Oneida- Joel Miller x Reader
đžđ·đźđČđđȘ- (4.7k words)
Relationship: Joel Miller x Reader
Summary: Joel tries to break up with you, only wanting the best for you.
Warnings: a pet goes missing but HE IS FOUND SAFE I PROMISE!!!! angst, breakup, joel is insecure sad face, pinv sex, as usual not beta read
Authors Note: this came to me randomly one afternoon and I wrote most of it hiding in the bathroom from my family. enjoy! also idk what currency system is used in jackson so pretend its coins or something idgaf
ps. title is from a tyler childers song lol
pps. yes ted is named after ted garcia. yes im patting myself on the back for that one
Joel Miller was stubborn man. So stubborn, in fact, that he hadnât spoken to you in days.Â
Very mature, the silent treatment.Â
The man who you considered your boyfriend despite never making things official, the one whoâs house you spent most of the time in anyway, who you had fallen in love with over the course of the years youâve known him.Â
The one who snapped at you all of the sudden, calling you clingy and micromanaging, telling you to give him some space. Telling you that you were too young and naĂŻve. Telling you that this wasnât working anymore.
You swore you could see the sadness in his eyes, despite his words being so harsh and painful.
Youâd stayed in your house since. You were thankful that you hadnât yet officially moved into his, or else this whole situation would be a lot more difficult to navigate.Â
As it stood right now, though, you were left wondering what you had done wrong, why he was so mad at you.
Joel was a man of few words, but you had always been fairly good at picking up on his cues. If he needed some alone time, silently working at his woodworking desk on a particularly hard day, or after a fight with Ellie.Â
But he would always gravitate back around to you, even if he didnât verbalize any of it. You felt it in the way he would kiss your cheek after when you made him dinner, appreciating that you let him be without him having to ask.Â
Clingy. Micromanaging. The words clunked around in your head, painful reminders of the things you hadnât seen. Even words he didnât say, but your own mind supplied, convinced that youâre driven him away. Annoying. Too much. Useless.Â
The days had been tough.Â
You attempted to communicate. You showed up the next morning, his favorite pumpkin bread in tow, wanting to talk. He had his boots laced up and shook his head. Told you to get lost, that he had to go on patrol.
It was an enigma. It was heartbreaking. You felt like you were in the twilight zone.Â
You cried as you walked home, pumpkin bread left on his porch as you hugged your arms close to your chest, feeling like it might cave in. It was embarrassing. You were certain that people could see and hear, and you just wanted to disappear.Â
Youâd shut yourself in, then. The only thing that brought you comfort and a molecule of joy was the stray cat that seemed delighted that you returned after spending so much time at Joelâs.
See, youâd always had a soft spot for animals. Even before Jackson, before the apocalypse, you were content with having plenty of cats and dogs to keep you company. Finding out Jackson had their own share of stray cats to keep the rodents away made you fall in love on the spot.Â
One particular cat was a skinny orange thing, whom you lovingly titled Ted. Ted was weary, but you were smart. You knew cats, despite yourself having more energy of a dog- loving of everyone you met and deeply emotional.Â
You left food out for him every morning and night when you could. Sometimes it wasnât much, just some leftover meat scraps or whatever you could afford to scrounge up, but it was enough for him to trust you, and to return to your backyard most nights and mornings.Â
You got attached quickly; despite knowing it wasnât a good idea. Ted, as cats often do, came back every night and every morning when he heard the back door open, chirping as you set the bowl down.Â
Joel even knew about Ted. It was one of the biggest reasons youâd been hesitant to move into his house. You were worried Ted wouldnât understand and would go hungry. Joel laughed softly but nodded and said he understood.Â
Ted let you pet and love on him eventually, too. You attempted to keep him as a pet, but as most stray cats are, he enjoyed having time to roam around outside- although he did enjoy snuggling with you on the couch at nights. You settled on a pet hole in the back door. Joel even installed it for you, despite his mumbles of how it was a bad idea and how youâd wake up with a raccoon snuggling against you instead. You just grinned and said the more, the merrier.Â
Ted stayed with you that day, when you came back in tears, an absolute mess. He could sense your anguish, and climbed onto your back as you sobbed into the sofa.Â
You werenât able to do much. You didnât have the heart or energy to cook for yourself. You gave Ted the salmon that was supposed to be for you, and passed out on the couch.Â
On the second day of nothing from Joel, you felt like a ghost.Â
You hated it. You hated that you let a man affect you this much. You hated falling for him so quickly, when he seemed so quick to just brush you off. You thought about waiting around to find Ellie, ask her what the fuck was going on, but you didnât want to seem like a stalker.Â
It was the ambiguity that hurt the most, though. You saw no signs. There was no giant fight or impasse that the both of you had reached. Just sudden coldness, like you were hit by a violent snowstorm in the middle of summer, and frostbite was beginning to take over.Â
You try to go outside that afternoon, convincing yourself that the sunshine and fall air would somehow cure your devastation.Â
It didnât, so you ended up sobbing into your hands in your backyard.Â
Ted, of course, was simply happy to be back outside, and the last thing you notice is him slipping away, slinking under the fence.
