Ginko and Adashino: a study in Daoist perspectivism
Huizi said,Β βI am not you, to be sure, so I donβt know what it is to be you. But by the same token, since you are certainly not a fish, my point about your inability to know the happiness of fish stands intact.β
Zhuangzi said,Β βLetβs go back to the starting point. You said,Β βWhence do you know the happiness of fish?β Since your question was premised on your knowing that I know it, I must have known it from here, up above the Hao River.β
βZhuangzi: Essential Writings, pg. 76
It would be criminally neglectful to talk extensively about Mushishi without discussing Ginko and Adashinoβs friendship. Apart from Ginko himself, Adashino is the most frequently recurring character in the stories, and he and Ginko obviously share a connection that goes well beyond trading in mushi-related goods.Β
In contrast to Ginkoβs other significant relationship, this one is not with someone who shares his degree of centeredness. Adashinoβs focus is markedly external, his habits of life and outlook very much out of line with the teachings of Lao Tzu. Most obviously, he stockpiles a wealth of mushi-related treasures and is always on the lookout for more, while Ginkoβs possessions are pretty much what he has in his backpack. The storing up of wealth and possessions, the Dao De Jing warns, can only bring grief: βAmass a store of gold and jade,β it says in verse #9,Β βand no one can protect it.β And indeed, Adashinoβs storehouse is invaded with dire consequences no later than the tenth episode of the first season. His insatiable desire for interesting items persists nonetheless, leaving him open to a level of emotional excitability Ginko never displays even at his most distressed.
(Still, a manβs gotta protect his propertyβ¦)
This is hardly the only particular in which Adashino and Ginko are decidedly unalike. S2 E8 "Wind Raiserβ especially develops their differences. When Adashino takes credit for Ginkoβs cure, Ginko completely ignores it; when Adashino speculates about what the young man Ginko advises will do, Ginko responds with a laconic,Β βWho knows?β These simple interchanges point toward their fundamental contrast: Ginkoβs mindset is Daoist, and Adashinoβs is (mostly) not. In accord with multipleΒ verses of the Dao De Jing (#2, #10, #30β¦), Ginko doesnβt care a damn about who gets credit for his work; neither does he care to speculate about future events, preferring to βmove with the presentβ (Dao De Jing #14).Β His focus is centered; Adashinoβs is outward.
Given these divergent values and the fact that Ginko reguarly cheats Adashinoβof which Adashino is well awareβan observer mightΒ wonder why these two have anything to do with each other, much less why theyβre such good friends.Β
But their bond makes perfect sense through a Daoist eye.Β
To the Daoist mind, contrasts and differences are part of how the world functionsβand this includes differences from the Daoist mind. Zhuangzi not only teaches followers of the dao to not disdain non-Daoist values but hold βperfectly to the differing allotments of thingsβ (Zhuangzi: Essential Writings,Β pgs. 70β71); his own closest friend Huizi is a man with whom he trades debates and criticisms throughout the ZhuangziΒ (pgs. 8, 38, 112β¦). This worldview doesnβt seek the exclusion of othersβthe Daoist idea ofΒ βonenessβ means that opposing views and forces are inherently one, without being made to unite or agree.
Along with this embracing of contrasts comes a firm belief in perspectivism: that anything that can be affirmed from one perspective can be negated from another and vice versa, and that each person and creatureβs nature and experiences determine what is right from her/his/its own perspective. "The embrace of the same viewpoint,β says the Zhuangzi,Β βcomes simply from being in the same positionβ (pg. 101).
Just as Ginko understands that the natures of the mushi are rightful parts of the world whether theyβre valued by humans or not, he also understands the validity of differing human viewpoints. Though he scolds Adashino for the trouble his collection causes, he doesnβt consider him lesser or unworthy of friendship because of it, or because of any other contrasts between them. Through all the disparity in their values, they share a connectionβand in true Daoist fashion, their differences are likely what brought them together in the first place. Ginko gathers mushi-related items, and Adashino wants them. Ginko has no desire to collect things or haul them around, so heβs happy to sellβ¦ if not always honestly.
