pvrateboy:
His look of despair faltered at the mention of fairy dust. Leland had been only expressing bitterness when he mentioned flying. Only Theo would take that seriously and it broke the pirate’s heart even more knowing that he would still never be deserving of someone like the demigod. His eyes fell to the floor and he could feel his vision blurring. If tears were ever shed between them, he always expected them to come from Theo first because of something Leland had done, not the other way around.
His fingers curled into the fabric of his pants, holding tighter and tighter as he forced himself to listen. Then Theo came into his line of sight once again when he knelt before him and he had to shut his eyes which prompted his tears to overflow and cascade down his cheeks. This made Theo the third person to ever see him cry in his entire life. Tears were his ultimate shame but how could he bring himself to care when the simple act of breathing felt like he was inhaling broken glass. It just all hurt so much.
Leland didn’t know what he would have done if Theo had left him in person. Maybe he would have made a fool of himself begging him to stay or left Auradon entirely. The Isle had been his home once. The pirate was only half hearing the demigod, confused as to why Theo was apologizing for breaking up with him. This kind of apology was far from kindness. It was a cruelty that not even Leland could fathom.
He jumped when the other male made contact. It was a light pressure but his eyes snapped open and he scooted back on his bed like he had been burned. “Don’t touch me an’ wh-why should I forgive ye? Ye — Ye left me. Ye don’t want me anymore.” He paused to take a shuttering breath, trying to steady his voice so he didn’t sound as pathetic as he felt. “Why do ye want me forgiveness? Why do I matter tae ye if ye broke up with me? If this be some Auradon courtesy ‘tis bullshit. Not even I was this cruel on the Isle.”
Out of all the possible paths Theo had envisioned this conversation taking, nothing could have prepared him for Leland's tears. Though he could count the number of times he had seen Theo in his own bouts of saline-stricken grief or anxiety, the thought of Leland being somehow... invincible when it came to these things sometimes lingered in his mind. He was able to forget the expectations that came with having the blood of a God running through his veins, to collapse into a true, fallible human state and know that no matter how he stumbled, Leland wouldn't look down on him for it.
Heart clenched as he watched the tears roll down pale cheeks, his fingers itched to cup Leland's face and brush them away. That was what a good-- no, even a decent boyfriend would do. But when Leland all but jerked away from him, Theo himself flinched back, mirroring Leland's earlier action of curling his fingers around the fabric of his pants. Initially, he could feel his head lowering in shame at the truth of Leland's words. A part of him wouldn't blame the other for it - why should he forgive him? Maybe after some time passed, but even then Theo felt that it might be longer than he'd like for even a blossom of forgiveness to sprout.
His head suddenly lilted upright as Leland continued, however, his features betraying all the bewilderment now springing to the surface. Broke up with him? Theo's mind instantly traced back the contents of the letter; nowhere in it could he recall even remotely stating that he'd wanted to break up with Leland, nor could he fathom the thought of ever wanting to in the first place. Then again, the final draft was a tad on the jumbled side, written in frantic haste after so many failed copies before it. Oh Gods, and to leave right after delivering it, not even in person--
"Oh my Gods, I..." Theo gasped sharply, hand rising to clamp over his mouth for a moment. Realization flooded over him in waves, along with an extreme urge to slap himself in the face. Hard. Slowly lowering his fingers revealed a small, miserable choke of a laugh ghosting past Theo's lips. "Leland, I never wanted to break up with you. I-- I wasn't breaking up with you, in that letter. I was trying to get everything out but, it all sounded so pathetic and desperate that I just, scrapped all of it. Tried a condensed version, I guess?" He shook his head, feeling the familiar pin-prick of tears gnawing at his own eyes. "I never once thought about how it could... Leland, please never think I wouldn't want you. T-that's... Gods, I always thought that I was clinging to you too much, I-- I'm sorry," His voice crackled towards the end, but he knew he'd never be able to repeat the phrase enough.
















