The Problem with Tributes
The Philippine High School for the Arts (PHSA), a government-funded secondary school with a special curriculum for the arts located in Mt. Makiling, likes commemorative events. Buwan ng Wika, Buwan ng Kasaysayan, World Teachersâ Day, International Womenâs Day, and National Festival of Talents are some of the festivals and celebrations mandated by the Department of Education (DepEd). The Regional Offices of DepEd organize events like Regional Literary Joust to celebrate National Book Week. Students from different public schools would gather to compete in different contests such as essay writing, oral reading, storytelling, and poster making. Some of its objectives as stated in the memo are âto inculcate in the Young Filipino learners the love for booksâ and to âdevelop among the students essential reading and literacy skills.â
Although the PHSA is not directly under DepEd, it is considered an attached agency. Thus, it follows some of the Departmentâs memorandum orders but it also has the privilege to institute its own festivals. Because it is not just an arts school but also a regular government institution, with a huge budget allocation for a very small student population, its programs must be created with utmost care. The PHSA should be more critical to tributes. Furthermore, because it was Imelda Marcos who founded the school, the administration must and should always be wary of creating events that would even slightly suggest paying tribute to the woman behind its foundation.
Five years ago, however, the school launched âAraw ng PHSAâ, celebrating the foundation of the school. Araw ng PHSA also pays tribute to its alumni and holds various lectures and family-oriented activities like Kite Flying. This school year, Araw ng PHSA ran for three days, with a tribute to Lucresia Kasilag or Tita King. The eventâs press release announced a program called Alay Kay Inang Kalikasan, in which the school director will awarded a Gawad Direktor to partner institutions and individuals.
But instead of celebrating its foundation dayâsomething that must actually be abolished since PHSAâs founder is a dictator, plunderer, and murderer who is guilty of 7 counts of graft but remains scot-free while children are being jailedâwhy not celebrate more socially relevant programs? How about celebrating International Rural Womenâs Day for its Gender and Development program? Why not celebrate historical achievements made by Filipino artists who were also peasant advocates and human rights advocates, and not just artists who became successful because of the padrino system, exhibited their works in galleries owned by hacienderos, and became National Artists? We like paying tribute to artists but never talking about the politics behind their recognition.
Other celebrations at PHSA include Buwan ng Wika, where advocates from Komisyon sa Wikang Filipino (KWF) are invited almost annually to deliver lectures on the Filipino language. Students would be required to wear Filipiniana costumes during the program. Teachersâ Day is celebrated by allotting an hour or two to short speeches by students for their teachers, presenting tokens of appreciation from the school or made by the students, and playing Hep! Hep! Hooray! with the teachers (luckily, this was removed this school year.) The teachers are also treated to a lunch prepared by the school.
Mutyaât Lakan, a pageant in Mt. Makiling
In the beginning of the school year, Grade 10 students organize what they call âMutyaât Lakanâ, a pageant-like event that involves the freshmen or Grade 7 students. It is a tradition that began decades ago. The production varies every year but the concept remains the same. The Grade 10 students also lead the rehearsals for the freshmenâs âbatch danceâ and the overall flow of the program. It comes complete with a photoshoot. The photos would be flashed on the stage as the students walk on the catwalk like candidates.
The objective of the activity seems harmless and fun: it aims to create a bond between graduating students and the new batch of âIbarang.â Despite the facultyâs calls to stop the production, students continue to organize the event every year, with the approval of the school directors. For one, no matter how the older students resist establishing the hierarchy among batches, the idea of a production as its final output creates pressure between them. The older students also, may it be intentional or not, implement their formal training in mounting a show, complete with blocking, cueing, stage managers, technical directors for lights and sounds.
