The Great War
Pairing: Sam (Warfare) x female reader
Summary: After a one-night stand, you thought youâd never hear from him again. Until his letter from the other side of the world finds you, leading you to break the promises you made to yourself and lower the walls you had put up. As Sam fights a real war, you face the one inside you â between fear and longing, memories and desire, forcing you to confront your past⌠and your feelings for him.
Warnings: movie spoilers, angst, war, death, serious injuries, parental loss, epistolary relationship, mentions of life in the military/active duty, trauma, family dynamics, PTSD, angst, traumatic past, letters
Word Count: +15k
Note: This is a story split into 2 parts. At first, I didn't want to divide it but I was afraid it could be too long đ But I'm so happy to finally share it with you, guys. I've been working on it for the last 3 weeks and I really hope you like it! It's inspired on Taylor Swift's song The Great War, so you will find lyrics from it in the text. Just a little reminder: english isn't my first language, so please be understandable. Enjoy it!
There's no morning glory, it was war, it wasn't fair - January 2006
The bar was loud and crowded â laughter, clinking glasses, the crack of billiard balls colliding, and music struggling to rise above it all. The air smelled like beer and smoke and something electric â that restless energy that fills a room when people are trying too hard not to think about tomorrow.
Sam sat at a corner table with his team â six men whoâd seen more sand and blood than sunlight in the past year. It was their last night before shipping out again. Six months, maybe even more. He tried to listen to Macâs jokes, to the easy banter bouncing around the table, but his mind was already elsewhere â counting hours, bracing for what waited on the other side of the ocean. His thumb traced the rim of his half-warm beer. He could already feel the weight of the deployment pressing behind his ribs. The hands of the clock ticking quickly. A quick, bright laugh carried across the room â effortless, cheerful. It cut straight through the fog of his thoughts, pulling his head up before he even realized heâd turned. He looked around, scanning the entire room.
Until he saw you.
You were standing at the pool table, one hip resting against the edge, a bottle of beer dangling from your fingers. You wore a white satin top â slightly low-cut, sleeves brushing your arms â paired with fitted jeans and black low-heeled shoes. Casual, but elegant without trying. There was something effortless about the way you moved â confident, unbothered. The kind of woman who didnât need attention but drew it anyway. The dim lights caught the curve of your jaw, the glint in your eyes when you smiled â a quick flash of warmth that didnât reach your eyes, not completely. You laughed at something one of your friends said, tossing your hair over your shoulder, and for a moment, Sam forgot how to breathe and everything else blurred out. Then, you lined up a shot, brows furrowed in focus, and sank the ball with a smooth, controlled motion. Your friends groaned; you just smirked, the corner of your mouth lifting in a way that made something in Samâs chest tighten unexpectedly. When you glanced up, your gaze swept briefly across the room before colliding with his. Just a second â a spark, sharp and curious, but long enough to make Samâs pulse spike. You looked away, calm, composed, like he hadnât just been struck by a damn lightning bolt.
Erik followed the line of Samâs stare and let out a low whistle. âJesus, OâNeal. Youâre looking at her like youâve never seen a woman before.â Sam blinked, forcing a smirk. âMaybe I havenât seen that one before.â Erik leaned in, grinning. âThen go say hi. Last night in the States, man. Whatâve you got to lose?â
Sam wasnât the type to hit on strangers in bars. But something about you â something in the way you held yourself like you owed nothing to anyone, the way you laughed like you werenât afraid of anything â pulled him in. Erik was right. He has nothing to lose. So when you headed to the bar to grab another drink, he pushed himself up and followed you.Â
He reached the counter just as you set your empty bottle down. âLet me get you another,â he said. His voice was steady but low, with that quiet roughness of someone used to giving orders without raising his tone. You turned, gave him a quick once-over â tall, lean but strong, shaved hair, that quiet, composed. There was something measured in the way he held himself, like he was used to control. And when your eyes dropped to the chain hanging from his neck, you understood why. Dog tags. He was a soldier, of course. Your expression shifted almost imperceptibly. âI appreciate the offer,â you said evenly, âbut I donât accept drinks from militaries. Enjoy your night, soldier.â And just like that, you walked away before he could answer.Â
From his table, his friends, who had witnessed the whole scene, burst out laughing. âWell,â Mac said, cackling, âthat went amazing.â Sam just shook his head, a slow grin tugging at the corner of his mouth. Heâd been right from the start â you were something else. Dangerous. Trouble, probably. And, that made him want you more.Â
-
Later, when he spotted you again â this time at the dartboard â he didnât think twice. You lined up your shot, eyes narrowing, ready to throw, when another dart whizzed past your shoulder and hit the board before you could release yours. Bullseye.
âWhat theââ you spun around.
Sam stood a few feet away, one brow raised, the hint of a challenge tugging at his mouth. âThought Iâd give it a try.â Your lips curved in something between amusement and annoyance. âYou donât give up easily, do you?â He tilted his head, eyes steady on yours. âNot when it matters.â
You crossed your arms. âThat supposed to impress me, soldier?â âWasnât trying to impress you.â His tone softened, eyes locked on yours. âBut maybe you could give me a chance to change your mind.â
You sighed, fighting a smile. âHow?â âA game,â he said simply. âWhoever hits the bullseye more times wins. If I win, you have a drink with me. If you do, I walk away, no more questions asked.âÂ
He lifted a dart and offered it to you.
You swallowed hard and studied him for a moment. Your mind was racing, scrolling through the various options. The quiet voice inside you was telling you to go away before it was too late. But something about him â maybe that mix of confidence and quiet restraint â was holding you back. Plus, you loved a challenge and never backed down. âFine,â you said, feigning annoyance and taking the dart. âBut donât cry when you lose.â
-
You lined up your second throw, rolling the dart between your fingers the way you always did when you were settling into your rhythm. The bar noise faded just enough for you to hear your own breath. You inhaled, released, andâ
Thud.
Another bullseye. You allowed yourself a quick, satisfied smirkâuntil you felt it. His gaze. Sam watched every movement you made with a focus that was⌠disarming. Not loud or cocky like most men here, but steady, intent, almost curious. You could feel his eyes on you every time you leaned forward, the weight of his attention slide over your spine, warm and unsettling in ways you tried hard to ignore. He was also good. Really good, actually. His focus was unsettling â unshakable. There was something about the way he moved, methodical but unforced, that made your pulse pick up. He was the kind of man who didnât blink under pressure. You traded point after point, every throw landing with sharp precision. Each time youâd score, heâd answer it. Each time heâd pull ahead, youâd catch up. A quiet rivalry built between youâsmiles that lasted a little too long, glances that lingered, an edge of challenge that wasnât just about the game. Meanwhile, a crowd had gathered around you, cheering softly for the both of you.Â
It came down to the final throw. Yours skimmed just off-center â barely. His landed perfectly, slicing into the middle of the board with a dull, satisfying sound.
You exhaled, shaking your head. âFuck.â
Samâs grin deepened. âGuess that means you owe me a drink.â
âFine,â you said, arms crossing despite the small smile tugging at your lips. âBut youâre paying. Consider it the penalty for beating me.â
He laughed under his breath, shaking his head. âFair enough. After you.â
You rolled your eyes, already turning toward the bar counter.
-
Sam took a slow sip of his beer, searching for words. You leaned in slightly, one elbow on the counter, your eyes locked on him â a sharp, guarded gaze that always made people shift in their seats. But not him. He held your stare like it didnât scare him at all.
After a few sips, your guard started to slip. Just enough to reach out. Your fingers brushed his skin as you slipped the chain free from his shirt, pulling his dog tags into view. Sam didnât move at all, staying perfectly still as he waited for your next move. His eyes locked on you, tracking every shift of your body with the focus of a soldier on a mission, as if you were his target.
You turned the metal tags between your fingers, glinting under the bar lights. âSamuel OâNeal,â you read aloud. Then your eyes lifted to his. âWhich unit are you with?â
He smiled â small, genuine. âDon't you think I should first know the name of the woman I'm having a drink with?â
You hesitated, weighing the thought of giving him a fake name â safer that way. Less problems.Â
But lying to him felt wrong. âY/N,â you said finally.
He extended his hand, palm warm and sure. âNice to meet you, Y/N. Iâm Samuel but everyone calls me Sam.â
You took it, holding his gaze longer than you intended.
He answered your question then, quietly. âNavy SEALs.â You tilted your head, impressed despite yourself. âA Navy SEAL. That explains a lot of things.â His brows lifted, curious now. âLike what?â
You shrugged as if it were obvious. âYour aim when we were playing. Your focus. Your control.â
He put his beer down and studied you. âYou sound like someone who knows what thatâs like.â
You didnât answer. Instead, you took a sip of your drink, looking away and letting the silence stretch just long enough to make him wonder.
