Hello Mel!
I love your Sanji rants and vids! I'm not sure if you've covered this anywhere else, but what do you think of Sanji's "if I'm not myself, kill me" moment?
On one hand, Zoro's a man of his word and would absolutely do his best to uphold his promise; but on the other, Sanji is his nakama. Zoro literally sacrificed himself in place of Sanji and Luffy, so I find it hard to believe Zoro would allow one of his nakama to die (or be killed) without a fight.
Basically, do you think that their death pact is Sanji's way of making sure Zoro keeps him accountable? And do you think there's a possibility for Sanji to become Stealth Black in the future?
I've talked about this a lot in different places but yes I 100% think the reason Sanji chose Zoro is because he thinks Zoro is the best person to carry out the promise. Not only do Zoro and Sanji have this understanding between each other - which comes in the form of a 'secret' with what happened on Thriller Bark as they both saw how self sacrificing the other was for the crew (yes, Brook and Robin saw it, but that moment wasn't between them and is not for them to share. This is why Brook/Robin have never told anyone of what happened on Thriller Bark). BUT Sanji also understands how much a promise means to Zoro, he literally SAW Zoro's promise to himself and to Luffy during the Baratie. As we know, that moment impacted Sanji greatly, and Zoro's whole scene at the Baratie was even one of the reasons Sanji decided to join the crew.
When it comes to Thriller Bark, the 'nothing happened' scene cemented Zoro and Sanji as the wings, while also giving us an insight of what Sanji and Zoro think of each other. Sanji believes he embarrassed himself due to Zoro being the one to actually take Kuma's pain, but Brook assured him Sanji's own resolve was equally as admirable as Zoro's. And, if we fill in the blanks, we can definitely see Zoro refuses to let anyone die, hence why he refused to let Sanji take his place in front of Kuma. Either way, Thriller Bark was a huge arc for Zoro and Sanji, because it gave them something specific and insane - a secret they have to keep from LUFFY.
They both know how angry Luffy would be if he found out they tried to die in HIS place, and they also wouldn't want Luffy to feel that guilt. At the same time, SANJI now feels that guilt due to the damage Zoro took from Kuma, and I see this as an unspoken tension between the two of them - especially when we consider how desperate, frustrated and terrified Sanji was when being knocked out by Zoro and finding Zoro standing in a pool of his own blood. So, as controversial as this idea might seem...I think? Sanji has become Zoro's emotional pillar to lean on.
I can't exactly say it works vice versa, because WCI was an example of how Sanji isn't afraid to rely on Luffy - even though he felt guilty to do so until Luffy...quite literally punched his love into him LOL
As the wings, Luffy relies on THEM to boost HIM up, and Zoro takes this very seriously. But when Zoro needs the help, who can he turn to? Well, probably the guy he shares a whole ass secret with that not even their captain can know about! The biggest moment to portray this is in Onigashima, when Zoro was knocked out on the rooftop to protect Luffy (and others), and Sanji literally CARRIED and BANDAGED Zoro on the battlefield afterwards. While Zoro could feel some guilt regarding not being strong enough against Kaido, he is comfortable enough to sleep on Sanji's shoulder and trusts in Sanji keep him safe.
Sanji saw Zoro in Thriller Bark, after all. He not only saw Zoro at death's door, but in a vulnerable state of desperation to keep the captain and crew alive. Promising death together, in front of each other, or for one another...is an incredible act of affinity to me! Zoro had one foot in the grave in front of Sanji before, so Sanji protecting him as he's totally immobilised on a battlefield isn't going to really bother Zoro!
Yet, as we get to the death pact, the matter of death comes up again. Instead of a promise made to an outside source - which Zoro can throw himself in front of - this is a promise made BY a crewmate. Zoro can't just replace Sanji in this situation, he can't knock Sanji out and keep him safe, HE has to kill HIM. I always saw this as Sanji not only being at his most vulnerable with Zoro, but as a cruel payback for what Zoro put Sanji through in Thriller Bark. Not in any malicious way, of course, but as an ironic twist of fate that Zoro simply cannot escape.
Can't replace Sanji, can't save Sanji, can only kill Sanji - and now Zoro has to suffer possibly seeing Sanji with one foot in the grave. Or worse...IN the grave.
All this to say, I do not believe Zoro could kill Sanji because I agree with you, I can't see him ever killing a crewmate. They mean too much to him, all of them, and Sanji is part of the Strawhats. Not to mention, as I said, I believe Sanji is a pillar Zoro can lean on - and he's being asked to quite literally destroy that pillar.
Yet, Sanji has so little self respect and sees Zoro as someone so overly ambitious I think he thinks Zoro can kill him if needed. As much as I believe Sanji can read Zoro, I think he's vastly underestimated just how much...he means to Zoro?? And I don't even mean that in a gay way or ship way, just in a general crewmates way. I think what Sanji has asked Zoro is entirely too cruel, because Zoro will break that promise, and I don't think Sanji even sees it that way. Yet, Sanji apologised for what he's asked of Zoro, meaning he knows it's a big ask for Zoro to kill him - I just don't think he knows how big of an ask it really is.
Sorry I rambled, but yes I think there's a full possibility of Sanji mutating completely because I cannot see Sanji's new, sparkly superpowers that make him the deus ex machina of battle heavy moments existing without some kind of drawback. Even Gear 5 has drawbacks, surely Sanji is snowballing into some horrible situation. How Zoro will handle that...is beyond me! I hope there's crying!


















