These readings pose the question, at what point is taking inspiration and using others work in your art wrong? Is it wrong to take inspiration from another artist? Is it wrong to use their image and transform it without paying them a fee? Â In my opinion the answers to these questions are blurred and confusing. To put it into the most simple of terms, I think that if what you are doing is robbing someone of monetary gain by using their work without paying them, you have committed an offense.
           For instance, in the article about Janine Gordon suing Ryan McGinley for taking inspiration from her works and not paying her for them, I believe Gordon has a negligible case for suing McGinley. He did not use any of her work in his, and saying he even somewhat copied her work is a bit of a stretch. Pointing out that models’ arms are stretched in the shape way is hardly copyright infringement. Likewise, if this were a punishable offense then most every piece of work in existence would be liable for damages, because there isn’t a work out there that wasn’t inspired by something else.
           In Shepard Fairey’s case the lines begin to blur. He used such a generic image of president Obama that the company that owned the picture didn’t even recognize it, let alone the person who actually took the picture. However, Fairey did use an image that wasn’t his without permission from the people that owned it, thus he begins to tread in the murky waters of taking a monetary gain away from someone by using their image without licensing.  If I were the one to decide on this case I would probably allow for Fairey to be sued for doing this.
           The case of Girl Talk is pretty clear-cut in my opinion. Girl Talk uses music that doesn’t belong to them to profit and this is clearly a punishable offense. In the article it even states that nobody sues him just because they believe a lawsuit against him would kick off a storm of copyright reform in which they could no longer sue lesser-known artists any longer. However I believe what Girl Talk does is also a punishable offense and worthy of a lawsuit because at the end of the day, he is using others work for his own profit.