After a few seconds, he spoke again, carefully. âEarlier you said you donât accept drinks from military guys. Whyâs that?âÂ
You let out a slow breath before answering. âI was⌠in the army. A few years ago.â Your voice stayed calm, steady, while you were trying to chase away the memories. âLetâs just say Iâve had my share of battles too and Iâve dealt with enough soldiers for one lifetime. That chapter is closed. For good.â He nodded, trying to absorb that. âAnd now? What do you do?â You shrugged, drinking your beer. âI work at the hospital nearby. Iâm an ER doctor.â
That surprised him. His expression softened, something like respect flickering there. âFrom combat zones to the ER. Thatâs impressive.â
You shrugged, staring at your bottle. âNot really. Same chaos, just a different kind of uniform. And at least now I get to save more people instead of losing them.â
He studied you, and you could tell he wanted to ask more, to peel back the layers â but you didnât let him. Youâd learned long ago that the less you knew, the less it could hurt later. That world â uniforms, missions, funerals â had taken enough from you. Your father, your brother, your peace. You didnât want to let it take anything else. So you steered the conversation away. âWhen do you leave again?â
He hesitated. âTomorrow.â
You almost choked on the beer, your eyebrows lifted. âTomorrow?â
He nodded once. âYeah. Iraq.â
For a moment, both of you just stared at each other, the noise of the bar blurring into something distant. âWow,â your murmured, looking away, ânow I feel a little guilty for turning you down earlier. You know, considering itâs your last night and all.â
He tilted his head, smiling. âYouâre still in time to make it up to me.â
You laughed under your breath. âOh yeah? And what do you want? Any last wishes before you leave?â
He smirked. âHmm.â His voice dropped a little, almost teasing. âI could think of a few ideas.â
The space between you seemed to shrink, both aware of what was hanging in the air, both pretending it was just a joke. But it wasnât. Not anymore.Â
You looked at him. âWell,â you whispered, âdonât think too long. Youâre running out of time.â
-
You told yourself it was harmless.
One night. No expectations. No feelings. Heâd be gone tomorrow, and youâd go back to your life â clean, simple, safe.
That was all.
His apartment was small, simple â nothing out of place, everything folded, aligned and polished, just like you had expected. A half-packed deployment bag sat near the door, boots lined perfectly beside it. His uniform hung pressed and ready. A silent reminder of who he was and what awaited him tomorrow. The entire space smelled faintly of cedar and clean cotton. He handed you a glass of water and you accepted it.Â
âCareful,â he said, looking at you, one corner of his mouth lifting. âThis is the second drink youâre accepting from me. A soldier. Youâre breaking all your rules.â You rolled your eyes, though your pulse jumped. âJust for tonight,â you murmured, stepping a little closer, âIâm calling a truce. One-night ceasefire.â
âIâm honored to be your exceptionâ he said, amused, putting a hand over his heart.Â
You moved toward him. âCareful. I can still leave.âÂ
âBut itâs not what you want.âÂ
His hand brushed your hip â subtle, testing.
You didnât pull away. And that was the answer, all the permission he needed.
He leaned in, his breath warm against your cheek before his lips finally found yours. The kiss was slow at first, deepening with every second you didnât stop him. Your fingers curled into his shirt. His hand slid up your spine, pulling you closer with a quiet, restrained urgency. You cupped his face with your hands.Â
You stumbled together toward his bedroom, lips never parting.
In a rush â urgent, breathless â jackets slid off shoulders, shirts tangled and fell to the floor. Buttons were fumbled open with impatient hands. The soft thud of clothes hitting the hardwood filled the room, one piece after another, leaving both of you naked. You kissed like you were trying to memorize each other before time took him away. A kiss that tasted like goodbye before it had even begun. His breath caught when your nails traced his shoulders. Yours hitched when his hands gripped your waist, firm, certain. The air cracked with heat and want and something dangerously close to longing. When he lifted you, laying you down on the mattress with a mix of hunger and unexpected care, you let yourself stop thinking â just for tonight. Just this once.
It felt like surrender. Like relief.
A ceasefire with yourself.
-
The light slipped through the blinds, pale and soft, waking you before him. Sam lay beside you, breathing slow, peaceful, one arm draped loosely across the sheets.
You sat there for a second, memorizing the calm on his face, his features â before reality could catch up.
Because dawn meant the ceasefire was over.
You slipped out of the bed quietly, gathering your clothes from the trail you had both left across the room. You dressed fast, quietly, your heartbeat steadying back into the familiar rhythm of someone who survives by leaving first.
For a moment, you considered writing a note. Something simple. A good luck. A goodbye. But then you remembered what goodbyes did â how they linger, how they could hurt. So you just walked out the door, the sound of it closing behind you the only trace you left.
You told yourself it was better that way.
Youâd never see him again.
And maybe that was the mercy in it. - Uh-huh, the bombs were closer My hand was the one you reached for All throughout the Great War -
February 2006
The heat in Iraq was the kind that got under your skin â dry, relentless, heavy with dust. The air smelled of gun oil, sweat, and sand.
Sam sat at the edge of his bunk. The room around him buzzed with low voices, the distant hum of generators, the occasional thud of boots on floor. He rolled the pen between his fingers, staring down at a half-finished letter addressed to his sister back home.
But his mind wasnât really there. It was back in that dimly lit bar, the smell of whiskey and wood polish, the sound of your laughter slicing through the crowd. He could still see your hair fall over your face when you'd leaned over the pool table, the look you'd given him when you finally told him your name â like you were giving away a secret you hadnât meant to.
âJust one night.â
No contact. No feelings. No complications. That had been the unspoken agreement between you. And at the time itâd been easy to accept, to keep it. He was leaving the next morning; even if heâd wanted to see you again, he wouldnât have had the chance. But day after day, Sam found himself wanting nothing else. At night he closed his eyes hoping heâd dream of you â and when he didnât, he retreated into his memories just to see you again. If only heâd had more time. If that night hadnât been his last one in the States, he wasnât sure he wouldâve managed to honor the silent deal youâd made. He probably wouldâve gone back to that bar, searching for you, hoping youâd walk in again. What could he do now? He was thousands of miles away from you, unable to reach you, unable to see you. He looked at the unfinished letter to his sister and an idea sparked. He set it aside and pulled a new blank sheet in front of him. He stared at it for a long moment, weighing whether this was a good move or a suicide mission. He didnât know much about you â just a name, a profession youâd hinted at. And he had the necklace. Your necklace. Heâd found it tangled in his sheets that morning, after youâd left. A thin gold chain with a small charm that had caught the first light filtering through his window. Heâd told himself that when he got back, heâd find a way to return it to you. A promise to himself. To you. That thought had stayed with him for weeks; itâd became his reminder that he had to make it home. Alive. And maybe, if he was lucky, he could see you again. Until then, heâd wear it under his uniform, close to his skin. He told himself it was for luck, protection, but deep down, he knew better.Â
He had also an address. Not yours but the barâs. That night, heâd watched you walk through the place as if you owned it, as if you knew every inch by heart. Maybe you were a regular. It wasnât much â but it was something. Better than nothing. And maybe his plan could work.
So, that night, under the dim yellow light of the room, he let out a slow breath and lowered his pen to the page. Maybe it was stupid â writing to someone he barely knew, sending a letter to a bar of all places. What could he even say? Youâd made it clear there wouldnât be a next time. He looked around thoughtfully. But what did he have to lose? Nothing.
So Sam began to write.
When he finished, he folded the page carefully, slipped it into an envelope, and scrawled the address of the bar. It wasnât much of a plan, but it was all he had.
When the mail truck left the base the next morning, his letter was among the hundreds heading west â a single thread thrown into the unknown.
He didnât expect an answer. But he needed to try.
-
You tried not to think about him â and at first, youâd even succeeded.
Work drowned out everything. Long shifts, tired nights, the kind of exhaustion that left no room for thoughts or memories. Some nights you wanted just to go to bed and sleep. But then, one evening, youâd found yourself back at the Rusty Anchor. And then again. And again.Â
Every time you sat there, you glanced at the spot where you and Sam had talked, replaying in your mind the memories of that night.Â
You remembered the way heâd listened without asking for more, how heâd understood things without saying them aloud. His confidence when heâd challenged you to darts. Or his smile when heâd beaten you. Sometimes you caught yourself wondering if he was still alive. If heâd been hurt. If he thought about that night too.Â
But every time you shut those thoughts down quickly, pushing them aside like a reflex. Telling yourself it was just curiosity, nothing more. After a shift that had drained you down to the marrow, you pushed open the door of the Rusty Anchor for a quick drink. It was a weekday, so the place was quieter than usual â a low murmur of conversations, clinking glasses, the soft hiss of the fryer from the kitchen. You hair were pulled back in a messily, your entire body tense and aching.
âRough day?â John, the bartender, asked, already sliding your usual drink toward you.
