everything except exit signs
pairing. luke hemmings x female reader word count. 7613 synopsis. you've always had one rule: never answer a Luke Hemmings text after midnight. it was the only thing keeping you sane, the only boundary you'd managed to hold onto after years of being his emergency contact, his late-night call, his built-in therapist who also sometimes fucked him. but when he shows up at 2 AM with bloodshot eyes and the same brand of cigarettes from years ago, all your rules and morals go up in smoke â along with your resolve, your self-respect, and the last shred of distance you'd carefully constructed. after all, the two of you had always been experts at noticing everything about each other except the bright red exit signs. warnings. smoking (cigarettes), profanity, angst, toxic relationship dynamics, sexual content (hair pulling, degradation, spitting, dirty talk, slight choking), emotional manipulation, self-destructive behavior, slight power imbalance in relationship, mentions of past emotional trauma inspired by: iloveitiloveitiloveit by Bella Kay
Youâve always had one rule: Never answer a Luke Hemmings text after midnight. All they did was get you into trouble â trouble that you didnât need to deal with.
A couple years ago, you couldâve blamed it on youth. On the reckless pulse of an adolescent brain chasing a high only he could deliver. Sneaking around with one of the worldâs most sought-after frontmen? That was a flex in itself â but that was just the surface. Luke Hemmings was so much more intricate than that.
But thatâs exactly why you couldnât have him.Â
You couldn't have him â not really. Being with him was always a race against something: a tour schedule, a press cycle, the dark monologue in his own head telling him he didn't deserve you. It was a vicious rhythm â one minute he needed you like oxygen, the next he couldn't bear the sight of you.Â
So you drew a line. Midnight. No exceptions.
Which is why, when your phone buzzed at 1:47 AM, you knew it wasn't some publicist-approved message filtered through three assistants.
Luke: You up
You stared at the ceiling of your apartment for exactly eleven seconds. Rules. That's what you told yourself. You had rules about this now. You were done with that life from years ago. Done being the one people fell back on. Done being the thing Luke Hemmings reached for at 2 AM when the tour bus got too quiet and his thoughts got too loud.
But if you were being honest with yourself?
You were never really good at following rules.
Y/N: dependsÂ
You paused, contemplating turning your phone off and going to bed. But â as always â his text bubbles appeared again, in the same routine they always do: typing for a few seconds, then disappearing, then typing, then disappearing, then the message.
Luke: Depends?
Luke: Depends on what?Â
Luke: I know youâre awake.
How could you ever respond to something like that?Â
Before you could think of a response, Luke was typing again.
Stopped.
Started again.
Stopped.
The little bubble disappeared for so long you convinced yourself he'd come to his senses.
Luke: Can I ask you something?
Y/N: great opener.
Luke: Is the key still under the mat?
Your thumb hovered over the keyboard like it was wired to a bomb.
âIs the key still under the mat?â
You wanted to lie. You wanted to type no so fast your screen cracked. But the key was still there. Had been for years, through two different leases, through a dozen nights you told yourself you'd finally move it. You never did. Some habits weren't habits at all.
Y/N: that's a dangerous question to ask at 1 AM.
Luke: It's 1:49.
Luke: Youâre stalling.
Luke: It's still there.
You bit the inside of your cheek. God, you hated how well he knew you. Hated how nine years and a thousand miles hadn't dulled that particular knife.
Y/N: you're in a different country, last time I checked.
Luke: Who said I was in a different country?
Your stomach dropped.
You sat up straighter in bed, suddenly hyperaware of the window â the way the city lights bled through the blinds, the way every shadow outside seemed a little too long, a little too deliberate.
You told yourself you were being paranoid. Luke Hemmings didn't just show up anymore. Maybe he wouldâve years ago. But now? He had schedules, obligations, and a life that didn't include sneaking through your building at nearly 2 AM. Not now, anyways.
But then again, he'd always done the thing he wasn't supposed to do.
Y/N: luke.
Y/N: where are you?
Three dots appeared. Disappeared. Appeared again. Then disappeared. You could picture him perfectly â his crystal eyes scanning his phone with a quiet determination, chewing the inside of his lip the way he did when he was trying to decide how much truth to spill.
Luke: Outside.
Luke: Not your door.Â
Luke: Down the street.
Luke: I don't know why I came here.Â
Luke: That's a lie.
You exhaled slowly. Outside. He was outside. Not on your doorstep â not yet â but close enough that the air between you had suddenly shrunk to nothing.
Y/N: what do you want, Luke?
You typed it before you could stop yourself. Blunt. Borderline cruel. But you needed to hear him say it, needed to make him put the words in the open where you could examine them, dissect them, decide if they were the same old nonsense or something that actually meant something this time.
