Would it be wrong, if I say I wanted an unethical and toxic fic between Safia, Gideon and Phyre
Like a AU fic where Gideon and Safia are fiancés after a century of dating but then Safia meets Phyre (the AU is just Gideon being alive and Safia not being rabid)
Imagine the excitement you get from a new crush, something like that. So the new feeling has Safia hooked (not to mention she’s READ about the nomad, she’s their biggest fangirl)
So Safia is unintentionally chasing this feeling with Phyre. At first she justifies it, makes excuses, is in denial
Then she just accepts this but is like, “Gideon is still my lover. They’re just a momentary fling.”
But it’s so intense that she’s basically (nah, literally) cheating on Gideon with Phyre. First it’s emotional only, then it inevitably turns physical
Though it’s only just a few kisses here and then (having a hard time imagining Safia going past that without crumbling into dust out of sheer guilt with Gideon alive and well)
Safia loves Gideon, she truly does. He’s such a deeply comforting presence in her unlife. But Phyre is this new, intoxicating and fiery romance (see what I did there) she can’t help but keep going back to
The forbidden nature of their relationship is also… part of the appeal
Bonus points if (when) Gideon finds out, he’s just chill about it and is just wondering why Safia did not just tell him outright
It’s only toxic and problematic when Gideon doesn’t know about it tho. I was initially just curious about how the characters would act in this scenario
What Safia would feel, how Phyre would handle being the side piece or whatever
But it’d definitely be funny if the whole fic is incredibly angsty, slightly romantic (cuz pining! ‘Oh no we can’t! can we?’ 👀)and lots! LOTS of guilt only for the last line to be like
Gideon: “Oh dear, why didn’t you just tell me and save yourself all this torment? Go get that elderussy” </3