âYou have no idea,â you muttered as you took your seat across from him at the counter.Â
He grinned. âThen this should help.â
Before you could take a sip, he held something else out to you â a white envelope. âThis came for you.â You blinked, confused. âA letter? For me?â
He nodded. âYeah. Got dropped off a few days ago.â
You frowned, taking the envelope from him. âJohn, nobody sends me letters. And definitely not here.â
He shrugged, wiping the counter with a rag. âHey, donât look at me like that. I'm as surprised as you are.â
âWhen did it get here exactly?â âThree, four days ago, I think.â âAnd who delivered it?â He sighed, rolling his eyes. âThe mailman, genius. Itâs a letter, not a bomb. Read it.â You rolled your eyes, but your attention snapped back to the envelope. You turned it over in your hands, the paper rough beneath your fingers â worn, sun-bleached. Like it had traveled far. Then you saw the name in the corner.
Samuel OâNeal.
You froze, your throat went dry.
For a moment, you just stared at it. You hadnât expected to hear from him. Not after the way youâd left. And the quiet youâd forced between you. Youâd been careful with him that night â you had shared only fragments of yourself. Nothing personal. Nothing too traceable. And yet he had found a way to reach you anyway. He had written to you. A real letter, from a war zone. It shouldnât have meant anything â and yet, it did. You were surprised, caught off guard, of course, but also⌠moved. You found yourself admiring him a little â that stubbornness, that quiet determination. Like that night, in that same bar, when heâd challenged you. Relief washed over you too. Because that letter meant he was also alive. Or at least heâd been when heâd written the letter, probably a few weeks ago. And for reasons you didnât quite understand, that simple fact made you feel lighter. You set the envelope on the bar. You brought your drink to lips, and took a slow sip, your eyes never leaving the paper, undecided whether to read it or not. You exhaled, placed the bottle down, and finally tore the envelope open. The bar faded away as you unfolded the letter.
Hey, Not sure if you remember me â though a part of me hopes you do. In case you don't, Iâm Sam, the guy from the bar. The one who beat you at darts. Sorry, I couldnât resist reminding you.
You smiled despite yourself.
I really donât know why Iâm writing this. Maybe because the days all start to look the same out here, or because thinking about that night keeps me sane when everything else feels too far away. I know you said no complications, and Iâm not trying to start any. Honestly, given where I am right now, writing to you might be the least complicated thing Iâve done in weeks. Besides, if you really didnât want to hear from me, you probably shouldâve been more careful â you left something behind that morning. Your necklace. I found it tangled in my sheets after you left. Maybe that's also why I'm writing to you, to let you know. Donât worry, Iâll give it back to you someday â thatâs the plan, at least. But until then I'll consider it my lucky charm. I hope youâll survive without it.Â
Your throat burned. Your necklace. The one youâd spent weeks searching for. He had it. You instantly cursed yourself for not being more careful.Â
How are things back home? Things are quiet here, for now. The kind of quiet that makes you think too much and make bad decisions. Maybe writing to you is one of those. Maybe this wonât even reach you. But if it does⌠if this finds you, I guess that means I got lucky twice. Sam
You stared at his name at the bottom. Then, you read the letter again. And again. While your drink stayed unfinished on the counter.
You hadnât planned on hearing from Sam ever again. But now that youâd⌠you werenât sure you could ignore him.
- I drew curtains closed, drank my poison all alone You said I have to trust more freely But diesel is desire, you were playing with fire -
For days, the letter followed you everywhere â tucked in your agenda or in your pockets, inside your bag, its paper worn from being read over and over again. You kept telling yourself you wouldnât reply, that it would be pointless. If you wrote back, he might write again, and then again. And you didnât want that. Youâd promised yourself no complications. No soldiers. No ghosts from that world youâd left behind. And replying to him could become a complication.Â
Still, you couldnât throw his letter away. Youâd find yourself re-reading it in the quiet moments â in the locker room, in your car, in the evening before going to sleep.
On the fifth day after receiving it you told your friends about it. Jenny, the most romantic of the group, was the first to speak. âSo let me get this straight,â she said, eyes wide, coffee cup in hand. âHeâs a soldier. Heâs in Iraq right now. Risking his life every day. But despite this, he took the time to write you an actual letter. And youâre telling me youâre not going to respond?â
You sighed, leaning against the chair. âThereâs no point, Jen. It would just⌠complicate things. And I donât want that.â
She folder her arms. âComplicate things how? Itâs just a letter. And think about it â heâs out there, miles away from home. Maybe he has no one waiting for him. And your letter could be the only good thing heâd get for weeks. Maybe he's just waiting for that. You really want to deny him that?â
You rolled your eyes. âJenny, heâs in Iraq. He has bigger things to worry about than waiting for a letter from me.â
But her words stuck with you. At first, you tried to brush it off, but as the days passed, you found yourself thinking about what sheâd said. Maybe she wasnât wrong. A few words wouldn't have hurt anyone after all. They were just that⌠words. And besides, it would have been rude of you not to respond.
Others days passed and the idea of writing back circled you slowly, quietly, like something inevitable.
And then came the night that broke you, forcing you to lower your defenses.Â
A long, brutal shift. Two red codes. One life saves, the other lost. A mother and her child. The hallway had smelled like antiseptic and blood, and for a split second, it felt like being back in the field â that same helplessness, that same hollow quiet after the chaos. You drove home in silence, hands shaking on the wheel. You dropped your bag next to the door, exhaling and sat at the kitchen table.Â
You needed someone to talk to. Someone who might understand that weight, who knew what it meant to watch life and death walk side by side. And somehow, impossibly, the only person who came to your mind was him.
You reached for a pen, a paper and started writing.
- March 2006
Itâd been weeks since Sam had sent his letter, and he still hadnât received anything back from you.Â
In the beginning, every time the mail arrived and the letters were handed out, Sam found himself hoping â just a little â that there might be one from you. Heâd stand by with the others, hands in his pockets, pretending not to look too eager while they called out names and tossed envelopes like cards in a game he couldnât win. But each time it didnât happen, something in him dipped lower, even though he told himself it didnât matter.
Some nights, when the desert finally fell quiet, heâd replay it all â the bar, the game, the way your hand had brushed his when youâd taken the darts from him. Heâd also curse himself for writing that letter in the first place, wondering what the hell heâd been thinking. It had been a doomed mission from the start â a reckless, stupid mission of the heart with no cover, no backup, no odds. He hadnât even told the guys in his unit about it, he didnât have the guts to. They wouldâve laughed, and honestly, he wouldnât blame them.
After a few weeks, Sam stopped looking up when the mail came. He told himself you probably never got the letter â maybe you werenât a regular at that bar as heâd thought, or maybe itâd ended up lost somewhere in the backroom of some post office. It was easier to believe that than the alternative â that youâd received it and simply hadnât cared enough to answer.
Not that he blamed you. Why would you have answered him?
Heâd taken a shot and missed. That was the truth.
But then, one morning, while sorting through a stack of envelopes just delivered to him, something caught his eye â his name, scrawled in unfamiliar handwriting. And yours, in the corner. He couldnât believe his eyes. His chest tightened. He turned it over in his hands, a little afraid to open it.Â
When he finally tore it open, carefully, as if afraid the paper itself might vanish, he found more words than heâd ever let himself hope for.
You hadnât told him off or to stop writing.
Youâd written about your life. Your patients. Your day.Â
A smile crept over his face â small, private, unnoticed by anyone around him. He could almost hear your voice in the rhythm of your sentences â see you, maybe sitting at the bar, drink in hand, brows furrowed as you searched for the right words.
Sam, Or should I call you Mr. Insistence? Seems fitting â youâve got determination to spare, Iâll give you that. You're also full of surprises, O'Neal. No oneâs written me a letter in years. And I definitely didnât expect one from you. I wasnât planning on writing back. Honestly, I told myself I wouldnât. But then again, I also told myself Iâd never sleep with a soldier⌠and we both know how that turned out. Truth be told, you need to thank my friend Jenny for this. Sheâs the hopeless romantic of the group â the kind who thinks every story deserves a happy ending. And apparently sheâs your fan already. She guilt-tripped me into it, saying itâd be cruel not to write back, especially considering where youâre and what youâre doing. According to her, although I hope it is not so, you might not have anyone else out there. So here I am. I wish I could say things are quiet here too, but theyâre not. Iâve had a rough week and I lost a patient tonight â a mother. You think you've gotten used to it but it never gets easier. Youâd probably understand that better than most. I donât even know why Iâm telling you this. Maybe because you asked how things were, and ignoring you felt wrong. Or maybe because youâre the only one who might actually get it â without me having to explain every little thing. About that dart game â you just got lucky. Iâd had a few beers that night, so I wasnât exactly at my best. We might have to call for a rematch someday. Take care of yourself, OâNeal. Stay alive â so you can bring me back my necklace. It means more to me than you think. Y/N
When he finished reading, he held the letter for a long while, turning it over in his hands. Then he read it again. Over and over again. As if he wanted to memorize it. He took the envelope and noticed that the return address on it wasnât the barâs. It was a street â a real address. Yours, most likely.
He knew he shouldnât. Heâd already been lucky twice: first when his letter reached you, and then when youâd answered. But the temptation was too strong to resist. He took out his pen and started to write. The words came easily, as if his hand already knew the direction his heart was taking.
