Idk What To Do

.

.

BBH hinted that its not just ONE person but a group of individuals, and the only people we’ve seen be “unaffected” by it is Ranboo and Tommy. Tubbo WAS affected by the egg, but instead of hating/liking it, he feared it and it made him cry.

Death was permanent in Tales of Mizu. Once the characters died, it was instant death. No 3 lives.

We don’t know how resurrection works in the SMP, in The City That Went Mad, death was permanent. So at some point before the original members joined, something happened to where each character was allowed 3 lives before death. What could that be? The book.

Dream said that if he dies, death would be permanent because only HE knew how to do resurrection properly. Which means that Dream could be a reason as to why each individual has 3 lives, but then you realize that Shlatt gave him the book during the Marburg v. Pogtopia War.

But if the book is a major key to resurrection (as well at the totems) then how were they able to keep their 3 lives before Shlatt gave the book to Dream? Shlatt wasn’t part of the server, so he didn’t have any influence. So...what if he found it when he was in the server? He bought it/stole it from someone or something/whatever and then gave it to Dream as a bargaining tool?

The book was created after the events of The City That Went Mad. It allowed that once a person died they had a choice. A chance once again in life to finish their goals, but if they die three times their chance is over. Along with this, if someone knew how to properly work the book they had the ability to resurrect even after permanent death. If Mizu takes place in where death is now permanent, something happened to the book. It was destroyed. This timeline is possibly the “bad end” of the server, since time is like a tree and each branch/twigs are different possibilities and what if’s (that Karl has the ability to travel)

Confirmed time traveler Karl who is progressively losing his memory. He’s found a hidden way of doing it, cause if he was a species who were made for this ability, it wouldn’t be a side affect. I can’t WAIT to see how this story arc goes. What was interesting to me is, is Karl seeing all this through the eyes of the “characters” in the “stories”? Cause when he died, everything went black then we’re back in the current present through Karl’s eyes. This could explain why he’s losing his memory. He’s repeatedly becoming someone else, becoming an entirely different being with their own memories/thoughts/opinions which could be factoring his own and making him slowly forget who HE is as a person. I’m also wondering if this ‘K’ person from the first book was Karl himself who set this story? Would we have moments have multiple Karl’s from different time lines seeing each other?

Based on the fact Dream had a secret room in the city implies he was never a citizen of it in the first place, and was probably the one who was poisoning the food supply. This also means that at some point, he’s either freed/escapes the prison and was never caught since. This could also possibly explain why Ranboo’s descendants idolized him? He had close contact with them and was manipulating them? For 100 years of generations in the city, it was only Ranboo’s generation that survived. Why? (This is just speculation tho)

Every book of this story was the complete opposite of the truth. Oddly enough, in my opinion, there wasn’t much about Tommy. For someone who Ranbob said was “very important” when mentioned, there were no books about him and who he was in the story expect he shared a room with Tubbo and was Tubbo’s “side kick”. I find that very odd since Tommy is an important character in the SMP and in Dream’s story. This could mean for whatever reason any major notes about Tommy were completely destroyed or not written.

I don’t think BBH’s room was part of the egg, since if it were we would see vines. This could’ve just been a design choice for his colors. This means at some point in the future he and Skeppy are brought back to normal.

Finally a question that’s still in my mind is, why was the city built in the first place? What drove them into the depths of the ocean in the first place? And why was it only Ranboo/George/Karl/Sapnap/Fundy/Tubbo/Tommy/Dream/BBH/and Skeppy? I understand Karl didn’t want to make rooms for the WHOLE SMP. That would take FUCKIMG forever, and I think that might’ve been a part. But I feel there’s a bigger story as to way they all went underwater and not everyone else.

Also the few minute glimpses of Techono joining the server is most likely a confirmation that he’s immortal and “never dies”