Dude I’m Tired

I literally have to get out my theories! Okay so we have multiple characters experiences dramatic actions that there is no way they did. Lucas with his son, Gwen with selling drugs to students, and Max with killing Safi.

First do I think Max shot her based on the photo? Yes, I say this only because she’s crying. My thoughts are this is a similar situation to having to let Nathan shoot Chloe if you want to save Arcadia.

Whatever Max has done is blurring timelines and realities and if she does not stop I imagine things will only get more out of hand.

I do not think it makes sense to say the history between Max and Chloe if she’s is alive is insurmountable just because that doesn’t really make sense. Life is strange largely felt like their shared story and in a way the entire reason Max even gets her powers back. A huge part of why people wanted more Life is Strange with Max was to have more Chloe also. More of them together even if it followed the comics and the parallel universe plot line.

Does not make sense to say Max was stuck in the past then show her wanting a future with Chloe. Or having Chloe worrying about rewind and then having Max say rewind hasn’t worked since high school?

Anyways the only way this isn’t terrible for Chloe fans and Pricefield fans is if this timeline is the worse one. Which makes sense if the photo we see is part of Max fixing and preserving the timeline she believes to be real.

I think that Lilith, recognizing Lucifer’s lost hope and shattered dreams, chose to leave and keep Charlie away from him. He had hoped to protect the only things he still had a reason to live for. However, Lilith, being a strong-willed individual with a mind of her own, sought to empower sinner to embrace freedom and do better. This aspect of her character is hinted at in the book Charlie reads at the beginning, which I suspect is from Lilith.

The scenes of Lucifer with Charlie as a baby is particularly poignant. He has confined himself to the same room, spiraling into despair, dedicating himself obsessively to his duck creations. Additionally, his role extends beyond just ruling Hell – he also governs the pride ring, a clear symbol of Heaven’s punishment for his rebellion and his belief in his own righteousness.

Lucifer’s relationship with Charlie is complex. He loves her deeply, as seen in their happy family pictures, yet fears her following in his footsteps – potentially leading to further loss, much like he experienced with Lilith. Ironically, Charlie mistakenly believes that Lucifer only reaches out to her out of boredom or need. In truth, like Lilith, Lucifer feels that, having lost his spirit as a dreamer and a fighter, Charlie wants nothing to do with him. Yet, he eagerly looks for any opportunity to communicate and spend time with her. This is beautifully illustrated in his anticipation of her call: he spends an hour getting ready, ensuring he’s perfectly on time, and greets her with a smile at the door, despite having the ability to teleport.

The extent of Lucifer’s suffering is heart-wrenching. An eternity of suffering is a formidable punishment, made even more crushing by the fact that it has alienated his wife and daughter. The duet between him and Charlie, where they express their gratitude for each other – “I’m grateful you’re my daughter/father more than anything” – is a perfect encapsulation of their reconnection. Their reunion is beautiful.