Max found himself cherishing her every touch and missing it as soon as it was gone. He wished that he could take it back, all of the things he’d done, maybe even start fresh. He wondered how things would go if he knew what he knew now and they could go back in time to when they first met, relive the things that they already had and do things differently.
“Of course you care,” he mumbled under the touch of her thumb, eyes fixed on hers. “I’d be offended if you didn’t care. People deserve… they deserve more than what I gave you. Everyone does.”
He glanced down to his lap, a heavy sigh escaping.
“Billy,” he repeated, lips wet with the way his tongue had brushed over the harsh chapped skin there. “You’re really with him, huh? You’re staying with him?” he asked, running a hand over his face.
Of course he did. Once you opened up that pandora’s box, it was hard to get it closed again, as if it was filled beyond the recommended line.
“Fuck Billy,” he said, shaking his head. He wanted to get angry. He wanted to throw something, punch something. His fists clenched around the sheets again, but he breathed through it, knowing it’d only startle Bradley, make her uneasy around him again. That was the last thing that he wanted.
“God, this just – it sucks… I’m sorry.”
He reached a hand up, placing it gently at her cheek, fingers caressing against the soft skin. He wished he could wipe away the bruising, make it go away.
“I love you,” he mumbled, lips pressed tightly together into a thin line as he glanced down between them. More than anything, he just wanted to close the gap, but he didn’t know if he had that kind of privilege anymore. Instead, he just found his hand wandering, lightly brushing over the skin of her neck to her collar bone and down her shoulders, brushing gently along her lower back.
“And I miss you. And… fuck Billy. He doesn’t have to know.”
“Yeah,” she exhaled, tone as irritably monotonous as a child forced to recite their five times tables in front of the rest of the class. “We live together and everything.”
Cracking a small smile like she’d just told a joke worthy of the five star comedy circuit, Bradley’s lips subconsciously parted as she stayed as still as set cement beneath his touch.
“It’s kind of the most serious relationship I’ve ever had, I guess.”
Pressing her mouth shut again, she swallowed down the urge to sigh and allowed her eyes free roam to wander his face, instead.
“My dad likes him, you know? He likes him. I don’t really--... I mean, that’s probably a fucking bad thing. I don’t know.” Wetting her lips, her stare shifted down between them as she searched for the words. “The last time he found out I was dating someone he got Marco to kick his front teeth down his throat. It’s an improvement.”
Fiddling absently with the moth bitten hem of her band t-shirt, she tugged it as casually as she could to cover the blotchy shape of a scar sitting high up on her thigh, shoving the sight of it away in her mental closet along with the rest of her skeletons. Billy’s lips had been infected with a grin for a whole afternoon, once, at how angry she’d gotten when he poked fun at them. Sometimes when she looked at them she could still hear how hoarse his throat was, a tittered “what, were you on bath salts trying to dig to fuckin’ China, or something?” echoing off of high ceilings as he sank back into cheap cotton sheets snorting to himself.
“He’s--...” she trailed off, wanting to finish with “not so bad” but not quite being able to stomach a lie of that magnitude. “He’s Billy. Whatever. I don’t--... I don’t fucking know what you want me to say about it, anyway.” Jaw clenching with the gut reaction to preemptively defend herself, her eyes flit aimlessly around the room away from him. “He’d try to fuck me either way, so. May as well...” Swallowing softly, she pitched a limp shrug like she wasn’t at all affected, like she was commenting on something as mundane as the morning weather report. “I may as well want him to, okay? I don’t want to talk about it. I don’t--I don’t want to fucking talk about it. If you’re just going to judge me, well... You can just fucking eat my ass and fucking not.”
Pulse insistently throbbing as she averted a bleary stare, she had to swallow to compose herself again as the tips of his fingers explored the small of her back.
“Sometimes,” she started after a significant delay, hesitance clear in the way she bit her tongue before meeting his eyes again.
The tension in the air between them was so thick that she was left wishing she’d brought a butcher’s knife to hack through it with.
“Sometimes I’d try to just pretend it was you but he’s--... It’s not the same. He acts like he’s manning a fucking mechanical drill half the time.”
Fingers straying along the waistband of his boxers, she tried to fool herself into believing she was merely investigating the softness of the fabric. An innocent act of curiosity without any ulterior motive.
“So it’s fucking... annoying. Can’t even close my eyes and imagine something different because he’s thrashing around like a fucking shark on land,” dissolved into a half laugh, lips wrestled together to contain it before it could linger for too long.
“I have to wait until I get in the shower,” she sighed, head angling onto a slight slant as she studied him, while the middle finger of her left hand continued in a casual path up her inner thigh that she wasn’t even conscious of having started.
“Wait, is that going to piss you off?” Hand having slipped beneath the elastic of her underwear, the rigid press of her knuckles created peaks and dips through a thin layer of cotton, a makeshift Himalayan mountainside buried between subtly freckled thighs. “I won’t talk about him any more, if you want. It’s just that he was sitting twiddling his thumbs in the next room while I was thinking about you,” she explained casually, hips shifting ever so slightly forwards as she mercilessly taunted her poor self control, “so he’s kind of relevant. You know, to set the scene. I take storytelling really seriously, Max.”