In defense of Ais (preview spoilers):
I've noticed controversy about Ais' character in the preview which I've been surprised about. Ais is a consistent character thus far in my opinion. Because of common criticism I thought why not make my own case for Ais.
I believe the marketing of the game always had Ais as a dominant kind of character, and this was driven home in the demo. That was always supposed to be his archetype and that was always the appeal. So I was surprised when I saw people genuinely complaining about the way he was acting in the preview. If anyone finds it corny or a little cringe that's completely fair and I see where you're coming from, and to some extent can agree, it just doesn't necessarily mean that something is poorly written.
In addition, I saw some felt the mark was missed in comparison to the demo, and I disagree. He had the same short way that he speaks combined with the same demeanor as in the demo.
In his character card it says that he "lets his emotions rule him". We see that if he feels a certain way in the moment he will act on it. If he feels genuinely annoyed with the mc in the moment he's likely to express that. This is a major character flaw that I can see potential development in where he learns to actually have some self control, for his own sake and also being cognizant about the way he reacts to the people around him he cares about.
Some people expressed the distaste of Ais going to the brothel and the implication that he might have gotten services there. I somewhat agree and disagree. I agree in the way that if he were real, I'd be turned off and disgusted. But this is a fictional world where sex work and receiving those services aren't taboo or potentially inherently exploitative in a way that mimics the real world. In TS it seems like a gray area, rather than reprehensible which I think adds to the already questionable morality that Ais has, combined with the loneliness he said he hates. Even with all that said, if you hated this and don’t fw Ais anymore because of this scene that is justified.
Speaking of Ais' loneliness, a lot of people felt like the pacing was way too fast for the preview in general (it was) but I think for a character like Ais it can work. Remembering that he is lonely and craves connection which causes him to get attached far too easily; what was basically a confession to the mc toward the end of preview before he goes cold, makes sense for him to do. He felt like he was losing the mc, someone who at that point- did not know the full scope of how violent and brutal he can be, in addition to unpredictability as said in another character card:
This shows the viewers where Ais is mentally (ill), with how he is already attached and drawn to the mc- who wasn't so naïve to not point out that they only just met. By the end of the demo he becomes extremely distant towards the main character and tells them not to talk to him again unless they’re ready to drink from the spring. Probably because he doesn’t want the mc to be around him when he loses control of his own body to Ocudeus, who is possessing him. This is where that unpredictability comes in again, because just minutes prior, he was seeking out the mc.
I used character cards that RSS made years ago and I usually wouldn't use information that viewers would have to find outside of the immediate material, but from the little I know about these kinds of games, promo character cards are normal to introduce the character and reference, correct me if I'm wrong.
I also think part of the issues with many fans finding the characters have become inconsistent is the large time gap of canon content that puts a lot of fans in a position where we'll just kind of forget. I don’t think Ais was poorly written, I think the writing in the preview could have been better if this is what is what to be expected from his actual route, if you catch my vibe.
I'm not the least bit worried about the direction RSS is taking with Ais. He is the first character they made and he is front and center in almost every cover piece that's like... their golden child. I'm not saying writers can't fuck up their own characters because I've definitely seen some crazy character assassination before, I'm just saying that as of now, I'm not concerned about RSS doing that. now i'm dick riding. Whatever.
Feel free to weigh in with your own opinions and interpretations. I'm genuinely interested to hear them, especially if you didn't like Ais in the preview, I'm not here to argue.