Y/N, First off â thank your friend Jenny for me. From what youâve told me, she sounds like a very wise woman. Iâm glad you listened to her â and I hope youâll keep doing it, especially if that means I get to read from you again. Iâm sorry you had such a rough day, and about your patient. Youâre right, losing someone never gets easier. Every time feels new, doesnât it? But Iâm sure you did everything you could. You donât strike me as the kind of person who gives up easily. Or am I wrong? You said youâre not sure why you told me about your day. But I think I might know. Sometimes itâs easier to talk to a stranger, someone who doesnât expect you to be okay all the time and wonât judge you. Anyway, Iâm glad you opened up to me, whatever the reason. I bet your patients are lucky to have you. Who wouldnât want an intelligent and beautiful doctor taking care of them? Probably half of them get better just from having you walk into the room. Iâve been thinking about the night we spent together. And I realized you probably know more about me than I do about you. Doesnât seem fair, does it? We should fix that. Maybe we can start with something simpler. The basics. They matter too. For example, whatâs your favorite color? Movie? The song you never skip when it comes on? Iâll go first. Color: orange â not too bright. Softer. The kind you see at sunset. Movie: The Big Lebowski. Have you ever watched it? Song: âHeroesâ by David Bowie. Always hits different out here. Your turn, doc. Sam
When he sealed the envelope, he hesitated for a moment, thumb pressed against your name. Sam knew that with this letter â with the gentle teasing, the questions, the attempt to know you better â he was taking a risk. Another one. Maybe youâd find it too much. Too personal. But that night, under the starry desert sky, he felt just brave enough to try. To find out whatâd happen next.Â
-
April 2006 When another letter from Sam arrived â this time at your home address â you didn't know whether to be relieved or irritated. Part of you had hoped heâd let things go after your reply, while another part wasnât surprised at all. He hadnât given up that night at the bar, so why would he stop now?
You were coming home from work, exhausted, your shoes digging into your feet, when you found the envelope in your mailbox as if itâd been waiting for you all day. The moment you saw his name, a quiet breath escaped you, feeling immediate relief. Another letter meant he was still alive.
You ran upstairs faster than you intended, kicked off your shoes and set your bag on the table.
You poured yourself a glass of red wine and curled up on the couch before finally opening it.
You said youâre not sure why you told me about your day. But I think I might know. Sometimes itâs easier to talk to a stranger, someone who doesnât expect you to be okay all the time and wonât judge you. Anyway, Iâm glad you opened up to me, whatever the reason.
You caught yourself smiling at that. He wasnât wrong.
I bet your patients are lucky to have you. Who wouldnât want an intelligent and beautiful doctor taking care of them? Probably half of them get better just from having you walk into the room.
You rolled your eyes at the blatant flirting, though another smile threatened to form as you kept reading.
Iâve been thinking about the night we spent together. And I realized you probably know more about me than I do about you. Doesnât seem fair, does it? We should fix that. Maybe we can start with something simpler. The basics. They matter too. [âŚ] Your turn, doc.
You exhaled slowly, staring at the letter, thoughtful.Â
This time he was asking questions. He wanted to know more about you. And even though a part of you wanted to answer him immediately, your hand stalled as you reached for the pen. Answering his questions meant opening up â letting him in. And getting to know someone was the first step to becoming attached to them. You didnât want that. You couldnât. Not to him. A soldier. Not when the odds of losing him were higher than anything else you could have or build.
Youâd learned the hard way a long time ago that it wasn't worth it. It was too risky. Too painful.Â
The army had already taken so much from you â too much â and you werenât willing to lose anything, or anyone, ever again. Thatâs why youâd left that world behind and going back, even through him, meant reopening wounds youâd tried so hard to close. Writing him back had been a mistake, youâd given him false hope and a reason to write to you again. You still could end it before it was too late, telling him to stop writing. Or you could simply ignore the letter altogether. Tear it, burn it, pretend youâd never read it. Simple, right? It was easier that way, you thought, trying to convince yourself.Â
But Jennyâs voice echoed in your head, needling at your conscience. âItâs just a letter. And think about it â heâs out there, miles away from home. Maybe he has no one waiting for him and your letter could be the only good thing heâd get for weeks. Maybe he's just waiting for that. You really want to deny him that?â
âDamn Jenny,â you muttered.
Besides walking away like that wouldâve been cowardly â something you were not.
You had to face him, even if it meant telling him to stop. Sure, it was still cruel, but not as much as not answering him.
You grabbed a sheet of paper and tried to write, but every line sounded wrong â too sharp or too soft. You crossed out and rewrote, crumpling sheet after sheet on the floor until the fifth failed attempt finally broke your patience. You stood, gathered the discarded pages, and threw them in the bin, sighing. âEnough for tonightâ, you whispered to yourself. Youâd try again tomorrow.
You slipped Samâs letter into a box along with the first one, telling yourself it was better that way â out of sight, out of mind. Then you went to bed, more tired than when youâd arrived, hoping the night would bring clarity. -
Days passed and you hadnât reread the letter, hadnât written back.
You always found an excuse â too tired, too busy, a headache, anything to push it off another day.
And yet his words kept finding you.
In the quiet moments.
In the spaces between thoughts.
Like the chorus of a song you couldnât forget. As had happened with his favorite song, Heroes. Youâd started listening to it.
The first time, itâd happened almost by mistake â you were out jogging, scrolling through the playlists on your iPod, when, without realizing, your fingers had already typed the title. By the time you thought to stop the song, Bowie was already singing. And in the days that followed, you caught yourself playing it again. And again. One evening, with a glass of wine in hand, you were flipping through channels when a movie caught your attention. You checked the title. The Big Lebowski. Samâs favorite movie. Instead of changing the channel, you set the remote down on the table and leaned back on the couch.
You told yourself it was just curiosity â youâd never seen it, after all. You werenât watching it because of him. But by the time the credits rolled, you were smiling faintly. During the movie youâd even laughed â real, warm laughter that felt foreign after days of weight on your chest. You understood why he loved it â there was something oddly comforting about it, an odd mix of absurdity and warmth, the kind that made you forget the rest of the world for a while. When it ended, you sat there in silence, feeling unexpectedly alone as you realized the only person you wanted to talk to about it was Sam. You couldnât, of course â he was thousands of miles away. But you could write to him a letter. That thought lingered. You told yourself you didnât have to send it. You could simply⌠write. Put down your thoughts and get them out of your system.
You opened the box, where youâd put his letters and you read them again. Then, almost without hesitation, you pulled out a blank page and grabbed a pen. Before you could talk yourself out of it, you were already writing. In the end, they were just words. Werenât they? They could do no harm, you said to yourself. Even if you werenât so sure.Â
Sam, You really donât know when to quit, do you? Anyway, I think youâre wrong. If we look at it a certain way, Iâd say you already know me pretty well. Or have you forgotten the night we spent together?
Your pen moved almost on its own.
I have to admit, though: youâve got good taste in music. Heroes is really a good song, it has been stuck in my head for days. And you probably wonât believe this, but I just finished watching The Big Lebowski for the first time. Before you say anything â no, I didnât watch it because of you. It was on TV, and since Iâd never seen it, I figured Iâd give it a chance. Pure coincidence. So donât get too full of yourself. You just got lucky. It wasnât bad, though. Actually, I liked it more than I expected and it also made me laugh. I can see why you like it but Iâm not gonna lie, your choice surprised me. I wouldâve bet on Fight Club or The Godfather. I've to admit: you keep surprising me, OâNeal. Anyway, I guess itâs my turn now. -Favorite color: navy blue. -Favorite movie: Kill Bill. Uma Thurman is brilliant, fierce and unapologetic. Easily one of Tarantinoâs best. Also Rear Window by Hitchcock. Iâve always had a soft spot for thrillers, whether in films or books. -Favorite song: Running Up That Hill by Kate Bush. Even if Unwritten by Natasha Bedingfield has been an obsession lately. I love the part that says: Release your inhibitions Feel the rain on your skin No one else can feel it for you Only you can let it in⌠Today is where your book begins. Thereâs something about it, a sense of freedom, of starting over. I canât quite explain it, but it makes me feel⌠lighter, carefree. Like I could breathe again.Â
You paused, rereading what youâd written, surprised by how much you were writing, how much you were revealing about you. Youâd answered his questions. That shouldâve been enough and for a moment, you considered stopping there â maybe rewriting it, making it sound less⌠personal. Writing less details. But the thought faded as quickly as it came. And before you could realize, you started writing again.Â
Anyway, since you started this little game between us, I think itâs only fair that I get to ask you a few things too. Favorite food? Mineâs pizza. Pizza margherita, in particular. Simple, I know, but hear me out, you canât go wrong with it. It never disappoints. Do you like animals? I think that says a lot about a person, so be careful how you answer. It could be your last chance. If the answer is yes, which oneâs your favorite? And hereâs a harder one â why did you enlist? We never talked about this. Was it something you always wanted? Or something that just⌠happened? Feel free not to answer if you don't want to. Anyway, thatâs enough for tonight. The interrogation is over. Take care of yourself, Sam. And be careful out there. I know you'll write to me again, Mr. Insistence, so see you in the next letter, I guess. Y/N
When you finally looked up, the clock on the wall read 1 a.m. You blinked, surprised by how much time had passed. Before you could change your mind, you folded the letter, slipped it into a cream-colored envelope, and sealed it shut. You wrote his name and the address you had already memorized, then placed it beside your keys so you wouldnât forget it in the morning. The next day, before heading to work, you dropped the envelope into the mailbox without a second thought. As you watched it disappear through the slot, your chest felt lighter â for the first time in days.