You sigh. You couldnât blame him. You were a pretty sad sight. It was almost ironic and made you laugh a little. No man wanted to be around you anymore.Â
You spent the rest of the day wandering around your house like a ghost. You were starting to run low on groceries, and you eventually would have to get back to your chores around town.Â
That night was quiet. Ted hadnât returned yet, which didnât necessarily worry you. He usually stayed gone until you set his food out, and even sometimes later.Â
You forced yourself to eat something. It was small, just some oatmeal and an apple, but it was all you could stomach. You set out the leftover salmon for Ted and went to bed.Â
Day three. Absolutely nothing from Joel. You hoped that you would suddenly hear a knock on your door, Joel with those big puppy dog eyes holding your favorite flowers and falling to his knees to apologize.Â
Of course, it didnât happen.Â
You would have to re-introduce yourself back into society today. You wondered if Maria and Tommy had known about the whole thing, and thatâs why Maria hadnât come knocking your door down to grill you on why you werenât helping in the kitchen or garden.Â
Along with that, your groceries were getting grim, and although you didnât care as much for yourself, you wanted to feed Ted.Â
That was when it hit you, when you looked out the window. His food bowl was untouched, still filled. There was no sight of him either.
Your heart dropped to your feet, but you tried to swallow the fear. Cats do this, you told yourself. Heâs probably just sleeping in the barns.Â
You shakily replaced his food, trying not to freak out. He would show up again, and you would feel stupid for worrying. Itâs what cats were best at.Â
By the time the sunset, Ted hadnât shown his whiskered face around, his food remaining untouched.Â
You were inconsolable. If the whole situation with Joel had you heartbroken, Ted disappearing on top of it made you feel like you were choking.Â
You cried the entire night, not sleeping once.Â
You were hysterical by the time the sun came up the next morning. Tedâs food bowl still sat untouched.Â
You were still crying, feeling like your soul had left your body, but you threw some clothes on and marched your way to Tommy and Mariaâs house.Â
Maria, being the busy woman she was, was absent. But Tommy opened the door, immediately concerned by your haunting expression.Â
âTommy? My cat⊠He hasnât come back for a couple days. Can we look for him? Can we have a couple people out looking? I need him homeâŠâ You said through sobs.Â
Tommy comforted you, invited you inside. Made you tea and patted your shoulder as you cried.Â
âListen, I want to get your cat back, but heâs a stray, honey. We canât have people spending time out looking for him, we just donât have the time. What has Joel done?â He asked, trying to be as sympathetic as possible.Â
âJoel kicked me out, three days ago,â You explained, shaking your head softly. âHe probably couldnât care less.â
Tommyâs expression dropped, concern filling his face. âWhat? He kicked you out? Why? Did yâall have some fight, or somethinâ?âÂ
You shook your head again, shrugging softly. âI donât know. I donât know what I did wrong. He just⊠said I was too clingy and sent me away. I havenât see him since. Wonât talk to me. And nowâŠâ Your voice breaks, the situation hitting you all over again. âThe one thing I had left is gone. Iâm all alone.âÂ
Tommy nodded, feeling guilt. âFuck. Iâm sorry, I really am. Iâve always warned him, he doesnât know a good thing when it hits him upside the head. I love my brother, but⊠he shouldnât have done that. And, uh, listen⊠I canât promise anything, but Iâll do my best to look around for the cat tonight, alright? Iâll keep an eye out, spread the word. I promise.â
His words bring you little comfort, but you at least appreciate the gesture. You just nod, feeling even more hopeless.Â
âTed. His name is Ted.â You say, standing up to leave.Â
You decide to walk all around Jackson, searching anywhere to find your boy. The alleys, the barns- you were even tempted to jump some fences just to make sure he hadnât gotten stuck in someoneâs garden or something.
