever met in my life," you spat, your tone lethal and cold. "Michael, I don't even ask for half the stuff you buy me! Just because you want to play house and act like my boyfriend when you won't commit to me isn't my fucking problem!"
"Thank God I'm not your boyfriend!" he snapped back defensively. "Why would I ever want to date someone as shitty as you?"
"Look in a damn mirror, Michael!" you yelled back, tears finally stinging the corners of your eyes. "Let's talk about who's actually shitty here! I'm not the one throwing tantrums because my best friend went on a date that had nothing to do with them! You make me feel guilty for the choices you make, and then expect me to worship the ground you walk on!"
You poked him hard in the chest, pushing him back a step.
"I carry my weight in this friendship too! I make sure you eat! I keep track of your schedules, your interviews, your rehearsals, and your family's birthdays because your forgetful ass can't even remember my birthday!"
The room went dead silent. The strike hit home, and Michael flinched as if you’d physically slapped him.
"I do everything for you, Michael," you choked out, the anger dissolving into raw pain. "So fine. Don't date me. I sure as hell don't want to be with someone who hides behind a victim mentality instead of facing his actual feelings."
Michael stood frozen, his mouth slightly open, completely stripped of a rebuttal. Every word you said was an undeniable truth. He had forgotten your birthday last year—a mistake that had eaten away at his soul, even though you had gently forgiven him on the spot, making excuses about how stressed he was with tour prep.
Seeing you stand in front of him now, your makeup slightly smudged from stray tears, hands trembling as your defenses finally collapsed, broke something inside him.
"I'm sorry," Michael whispered softly. The anger was entirely gone from his voice, replaced by absolute desperation. He stared down at the floor, unable to meet your eyes. "I... I get so caught up in my head. I don't think before I speak. I should’ve been happy for you, or just talked to you normally, instead of acting out of bitterness."
You remained silent, wrapping your arms tightly around yourself as you listened.
"You're not a shitty person," he continued, his voice trembling as he stepped closer. "I am. I don't do things for you just to hold them over your head, but I did tonight, and I'm so sorry. Anyone who gets to date you would be the luckiest person alive... but the truth is, I can't stand the thought of anyone else holding you. It’s supposed to be you and me, baby. I need you. Your Mikey needs you more than anyone else in this world."
"Then why couldn't you just tell me that from the start?" your voice cracked, soft and broken. "You can't expect me to read your mind, Michael. You don't give me a reason to stay."
Michael opened his mouth, but no sound came out. He didn't have a logical defense. The unspoken arrangement had worked for so long because neither of you had dared to dig up the root of the problem.
The silence returned, heavy and suffocating. You looked at him, feeling a hollow ache in your chest. The irony of the whole night was that the date had been awful—the guy was rude, arrogant, and you hadn't even liked him. You had come over to Hayvenhurst eager to laugh about it with Michael, change into his oversized clothes, cuddle up on his chest, and fall asleep in the arms of the only man you actually wanted.
Instead, you were standing in the wreckage of a massive fight.
Unable to take the tension any longer, you walked over to the corner of the room, kneeling down to gather your discarded bag, shoes, and jacket.
Michael’s eyes went wide with panic the moment he realized what you were doing. "Stay—please, stay."
You didn't look back at him, keeping your spine straight as you held your shoes. "Why?"
"Let me show you," he pleaded, his voice dropping into a low, vulnerable whine as he closed the distance between you. "Let me show you how badly I want you. How badly I need my baby back. Please don't leave me tonight."
A wave of heat surged straight through your veins at the tone of his voice. You hadn't wanted to leave in the first place; all you had thought about all night was the feeling of his hands on your skin, the taste of his mouth, and the feeling of his weight over yours.
You dropped your belongings back onto the floor with a soft thud. Slowly, you turned your head back toward him, your eyes locking onto his.
"Unzip my dress then, won't you?"
