some of you are saying enemies to lovers when you mean rivals to lovers and some of you are saying enemies to lovers when you mean enemies with benefits. but these are all distinct categories
See, I feel like there are actually a ton of different archetypes here?
* in-universe-acknowledged Worthy Adversaries who would stop at nothing to kill the other but genuinely respect each other
* metanarrative Worthy Adversaries who genuinely despise each other but are explicitly designed to be matched. Usually a lot of obsession going on.
* stories where the hero genuinely hopes to save the villain (usually in more fantastical stories where the bad guy's actions don't hit too close to home)
* stories where the villain is far more powerful than the hero (who might be just a normal person) and likely kidnaps them or whatever
* people on opposite sides of a conflict who genuinely like each other and wish they didn't have to fight
* two people who personally hate each other but are extremely attracted to each other (and usually end up realising they both judged the other based on their biases) (I think THIS is what a lot of people say is really 'rivals to lovers'...? But I'm honestly not sure.)
* two people who personally hate each other but slowly over time come to understand one another better (arguably should be classified 'enemies to friends to lovers' but not everyone is familiar with that term)
I guess if I had to have an opinion, there are two things that people tend to lean on to define 'Enemies to Lovers': either being on Opposite Sides in some greater conflict, or personally disliking each other. That's why it's hard to sum up easily what does or doesn't qualify, because most EtL ships will have some degree of both going on, and it's only in the extreme cases that people start disagreeing.

















