The Pros and Cons of Being a Generalist and Specialist in Graphic Design Industry
Every year, a huge batch of new graphic designers come in the scene. Some of them land a decent job that helps them grow and improve, some stick with freelancing, trying to create a name all by themselves, while some are stuck in the job hunting process. And within these designers' minds are endless questions like 'how do I get my first client', 'how do I market myself', 'how much should I price a logo' and the list goes on. But these questions are just minor decision making process. In a graphic designer's career, especially those who are starting, one of the hardest decision to make is whether to be a SPECIALIST or a GENERALIST.
Then there's another question, DOES IT REALLY MATTER?
Well, in some people, it does. Firstly, I would define what is a Specialist and a Generalist. A generalist, in a graphic design perspective, is a person that provides every services possible. Logo design, brochure, flyer, billboard, website, et cetera. You name it, he can do it. he is the Jack Of All Trade of the industry. On the other hand, a Specialist is someone who devotes his time perfecting one specific craft. Be it logo design, web design, animation (even this has two more branches: 2D or 3D). He is the kind of 'Master of One' person. So where does the question came out from?Graphic Design these days is a very complex profession. Even the most irrelevant mind is not contented with an "I am a graphic designer" answer they ask about your job and they eventually follow their questions up with "what kind of graphic designer?". There are designers that learns a few skills at a time and when they reached a level that they do well in that specific skill, they tend to learn more and more skills associated with it. And there are those who learns a lot of skills at a time and settles into one specific skill for him to improve and master. But what about those designers who are just starting out? The following are some points to ponder that may help you decide.
The Pros and Cons of Being a Generalist
When you are a 'Jack of All Trade', you are: When you are a generalist, you are HIGHLY SELLABLE. When you have a wide variety of skill set, your profile is highly sellable in the market. When you go out there with a lot of hats to wear, chances are your different skills attract clients both individually as well as collectively.
Moreover, there are a lot of clients who prefers to work with a single person rather than work with a different person for a specific project.
Generalists can also easily add, remove, or update their services depending on the market. They have a broad area of knowledge, which makes them the clients' one-stop-shop. However, everything has its own Cons. When you are a generalist, there are instances that you turn down or outsource specialize works. While there are clients who prefer to work with a single person for multiple projects, there are also those who prefer to invest on a seasoned specialist.
Generalists also prove to be more stressed when it comes to project management. Since they have a lot of skills in their arsenal, chances are they also work on multiple projects at the same time. Worst, they will also outsource excess jobs.
Another bad thing about being a generalist is that they cannot charge more. Clients are smart. If they're going to pay a thousand bucks for a single project, they would rather give it to a more experienced person in the same project.
The Pros and Cons of Being a Specialist
Being a 'Master of One', you probably are:
The expert in your specialty. Since you devote your time, money, and efforts perfecting a single craft, you practically stand out among others. And because you have a deep experience, it becomes your greatest asset.
You have a more streamlined approach to your projects. Since you have been doing your job a lot of times, you develop a design process which makes it easier for you to finish new tasks.
As a specialist, you can charge more. Whenever you put the title 'specialist' in your profile, it automatically gives a positive impact on the other person. And if you tell your client that you are a specialist in that area, they will probably not argue and agree to pay you handsomely for you expertise. (Just make sure your works support your claim as being a specialist). And for the record, here are the disadvantages of being a specialist: The most basic and probably the most obvious disadvantage is that you do not have a lot of alternatives. Since you are working on a single skill set for ages, you do not have a lot to offer your client, which results to the next disadvantage.
You outsource every project that is out of your expertise. Although some may say that it is not really a disadvantage, outsourcing divides your profit. And with it, you cannot control the overall quality of the project which may affect your market reputation.
Another thing is that there is lower chances of business expansion. When thinking for an expansion, your business should have a lot to offer. The design industry is continuously growing and more and more sub branches comes out. If you are a specialist and you are eyeing for an expansion, chances are you will rely on external help. As a conclusion, specialists and generalists in graphic design are just like in the medical field. There are general practitioners who can provide you the initial service you need and there are these doctors who specializes in one specific area who can take care of you further. There will always be an advantage and disadvantage. But for me, the only way in becoming successful is by loving what you do, whether you are a specialist or a generalist.