The typing started. Stopped. Started. Stopped.
Luke: I want to know if that key works.
Luke: I want to know if you'd let me use it.
Luke: I want to know if you're still the person who used to leave the porch light on for me.
Luke: And I want to know if you hate me for asking that.
Your throat tightened. The porch light. You'd forgotten you used to do that â a small, stupid ritual that you'd never admitted out loud. He'd noticed. Of course he'd noticed.Â
Luke noticed everything except the bright red exit signs.
You stared at your ceiling again. Eleven seconds turned into thirty. Turned into a minute.
You were never good at rules.
Y/N: the porch light's been broken for two years.
A pause. You could feel his disappointment through the screen, even before he replied.
Luke: Oh.
Y/N: but the key still fits.
You watched the screen. Watched the three dots appear, disappear, appear again, disappear again.Â
Luke: Can I come see you?
Luke: Just for a minute.
Luke: I swear I'm not here to mess with your head.
Luke: Okay maybe a little.
Luke: But not the way I used to.
You laughed despite yourself. Same Luke. Same infuriating, self-aware, absolutely devastating Luke.
Y/N: you have five minutes.
Y/N: and if you wake my neighbors, I'm telling them you're a burglar.
Luke: I'd make a very attractive burglar.
Y/N: five minutes start now.
Luke: I'm running.
Y/N: oh god.
âââââ ââ ââ â âââââ
Just two minutes passed before you heard footsteps at your front door.
The lock turned slowly, like whoever was on the other side was giving you one last chance to stop them.
You thought about it. You had zero obligation to that door. You had zero obligation to the man on the other side. You didn't wait hand and foot for Luke Hemmings, running towards his every beck and call. Â
But something inside you pulled you towards that door.
It opened six inches before it caught on the pile of shoes you'd forgotten to move.
"Still can't keep an entryway clear," Luke said quietly.
And there he was.
It had been six years since you'd seen him in person â nearly seven since you'd touched him with any intention.Â
The man that opened the door wasnât the Luke Hemmings youâd grown up with. He looked different. Older. The baby fat that had clung to his cheeks in his early twenties was gone, replaced by sharper angles and a jaw that looked like it could cut glass. His hair was now a deep black, a stark difference from his usual bleach blonde you'd grown used to over the years.Â
He looked expensive. He was wearing a designer leather jacket over a thin t-shirt, accessorized with Gucci sunglasses, high-heeled boots, a watch that had to have cost more than your rent, and an ostentatious amount of silver chains. The whole get-up was inappropriate for both the weather and time of day, but then again, Luke Hemmings had never been particularly good at dressing for anything other than the aesthetic.
But somehow, under all the glamour he was exuding, he looked absolutely exhausted.Â
"You look like shit," you said.
It wasn't true. He looked devastatingly beautiful. But you couldn't admit that, and you needed to say something to break the spell of just standing there â staring into his ever-eluring blue eyes.
Luke's mouth quirked â that half-smile that had ruined you more times than you could count. "That's all you could come up with? It's been half a decade and you still can't conjure up a comeback."
"I'm just surprised you remember how to use a key. Tour buses don't really need those."
The half-smile flickered. Just for a second. But you caught it â caught the way his eyes dropped to the floor, the way his hand came up to rub the back of his neck.
"Can I come in?" he asked. "Or are you gonna make me stand out here and have this conversation with your welcome mat?"
You stepped away from the door, kicking your shoes towards the corner. Not because you wanted to. You knew you'd regret it either way, and at least this way you could control the narrative. At least this way he was in your space, on your terms.
Luke stepped past you, close enough that you caught the familiar scent of him â cigarette smoke and something darker, something that had always smelled like trouble. The smell clung to his jacket like a second skin. He paused, looking around like he was cataloging every change.
"New couch," he observed.
"The old one broke."
Luke turned to face you fully, and for a moment, neither of you spoke. The silence stretched between you like a thread pulled too thin â one wrong move and it would snap.
His hand drifted to his jacket pocket, patting it absently. A nervous habit you remembered too well.
"I need a cigarette," he said abruptly, already pulling a crumpled pack from his pocket.
"Camel?" you asked, your voice carefully neutral.
"Obviously." He shook one out, pausing to look at you. "You're not going to lecture me?"
"What's the point?" You pushed off the wall and walked toward the back of the apartment. "You never listened before."
The back porch was small â barely big enough for two chairs and a dying plant you kept meaning to water. The city sprawled out below, lights flickering in the early morning haze. Luke followed you out, already lighting the cigarette before he even sat down.
"You quit, didn't you?" he asked, exhaling smoke into the night air. "Seven years ago."
