The buzzer screeched, the sound ringing through the entire gymnasium, but Nash was already in the air. The ball, thrown with skill and dexterity soared through the open air, up over the rim of the basket... and teetered in, clinching the victory. The crowds erupted, the game-winning hail mary shot was legendary, but Nash Marks was already a legend to his school. He landed on his feet, and immediately was being swarmed by teammates and fans, his family mixed in the crowd somewhere.
Notably, one teammate stood off to the side, not joining in on the revelry. Todd Glick, faked rubbing sweat off his face, was hunched and leaning on his knees. The reality beneath the facade of exhaustion and heat was that of steep jealousy. He loved and loathed his friend, and tonight was the last straw. Ostensibly, he was Nash's best friend. They grew up together. But that changed when Nash grew and developed into the most shrewd and composed point guard ever seen in Valley River.
And Todd was ready to explore his options. He didn't want to stand in Nash's shadow anymore.
Later, at home, Todd was freshly showered and coming down for a late snack before bed. He was not surprised to see his younger brother, 16, sitting at the counter working on some homework. He had a glass of milk, and the napkin by the glass was covered in crumbs, most likely cookies.
"Still working, Seth?" Todd asked. Seth looked up, his gray eyes comically large from behind his coke bottle glasses.
He nodded, and shoved the homework across the counter. "I have a love-hate relationship with calculus."
"Oof, I know the feeling. I took this last year. Would you like some help?" Todd inquired. The two began to review the homework. Todd and Seth may have been very different brothers, personality-wise, they did get along like many teenage brothers simply don't. They never fought, they helped each other, and they always had each others back when one of them goofed off or broke a rule.
Secretly, their parents were proud of that. However, it made it very hard to hold them accountable when they were as thick as thieves, and literally helping each other steal or sneak out. Nothing too serious, mind you. Just enough to remind their parents of their own hijinks from that age - and make them wish their siblings had been as cooperative.
After a while of working on the homework, Seth was flying through the rest of the assignment. Todd and Seth were both clever boys. Todd just leaned towards the athletic side of life, whereas Seth enjoyed theater and creative outlets. He was often trying out for different roles, but the biggest hurdle for him was his serious ocular deficiency. While Todd had been blessed with a physically fit and capable body, Seth was diagnosed early on with extremely poor eyesight. Testing showed his sight even with the glasses still fell short of the 20/200 minimum.
Seth had often been emotional about the situation. He hated that so many things he wanted to do were limited just by a fluke of genetics. And it killed Todd, too. He was always protecting him, helping him walk and navigate, driving him around. He didn't mind it, not even one bit. He just wished there was a way to give him the life he imagined his brother deserved.
And it was there, at the countertop, that the idea struck Todd. There was a way to help both himself, AND Seth. And what's more? To knock Nash off his pedestal. Better yet, to steal his spot on that pedestal.
Before he roped in Seth, he needed to gather materials and find out exactly how to make this plan a reality...
The materials ready, the plan in place, Todd first had to make sure Seth was game for his gambit. It was late at night again, but Todd found Seth in his room. He was sitting up on his bed, headphones on. When he approached he could hear the soundtrack of Sweeney Todd playing.
Tapping his brothers shoulder, Seth jolted and looked to see it was Todd. "What's up?"
"I wanted to talk to you about something. A proposal..." Todd said, struggling not to sound too ominous.
"Sounds like this isn't our usual bait-and-switch with Mom. Are you sneaking out?" Seth asked, grinning.
"Actually, it's more like the bait-and-switch. Maybe not in the way you think though. I want to ask you something, and I swear, on God and my life, that what it is I am 100% serious about." Todd put his hand on Seth's knee. Seth looked down, and knew that this was Todd's gentle, but obvious signal he was being dead-serious.
"Ok, I'm all ears." Seth turned the music off and tucked the headphones and his phone to the side.
"Have you- have you ever wondered what it would be like, to be me?" Todd asked. Seth narrowed his eyes, which looked a little funny since he wasn't wearing his glasses. He was very used to seeing the world as blobs and blurred colors, but he knew his brothers blob very well.
"I can't lie. I have. Not in a creepy way. I guess I have wondered what it would be like to play basketball or drive." Seth admitted.
"What if I told you I had a way to switch us?" Todd explained. "Like, you would become me, and I would become you."
"Honestly, probably I would think you were a bit crazy. Well-intentioned, but crazy." Seth cracked a smile.
