The Movie Whisperer: Case #001 Deep Blue Sea
Who is The Movie Whisperer?
Find me a movie that fills three requirements:
1. The first is something that is a common movie trope. For example, something like âManic Pixie Dream Girlâ or âa team of underdogsâ or âitâs based on a bookâ.
2. The second is something random and specific, like âat one point, the characters are in an elevatorâ or âeveryone breaks out into songâ or âthe main protagonist tells his love interest sheâs beautifulâ.
3. The third is something that is the Whispererâs own opinion, like âthe soundtrack is awesomeâ or âitâs funnyâ.
 The Watcher picks these requirements and the Whisperer has to find a movie that has all of these things. The Watcher then writes about the movie specifically on the three requirements and how well the Whispererâs movie fulfilled them on a scale of 1-10. There is a 10-point bonus for picking a movie The Watcher has never seen before, and one more 1-10 grade for quality of the movie.
 Things you cannot ask for are:
Specific actors, directors, or individuals
Specific release date, eg movies that were released in the 90s
Specific quotes longer than four words
 Hereâs an example of this game:
THE WATCHER: I want to watch a movie! Whisperer! Help a brother out.
THE WHISPERER: Sure, brah. What are you looking for?
THE WATCHER: I want to watch a movie in which 1) someone is framed for a crime they didnât commit, 2) someone is ambushed in an elevator, and 3) has a great twist ending.
THE WHISPERER: Well then, sir, might I recommend âJack Reacherâ?
Why are we doing this? Honestly, we just wanted an excuse to watch more movies.
As my dad always said, your greatest enemy is always yourself, something that would often come up when I failed to lift heavy objects or open jars or bet against his heroes, the Manning brothers. However, I disagree: your greatest enemy is your friend who turns out to be your greatest enemy when you least expect it or when it is convenient to the plot. I want to watch a movie in which the good guy turns out to be the bad guy.
Another thing my dad used to say while pointing out my many flaws is âonly speak when spoken to, because speaking is when Charlie gets youâ. Therefore, I want to watch a movie that perfectly exemplifies what my dad learned in Vietnam apparently, in which someone dies in the middle of a speech.
Lastly, my dad will only watch political spy thrillers, which all have webs upon webs of intrigue. So I guess I want to watch a movie with a complicated plot.
Let me begin by saying anyone who accidentally puts another animal above us on the food chain is endangering all of humanity and thus is a BAD GUY in my books. Imagine a world where you no longer feel safe during a biathlon race because a bear with supersonic hearing and laser eyes can gun you down with his M14 from a mile away. This is the world that almost came to be in Deep Blue Sea. And the clear antagonist of the film is not the poor helpless sharks who are being experimented on in international waters in order to circumvent clear animal abuse laws. The nefarious villain of this tale is no one other than Doctor Susan McAllister, the one who created these super intelligent psychic hyper sharks. And we all hold this statement to be self evident since when she does finally get devoured by the monstrosity she created; we do not mourn her passing but rejoice that this no-good mad scientist gets her comeuppance. She is undoubtedly the villain and defiler of this deep blue sea.
McAllister villainy is juxtaposed against the valiant Russell Franklin who is butchered prematurely by one of McAllister demon shark brood during his moving sermon. Let us not forget that speech, though severed in its prime did deliver Franklinâs harrowing account of being caught in an avalanche and doing the unthinkable to survive. Some of that speech is paraphrased below for your benefit.
âWhen that avalanche came it took us a week to climb out. And somewhere we lost hope. I donât know when we turn on each other. I just know that seven of us motherfuckers survived he slide and only five motherfuckers made it out. Now, we took an oath that I'm breaking now. Swore that weâd say it was the snow that killed the other two. Now Iâd like that, but that shit aint the truth. Nature can be lethal. But it doesn't hold a candle to man. (...) so weâre all going to pull together and find a way to get out of here! (Eaten by McAllister monster shark)â
Some may doubt the assertion that Deep Blue Seaâs plot is complex but let me persuade you otherwise, that this film is a complex romp involving a menagerie of scientists and wicked leviathans of ocean. An underwater submarine facility that genetically modifies sharks in order to find a cure for Alzheimerâs disease? Thatâs complicated shit. Throw in Samuel L. Jackson as a corporate executive and LL Cool J as a cook with a parrot sidekick and the complexity reaches unimagined levels that cause an elevator shaft to burn uncontrollably and possibly destroy a submersible.