"Six," you corrected, sitting down beside him. "And Iâm still clean. Unlike some people."
"Good for you." He took another drag, and you watched the way his fingers curled around the filter â the same way they always had, even when you were teenagers sneaking cigarettes behind the bandâs tour bus. "One of us had to grow up."
He offered you the cigarette. An old ritual, one he'd never quite stopped performing.
"I don'tâ" You paused. It would be so easy. One drag. One moment of weakness. "I quit, Luke. I'm not starting again because you showed up."
Luke's mouth curved into that half-smile again. "Come on. One won't kill you."
You hated that he knew exactly what to say. Hated that your hand was already reaching out before your brain caught up.
Your fingers brushed his as you took the cigarette â deliberately, you knew. Luke Hemmings didn't do anything accidentally. The touch was light, fleeting, but it sent a shiver down your spine that you couldn't blame on the cold.
You brought the cigarette to your lips, inhaling, and the familiar burn hit your lungs like a betrayal. You coughed once, then again.
"Smooth," he said, watching you with something between amusement and satisfaction.
"Shut up." You handed it back to him, though your fingers lingered for a second longer than necessary. "Since when do you smoke this much?"
"Since the last album cycle." He took it back, inhaling slowly, letting the smoke out in a long, careful stream. "It's a problem."
"Everything is a problem with you."
He laughed â a real laugh, surprised out of him. "Fuck. You haven't changed at all, have you?"
"Neither have you." You watched the ember glow in the dark. "You're still showing up at my door at 2 AM asking questions you already know the answers to."
Luke was quiet for a long moment. The cigarette dangled between his fingers, forgotten.
"I didn't know where else to go," he said finally. "That's not â I mean it. I was on tour, and I was in this hotel room, and I couldn't breathe. I kept thinking aboutâ" He broke off, shaking his head. "I don't know. I just got in a car."
He lifted the cigarette to his lips again, and the gesture was so familiar it ached â the way his eyes half-closed, the way his shoulders dropped just slightly as the nicotine hit. Seven years since you'd watched him do that, and nothing had changed.
Nothing except you. You'd quit. You'd moved on. You'd built a life that didn't revolve around Luke Hemmings and his emergency packs and his 2 AM confessions.
And now here you were, sharing a cigarette with him on your back porch like no time had passed at all.
"You should quit," you said quietly.
"I know." He looked at you, really looked at you, and for a second the exhaustion on his face was unbearable. "But some habits are harder to break than others." He paused. âRight?â
You scoffed, taking the pack off his bouncing leg and lighting your own. The city hummed below you: distant cars, a siren somewhere in the distance. The sounds of a world that didn't care about the two broken people on a tiny balcony.
"I'm not your therapist, Luke,â you said. "I'm not going to be your emotional support person. I'm not going toâ"
"I know."
"âlisten to you talk about how hard everything is and then let you disappear for another six years andâ"
"I know." His voice was sharp, cutting through your rambling. "I know, okay? I'm not asking you to fix me."
"Then what are you asking?"
Luke stubbed out his cigarette on the railing, flicking it off the balcony. He turned to look at you, and in the dim light of the city, his eyes looked almost black.
"I don't know," he admitted. "I justâŚI needed to see you. I needed to remember you were real. That you still existed, that you didn't justâ" He gestured vaguely. "Disappear."
"I'm not the one who disappears, Luke. Thatâs you."
"Okay." He nodded, accepting the blow. "Okay, fair. I did. I do. I'm not good at staying."
"You're good at running."
"You're good at pretending you don't care."
The words hit harder than you expected. You turned away, staring out at the city, the cigarette burning between your fingers.
"I never pretended," you said quietly. "I just got tired of being the one who cares more."
Luke moved. You felt it before you saw it: the shift in the air, the way he leaned closer, his presence overwhelming in such a small space. His hand came up, and you flinched â but he didn't touch you. He just took the cigarette from your fingers and stubbed it out beside his own.
"You're shaking," he observed.
"It's cold."
"It's seventy degrees."
You didn't respond. Because he was right â you weren't cold. You were something else entirely. Something that had been dormant for two years, waking up the moment you saw his face in your doorway.
"Why do you always come here?" You asked as you rose from the chair, crossing your arms tight against your chest in an attempt to make yourself smaller â a habit youâve had forever.
Luke blinked. He looked genuinely confused, like the question didn't compute.
"You have friends. You have your band. You have a family. You have god knows how many therapistsââ
âI have two.â
You scoffed. "You have so many people who would drop everything for you. So why do you always come here?"
Luke stared at you. The silence stretched, thick and heavy.
"Because you always answer," he said finally.
Not an âI love youâ or an âI miss you.â
You always answer.
