Since I’ve been rewatching Grimm, I’m reminded of one of my least favorite fan complaints about poor Juliette Silverton. Namely that she is “useless”.
Leaving aside the fact that a female character should have more value than just what she offers to a male character, even if he’s the main character of the show, this complaint always bothered me, because Juliette really couldn’t win no matter what she did.
In season 1, she had no idea what a Grimm was. That’s on Nick, who, much as I love him, really has a problem with letting his friends and allies know exactly what’s going on even when it affects them directly. (See also: Hank and Wu.). So how the fuck was she supposed to be useful if she didn’t know what was going on?
That said, she still managed to be pretty useful when Nick was trying to make the street kids comfortable in Orphan Grinder so he could get information about the one that turned up dead. She’s the one who reached out to the abused bird woman when they were on vacation together. She’s the one who noticed the Eisbiebers watching the house, leading to Nick’s confrontation and subsequent befriending of them.
In season 2, she was amnesiac and subjected to a very nasty obsession curse on the part of Adalind. This wasn’t Nick’s fault, but it was because of him. That said, she still willingly acted as a Spanish language interpreter, and saved Nick from the Musai’s influence. So even in this case, she was “useful”.
I remember, by the way, getting into arguments on TWOP and similar forums because I dared to suggest that, as a veterinarian, Juliette’s knowledge and expertise might actually come in handy when it came to dealing with people who were also ANIMALS. (This was apparently insulting to Wesen, per the people I was arguing with.)
I was vindicated by season three however. Season three was the season where Juliette actually knew what was going on, and she was useful in damn near every storyline. She’s the one who figured out how to disseminate the zombie cure in that story-arc. She helped lie to cover up for Nick once he was cured. She figured out why the Blutbaden victims’ stomachs were exploding at that restaurant. She translated again, and explained El Cucuy. She’s the one who diagnosed the Grauser, who would usually have been killed for being “possessed.” In the meantime, she regularly assisted in research at the trailer, acted as a sounding board, helped Nick make contact with his mother, helped protect Adalind and the baby (when they appeared uninvited on her doorstep! After everything Adalind had done already!), and helped Nick with Trubel, housing the girl in her own home.
In season four, Juliette had her own problems. And don’t get me started on the people who use the fact that she “went dark” against her, when we KNOW how that happened. Remember? She was helping to cure her boyfriend, who had lost his powers after being raped by the character these fans tend to like better?! And hey, repowering Nick ought to count, right?
The thing is, Juliette shouldn’t have to be “useful” to justify her existence. But if we are looking at that criteria, then during the one season where Juliette knew what was going on and was in her right mind, yes, she was very useful.
But let’s be fair here. Most of the people who complained about Juliette’s “uselessness” were Adalind fans. And compared to the woman who raped Hank, tried to use Hank’s life to blackmail Nick into getting her a key, put Juliette in a coma, bespelled Juliette and Renard to become obsessed with each other, seduced Renard while he was under the influence, sold her unborn child to get her powers back, reneged on the deal, tried to get Renard to kill Nick, repeatedly betrayed everyone she ever allied with as soon as she felt like she was in danger, or could get what she wanted another way, and then raped Nick in the guise of Juliette to take his powers away, I can see why Juliette’s usefulness is in question.