Hilariously, when I tried to find this movie on Netflix, I instead found The Deep Blue Sea starring Rachel Weisz and Tom Hiddleston that came out in 2011. There are no sharks in this! Get out of here!
Iâve never seen the entirety of Deep Blue Sea. I remember seeing part of it on CityTV when I was a kid. There was someone peeing in the wind, and two sharks who killed another shark in a cage in an incredibly vicious fashion. Also, Samuel L. Jackson gets eaten by a shark, according to Dave Chappelle.
Another reason I havenât seen DBS before is that I hate horror movies. The gore freaks me out, the acting is jarringly bad, and most of the time I want all the characters to die, which would be fine if it werenât for my first point.
Anyways, letâs get to how well our Movie Whisperer did this time:
 Requirement #1: The good guy becomes the bad guy
Technically, the bad guys in DBS are the three super smart sharks since, yâknow, theyâre super smart sharks and even normal sharks are capable of great evil. However, if you really want to get into people who started out with a noble cause and subsequently not worrying about the means of which to attain their goals, then the main protagonist Dr. Susan McAlester (Saffron Burrows) sort of fits that bill. In an attempt to get enough brain tissue to harvest enough protein for an Alzheimerâs Cure, she increases the three evil sharksâ brain size. Obviously, this all goes terribly, and she doesnât seem all that broken up about it even when it goes terribly. So I concede that this is a case of noble cause corruption and technically is a case of the good guy becoming bad, but it gets revealed way too early in the film to really fit this movie cliche. (7/10)
Requirement #2: Someone dies while making a speech
Requirement #3: Complicated Plot
Don't let the science-based plot fool you, this is not a complicated plot. Itâs more of a dumb one. As mentioned, Deep Blue Sea is about that scientist lady who wants to cure Alzheimerâs Disease, but she needs shark brain proteins (or whatever. Who cares?) to do it. In order to get enough of this protein, she needs to make their brains bigger, which leads to them getting smarter. Then the ocean facility where they're conducting these experiments gets hit by a storm and the sharks break loose, picking off the skeleton crew one by one. In a nutshell, lady tries to play God, Godâs oceanic assassins strike back.
Thatâs not saying itâs a bad plot, in fact it is a pretty good basis for what a horror plot should be. Itâs simple and it gets out of the way pretty early. There are sharks, theyâre super smart, and theyâre trying to kill all humans, all of which is conveyed within the first thirty minutes. That allows the bulk of the movie to be about evading these sharks, which is the point of this whole enterprise. Itâs something that this genre should aspire to. If I have to know more about why these generic characters are trying to escape their inevitable demise, then youâve failed.
But yeah, just because science is involved does not make it a complicated plot. Good day, sir! (2/10)
Again, itâs alright as horror movies go. It has the same problems as most horror movies, especially older ones. The CGI sharks look pretty awful by todayâs standards, understandably. The only characters whose fate I cared at all about are LL Cool Jâs Preach and Samuel L. Jacksonâs suit guy, and neither of them are anywhere near primary protagonists. Everyone else is cookie-cuttered from other horror movies or simply serve as extra shark chum. I didnât like anyone enough to worry about them surviving, and I didnât hate anyone enough to want them to die, which is a tragic flaw in these types of films.
But at least no one is particularly bad in the movie. Unlike most horror films today, every member of the ragtag main crew is portrayed by a decent enough actor or actress, and while theyâve been handed sort of awful characters, they are at least believably act like the doomed scientists they are rather than someone who wears the hell out of a bikini. (5/10)
Requirement #1: The Good Guy becomes the Bad Guy (7/10)
Requirement #2: Someone dies making a speech (10/10)
Requirement #3: The plot is complicated (2/10)
Movie Quality: Itâs alright (5/10)
BONUS for unseen movie (10/10)