Something cracked in your chest. You wanted to argue, wanted to point out that you'd been trying to not answer, that you'd been trying to build a life that didn't revolve around him, that you'd almost succeededâ
But you were here. On the porch at 2 AM. Smoking cigarettes you'd quit six years ago. Letting him in.
"I hate you," you said quietly.
"I know."
"I mean it. I hate you. I hate that you can just show up and I let you. I hate that I still have the key under the mat. I hate that I fixed that stupid porch light after it broke six fucking years ago, just in case you came back."
Luke's expression flickered â something raw and vulnerable breaking through the carefully constructed walls.
"The porch light," he said slowly. "You said it was broken."
"I lied."
"Why?"
"I don't know." You laughed, but there was no humor in it. "Because I wanted you to think I'd moved on. Because I wanted to prove something. Because I'm an idiot who can't let go of you no matter how hard I try."
Luke crossed the space between you in two steps. His hands came up to cup your face, and you let him. You let him tilt your head up, let him look at you with that expression that always made you feel like you were the only person in the world.
"You're not an idiot," he said. "I'm the idiot. I'm the one who keeps leaving and then coming back. I'm the one who can't figure out how to stay. But youâ" He swallowed hard. "You're the only thing that makes sense."
"That's not true," you mumbled, looking away from Luke and into the cityscape.
"It is." His thumb traced your cheekbone. "It's always been true. I just didn't know how to handle it."
"LukeâŚ"
"Can I kiss you?"
The question hung between you. He was asking â actually asking. It threw you off balance.
"Why are you asking?" you managed.
"Consent,â he laughed, earning a soft smirk from you. âNo, seriously. I'm trying to be better." His voice was rough. "I don't want you to think I'm just here to use you. Because Iâ" He stopped and shook his head. "Just tell me. Yes or no."
You should have said no.
You should have pushed him away, gone back inside, locked the door, moved the key, changed your number, done any of the things you'd been telling yourself you would do for the last six years.
But you were never good at rules.
"Yes," you whispered. "Yes, fuck, okay, yes."
And then he was kissing you.
It wasn't soft like youâd remembered. It was desperate â six years of absence poured into the way his mouth moved against yours, the way his hands tangled in your hair, the way he pulled you so close you couldn't tell where you ended and he began.
You kissed him back with equal ferocity, your nails digging into his shoulders, pulling him closer even as you told yourself to push him away. He tasted like cigarette smoke and something sweeter underneath, and you remembered how he kissed like he was trying to memorize every part of you.
"I missed you," he breathed against your mouth. "God, I missed you so much."
"Don't." You pulled back, gasping. "Don't say that. Don't make thisâ"
"Make it what?"
"Real. Don't make it real. You're going to leave anyway. You're always going to leave."
Luke's eyes â those sad, blue eyes that had always been your achilles heel â softened. "I'm right here."
"Youâre a bad idea, Hemmings."
"Iâm a good time, Y/L/N."
You shook your head, but you didn't pull away. His hands were still in your hair, and you were still pressed against him, and every logical thought in your head was being drowned out by the feel of him.
"You're going to leave," you repeated. "You're going to leave, and I'm going to be here, and I'm going to spend the next six years trying to forget you again."
"Then let's not think about that," he said. "Let's just have tonight."
"That's the same thing youâd always said."
"Because it's the only thing I know how to say." He pressed his forehead to yours, eyes closed. "I'm not good at this. I'm not good at relationships, or staying, or being what you need. But I'm here. Right now. And I wantâ"
He stopped. Swallowed.
"What?" you prompted. "What do you want?"
Luke opened his eyes. "I want you to tell me to stay."
It was the most honest thing he'd ever said.
âFine. Stay,â you mumbled, gripping his jacket with full force.
You kissed him again â harder this time, more demanding. You pulled him inside, away from the porch and into the dim light of your apartment. The kiss didn't break until you reached the kitchen, and when it did, it was only because you needed to breathe.
âFuck, Hemmings,â you groaned into his lips as he lifted you onto the countertop. Your wine glass from earlier tipped over, shattering on the floor. Neither of you stopped to clean it up. Neither of you stopped at all.
"Tell me to stop," he breathed against your neck. "Tell me to stop and I will."
But you didnât. You pulled him closer by the roots of his hair, and the sound he makes is almost wounded.
"You want to know why I keep coming back?" he asked, pulling away just enough to meet your eyes. "Because no one else makes me feel like this. No one else makes me feel like I'm burning alive. You make me want to self-destruct in the most beautiful way."
"You're such a fucking poet."
"I mean it."
"So do I." You yanked him back in. "Shut up and kiss me."