"Oh, I bet. But I can assure you, this is definitely real." Todd said, a definitive tone to his voice.
"Ok, then. I will trust you on account of our honesty-among-thieves policy." Seth said, crossing over his heart their sign of infinite brotherly trust.
"If I do this, though, I need your help in a scheme. Possibly the biggest scheme we've ever done. And I 1000% won't go through with it if you aren't totally on-board." Todd said.
"Well, now you've got me absolutely intrigued." Seth said, leaning forward to see Todd's face a bit more clearly, as little as it actually helped.
"I mean no offense when I say I don't want your body, little brother. But I do want to give you mine." Todd said.
"So, if this is a body swap, as I'm understanding it, then how would that work? If we switch, you'd be in my body, right?" Seth asked, looking a bit confused.
"Yes, that's right. But I don't want to keep your body. This is why I need your full cooperation. If you agree, it likely means never going back." Todd explained.
"Wow... so you want to permanently give your body to me? I know we're tight, but I didn't think you'd be so selfless." Seth smiled.
"Here's the thing, I want to give someone your body. Actually... it's more like trap them in your body." Todd said, the blood draining from his face as he approached the climax of the revelation.
"Hot damn!" Seth said, a bit too loudly. They both craned their necks and tried to listen for any sign their parents were going to investigate. When it seemed all clear, Seth leaned forward. "You want to force someone else to be me?"
"Yes, exactly. And I know who it would be. The problem, it would mean you'd be me forever." Todd said, looking a little grim. He was scared partly because he thought Seth might reject it. But a little part of him was getting nervous about actually doing this.
"Wooooow. Wow. Wait... Before I say yes or no, I need to know who you are targeting." Seth said.
"It's Nash." Todd said, a bit too quickly, a bit too stiffly.
"I knew it." Seth said. Todd whipped his head around to stare into Seth's eyes.
"You did?" Todd asked, surprised.
"Oh come on, I may be blind but I'm not deaf. I've noticed since you were like 13 or 14 that you seem to talk about him a lot differently than when you were younger. I could tell you were jealous of him, maybe even a little angry." Seth explained.
"Does that mean you won't do it?" Todd inquired.
"Fuck no. Let's knock him down a peg or ten." Seth smiled, evilly. "Just one more question... what does it mean for us after you swap with him? Are you going to take over Nash's life?"
"Yes. This is why I need you. I can pull off living as you or as Nash, I've lived long enough around the both of you to know most of everything about your lives. But I need you, with your acting skills, your brains, and what you know about me to play the part of 'Todd.'" Todd said. He was gesturing a little more excitedly now, which Seth could only interpret as rapidly moving blurs.
"I just don't want to lose you. It's going to be weird, living with Nash trapped in this body, but you living across the neighborhood." Seth said, a little solemnly.
"I know, little bro. But there's a silver-lining. College." Todd breathed.
Seth's eyes lit up like headlights. "Oh my fucking god... I totally forgot."
"That's right. Nash and I both got into our dream school together. He was already recruited for the team. I wasn't drafted, but encouraged to try out when I started there next year." Todd was happily explaining. "What that means - is you can decide to try basketball out with my body, or just be a college kid. Or better yet, try out for the drama club!"
Tears, actual tears started leaking from Seth's eyes. He suddenly thrust forward, throwing his arms around Todd. He sobbed into his shoulder. "This is so evil, but you are my actual fucking hero."
Todd felt a little shift in his soul. He realized he could balance this evil act of stealing Nash's body and life, by finally giving Seth the opportunity to pursue one of his dreams.
With the decision made, the two brothers would spend a long time sitting there and planning just how to do it. As a sign of good faith, Todd even swapped their bodies right then and there. It was a strange feeling that night, falling asleep in his younger brothers body. But he knew it was all worth it for the end goal.
Two nights later, the last game of the season was up. They were up for the championship, and the two brothers had planned it perfectly. The perfect heist, as the two described it.
First, the two had to split up. Todd and Seth knew that Seth wouldn't be able to play the game nearly as well as Todd would, but they weren't worried about that. Todd manufactured a reason for "Todd" or his body anyway, to be benched. This was a bummer to their parents who sat in the audience, but they were still supportive. "Seth" was sitting up there with the two. In the excitement of the game, however, they would not pay much attention to Seth slipping away in the crowd and down into the locker room.
