Oooo congrats on starting the comics! 

I can try my best to rec things to you but unfortunately my memory is shit lol so I have trouble remembering what titles go to each plot line/serial and when they came out. Like I started a re-read and started at ASM #1 (1963) got like 40 issues in realized I retained like none of it and went back and now I’m taking notes as I read...which is defiantly normal lol. Also I’ve also been looking for recs from people and I never get any responses LMAO

I’m gonna post this so hopefully people can share some suggestions in the notes

Anyway I don’t know all of what you have read but off the top of my head of what I like if you haven’t read them yet: 

Spectacular Spider-Man. Specifically The Child Within storyline.

Spider-Man: Life Story

Spider-Man: Blue

Spider-Man Noir (all of it lol)

Spider-Man American Son story arch

I like the Gwen Stacey comic that they started (and then didn’t continue) from last year so I def rec that even though it’s like two issues lol

 I like some of the What If? stories too but off the top can’t think of any of the titles lmao so idk I’d look at those too if you haven’t

I like the MC2 also but I mostly like just seeing Peter be a dad lol

A Death in the Family

Kraven’s Last Hunt (Edit: Here is a post by @traincat that’s helpful for this one)

Um this is all I cant think of off the top of my head but I’ll probably definitely come back and edit this with more