Thereâs no turning back now, you thought.Â
As you walked away, you caught yourself smiling â quietly, uncontrollably â already waiting for his reply.
-
âOâNeal!â
The voice cut through the heavy air like a gunshot.
Sam was in the middle of doing push-ups, killing time and trying to quiet the restlessness that never left him. At the sound of his name, he froze mid-motion, palms pressed into the ground, heart skipping once â reflex.
âThereâs mail for you,â the same voice called again.
Sam pushed himself to his feet in one swift motion, dusting his hands off as he jogged toward the man standing in the doorway with a bundle of letters. When he took the envelope, he immediately recognized your handwriting scrawled across the front. Something shifted in his chest. That familiar, stupid smile tugged at the corner of his mouth before he could stop it. Youâd replied him. Luck, apparently, was still on his side.
He muttered a quick thanks and headed back to his cot, already opening the flap with impatient fingers before he even sat down. He unfolded the pages carefully, as if they were something fragile. And, in a way, they were.Â
Not only youâd written back but youâd answered his questions, shared pieces of yourself, little details he hadnât expected you to share. And youâd asked your own questions too. It was a good thing, Sam thought. It meant you wanted to know more about him too. Â
He was halfway through reading your letter a second time, eyes scanning each line like it might reveal something new, when a voice snapped him out of it.
âEarth to Sam,â Ray called, waving a hand in front of him.
Sam blinked and lifted his gaze. Ray, Mac, Erik, and Elliot were all staring at him with matching grins, like theyâd just caught him doing something he shouldnât.
âWhat?â he asked, defensive, folding the letter halfway shut.
Mac tilted his head and smirked. âYou gonna tell us whoâs been writing you, OâNeal? And donât give us that âitâs from my momâ crap. Nobody smiles like that reading a letter from home.â
The others laughed, already circling in.
Elliot whistled low. âMust be serious if he didnât even hear Ray calling him. He was gone, man. Gone.â
Erik leaned forward, elbows on his knees. âOh, shit, I think Iâve got it. Itâs that girl from the bar, isnât it? The one from your last night out before deployment.â
Sam said nothing, but his silence gave him away. He could feel the heat rise in his neck before anyone said a word.
âOh, itâs her!â Erik crowed, pointing at him. âLook at his face, guys!â The others joined in, half-teasing, half-genuinely surprised.
âGentlemen,â Mac announced dramatically, âwar is officially over: Samuel OâNeal has fallen.â
The laughter grew louder, echoing against the walls of the room. Ray crossed his arms, smiling. âHold on. Youâve got a girl back home and you donât tell us? Seriously? Thatâs cold, man. I thought we shared everything here.â
Sam rolled his eyes and sighed, shaking his head. âItâs not like that,â he said finally. âSheâs not my girlfriend. We just⌠write letters. Thatâs all.â
âOh, sure,â Mac said, drawing out the words and clapping him on the shoulder. âYou just write. Thatâs what they all say before they start doodling little hearts in the margins.â
That sent them all off again.
âYouâre all idiots,â Sam muttered, though there was no bite in his tone.
When they finally drifted away, leaving him alone again, Sam exhaled slowly and looked back at the letter. He unfolded the pages again, letting his eyes trace your words.
You really donât know when to quit, do you?
No, he didnât. And he didnât want to.
Anyway, I think youâre wrong. If we look at it a certain way, Iâd say you already know me pretty well. Or have you forgotten the night we spent together?
Forgotten? Not a chance. Sam even doubted he ever could. That night had burned itself into him â every second of it. Sometimes, when he closed his eyes, the memories came back in fragments: your smile, the way youâd looked at him in the half-light of his apartment, and your voice screaming his name while he was inside you. The warmth of your skin against his, your hair brushing against his shoulder, the quiet between you that didnât feel empty. And your scent â vanilla and caramel â the same one that had lingered on his sheets the morning after, when he woke to an empty room and sunlight spilling across the floor. Heâd never admit it, but every now and then heâd catch a trace of something that smelled like you â a passing stranger, a bar of soap, coffee with too much sugar â and it would hit him like a memory he didnât know he still carried.
And you probably wonât believe this, but I just finished watching The Big Lebowski for the first time.
Sam chuckled softly under his breath. Not only had you approved of Heroes, but youâd watched his favorite movie. That was something. He leaned back against the thin metal frame of his cot, picturing you on your couch or bed, with a beer in hand, laughing at the same absurd moments he always did. And then he allowed himself to picture the two of you watching it together someday â you next to him, your legs tucked under you and a bowl of popcorn between you. Maybe, after, youâd make him watch Kill Bill. He could already hear you quoting Uma Thurman, pretending to wield a katana. He wouldâve loved that. Every single moment of it.Â
He grinned at the thought and shook his head. He took mental notes of the others details youâd shared â navy blue, Unwritten, Running Up That Hill, pizza margherita. Maybe one day he'd need that information. To surprise you. Maybe for your first date. If there ever was one.Â
But that day was far away. Right now, all he could do was writing back.
He looked down at the blank page in front of him, the paper was slightly creased, corners bent from being shoved into his pack. He stared at it for a long moment, keeping a pen in hand.
It felt like walking across a minefield. There were so many things he wanted to ask, but no page would ever be big enough to write them all. And he had to choose carefully his words. If he said too much, too soon, he might scare you away. That couldnât happen. Not now. Not when you were finally starting to open up. He took a deep breath, weighing every word before letting the pen touch the paper â as if each one could bring him closer to you, or push you further away.
-
August 2006
After your last letter, others followed â both yours and Samâs. Weeks turned into months, and the box where you kept them was slowly filling up, its corners growing soft from being opened again and again. What had started as short and cautious exchanges had become longer, richer, filled with stories and confessions that felt like small windows into each otherâs worlds.
Every day before work, and again when you came home, you checked the mailbox. Every time you found a letter from him, it felt like waking up to Christmas morning. Reading them and replying had become part of your routine. When weeks went by with nothing new, you reread the old ones, from the first to the last, tracing his words with your fingertips as if they could somehow bring him closer. Sometimes, between one letter and the next, you caught yourself wondering if he was still alive â if the silence wasnât just distance, but something worse. The thought terrified you each time â but then, when another letter finally arrived, the relief was so sudden, so physical, it felt like breaking the surface after being underwater for too long.
Through each letter, you were getting to know each other. Youâd learned he loved mac and cheese â homemade, heâd underlined, not the powdered kind. He liked dogs; he and his younger sister had always had one growing up, and someday he wanted one of his own. He even had names picked out: âGuinness,â after the beer, or âDude,â after his favorite movie character. Youâd laughed at that and teased him that they were terrible names. Before you could realize it, you were suggesting better ones â as if you were naming your future dog too, not just his.
Heâd also told you why heâd enlisted. After high school, heâd been lost â no plan, no clear idea of what to do next. College hadnât felt right, home had felt too small, and one day, almost without meaning to, heâd found himself filling out enlistment papers. âIt just felt like the right thing to do at the time,â heâd written. And you understood what he meant. Maybe too well.Â
Month after month, youâd let your guard down, breaking the promises youâd made to yourself long ago â not to let another soldier into your life, not to get tangled in anything tied to the military. But Sam had found his way in. Maybe even into your heart.
At first, youâd been careful, answering his questions without giving too much away, but little by little, you found yourself writing more than you meant to: about your job, the difficult patients, the things that made you laugh or kept you up at night. Youâd even started sending him things along with the letters â a book, a CD, a photo of you that you told yourself it was casual but had taken twenty minutes to take. You wanted him to have something real to hold on to, something that could distract him from the war, the blood and the missions. Something of you. Slowly, the tone of your letters had began to shift. What had started as innocent and cautious had became something else â more intimate, warmer, threaded with a quiet kind of longing. Sometimes you wrote about that night you spent together â the one neither of you seemed able to forget â hinting at what you remembered, what you missed, and what youâd do if you were together again. There was something thrilling â something undeniably exciting â in knowing you were the last woman heâd been with. That even across miles of desert, through the dust and the silence, you were the one he dreamed of. The one he still wanted. Heâd been the last for you too. It wasnât that you hadnât tried. You went on dates, met new people, but no matter how kind or charming the guys you dated were, you couldnât go further than a kiss. Every time, your mind drifted back to him â the feel of his hands on your skin, the way heâd looked at you, the sound of your name on his lips. You kept telling yourself you owed him nothing. He wasnât your boyfriend. But then, what was he to you? What were you to him? Friends? No. A friend shouldnât know the way you taste. Friends didnât fall asleep replaying the way their bodies fit together like they were made for each other. And yet, that was exactly what you did. He was the one you thought about at night when you tossed and turned, wondering where he was, whether he was safe or not.Â
Sometimes, after reading one of his letters, his words lingered inside you longer than you wanted them to. They pulsed, heavy, alive, until it almost hurt. Lying back on the bed, you closed your eyes and let the ache spread through you. You could almost hear his voice, feel the weight of his hands against your skin. But he wasnât there, and the hands moving down your body, lower and lower, were yours. By the time your fingers reached the hem of your panties and you gently caressed yourself, you were already wet. And sensitive. Your body was already reacting to the memory of him. You touched yourself slowly at first, almost shyly, but it took only seconds before the need overcame hesitation. Your mind replayed that night in flashes â the way heâd looked at you before kissing you, the way heâd pulled you closer, the way youâd broken apart under him. And then came the words heâd written. The things heâd hinted at. The way heâd said heâd touch you if he were there, the things he wanted to do to you. Your hips lifted instinctively, chasing a contact that wasnât there, your body tightening in a sweet, unbearable tension. Within minutes, your legs were already shaking and your forehead damp with sweat as you came screaming his name into the empty room.