You spent the entire afternoon looking, the sky becoming a dark grey as time marched on.Â
A storm was imminent, you could tell by the breeze. The thought of Ted being stuck somewhere in the rain and thunder made you feel sick.Â
You had not found any leads by late afternoon, the clouds becoming angry overhead. You had no other choice but to grab a few groceries from the local shops and walk home. By the time you stepped out of the soap shop, raindrops were pummeling down.Â
You were cold and wet, so the trek back to your house was especially depressing. It felt, once again, almost ironic, but you didnât have the energy to smile or laugh about it this time.Â
The only thing you checked was that his food bowl was still untouched when you got back to your house. That was the only thing left you cared about before you collapsed into bed, exhaustion finally overtaking you.Â
You slept surprisingly peacefully, your body happy to be off in dreamland instead of dealing with the waking nightmare that your life had suddenly become.Â
You woke the next morning to knocking.Â
At first, you thought you mightâve just went crazy finally. But then you realized that the sound was coming from your front door, not your head. You threw on a jacket and rushed down to the door.Â
Maria stood there, and more importantly, Ted was curled into her arms, clearly trying to escape.Â
You gasped immediately, wondering if you were still dreaming.Â
âMaria! You found him?â You asked quickly, taking Ted from her arms. He willingly went, jumping into yours and clinging to you instead. âI canât even find the words to thank you. Oh my god! Where was he?âÂ
Maria smiled, taking in everything youâd blurted out quickly. âUh, actually⊠Joel found him. Tommy⊠told me and Joel about it. I was just going to have the kids go out and look, but Joel insisted. Bribed everyone over at the Tipsy Bison that if they went to look, heâd buy their drinks for the night. They found Ted stuck in the dumpster out by the barn.â
You nod softly, slowly processing what Maria told you. Why would Joel care? He was the one who pushed you away, who abandoned you. He didnât care about you anymore.
âI⊠I told him he needed to be the one to bring Ted back to you, but⊠You know Joel.â Maria said, a sympathetic look on her face as she shrugged.
âOh. We arenât⊠uh, Joel and I arenât together anymore⊠I guess.â You reply quietly.
It cut deep to say it out loud for the first time. Werenât together anymore.
âOh. I know. Tommy told me. For what itâs worth, Iâm sorry. Joel doesnât know a good thing when it slaps him upside the head.â
You canât help but laugh softly. âTommy said the same thing. Thank you, though. Iâm just happy Ted is back.â You sigh, pressing a kiss to the orange fur of his head. âHey, actually, does Joel have to go on patrol tomorrow?â You ask quietly, as if you had to keep it secret.
âNo. Heâs off the next two days.â Maria reassures. She doesnât bother asking why, because she knows, but youâre thankful that she doesnât. âLet me know if you need anything, alright?â She finishes with a nod, stepping away from the door.
You nod back, smiling. âThank you, Maria.â
You shut the door, kissing Tedâs fur more. âPoor boy. You know now not to get yourself stuck in a dumpster, huh? Little trash monster.â
Ted curls beside you in bed that night, seemingly grateful to be rescued from his days of being trapped in a wastebin.
Meanwhile, your thoughts were stuck on Joel. None of it made sense to you. Why would he do any of this? It just made you feel worse. You felt indebted to him now, on top of being a mix of upset and angry at him. It was a bewildering sensation, wanting to both kiss him and punch him.
You showed up the next day when you knew heâd be making his morning coffee- the coffee you usually made him.
You didnât bother knocking, knowing the door was almost always open. You walked in, slammed a bag of coins down on the kitchen table.
Joel turned around, an incredulous look on his face.
âYou cannot just storm in here whenever you want-â
You give him a warning look, one that he quickly and rightfully recognized as the shut up now face.
âI just wanted to pay you back for what you did last night. Payinâ those guys to help look for Ted.â You admit, unable to look at him in his eyes anymore.
He takes a tentative step closer, hesitant like heâs afraid to scare you away.
âDarlinââŠâ He says instinctively first, quickly wishing he could retract the nickname. âYou donât have to repay me. Not looking for payment. It wasnât⊠a transaction.â
You swallow. You wanted to argue, to yell at him. Release the pent-up turmoil of the past days.
âWell, just take it. I just wanted to do this so I could⊠break it off cleanly.â
When you finally find the courage to look at Joelâs face, he looks sad. No- not just sad. He looked devastated in a way youâd only seen him a few times. On days when Sarahâs memory crept up on him and wouldnât leave him, or when he and Ellie got into an argument over something trivial and she wouldnât speak to him for a few days.
It was hard to see, and your instincts wanted to run over and comfort him. But you were swiftly reminded that he was the one who broke up with you.
He nodded at your words, looking down at the floor. He worked his jaw, like he was fighting the urge to say something.
âCan I just⊠Iâll leave if you want me to, but just for my own peace, I think I deserve to know whyâŠâ You felt your voice break, but you refused to succumb. âWhy you donât want to be with me anymore. Iâll leave you alone, I swear. I just⊠need to know.â
You met his eyes and couldnât believe what you saw.