The kitchen was too bright. He pushed you toward the hallway, through the living room, and into the bedroom. He pressed you into the mattress, and for a moment he just looked at you. Disheveled. Flushed. His thumb traced the line of your jaw.
"Look what you do to me," he murmured. "Look at what you make me."
"Lukeâ"
He kissed you like he's trying to prove somethingâmaybe to you, maybe to himself. You kissed him back the same way. It was the kind of kiss you'd be embarrassed about if anyone else were watching.
"I've thought about this," he said between kisses. "Every night. I've thought about what you sound like, the noises you makeâŚ"
"Then you shouldâ" You gasped as his teeth grazed your collarbone. "You should know what to do."
"Oh, I know exactly what to do."
His hands found your waist, fingers digging in hard enough to bruise. He guided you backward until your ass hit the bed, and then he was on top of you, covering your body with his.
"You're so fucking beautiful," he said. "I forgot how beautiful you are."
"You're lying."
"I never lie to you." His mouth found yours again, and the kiss was messy, all teeth and tongue and barely contained hunger. "I hold things back. I disappear. But I never lie."
When he pulled your shirt off, he tossed it somewhere across the room. Your bra followed. He was still fully dressed, and the power imbalance made you feel exposed.
"Tell me," he said, his lips at your ear, "tell me how much you hate this."
"I hate you."
"Tell me."
"I hate how you do this. IâŚI hate how you show up and ruin everything and I stillâ" you gasped as his mouth found your collarbone, "âI still let you."
The sound you made was a half-groan, half-sob â caught somewhere between pleasure and the sheer humiliation of wanting him this badly. His teeth grazed your collarbone, and you arched into him like a reflex you never unlearned.
"That's it," he murmured against your skin. "That's my girl. Always so fucking honest when you're falling apart.
"Look at you," he said, and there's something almost reverent in his voice, even as the words turn cruel. "Six years and you still spread your legs the second I show up. Pathetic."
You should push him off. You should slap him. Instead, your hips roll up against his thigh, and you hate yourself for it.
"Say it," he demanded, one hand sliding up to grip your jaw, forcing you to meet his eyes. "Say you're pathetic. Say you've been waiting for this."
"Fuck you."
"Wrong answer." He released your jaw and sat back just enough to pull his shirt off in one fluid motion. The leather jacket hit the floor; his chains clinked against each other as they settled across his bare chest. He's all lean muscle, sharp lines and tattoos you've never seen before.
"Like what you see?"
"Don't flatter yourself,â you scoffed.
"Too late." He leaned back down, his mouth hovering over yours, not quite kissing. "I've been flattering myself since the day I met you. You know why? Because you let me. You always let me."
His hand slid down your stomach, fingers hooking into the waistband of your jeans. He didnât pull them off. Just toyed with the button, tracing the edge of it like he had all the time in the world.
"Tell me you want it," he said. "Tell me you want me to ruin you."
"I want you to shut up."
He laughed snarkily before yanking your jeans down your hips so fast you barely had time to gasp. They caught on your ankles, and he didnât bother to untangle them. He just pressed his knee between your thighs, spreading you open, and the rough denim of his jeans dragged against the thin cotton of your underwear.
"Jesus," you breathed.
"Not quite." His hand cupped you through the fabric, and your hips buck up against his palm. "But you can call me whatever you want if you say it right."
"Lukeâ"
"That's not what I want to hear." He pressed down harder, the friction maddening. "Try again."
You shaked your head, teeth clenched. You wouldnât give him the satisfaction. Wouldnât let him win.
But then his fingers hooked into your underwear and pulled them aside. His ringed thumb found you exactly where you needed him most, and every coherent thought dissolved into static.
"There she is," he murmured, watching your face. "There's my girl."
His thumb circled you slowly, deliberately, and you were already embarrassingly close â six years of nothing and suddenly, your body didnât care about pride or rules or any of the walls you built.
He laughed low and dark, pulling back just enough to look at you. "You're so desperate. You've been desperate since I walked in the door. I could smell it on you."
"Lukeâ"
"I could smell how much you wanted me. How much you needed this. You've probably been touching yourself thinking about me, haven't you? Imagining this."
"No."
"Liar."
"Iâ" You couldnât even finish the denial before he pressed his palm against you, feeling how wet you already were.
"Pathetic," he said, but there's no cruelty in it. Just heat. Just hunger. "You're soaking through your panties, and you're going to tell me you haven't thought about this?"
"I thought about it," you admitted, barely a whisper. "I thought about it all the time."
"That's my girl." His fingers hooked into the waistband. "Tell me what you thought about."
You swallowed hard. "I thought about youâ"
"Specifically."
"I thought about you fucking me from behind. I thought about you pulling my hair. I thought about youâ" You stopped, embarrassed by your own honesty.