One canât help but think that this may be considered as a form of âinitiation.â The community watch as Grade 7 students walk, like models in a runway, and introduce themselves. âI am Leona Esteva from Tacloban City and Iâm a Creative Writing Major.â In the previous year, female students even wore gowns. Judges sit across the stage. Much like a Miss Universe pageant, they judge the students based on audience impact, confidence, X factor, and demeanor, and select the finalists. The finalists are asked to present their talents through singing, dancing, playing the violin, or reciting a poem. Here, the audience claps and guffaws as some of the students dance their heart out or make a fool of themselves. Then, they have to answer questions ala-Show Timeâs âMiss Q & A.â The wittier, the better, even if both the question and answer donât make sense.
Then, the freshmen dance to the song of Bruno Mars or Black Pink or a current hit song. This number is the product of their nightly rehearsals. The production ends with a new female Mutya and a male Lakan. The Grade 10 students accomplish their first task for the school year and the Grade 7 students are introduced to the communityâor remembered for their witty answers or silly dances.
Traditions are difficult to break. It is a week-long rehearsal for an initiation into the PHSA community in the form of a pageant: all this effort for camaraderie? No formal evaluation has been made to prove that the activity actually strengthens the bond between and among students. It actually forces all the freshmen to participate in a public activity that may either be exciting for some and traumatizing for others. The activity will only yield to actual positive outcome, if only the effort is guided well, assessed thoroughly, and modified to get the students to help each other and remove the pressure of staging a production.
The problem with commemorations
How many tributes and programs have we spent for the sake of staging a âtributeâ or following a DepEd memo? âMutyaât Lakanâ is something that the alumni would even reminisce with pride or humor. No one complains to the school directors about the practice, and parents even attend to support their children. Here again is a practice that we continue for the sake of tradition.
Teachersâ day is often celebrated merely in compliance with a DepEd Memo, without minding real interaction or exchange between students and teachers to appreciate teachersâ role in social transformation. On World Teachersâ Day, October 5, 2018, schools such as St. Scholasticaâs College, University of Sto. Tomas, and the University of the Philippines celebrated with Lumad teachers and students who travelled to Manila and exchanged experiences of their own schools being militarized, bombed, and forcibly closed. One thing that a Teachersâ day tribute could emphasize is the fact that some schools are more privileged to hold this celebration without the threat of state forces.
I write this essay a day before International Womenâs Day. The PHSA has put up a tarpaulin that carries the Civil Service slogan âWe Make Change Work for Women.â Yet the school has not implemented a real campaign or initiative for gender development, except for team buildings and an occasional talk. Tomorrow, PHSA employees along with other government employees will wear their purple shirts and join the parade, which often gathers at the Los BaĂąos City Hall. Last year, I read posts about the eventâs host delivering sexist jokes.
Tributes and festivals play a significant role in honing cultural leaders, and PHSA aims to produce cultural leaders. It is through arts festivals that they meet practitioners and commemorate historical events. Hence, the programs that are seen to be conducted to merely comply with memos actually build the world outside their classrooms. These commemorative events are from where PHSA students draw their definition of their Filipino identity. It allows them to ask the questions: why are we studying art? What is the purpose of our education?
Commemorations need to be rethought. Most national commemorations are often composed of performances dictated by a theme and a series of activities and competitions. Nothing is really examined or questioned; everything is passively celebrated. Thus, we often forget that history is written and dictated by people in power. Â
Paying tribute to historical events can also be tied with discussions on pressing issues and national concerns. While we celebrate the EDSA Revolution, we need to examine why our fellow Filipinos continue the armed struggle. What does ârevolutionâ mean? While we celebrate Buwan ng Kasaysayan, we must remind our children that the history of the Philippines is a history of struggle, that many of our people still struggle for land. We celebrate Independence Day and explain why we must uphold national sovereignty. We don ethnic costumes for Buwan ng Wika, yet we do not know that Lumad schools are forcibly closed because of red tagging. We don ethnic costumes but we donât know that our indigenous people are being killed for protecting our ancestral lands. We must celebrate International Rural Womenâs Day and remind our students that the Philippines is an agricultural country. Seventy percent of Filipinos are agricultural workers. What is the status of our farmers today? We rarely discuss them in school textbooks. We rarely pay tribute to our farmers, to the people who feed us. Our current school commemorations distract us from the most basic and essential.