Todd had made sure to practice with Seth a lot to pull off maneuvering around in his form, with his limited eyesight. It paid off, when he was able to make it to the locker room right as the halftime break came. He sat with "Todd" which didn't look odd to the team at all, because they often enjoyed Seth's nerdy presence since he was so supportive of the team and over the years had sort of adopted Seth as their unofficial team manager.
As the time was running down, and the players were done freshening up and heading out, "Seth" stopped Nash and said he wanted to give him something, a good luck charm to clinch the win for Valley River. Of course, Valley River was already ahead 20 points, but Nash was too kind to Seth to say no.
Nash's kindness and naivety would prove to be his downfall. He was blindsided - literally - when the charm handed to him by "Seth" spread a strange cold feeling through his body. He would feel a similar sensation to Seth and Todd when they first swapped bodies two days before. A spinning feeling, with a cold sweat overtaking the body, before it settled and they came out of the trance in their new bodies.
Todd opened his eyes, and knew he had completed the plan when he saw with crystal clarity. He felt the sweaty uniform clinging to his - Nash's - skin. He felt the power of a body that reminded him of his own. Powerful from years of training and exercise. He beamed, and looked at "Todd" who was also grinning.
"Nash, it's time to go win a championship." Seth said, from out of Todd's mouth.
"I think you're right, Todd!" Todd said, enjoying the sound of Nash's voice, flicking his tongue over Nash's perfectly straight, white teeth. It was a component of his jealousy, that Nash was insufferably attractive. And now it was his.
"Wait!" Seth's scrawny, bespectacled body snapped. "What the fuck is happening? What is this?"
Seth's body was frantically feeling his chest, arms, and face. He hovered over the glasses, pulling them away and seeing just how blind he was now.
"Nash, or should I say 'Seth' we have a game to go win. Go find your parents and enjoy the rest of the game." Todd sneered, from his new body. Todd and Seth left to return to the court before Nash could say anything else.
The rest of the game went well. Todd seemed to adapt to Nash's body quickly. Score after score added up, and the lead only grew. Seth was enjoying watching the game from the bench. And he truly was enjoying the watching. He had never seen with such clarity his entire life. The past two days living as his older brother was an adjustment, but one he enjoyed every second of. And with his penchant for acting, he had pulled off the greatest role of all time. No one suspected that Todd was really his younger, dweeby brother.
In the end, the game was a lock. The boys cheered as the team and fans flooded the court again, to raise Nash up and celebrate their amazing, one-of-a-kind athlete. No one even noticed the nerdy looking boy feeling his way along the side of the gymnasium desperately trying to find his way back to his body.
Months later, Nash and Todd were moving in to college together. They had gotten to the point where they fully adopted the name of their body, and referred to each other in the same manner. Todd, the former Seth, had done a masterful job dealing with the new Seth.
For months, the deposed king athlete was desperate to prove he was body swapped and needed to be swapped back. Todd and Seth's parents were perplexed, but Todd had convinced them that this was a new role that Seth was exploring, for a play he was writing. Some idea about two brothers switching bodies.
In the end, new Seth gave up. He was still bitter and resentful, never recovering the zeal for life and athleticism he once had as Nash. He couldn't even stabilize into an approximation of Seth's former life. Instead he fell into a depression, and slacked off a lot in school. He'd eventually find a way to cope with being Seth, but everyone was worried about Seth for years to come.
Todd and Nash on the other hand completely bloomed. It seemed that Nash's body was a complete level-up for the original Todd. He was stoked to learn that he was as competent or more of a player, it was just that his former body wasn't as dextrous or agile. Whatever the case, he quickly grew to become an all-star, and MVP of the college team.
Todd, the former Seth, also found his dreams materializing. Early on, he decided not to pursue basketball, which shocked his parents a bit. However, when he joined the drama club and started acting, he was quickly a darling star of the stage. Years of perfecting diction, singing, and various accents when he couldn't properly act on stage was a hidden superpower of his. And Todd's physically adept body and good looks made him into the ultimate acting weapon. He aggressively practiced dance as well, to become an honest-to-goodness triple threat.
Somehow even more surprising was when Todd came out as gay. Nash was so supportive of it, and his parents as well. Seth notably threw a tantrum, but everyone else seemed to respond positively.
Occasionally, the new Nash would consider the morality of his actions. Sure, he had undeniably stolen something from another. But he also gave something to himself and his brother that just couldn't have happened otherwise. Maybe two wrongs don't make a right, but could two rights undo a wrong?