Sam, on the other hand, fought his own battles too â not just in the field, but inside his head. Your words had a way of disarming him, slipping under his armor as he read your letters in silence, sometimes even alone. Sometimes he needed to adjust himself with a frustrated sigh, because your words did things to him he had no control over. His body reacted before he could think, before he could even curse your name under his breath. He could almost see you as he read. The way you might look as you wrote. It was torture â sweet and unbearable â to read those words, imagine you and not be able to touch you, to see you. Every time he wished he could be there with you, wherever âthereâ was.
Maybe one day, he thought, that wish would stop feeling like a fantasy and would become reality.Â
He hoped that day would come soon.
But for now, all he had were your letters and his imagination â and for now, that had to be enough.
For now.Â
-
Weeks passed. The days blurred together in dust, noise, and waiting.
When the mail finally arrived one morning and Samâs name was called, he wiped his hands on his pants and reached for the envelope with your name on it. It was smaller this time â thin, almost weightless. Not like the ones heâd grown used to, the ones stuffed with books, CDs, or whatever small pieces of you you tried to sneak across the world. For a second, disappointment hit him low in the stomach. Then he caught himself â it was still something from you. And that was more than enough.
He sat down on the edge of his cot, turning the envelope over once, twice, before opening it. He pulled out the letter carefully, not noticing the other object youâd slipped inside.
He unfolded the page and began to read.
Sam, Iâm sorry if my last words had that kind of effect on you â that wasnât my intention. Or maybe it was, a little. Either way, Iâve been thinking about how to make it up to you. Words can only do so much, and maybe itâs time for something a little more real. Something to help you when the nights get too long or things get hard. I hope youâre more of a âhipsâ guy than a âboobsâ guy â just this once, at least. If you havenât already guessed or understood, look again inside the envelope. Keep it safe. I know you wonât show it to anyone. I hope it helps. Y/N PS: Donât forget: stay alive, stay safe out there.Â
Sam read the letter twice, eyebrows drawing together. Look again? Then, almost cautiously, he reached for the envelope and noticed the small weight inside â something he hadnât felt before.
A photograph.
He pulled it out slowly, his pulse quickening, glancing around the barracks to make sure no one was watching. There were only two other guys nearby, playing cards, oblivious. He lifted the picture. It was a black-and-white polaroid â the kind that looked like a memory caught mid-breath. You were lying on your side on a bed he didnât recognize, half-turned away from the camera. You were nearly naked, wearing only lace panties that left nothing to imagination. Your head rested on your arm, hair spilling over the pillow in soft, messy waves. Your tattoos flowed across your skin like a painted canvas. Sam blinked, once, twice, his throat suddenly dry. He looked around again â the other two soldiers were still playing and talking, unaware. As he brought the photo closer, brushing the edge of the image, Sam swallowed hard. He slowly traced the curve of your body â the line of your back, the gentle rise of your hips, the soft swell of your ass framed by lace â as if by touching the picture he could feel you, touch you again. He let the photo slide between his fingertips, slow and reverent, like touching the paper was the closest he could get to touching your skin again. His body reacted immediately, betraying him before he could even think. A sharp, involuntary throb â one that made him shift on the cot and squeeze his thighs together, trying to ground himself in the discomfort. He hated and loved how easily you did this to him. It wasnât just desire, it was longing. Everything heâd been trying to bury since the moment he got on the plane months ago. He stared at the image for a long time, letting it burn into his mind until he was sure he would never forget it. Then he slid it carefully back into the envelope and tucked it into the pocket inside his jacket â close to his chest, where no one could find it.
Youâd told him to keep it safe. And he would. Not only because you asked him to, but because that picture wasnât meant for anyone else.
In that small, fragile photograph, you were his â and he was yours, even from a world away.
-
A few days later, Sam found himself going through the small stack of photographs youâd sent him in the past months. Some showed you smiling directly at the camera; others were stolen moments â blurry, spontaneous, your face half-hidden behind a mug or caught mid-laugh. The smiling ones were his favorites. There was something about them that made him forget where he was or what he was doing. Your smile was warm, unguarded, the kind that could light up a room â and Sam liked to imagine it was meant for him.
He was sliding the photos back into an envelope when one slipped from his fingers, fluttering to the floor and landing a few feet away. Samâs chest tightened. It wasn't just any photo but the last one youâd sent him. The one lying on the bed, half naked. He bent down quickly to grab it before anyone could see or take it. But someone preceded him.Â
A voice cut through the noise of the barracks, loud and teasing. âWell, well, what do we have here, OâNeal?â, the voice paused. âIs this your girl? Not bad!â
Sam froze. His blood went cold. Jeff. Sam barely knew the guy, but enough to know he didnât like him. Arrogant, always smirking or insulting, he was the kind of man who enjoyed provoking people just to watch them react. He hated that Jeff was holding your picture. It felt like a promise breaking right there in his hands.
Samâs voice came out low, controlled. âGive it back.â
But Jeff didnât. Instead, he lifted the photo closer to his face, studying it with a grin that made Samâs hands curl into fists. âHold on, just a second. Gotta appreciate the view first.â Sam felt something sharp twist deep inside him â anger, possessiveness, something dangerously close to violence. He couldnât stand Jeffâs eyes on you â him looking at you like that. But he needed to maintain the calm. He took a step forward, his jaw tightening and his voice sharper. âI said give it back.â
Jeff stepped back, grinning wider, enjoying the tension and the attention. A few heads had turned, drawn by the tone in his voice. The room quieted slightly, the lazy chatter fading as the men turned to watch. Samâs hands curled into fists, as he was trying to maintain the calm. He lunged forward, his hand shooting out to grab the picture, but Jeff pulled it away at the last second, laughing.
âCome on, OâNeal, donât be so jealous. Why donât you share? Sheâs too pretty to keep all to yourself ââ
Samâs patience snapped. He closed the distance in two strides, ripped the photo from Jeffâs hand, shoved it deep into his pocket, and turned away before he could do something he regretted. He had barely taken three steps when Jeff called out again, loud enough for everyone to hear: âWhatâs the problem, OâNeal? Maybe she can send me one next time! Or is she too busy fucking around?â
The room went still. Sam stopped.
He turned around slowly, his face darkening, every muscle in his body tight with anger. He walked toward Jeff, closing the distance between them one step at a time, his fists already curling. âWhat did you just say?â His voice was low, dangerous.
Jeff smirked again. âOh, donât tell me your girl only spreads her legs for you. A pretty thing like that must have a damn waiting list.â
The punch came fast and hard. Jeffâs head snapped to the side as he stumbled back, then swung in return, hitting Sam in the cheek.
Jeff laughed, spitting blood from his mouth. âWith a body like that I bet sheâs a fucking handful in bed. Isnât she, OâNeal?â Sam was blinded by rage. With Jeff's words echoing in his head, he quickly advanced and punched him in the face again, knocking him to the floor. âSon of a bitch!âÂ
âHey, Sam! Stop it!â, Mac yelled.Â
But Sam wasnât listening. He was busy hitting Jeff again â and again â until Erik and Elliot pulled him back, while Mac and Ray stepped between them. Jeff was on the floor, wiping blood from his mouth and muttering curses. Samâs chest rose and fell rapidly. His knuckles were split and bleeding; his cheek burned where Jeffâs punch had landed. His heart was pounding so hard he could barely hear anything else. âLet me go,â he muttered, shaking his friends off. âIâm fine.â
âYeah, sure,â Mac said, guiding him toward a chair, away from Jeff where others soldiers were helping him. âSit down before someone walks in and starts asking questions.â
Reluctantly, Sam obeyed and sat. Ray grabbed the first aid kit and began to treat his wounds, while the others hovered around him â silent at first, unsure what to say. They knew better than to push too hard when he was like this. Sam rarely spoke about you but they knew enough to know that every time he smiled reading a letter, it was from you. Theyâd all realized â maybe even before he did â just how gone he was for you.Â
Sam's face contorted in pain as Ray disinfected his wounds, still trying to steady his breathing. Jeffâs words replayed in his head, each one twisting deeper.