𝜗ৎ Bsf Michael who gives you the best makeup sex ever and makes sure you know how sorry he is⋆˚࿔
╰┈➤ "Oh my God, fuck me, Mike—fuck me!" you wailed into the quiet room, your hands frantically gripping the satin sheets.
Michael had you pinned on your back, one of your legs draped over his broad shoulder while he drove his hips forward, burying himself deep inside your wet heat with relentless, powerful thrusts. Every hit was precise, striking the exact spot that made your vision go blurry with stars.
"Yeah?" Michael’s voice rasped in your ear, dripping with a condescending, filthy tone that sent shivers down your spine. "You're taking it like such a good girl, aren't you?" He leaned down, placing one heavy palm flat on your lower stomach to push himself even deeper into you, his other hand gripping the headboard above your head. "Fuck... this pussy is so tight, mama. Gripping my dick like it belongs to you."
"It does—ah! Mikey, please!"
He stuttered his hips for a brief second, setting a bruising pace as he slammed into you over and over. "Who does this dick belong to, baby? Is it all the way inside you? No one else gets to touch this pussy. Only mine."
You nodded frantically, your French manicured nails digging deep into his back, leaving red, stinging scratches across his skin.
"He couldn't fuck you like this, could he?" Michael growled softly, biting at the sensitive skin of your neck. "He can't make you scream like this. Tell me I'm the only one."
"Yes! Yes, Michael, only you!" you screamed, your head tossing back against the pillows. "Fuck, baby, you're so deep..."
"Yeah, I'm deep in it, mama," he breathed heavily, his shallow, fast thrusts driving you right over the edge. "Gonna leave my mark inside you..."
Your heart fluttered wildly, your walls clenching around him so tightly that Michael groaned aloud, his pace growing frantic.
"Oh, you like that?" he teased, a devious smirk touching his lips as he watched your undoing. "You want my nut so bad, don't you? Want to make me a daddy?"
The word slipped out before you could stop it, but Michael clearly loved it. The sudden shift in power gave him another burst of energy, the wooden headboard thumping rhythmically against the wall with every punishing drive of his hips.
"Cum for me, daddy! I need it!" you sobbed out, completely overwhelmed by the intense pleasure.
"That's it, take it for your best friend," Michael whispered, his voice dark and intoxicating as he pulled your other leg around his waist, locking you flush against him. "Good girl. You take my dick so well."
"It's yours, Mikey... fuck me, cum inside me!"
"Yeah? Gonna cream all over it, mama? Let me feel it," he murmured, leaning over you. "Open up for me."
You instinctively opened your mouth, and Michael spat directly onto your tongue. You looked him straight in his dark, heavy-lidded eyes and swallowed it down before opening up again, silently asking for more.
Michael let out a low, breathless laugh, his gaze dark with possessive pride. "Such a filthy little girl. You like that? How about you take my nut next, huh?"
The thought alone sent you over the precipice. Your eyes rolled back, your back arched off the bed, and your entire body shuddered as a violent orgasm ripped through you, milking him mercilessly.
"Oh, shit—no warning?" Michael gasped out, fucking you straight through your climax until he couldn't hold back any longer. He abruptly pulled out, trailing his hands over your thighs. "On your knees. Tongue out."
You scrambled into position without hesitation. Michael gripped his length, stroking himself fast and hard right in front of your flushed face.
"Take it all, baby," he groaned out, his head throwing back as a deep, guttural moan tore from his throat. He came heavily across your tongue and face, stroking through the final spurts until he was completely spent.
Breathing heavily, he looked down at you like you were the most beautiful piece of art he’d ever seen. He leaned down, cupped your chin, and lifted your head to press a series of soft, sweet pecks against your messily covered lips.
"You'll always be my baby," Michael whispered into the quiet darkness of the room, pulling you against his chest as you both caught your breath. "My best friend."
There was no formal confession, and maybe there never would be. But as you rested your head against his beating chest, wrapped safely in his arms, none of that mattered. You belonged to each other, completely and utterly—and really, what else were best friends for?