Joel Miller, the man who practically choked when he had to say sorry, who would rather build an entire castle than have to face his emotions, was about to cry.
âI- I just⊠You should be with someone your own age. Someone who hasnât seen the shit Iâve seen. Done the shit Iâve done. I.. I love you, I truly, truly do, darlinâ, but I have to do whatâs right. You deserve someone who can keep up, and someone who isnât⊠haunted by the things Iâve done. I wake up every night and go to bed every night worrying that someone might try to hurt you, or that I might hurt you, as karma for all the bad shit Iâve done. It kills me to let you go, but I know youâll be okay eventually. I can keep you safe, and happy, like this.â
The knot in your stomach was now a full-on tangle. You felt tears of your own gathering.
âJoel⊠Iâd be safe and happy with you.â You say, taking a step closer. He doesnât step back, despite wanting to. âThatâs such bullshit. I want you. I want to be with you. I need you. I donât need someone younger, or innocent, or whatever the hell. Because guess what? Someone could decide to kill me for no reason. I could die tomorrow, or a year from now. And Iâd be alone, and unhappy, and scared. Iâm scared without you, Joel. What youâre doing now is hurting me- itâs killing me. Please just⊠let me in. Stop hurting me, please and justâŠâ
Your voice broke again, tears falling this time.
This broke him as well, him swiftly approaching you in a couple of steps.
His fingers were on your face, wiping away your tears before kissing you like you were his oxygen.
He was practically hyperventilating, trying to straighten his thoughts out and explain himself. âYou showed me what happiness was. It was so bleak without you, and I tried to tell myself I would get over it eventuallyâŠâ He whispers. âSeeing you look at me with so much hurt⊠I felt so⊠abysmal. Like I couldnât live with myself knowing I hurt you so badly. I didnât mean anything I said, I swear it. Youâre not naĂŻve or too clingy. Youâre so-â
You cut him off with another kiss, being the one to wipe his tears away this time.
âIâm still mad at you, but staying away from you was the hardest thing Iâd ever had to do.â
He canât help but chuckle, which makes you laugh in turn.
âI deserve it. I deserve your rage, your sadness, all of it.â He says, his voice becoming quieter. âI just want whatâs best for you.â
âYouâre best for me.â You reply, without a second of hesitation. âEven if youâre a fucking dick sometimes.â
He kisses you again, his lips pressed to yours like he was retracing how every millimeter of the sensation felt.
You felt your back pushed against his kitchen counter, the kiss slowly morphing from sweet and heartfelt to sexy and hot.
You brought your hand to his shoulders, gripping on like he might disappear if you let go.
The desperation and rawness of the both of you made things escalate quickly. You felt like before you could even catch your breath or realize what was happening, your hands were rushing to pull his flannel and undershirt off, while his hands wandered to your chest and stomach over your shirt, squeezing appreciatively.
You whimpered softly, fumbling with his belt while he tried (and failed) to remove your shirt at the same time. If it wasnât so frenzied, it mightâve been funny, but you both were desperate to feel each against the other, to be filled and completed. Whole.
You managed to throw most of his clothes off when he took over and lifted you onto the counter.
Doing part of the work for him, you pulled your shirt and bra off, letting him scrabble with your own pants. When he patted your ass to make you hop up so he can pull the pants the rest of the way off, you ran your fingers softly over the bulge in his boxers, watching the way he shivered but tried not to get distracted.
It was sexy, somehow, watching him lock onto the task at hand- almost like you werenât even there and he was trying to work.
You looked up at him like heâd hung the stars, watching him with wide eyes. When he finally managed to pull and throw your pants and underwear off, he noticed your doe-like expression and went practically feral. He pressed his lips to yours again.
It was bruising this time, hurried like he only had a few seconds to make you feel his lips against yours for the next week.
You kept your hand pressed to his bulge as he re-adjusted you, bringing your legs around him to trap him in place.
His cock wasnât fully erect yet, but definitely hardening, swelling. You could feel it throb, and it brought a special thrill to your touch.
Usually by the time Joel actually fucked you, he was hard as a rock and made you feel every inch of it. But there was something intimate, something, ironically, soft about him still being soft. Like you were actively feeling the effect you had on him.
He pulled his cock out, gripping it before lining it up with your hole. He didnât even bother breaking the kiss, your head turned up to meet his as you felt him begin to breach you.
You gasped as Joel sighed. Your mouths were no longer pressed together in a kiss, but more like you were breathing into each otherâs mouths, swapping oxygen and spit.
