Can men and women be platonic friends?
Itâs a question that I have debated over for years. I am a male that has had many platonic girlfriends throughout his life. Probably too many. It dates back all the way to elementary school.
As someone who has had about 12 serious platonic girlfriends during his life (serious meaning we talk on a regular basis and they are the go-to person in a crisis), I DONâT think men and women can be platonic friends on a long-term basis.
How can this be? I just stated that I have had a lot of platonic girlfriends. Am I full of shit? Well, based on my extensive experience, I believe that there are two ways men and women can be platonic friends and it ends with a caveat.
1. No Sexual Chemistry or Desire
Sex changes everything. Once you have sex with someone, you canât go back. Even if you were friends, itâs going to be different. So no sexual chemistry is the most important component of a platonic, co-ed relationship.
You canât think about your friend in a sexual manner. In order to be friends, you canât secretly undress your friend every time you see him/her. Somewhere down the line, youâll resent them, because face it, youâre the person thatâs going to hear all the good and bad dating stories. If you have the slightest attraction to that person, at some point, youâre going to blurt out something like, âWhy donât we just do it? We know weâre good together.â Poof. End of friendship.
2. Respect for a New Relationship
When you and your friend are both single, life is great. You fill the void of companionship for one another. You hang out on weekends, you text each other during the week. There is no loneliness because you have your buddy. But when one person finds love, that throws off the whole dynamic.
You canât keep communicating at the same pre-relationship volume as you once had. Attention must now be shifted from friend to lover. If not, the relationship wonât work. You canât be pushy and demand the same amount of attention as you once had.
Donât be surprised if your friend falls off the face of the Earth either. That happens during new relationships. But make sure you send enough occasional text messages and coffee dates to keep the friendship alive. Youâre going to need that person if (when) that relationship ends.
Itâs these same two rules that make me think men and women cannot be platonic friends forever. I think these friendships are fleeting moments that will always be remembered, but can never be long-lasting. The only reason why I have some great friendships with women is because theyâre far away. There is a reason why Iâve had so many platonic friendships. They come and go.
Ultimately, the reason why I think opposite sex, platonic relationships wonât work is because at some point, there is always one person who would be willing to give it a shot (I say this with no scientific data, but am 98% sure Iâm correct).
You canât hang out with someone for such an extended period of time and not think about taking it to the next level. Either one person is secretly harboring sexual feelings for the other, or your emotional bond has become so strong, that you think, âWhy arenât we together?â Then the platonic, friendship paradigm is changed forever.
Maybe Iâm cynical now because Iâm in love with a girl who only wants to be my friend, but I just donât think it will work. Either you go off and find someone to love and leave your friend behind or you are left wondering and dreaming what might have been.
Enjoy your platonic friendships now. Theyâre great. They do serve a purpose. You might always consider yourself friends, but just know, this extremely close time you have together is a brief window. In the end, youâll stay connected through monthly texts, bi-yearly visits, and the occasional Facebook like. All platonic friendships between men and women have an expiration date.