He stopped too, hand still resting on your hip. "What?"
"You."
His eyes darkened. "What about me?"
"I thought about you saying my name like you meant it. Like I was the only person in the world."
Something flickered across his face â too fast to name. Then it was gone.
"That's sweet," he said, but his voice was rougher now. "Sweet and pathetic and so fucking hot." Luke pulls off your panties before letting his fingers slide inside you. "You want me to say your name? You want me to remember who I'm fucking?"
"Lukeâ" You gasped.
"Because I'll remember." He curls his fingers, finds the spot that makes you see stars. "I'll remember every sound you make. I'll remember how you feel. I'll remember that you came on my fingers before I even took my pants off."
You arch into his hand, chasing more, and he watches you with something like satisfaction.
"You know what I thought about?" he asks, adding another finger. "I thought about you on your knees. I thought about you begging."
"Lukeâ"
"I thought about you telling me you needed me. About you admitting that no one else makes you feel this way." He's pumping his fingers faster now, and you can hear how wet you are, and you'd be embarrassed if you had the capacity for embarrassment right now. "And I thought about how good it would feel to make you come so hard you can't speak."
He doesn't give you time to respond. He slid out of his jeans and pushed into you in one sharp thrust, and the breath leaves your lungs in a broken sound. He's not gentleânot like he used to beâand you feel every inch of him, every place where you're stretched to accommodate him.
"Fuck," he groans, head dropping forward. "Fuck, I forgot how good you feel. I forgot how perfect you are."
He doesn't move for a long moment. Just stays there, buried inside you, letting you feel the weight of him. Then he pulls out almost all the way and slams back in, and your vision goes white.
"Yes," you gasp. "Yes, yesâ"
"That's right." He sets a brutal pace, each thrust punishing, each one driving you higher. "Take it. Take all of it. You were made for this. Made for me."
His hand finds your hair, tangling in it, yanking your head back. You can't see anything but the ceiling, can't think about anything but the way he's moving inside you.
"Look at me," he demanded. "Look at me when I fuck you."
You force your eyes open, and his gazewaswildâhungry and desperate and something else, something almost scared.
"God," he breathes. "I hate how much I need this. I hate how much I need you."
"Lukeâ"
"Shut up." He slaps your thigh, hard enough to sting. "Shut up and take it."
He pulls out, flips you onto your stomach, and pushes back in before you can catch your breath. The angle was deeper, harder, and you buried your face in the pillow to muffle the sounds you made.
He grabbed a fistful of your hair again, pulling your head up, and the sting of it sent sparks through your entire body.
"Don't hide from me," he growled. "I want to hear you. I want to hear what I do to you."
So you stopped hiding. You let him hear everything â every moan, every broken plea, every time you said his name like it's the only word you remember.
His hand came down on your ass, sharp and sudden. Then again. Then again.
"You like that?" His voice was rough and absolutely wrecked. "You like being treated like this? Like you're fucking nothing?"
"Fuckâyesâ"
"Of course you do." He spat on your back â right between your shoulder blades â and the wet heat of it made you shiver. "You're dirty. You're so fucking dirty for me."
He pounded into you harder, faster, and you felt the orgasm building again, coiling low in your belly.
"Please," you begged. "Please let meâ"
"Not yet." His grip on your hair tightened. "You don't cum until I tell you."
"I can'tâI can't hold itâ"
"Yes you can." He slowed down, just slightly, just enough to keep you teetering on the edge. "You can do it. You're so good at doing what I say."
You whimpered into the pillow, and he laughed â dark and pleased.
"Look at you. So desperate. So pathetic. You'd do anything for me, wouldn't you?"
"Anything," you admitted, and the confession tastes like ash.
"I know." He sped up again, slamming into you with renewed force. "I know. That's why I keep coming back. Because no one else would let me do this. No one else would let me ruin them and still say please."
His hand slid around to your throat, pressing just enough to cut off your air. Not enough to hurt â just enough to remind you who was in control.
"Tell me you love it," he said. "Tell me you love being used."
"I love it," you choked out. "I love it, I love itâ"
"Tell me you love me."
The words hit like a slap. You couldnât breathe â not from his hand, but from the weight of the question.
"Tell me," he demanded, voice cracking. "Tell me you love me. Even though I don't deserve it. Even though I always leave."
"I love you." The tears came then â silent, hot, running down your face into the pillow. "I love you, Luke. I never stopped."
He made a sound â broken, almost a sob â and he pulled you up, pressing your back to his chest, his arm locked around your throat and his other hand gripping your hip. He fucked you like that, deep and slow, and the change in rhythm made you dizzy.