Your brows furrowed together, eyes rolling at the feeling of his thick cock entering you with no foreplay or preparation.
You could feel him swell and throb inside you, reaching full hardness, and it practically made you come on the spot. The sensation was so hot- both temperature wise and emotionally.
You crossed your legs behind his back, bringing him in closer and making it so he was buried inside you as deep as he could go.
You both were pretty much gone when he started thrusting. It was hard for you to do any of the work with how he had you positioned and how he drove into you, but you rocked your hips, nonetheless.
With every lunge he hit that spot deep inside you, hard, in a way that you knew youâd be sore tomorrow.
It was wild, untamed. You could see the way he grit his jaw and the sweat accumulating on his forehead, his perfect curls bouncing with every plunge of his hips.
You moved your hands to hold onto his back too. You tried to keep your nails away, trying to hold onto him with your palms instead so you wouldnât scratch him.
He grunted softly, pulling away from your mouth. âMark me, baby. Scratch me up. I deserve it. Want to feel it. Please, darlinâ. Take it out on me.â
You felt your legs weaken despite being wrapped around him. He had never begged like that, never sounded so desperate.
You did as he asked, though. Careful at first, not really wanting to hurt him.
But then he fucked into you especially hard, and all you could manage to do was hold on for dear life. Your nails dug into his back, and you werenât sure if he was moaning in pain or pleasure.
You moaned too, feeling his hand wander from gripping onto your hips to your clit.
Heâs not slow and calculated like usual. He doesnât play games. He just spits onto your cunt and rubs frantic circles into your clit, applying just the right amount of pressure for you to see stars.
You feel the white molten pleasure start to gather in your abdomen, barely even having time to realize you were coming until you were, your mind going absolutely blank.
You mightâve even screamed- you werenât entirely sure. It was all so quick and feral.
It wasnât like any other orgasm youâd had. It was over just as fast as it started, but it felt so intense, like a star had exploded inside of you, and then just as swiftly died and disappeared.
You were left breathless, still moaning as you came down while Joel chased his release.
When your ears stopped ringing and he finally released your clit, you could hear him grunting words.
âFuck, I wouldnât survive you being with someone else. No other man. Just me.â
You caught your breath before speaking, gripping his face with your hand.
âNo other man can fuck me like you can. Fuck me like you love me, Joel. Make me feel it. Remind me Iâm yours.â
You spurring him on only made him more hungry, fucking into you so hard your body jolted against the counter with each movement.
You gasped as you felt him come inside you. In all of your relationship, you had only ever let him come inside you a few times, when you knew you werenât ovulating and wouldnât be risking any little Joels running around.
The sensation was magical each time. Feeling him rut against you, spilling inside you and chasing the sensation mindlessly, filling your womb⊠It was perfect. You were full of him, but metaphorically and literally.
He hadnât even caught his breath, his head resting against your shoulder when he spoke.
âMove in with me. Please. For real this time. I canât bear you not sleeping here, with me, where I can hold you close to me.â
You knew your answer, of course. It was simple. ButâŠ
âOnly if Ted can come with me.â
Joel laughed softly, puffs of air hitting the skin of your neck.
âDeal, darlinâ. Iâll build him the biggest cat tree youâve ever seen.â
đ±đ„đŻđąđą đȘđŹđ«đ±đ„đ° đ©đđ±đąđŻ
You woke up, dazed. The sunlight was coming in through the windows, telling you it was later than you usually slept in.
And Joel was still beside you, awake and staring at you with a weak grin on his face.
You inhaled, trying to work off your sleepy confusion.
âWhat are you still doing here? Donât you have patrol?â
âIt snowed five feet overnight, love. Canât get out the door. Weâre snowed in. Youâre stuck with me.â He said, brushing a hand through your hair. He never understood how it was so soft.
âWhatever will I do?â You teased, grinning back. Your arm patted the bed, searching for a lump that the two of you had become accustomed to.
Ted was curled up under the blanket against Joel, purring happily at the warmth that both he and the blanket provided him.
You couldâve cried over how cute it was.
âLooks like youâve already got a snuggle partner,â
Joel laughed, rolling his eyes playfully.
âI thought we said no cats in the bed. What happened to that?â He said, although he had no malice in his voice. You knew he secretly loved having Ted in-between the two of you.
Joel pulled you closer, and the two of you cuddled against Ted, who flipped over, happily accepting the belly rubs and attention from the both of you.
âOur little family is complete. Iâve got my Joel, and Iâve got my Ted. Thatâs all I need.â
You looked at Joel, biting you lip for a moment. There was just one more thing you needed to add.
"Oh. And the baby." You placed your hand on your stomach softly. "I'm pregnant."