“ i haven’t really done much, ” she replies lightly, knowing that they’re both aware of the fact that stefan has missed a lot of events in her life. so many ups and downs, but elena’s just glad to be able to fill him in and have him in her life again. it feel so surreal to be able to think that to herself, but it brings such a sense of warmth and happiness that she lets the thought sit in the back of her mind. there were so many times in which she wondered if he was watching over her. when he says that he was there with her, her smile grows wider, because she feels as though she should have never questioned it. even if she doesn’t exactly know what peace is like, nor what that realm of the afterlife has to offer, she just feels like it should have been obvious to her because stefan was always beside her, every step of the way for years, and nothing could change that.
she wonders how much he really saw. if he saw her crying to every night during the first few months after his death, or when she would pause in front of her dresser almost every morning to glance at a picture frame that held an old photograph of them together, or if he saw how many times she’d go out of her way to visit his grave, even in the middle of finals or a heavy school week. the last part he’s somewhat answered already, but still, it makes her smile. everything he says makes her smile, really.
it’s then when elena realizes that that wasn’t the only thing he saw. those two years were full of confusion and turmoil in terms of her love life, too. while she can’t remember when she and damon took what they thought would be a temporary ‘ break ’ from one another, she knows that he must have seen it. at the very least, stefan saw the beginning of the end of them. needless to say, it was a difficult time in her life on multiple fronts. “ i’m sure you saw a lot of sad moments, ” she responds, her voice playful. her hands feel right in his, and his touch brings a sense of serenity that she hasn’t felt since he died. “ what about the years in between? ” she asks, wondering if he’s been back the whole time. she’s still processing everything he said. her eyebrows are slightly furrowed and lips parted, as though she’s ready to ask further questions but she can’t figure out exactly where to start.
Everything. He saw everything. The tears.. Even being at Peace with Lexi.. It hadn’t stopped hurting. Seeing her that way. Seeing her grieve him. Seeing her wake up without him being there to greet her. To tell her that everything was going to be okay. God he’d wanted to be, though. Of course, Lexi had called him a martyr for it. For watching. Watching her hurting. But could he really let her go through it alone? Sure, Damon had been there, too. His brother. They’d both grieved for him. But he couldn’t NOT try to be there. In whatever way he could. Even if they couldn’t feel him. He remembered willing himself to be able to reach out and touch Damon’s shoulder. Or Elena’s cheek. To wrap them up in an embrace and never let them go. It never worked. He was stuck, unable to help them. Lexi at his side. Just like she always was. She knew, too. She knew, as happy as he was to be with her, to be reunited with her in their Death Peace Pact.. that he longed for Elena and Damon and Caroline. To be able to do more for them. To take the pain away. The good times they had though.. Elena and Caroline and Bonnie reuniting. The girls. Josie and Lizzie and their mom falling in love with life. Damon and Ric back at their favourite bar, with their favourite Bourbon. Stefan nodded. Yeah, he saw everything he could. Every moment he could. When he wasn’t with Lexi driving and listening to Bon Jovi and singing at the top of their lungs. When they weren’t having those deep talks. Talks of regrets and wishes. He’d seen everything he could.
It’s the first time he looks away from her. When she asks that. His forest green hues darken, resembling the colour of a dimmed night sky from under a canopy of trees. His eyes close and hundreds of images flash behind his eyes; some of them, the most painful of them, involving Elena. Stefan squeezes his eyes tighter shut to blacken the picture out and his hand in Elena’s twitches, reminding him where he is, and where he’s not. He was no longer in that in between life. It still hurt, it still hurt more than anything, but he wasn’t there now. He was with Elena. Safe. Walking hand in hand with her. The whitelighter smiled slightly at that and turned his head to look at their intertwined fingers, almost as if bracing himself to look at her face again. When he does, Stefan smiles again, and shrugs his shoulders. “I would’ve come back the first second I’d been able to. As much as I might have wanted to stay away for you. For my brother. I couldn’t have been that selfless.” It’s not a complete answer, but it would have to be enough for now. Stefan could barely get out of his own mind for long enough at the minute. If he was going to go back inside his head later; he at least wanted these moments with her now.
With his eyes now back on her face, he pauses for a moment, stepping in front of her to reach for her face with his free hand ( having tucked her journal into his inner jacket pocket already ), thumb running the crease of her brow to smooth it out slightly. “A few sad moments.” he tells her, smiling back at her, but his voice turns more serious. “Elena.. about what I wrote.. what I said about Damon, I.. I’m so sorry, Elena. It.. it wasn’t on you to change him. To make him better. I never should have.. I should never have put that on you. It was never your job. It was never your FAULT, Elena. Wherever you two are at now.. I just. I want you both to be happy, but I never should have told you to forgive him. Not for the things that hurt you. I can never apologise enough. For what I said. For some of the things he did. Jeremy, Caroline, Tyler, Bonnie, Matt, I.. I’m sorry.” The list really did seem to go on, and every name he uttered felt like another punch to the gut. Not that he’d done any better by them. He couldn’t count the amount of times he’d hurt her, and hurt them, too. His hand raises slightly from her face as if he’s going to take it away again, but he doesn’t. He lays it to rest against her cheek, shaking his head as he looks between each of her eyes. “I know that was a big part of it. For a while, at least. Of why you were unhappy. Of why you were miserable.” He strokes her cheek with his thumb, gently trailing past her jaw to touch her chin. There’s regret in his eyes, and pain. For what he knows he put on her. Then, he swallows, and forces a smile onto his face again, continuing their walk through the graveyard. “Tell me some of the good things. The best things. Things I saw. Things I missed. Everything. I wanna know everything.”