Ray was the first to break the silence. âSo⌠was that her?â he asked carefully. âThe girl in the picture.â
Sam hesitated, then nodded.Â
âIs she your girlfriend now?â Erik asked, tilting his head. He shook his head. âNo⌠but I like her.â
That earned a few faint smiles, but no one dared to tease him further. Mac, always the one to lighten the mood, leaned forward after a pause. âSo whatâs her name, man? Or do we keep calling her Bar Girl?â
Sam looked up, frowning slightly. âBar Girl?â
Mac shrugged. âYou met her at a bar, didnât you? You never told us her name. And we had to call her something.â
Sam huffed out a quiet, tired laugh. âHer nameâs Y/N. Y/NÂ Y/Ln.â
There was a brief pause â then Elliot, the oldest in the group, lifted his head, his eyes widened a little. âWait,â he said slowly. âDid you say Y/N Y/Ln? Like⌠Y/Ln?â
Sam nodded, a little confused. âWhy? What about it?â
Elliot traded a look with Erik, lowering his voice. âYou really donât know? Her father â if itâs who I think â heâs a colonel. A big name. Old-school, strict, respected, the kind everyone in the force knows about.â
Sam blinked, processing that. âShe never really mentioned him. Just that her familyâs been military for generations and that she was in the army too.â
Ray leaned back, rubbing a hand over his face. âOh shit, I remember now. Didnât he lose a son a few years back? He stepped on a mine if I recall right. And the daughter ââ he hesitated, glancing at Sam, ââ apparently she was there when it happened. She saw the whole thing and couldnât do anything to save him.â Elliot nodded. The words hit Sam like a slow punch to the gut. For a few minutes, he didnât move. He just stared at the floor as the pieces began to click into place â your silence, your hesitation, your refusal when youâd turned him down that night at the bar. Heâd wondered for months why you never talked about your own experience in the army. Heâd thought about it again and again, inventing reasons, imagining even the worst ones, but heâd never asked. That night heâd sensed something, when youâd told him youâd been in the army. The way youâd said it⌠Your voice had tightened⌠And Sam had understood, even then, that it hadnât been a good experience. That whatever had happened to youâd left marks deeper than anything you were willing to admit. Heâd hoped that one day youâd tell him yourself, even just a detail â but you never did. Youâd been careful in your letters, always steering the conversation away.
Now it all made sense.
Youâd lost your brother. A soldier as him. And youâd seen it happen.
Now he knew why you wanted nothing to do with that world. Why that night youâd looked at him the way you did â like he was something that could hurt you. You were afraid of loving someone who might never come back. Just like him. He was a risk.Â
Sam felt a dull ache rise in his chest, heavier than any bruise. He leaned back against the wall, staring at the floor, the voices of his friends fading around him.
He finally understood why youâd tried to keep your distance from him, why itâd taken you so long to let him in. Because youâd already lost too much and now you wanted to protect yourself. And yet, somehow, you still smiled in the photos. You still wrote to him. Reality hit Sam in the face like a punch, even more painful than the one Jeff had given him. For the first time, Sam realized he could easily become another ghost in your life if the war decided to take him next.
-
Over the next few days, Sam couldnât get your name out of his head. Elliotâs words kept echoing again and again in his mind, until he found himself asking quiet questions in shadowed corners, trading cigarettes for half-whispered answers, confirming what he already knew â your father, your family, your brother. Every story pieced together what youâd never told him.
And once he knew, he couldnât unknow.
Guilt began to coil in his chest like smoke. He thought about the letters heâd sent you, wondering how many of them had dragged you back to memories youâd spent years trying to bury. How many times his words had cut into wounds heâd never seen. A slow, sinking realization settled in him: heâd done the one thing youâd fought so hard to avoid. Heâd pulled you back into the world youâd escaped. Some days, he hated himself for that. Heâd catch himself reaching for pen and paper, then stop. Or heâd stare at your last letter for long minutes, tracing the edge of the paper with his thumb. For months, heâd replied to you immediately. Every letter from you had been an anchor, and his answers had poured out of him without hesitation.
But now?
He couldnât bring himself to write a single line.
He wanted to answer. God, he wanted to. But what could he say now that he knew the truth?
He couldnât just pretend and ask about your day, ignoring the ghost standing between your words. Each night heâd sit at the desk, blank paper in front of him, fingers hovering. Sometimes heâd start writing only to tear the page a moment later, crushing it in his fist. He told himself you were better off without his letters. That maybe silence would be a mercy. Maybe you would feel relieved, even safer, if he finally faded from your life â if the soldier who unknowingly pulled you back into the past simply stopped writing. He was trying to convince himself it was the right thing to do â let you go.Â
But as the days passed, the silence began to weigh on him. He couldnât sleep. He pushed food around on his tray but rarely finished it. Every night he wondered if you were still checking the mailbox, thinking something had happened to him. That heâd been hurt. Or worse.
Maybe it was already too late to turn back.
Several days later, he found himself standing outside the mailroom, envelope in hand. Your name was written across the front, in his neat, careful handwriting. He stared at it for a long time. Then he took a deep breath and handed it over.
Silence wasnât mercy â it was cowardice. Heâd fought so hard to reach you, to earn even a piece of your trust only to disappear in that manner. He couldnât do that now. If a decision had to be made, it wasnât his. It was yours.
And so, for the first time since learning the truth, Sam had written with complete honesty. Heâd told you that he knew about your brother and you. That he finally understood why youâd turned away from everything connected to the army, why that night at the bar at first youâd refused to even have a drink with him. Heâd written that if this letter made you want to stop writing, he would understand. He wouldnât blame you, wouldnât try to change your mind. But first he needed you to know one thing: that your letters had meant something. That had made him feel like never before. That every word youâd written was carved into him like a tattoo â something permanent, something real.Â
Heâd ended the letter simply, his handwriting a little unsteady near the end:
If this is the last letter, thank you for every word. Iâll carry them with me, wherever I go. Sam
He sealed the envelope, holding it in his hand for a moment longer before slipping it into the outgoing pile.
As he walked away, he didnât look back. But the thought followed him anyway âthat maybe, just maybe, those were the last words he would ever send you.
- All that bloodshed, crimson clover Uh-huh, sweet dream was over -
September 2006
You received his letter a few weeks later.
After your last one â the one with the photo â youâd expected something light, maybe teasing, filled with that quiet tension that always hummed beneath your exchanges. You hadnât expected this.
There was nothing playful in those words. Nothing soft or ironic. It was serious â the kind of letter you and Sam rarely wrote. He knew. About you. About your brother.
Until that moment, youâd managed to avoid the topic â and youâd been grateful for that. It was comforting to speak with someone who didnât know, who couldnât look at you with pity or measure every word, afraid of breaking something fragile inside you. Sam had simply talked to you â not to the daughter of a colonel, not to the sister of the soldier who never came home, but to you.Those letters had become a space where the world didnât have to be heavy, where there were no ranks, no rules, no ghosts of the past. You liked that about him: that even though he belonged to the same world youâd sworn to stay away from, with him it somehow felt⌠different. Lighter. As if the uniform didnât matter. But secrets never lasted long, not even in the military world, and that fragile illusion was gone now. Something in you tightened â because now, even in his eyes, you feared you would no longer be you, but âthe colonelâs daughter whoâd watched her brother die and couldnât do anything to stop it.â You read Samâs letter again and again. He hadnât asked questions or pressed for more details. Heâd simply written that he was sorry â that he understood more now, and that he wouldnât ask for anything you werenât ready to give. You appreciated it. His restraint, his gentleness. But even a single mention of your brotherâs name had been enough to tear open old wounds. The words blurred as your vision filled with tears. Breath caught in your throat as those long-buried images came crashing back â the sand, the smoke, the sound of the radio that day â and suddenly you were there again. Your tears fell on the page, smudging Samâs handwriting until his words dissolved into small blue stains.
Days passed and you still hadnât written back. You didnât know what to say â or whether you should answer at all. Sam had left the decision to you, placing you at the same crossroads youâd faced when he first wrote to you. Back then, it wouldâve been easy to walk away. You couldâve ignored him and moved on with your life. But now⌠now it wasnât so simple. Something had happened between you â something you couldnât undo. He hadnât only stepped into your life, but into your heart too. You cared about him. Your choice now was between ending whatever existed between you â cutting the cord before it could pull you under â or continuing, risking the fall. The first would hurt, yes, but maybe someday youâd forget. Maybe Sam would fade into the background of your life, becoming just another page in a story already written. The second choice meant uncertainty â reopening doors youâd locked long ago, knowing you might lose him in the end.
Neither option felt right. Both felt like losing.