"I love you too," he whispered against your ear. "I love you and I can't stop coming back. I can't stop needing you. You're the only thing that makes sense."
"Cum with me," you gasped. "Pleaseâplease cum with me."
"Okay," he breathed. "Okay."
He counted down, and on three, you fell apart together â your body shuddering, his grip bruising, both of you crying out in the dark. He kept moving through it, dragging out every last wave of pleasure until you were oversensitive and trembling and begging him to stop.
The silence that follows is deafening.
Luke rolled off you, and you felt the absence of him like a physical wound. He lied beside you, staring at the ceiling, chest still heaving. Neither of you spoke.
"Are you okay?" he finally asked, and the question is so absurd you almost laugh.
"Define okay."
He turned his head to look at you. His eyes were red-rimmed, and there was a vulnerability on his face that you knew he never let anyone else see.
"I didn't mean toâ" He stopped. Shook his head. "Yes I did. I meant every second of it. But I alsoâ" He swallowed. "I didn't want to hurt you."
"You didn't hurt me." You stared at the ceiling. "You did exactly what I wanted. That's the problem."
"What's the problem?"
You turned to face him, and the look in his eyes made your chest ache. He looked young again â young and scared and desperate.
"The problem is," you said quietly, "I don't know how to stop wanting this. I don't know how to stop wanting you. Even when I know you're going to leave. Even when I know you don't really want me â you just want someone who makes you feel less alone."
"That's not true."
"It is true." You sat up, pulling the sheet around you. "You told me yourself. 'Because you always answer.' That's not love, Luke. That's convenience."
He sat up too, reaching for you. You flinched away.
"Don't," you said. "Don't touch me. Not right now."
His hand dropped. "I didn't mean it like that."
"Then how did you mean it?"
"I meantâ" He ran a hand through his hair, frustrated. "I meant you're the only person who sees me. Who doesn't care about the fame or the money or any of that shit. You see the real me, and you still answer. That's not convenience. That'sâ"
"What? Love?" You laughed, but there was no humor in it. "You don't love me, Luke. You love that I make you feel less broken. But I can't fix you. I never could."
"I'm not asking you to fix me."
"Then what are you asking?"
He opened his mouth. Closed it. His eyes were glassy, and you realized he was close to tears.
"I don't know," he admitted, throwing his hands up in dramatic fashion. "I don't know what I'm asking. I just know I can't stop thinking about you. I just know every time I'm in a city that's close to yours, I have to physically stop myself from coming here. And tonight I didn't. Tonight I let myself need you."
You closed your eyes. The tears were coming again, and you were so tired of crying over this man. So damn tired.
"Please don't cry," he said softly. "Please. I can't handle you crying."
"Then don't make me cry!"
âIâm not trying to!â Luke whispered-yelled, his voice cracking. âIâm not trying to.â
The words hung between you like smoke, like the ghost of the cigarette you'd shared hours ago. His eyes were wet, and you couldn't look at them anymore â couldn't look at the way they made you want to forgive him for everything, for years of nothing, for showing up like this and expecting you to still be here.
You looked away instead. At the ceiling. At the water stain in the corner you'd been meaning to get fixed. At anything except Luke Hemmings, who was breaking you open again with nothing more than the truth.
"I'm not trying to hurt you," he said, voice raw. "That's the last thing I'd ever want to do."
"And yet here we are." You pulled the sheet tighter, wrapping yourself in it like armor. "Here we are. Again."
"I know." He pressed the heels of his palms into his eyes. "I know. I'm â I'm so fucking sorry. For all of it. For leaving. For coming back. For making you feel like this."
"Then stop."
He looked at you then, really looked, and whatever he saw made his face crumple.
"I can't," he whispered. "I've tried. I've tried so hard. I've been with other people. I've done the therapy. I've done the meditation and the journaling and all the shit they tell you to do. But I stillâ" He broke off, shaking his head. "There's still this part of me that's yours. That's always been yours. And I don't know how to turn it off."
You laughed, but it came out broken. "You think I don't know that feeling? You think I haven't spent six years trying to unlove you?"
"Then whyâ"
"Why do I keep letting you in?" You turned to face him fully, and the tears were streaming down your face now, hot and shameful. "Because I'm weak. Because you're the only person who's ever made me feel like I wasn't just floating through life. Because when you look at me, I feel seen in a way that terrifies me. Because even knowing how this ends â knowing you'll leave, knowing I'll be the one left behind â I still want you. I still want you so badly it makes me hate myself."
Luke reached for you again, and this time you let him. His hands found your face, thumbs brushing away the tears, and he looked at you like you were something precious, something fragile, something he couldn't bear to break.
"I don't want to leave," he said quietly. "I never wanted to leave. I just â I didn't know how to stay. I didn't know how to be what you deserved."
