Rewatching seasons 1-2 of Alien Force just depresses me now. This series has regressed so much. They actually had the spine to commit to having the show grow up along with its audience. They said yup it's been five years, Ben and Gwen have long since put their childish bickering behind them, Vilgax is gone, Kevin's reformed, there're totally new main villains, Max is (mostly) gone, the stakes are very real and Ben has more or less fully learned how to control the Omnitrix and matured into a competent and responsible young man, a leader even.
Then the very next season straight up hit control Z on a solid half of all the above because growth is scary. How are we supposed to write Ben when he isn't a massive manchild who screws up everything? How are we supposed to manufacture tension if his powers don't constantly fail to work for no reason? What do we do now that the Highbreed were defeated last season? Invent another new threat? That might involve creative risk, let's just bring Vilgax back with all the flair and enthusiasm of a damp fart.
Look, I agree that Season 3 was ass, but acting as if the first two seasons weren't the root of the problem is disingenuous. I did a whole post detailing why AF fucked up from the start.
They actually had the spine to commit to having the show grow up along with its audience.
1.) It grew up WAY too fast, since the kid audience who began watching in 2006 would absolutely not be the same age range as the characters in AF in 2008.
2.) Did "the show" grow up, or did an entirely different show that didn't really want to be a sequel to anything just pop up in its place? (I can answer that: the latter.)
it's been five years, Ben and Gwen have long since put their childish bickering behind them
That's the only part that's fine.
Vilgax is gone
Why? Where did he go? Did he just stop wanting the Omnitrix?
Kevin's reformed
Why? He was depicted as a vengeful, misanthropic sociopath! How did he change?
there're totally new main villains
Which is fine on its own, but phasing out damn near the entire old Rogues Gallery isn't.
Max is (mostly) gone
Who did not need to "die" to be so, especially not in the stupid way it happened.
the stakes are very real
As if they weren't before???
Ben has more or less fully learned how to control the Omnitrix and matured into a competent and responsible young man, a leader even.
OK, show's over then. You just had Ben reach the natural CONCLUSION of his character arc, at the very beginning of AF, meaning he has nowhere left to go without being a boring main character. Regressing him sucked, but the only other option they had was either not continue the series or they get a new main character. Maybe if they had held off on maturing him until we actually got to WATCH him mature in real time, episode after episode, they'd have been in a better spot (similarly, if we had gotten to SEE Kevin redeem himself instead of handing him an insta-good guy badge, the fuckery that went down with him could have been avoided.)
Tl;dr, Alien Force was never a good follow-up series and its writers were incompetent.




















