You know those small inconsistencies with Minecraft roleplay - because it's improv? And most of the time you ignore 'em cus it doesn't matter?
Well if the reason for Scott's long name was that his parents were arguing and couldn't pick a name... Then how the hell is he the third of his name!
They're arguing, they're not gonna just pick a random ancestor and leave it there (although that is probably canonically what happened)
I have a funnier idea.
Scott's the third son. The first son was wanted, and proudly named Scott Antonius Mattheos Pagona Pavlos.
Then the boy died in childhood (happened a lot), and the second son was named in honour of his dead brother.
Then the third son appears, and whether son number 2 died, or whether his parents were just hedging their bets (which is funnier) Scott gets named exactly the same.
This is my reasoning now and I'm sticking with it.