"Then learn."
The words came out before you could stop them, raw and desperate and so much more honest than you'd intended.
Luke's hands stilled on your face. His eyes searched yours, like he was looking for something â permission, maybe, or a sign that this wasn't a trap.
"What?" he breathed.
"Learn." Your voice cracked. "Stay. Figure it out. I'm not saying itâs easy. I'm not saying I'll trust you right away. Honestly, I don't know if I'll ever trust you again. But I'm tired of being the one who cares more. I'm tired of being the one who's always waiting. If you want this â if you want me â then you have to stay. No more disappearing. No more showing up at 2 AM when it's convenient. You have to be here. All the way here. Or not at all."
Luke stared at you. For a long, agonizing moment, he said nothing. His hands dropped from your face, and you braced yourself for the letdown â for the excuse, the apology, the careful way he'd let you down.
Instead, he reached for his jacket on the floor. You watched him pull something from the pocket, heart sinking.Â
He was leaving. Of course he was leaving.
But he didn't stand up. He just sat there, shirtless and wrecked, holding a pack of cigarettes in his trembling hands.
"I threw these out," he said, staring at the pack like it had betrayed him. "In the car. Before I came. I threw them out because I knew you'd quit, and I wanted toâ" He stopped, shaking his head. "I don't know. I wanted to be better for you. I wanted to show up and not be the same disaster I always am."
He opened the pack. Inside were the last three cigarettes, crushed and broken.
"I got another pack from the corner store on my way here," he admitted. "I smoked three before I even got to your building. I put on cologne to hide the scent butâŚ" He laughed bitterly. "I still showed up smelling like them. I couldn't even give that up for you."
You watched him, heart pounding. He looked so small suddenly, so human, stripped of all his designer armor and expensive accessories. Just Luke. Just the boy who'd written you songs you never got to hear, who'd left you voicemails in the middle of the night that you never answered, who'd been carrying this weight for years and never knew how to put it down.
"Luke," you said softly.
"I'm trying," he whispered. "I'm trying so hard. I know it doesn't look like it. I know I keep fucking up. But I'm trying. I want to be better. I want to be the person who stays. I justâ" He looked at you, eyes crumbled and wet, and you saw the seventeen-year-old boy who'd first kissed you behind a tour bus. The boy who cried in your arms on his eighteenth birthday because he was terrified of what was to come. The boy who sobbed to you at twenty-one years old over his messy breakup, begging you to stay.Â
It was ironic. Â
"I don't know how,â he cried. âI don't know how to be anything other than this."
You reached out and took the pack from his hands.Â
"I can't teach you," you said. "I don't know how to be anything other than the person who lets you in. But maybeâ" You hesitated, the words sticking in your throat. "Maybe we can figure it out together. If you actually stay."
Luke looked at you like you'd just handed him something he'd been searching for his whole life.
"Really?" he asked, his voice small.
"Really." You took a breath. "But I mean it, Luke. If you leave again â if you disappear for another six years without a word â I'm done. There won't be a key under the mat. The porch light wonât be on. There won't be anything for you to come back to. Do you understand?"
He nodded, slow and solemn. "I understand."
"I'm not going to fix you. I can't fix you. If you need help, you have to get it somewhere else. I can be your partner â maybe, eventually â but I can't be your only lifeline. I almost drowned being that for you once. I can't do it again."
"I know." His voice cracked. "I know. I'm not asking you to fix me. I just â I want you to be here while I figure it out. If you can. If you want to."
You stared at him. Six years. Six whole years of convincing yourself you were over him, that you'd moved on, that you didn't still think about him every time you heard his broken voice on the radio. Six years of building walls, and here he was, dismantling them with nothing more than that broken voice.
"I want to," you admitted, and the words felt like letting go of something you'd been holding for too long. "I want to. I'm terrified, and I don't know if this will work, and I don't know if I can ever fully trust you. But I want to try. God help me, I want to try."
Luke moved then, pulling you into his arms so fast you almost fell. He buried his face in your hair, and you felt his shoulders shake.
"Thank you," he whispered against your skin. "Thank you. I won't â I promise I won't waste this. I promise I'll try. I promise."
You held him back, and for a moment, you let yourself believe it. Let yourself believe that this time could be different, that the two of you could somehow figure out how to be something other than a disaster waiting to happen.
It was stupid. It was probably the stupidest thing you'd ever done. But you were never good at rules, and Luke Hemmings had always been your exception to every single one. Maybe that's what loving him had always been: mistaking every broken rule and exit sign as another invitation to keep going.
It was a bad habit, of course. But loving him was one you couldnât break, even if you tried.