Which raises the next point about their relationship: Ginkoβs shady business ethics.Β
Perspectivism applies here too. As Zhuangzi tells us, βwhatever might be [from some perspective] strange, grotesque, uncanny, or deceptiveβ (pg. 13) can be affirmed as right from another view, and this certainly applies to Ginko and Adashinoβs exchanges. To an outsider, theyβre questionable as all get outβbut itβs not an outsiderβs view that matters. Both Ginko and AdashinoΒ freely choose to associate with each other on their current terms, because that choice makes sense to them. Adashino knows from the start that Ginko isnβt always on the levelβfrom his first appearance in S1 E5 βThe Traveling Swamp,β heβs questioning Ginkoβs story about the green sake cup. And as Ginko points out, Adashino is under no obligation to buy from himβhe chooses to, knowing the odds, and continues to choose to. And we can see inΒ βWind Raiserβ that Adashino values even the more questionable items Ginkoβs sold him; heβs held on to all of it, even the stuff heβs probably guessed is junk.
Whether this arrangement makes sense or seems right to an outsider is irrelevant. Ginko and Adashino accept each other as they are, and the only ones who need to validate those choices are themselves.Β
So, for all their differences, do Ginko and Adashino have anything in common?Β
In fact, they doβand one significant value they share is the very perspectivism that shapes their relationship.Β We can see as much inΒ βThe Traveling Swamp,β when Adashino asks Ginko why heβs so determined to save Io from becoming a mushi.Β
βIf the girl said she wanted desperately to live,β he says, βIβd understand. But she wanted to become part of the swamp, right? That might be her happinessβ¦ Sometimes thatβs the way it is in this world, though it sounds cruelβ¦β
Adashinoβs statement points to the path along which he and Ginko connect: No less than Ginko, Adashino is open to anotherβs perspective, even one that he acknowledges sounds terrible. He fully understands thatΒ βrightnessβ for one person is not the same asΒ βrightnessβ for another.
Ginkoβs reply underscores that he shares this value. In S1 E1Β βThe Green Throne,β he made a human a mushi because it was her choiceβdespite his own assessment that becoming a mushi is a terrible fate for a human. He seeks to prevent the same from happening to Io, not because he doesnβt value her choice, but because his observation of her has convinced him that she doesnβt understand what sheβs giving upβthat sheβs making her choice without full knowledge.Β
Interestingly, in this sense, Ginko and Adashinoβs exchange is reminiscent of one between Zhuangzi and Huizi. Crossing over a river with his friend, Zhuangzi comments on the happiness of the fish below. Huizi protests and asks, "Whence do you know the happiness of fish?β In his frequently smartass fashion, Zhuangzi replies that he knows it from the position where they stand, above the river, watching the fish (pg. 76).
Not simply a play on words, this exchange is an illustration of Daoist perspectivism. Zhuangziβs point is that, while we truly canβt know the perspectives of anyone other than ourselves, we must proceed from our ownβincluding our observations of what may or may not make others happy.Β Not able to consult Io on the matter, Ginko has to proceed from his own observations, which lead him to believe she still cherishes human feelings.
Like Zhuangzi and Huizi, Ginko and Adashino both know that perspective is individual, and they respect the choices others make from their own. Adashino respects that Io may, after all, want to become a mushi, and Ginko respects that, in his assessment, she probably doesnβtβjust as, in Renzuβs case, he respects that she does.Β
By this same principle, they respect each otherβs natures, Ginko accepting that Adashino is an outward-focused, obsessive collector of things, and Adashino accepting that Ginko will occasionally chastise him or sell him a bad coat.Β
On these multiple levels, their relationship is one of Daoist perspectivism. And in the same way that Ginko can guess what Ioβs happiness might be, we can βknowβ from observing them that Ginko and Adashino value their relationship just as it isβwith no need for any foundationalΒ βrightnessβ other than their own choices.
With all that said, there is another kind of rightness to their friendship. In their contrasts to each other, Ginko and Adashino fit together. This is even signaled visually: Adashinoβs light-reflecting monocle signifies the yang within his yin, just as the tokoyami in Ginkoβs opposite eye is the yin within his yang. Like Ginko and Tanyuu, Ginko and Adashino form a Taiji, interlinked and corresponding through their similarities and their differences alike.