The following weeks blurred together. You went through the motions, trying to quiet your mind, but the ache lingered â the ache of his words, and of everything they had stirred back to life. And then, amid all of that, came your brotherâs birthday. That day never failed to break you, no matter how much time had passed. It was a weird feeling because youâd once loved it â planning small surprises, teasing your brother about getting older. But after his death, the date turned into something unbearable, a cruel reminder of everything heâd never get to be. He wouldâve turned thirty-two that day but heâd always be twenty-eight years old. Even though you were the younger one, now you were older than heâd ever be. Time had stopped for him that day. But not for you.Â
- And maybe itâs the past thatâs talkinâ Screamin' from the crypt Tellin' me to punish you for things you never did -
October 2006
The night shift had been quiet. Too quiet. Then the doors burst open.
An eighteen-year-old boy. Scraped knees, torn hoodie, skateboard still clutched in one hand. Heâd taken a bad fall and hit the pavement hard, the paramedics said. It looked like nothing more than a broken arm and a few bruises. He was talking, joking even.Â
You smiled at him and reassured him it wasnât serious. âYouâll be fine,â you said. But a few hours later, his vitals dropped. Then dropped again. Until it was too late and he was gone.Â
You stood motionless as the monitors went flat, the room sinking into that familiar, unbearable silence.
After they took him away, you stayed behind in the trauma room, sitting on the floor against the wall. You stared at the empty bed. The faint smell of antiseptic hung in the air, the skateboard leaned against the wall, as if it was waiting for him to return.
You felt your throat tighten, your eyes filled with tears. It wasnât fair. None of it made sense.Â
Heâd come in for something small â something stupid â and now he was gone. Forever.Â
And in that moment, the truth hit you like a punch to the chest: none of us were safe. Not from death, not from loss. We could spend our lives building walls, trying to protect ourselves from pain â and still, it found us. Your brother had died in service, in war, a victim of something cruel and deliberate. This boy had died because of gravity and a stupid fall that shouldâve left nothing more than a few bruises. Two lives ended for two completely different reasons â one tragic, one absurd â and yet, in the end, both were gone all the same. So what sense did it make to keep hiding from life? To keep refusing to love, to feel, to live â out of fear that it might one day hurt again?Â
Even if your brother was gone, youâd been lucky to share a part of your life with him, to call him your brother. Youâd had moments with him that no one could ever take away, not even death. And somehow, that made the pain bearable. Because behind every painful memory there were many other beautiful ones.Â
You remembered a sentence you'd read a while ago that said âLoving and losing is better than never to have loved at allâ. Youâd spent years thinking loving wasn't worth it, a waste of time that only led to pain. But maybe the real waste was to live without loving.
You found yourself walking toward the staff room. You searched for a piece of paper and grabbed your pen.
After weeks of silence, the words spilled out â raw, trembling, unfiltered. You wrote everything youâd never dared to say: about your brother, about the fear, about how Sam had somehow brought you back to life without even knowing it.
You wrote until your hand cramped, until the ache in your chest loosened just enough to breathe again.
When you finished, you folded the letter carefully, sliding it into the envelope. You stared at his name on the front for a long moment, your eyes burning.
It was almost dawn when your shift ended. You walked out into the half-light, the city wrapped in a quiet mist. Your steps echoed on the empty street, your breath rising in small clouds. Halfway home, you stopped in front of the postbox, the one youâd used for every letter before.
The metal felt cold beneath your fingertips as you slipped the letter inside, hoping it wasnât too late â hoping Sam wasnât done waiting for you. -
The days passed, and no letter from Sam arrived.
At first, you didnât worry. You tried not to. Itâd happened before â sometimes the mail took longer than it should. Maybe he was on a mission. You told yourself that was all it was.
But when the days turned into weeks, then into months, the silence started to feel heavier. And doubt began to creep in.
You sent another letter â just in case the first one had gotten lost. For safety, you told herself. You tried to sound casual, light, though your hand trembled as you wrote.
But still nothing.Â
Another letter followed. And then another. You kept writing anyway, as if the act of writing itself was the only thing keeping you from falling apart, ignoring how desperate or foolish you might have seemed. Maybe heâd grown tired of you. Maybe heâd decided to let you go â for both of your sakes. Or maybe this was his way of paying you back, of giving you silence for silence. But that didnât feel like Sam. He wasnât cruel. He wouldnât vanish without a word.
But the question kept echoing in your head. Why wasnât he answering?
- Flashes of the battle come back to me in a blur -
November 2006
One night, after writing yet another letter, sleep came late â shallow and restless. And when it finally did, it brought a dream â vivid, merciless. It wasnât just a dream. It was a memory.
You were back in the desert â blinding sun, dust and smoke thick in the air. Your brother stood a few meters away, motionless, a strange, frozen look on his face. You called his name once, twice. But he didnât move. He couldnât. Then you saw it â the way his boot pressed into the dirt, right on top of something half-buried beneath the sand. A landmine.
You tried to reach him, screaming his name, your voice raw, but someone was holding you back â rough hands on your arms, dragging you away as you fought and kicked. âLet me go!â you screamed.
He looked at you then â calm, almost resigned â and mouthed something you couldnât hear. A faint smile. And then the sound â deafening, final. The explosion. The fire. Silence.
You woke up screaming, trembling and drenched in sweat, your throat raw, your cheeks already wet with tears. For a moment you didnât know where you were. The room was dark, still, the air too heavy to breathe. Even after you calmed down, the feeling stayed with you â a sick, cold dread that curled around your chest and wouldnât let go. It followed you through the shower, the bus ride, the sterile hospital corridors. It hid in the hum of the lights, in the metallic scent of disinfectant, in every sound that made you flinch. You told yourself that you were still upset because of the dream. Nothing more. It was just your mind playing tricks. But a voice deep inside whispered otherwise.
By the time your shift ended that evening, you couldnât ignore the feeling anymore. Maybe it wasnât just a dream. Maybe it was a warning. -
Your apartment was dark except for the glow from the kitchen. You stared at your phone for a long time before picking it up. The screen glowed in the dark, harsh against your eyes. Your fingers trembled as you dialed the number you hadnât called in months.Â
It rang twice.
âY/N⌠is that you?â Your fatherâs voice carried surprise, disbelief â and maybe a hint of relief. âHi, dadâŚâ you said quietly, pausing. âI just⌠I wanted to check in. See how you were doing.â
There was a pause, awkward and unfamiliar. It was strange â he was your father, yet in that moment, you felt like strangers, unsure how to bridge the silence between you. âIâm fine,â he said. âWhat about you? Did something happen?â
âNo, no, Iâm fine,â you lied quickly. âItâs justâŚIâve had this weird feeling all day. And I couldnât shake it. I thought maybe something had happenedâŚto you.â
âIâm fine,â he reassured you, gentle but firm. âYou donât need to worry about me.â You smiled, a little relieved. But the feeling was still there.Â
The line went quiet again. You almost said goodbye, but thenâ âDad?â
âIâm here. What is it?â
âI need a favor.â Your voice wavered. âI need you to check on someone for me. Just⌠to make sure heâs okay.â âWho?â
You didnât tell him everything, only what was necessary â enough for him to look into it. He didnât ask for more, sensing the delicacy of the situation.Â
âAlright,â he said after a moment. âGive me a few hours. Iâll call you back when I know something, okay?â
You nodded, even though he couldnât see you. âOkay. Thanks, Dad.â
When the call ended, you sat there in the dark for a long while, staring at the phone. The hum of the refrigerator the only sound in the apartment. All you could do now was wait. And hope. But hope for what? You didnât know what for anymore. If Sam was fine, then he was choosing not to answer â choosing silence. Choosing to forget you. But if he wasnât⌠if something had happened⌠You closed your eyes, pressing your hands to your face as you didn't want to think about that possibility. You sighed. Every minute stretched endlessly, heavy and slow, making the wait unbearable. -
When your phone finally rang an hour later, you jumped. You knew it was your father before you even looked at the screen. You stomach twisted as you picked up. âDad?â Your voice was barely a whisper.Â
There was a pause. Too long.
âHeâs alive,â your father finally said.Â
You let out a breath you hadnât realized youâd been holding. Relief rushed through you so fast it almost hurt. But then you heard it again â the slight hesitation, the heavy silence that followed. You replayed your fatherâs words in your head. He hadnât said he was fine. He had said he was alive. Something had happened.Â
Your throat tightened. âWhat else?â you asked, your voice breaking. âDad, please. What arenât you telling me?â
But deep down, you already knew. It hadn't just been a dream.Â
There was a pause on the other end. You could hear the sound of your fatherâs breath, the hesitation before truth. âHeâs alive,â he repeated softly, âbut heâs been injured during a mission. HeâsâŚâ
You stopped listening.
The words echoed in your mind, hollow and sharp, drowning everything else. Heâs been injured. Heâs been injured. Heâs been injured.
Your vision blurred as your eyes became glossy. The room tilted slightly out of focus. You could still hear your father talking, but his voice sounded far away, muffled, like underwater.
He was alive âbut at what cost?Â
TO BE CONTINUED...
Let me know if you liked it and if you want to be tagged in the last part.





















