This Bridge Called My Back: Writings by Radical Women of Color
The Barbara Cameronâs piece discusses the issue of racism that she has experienced during her lifetime as being a gay Native American. Whether the racist commentaries came from the whites or the gay organizations, Cameron points out the exclusion and the hate Native Americans go through in the mainstream atmosphere. She uses the term âthird world peopleâ that indicates the oppression of the minorities in the U.S. It includes black, Asian, and Native Americans, however many like the Third World Gay Conference of 1979 defines the term to be relevant towards mostly blacks. By having no regard for other minorities these types of interactions âalienateâ people of different backgrounds. No wonder the oppression caused by society leads to high suicide rates in Natives Americans. Feeling like outsiders in their own country can damage anyone and respiring different stereotypes or racist remarks towards such a race does not give them chance to be uplifted.
This relates to gendered oppression by understanding the struggles a Native American who is also gay female. She has heard from people âYou donât seem like an Indian from the Reservation,â which implies being in reservation make a person less than others. Cameron discusses her childhood âfeeling great sadness and helplessnessâ due to the whites doing whatever they wanted to her people. The oppressive impression came in the forms of killings, rape, and other forms of insults. This has been taking place ever since people of the Old World entered the Americas and had no regards of the natives of the land. However, in contemporary times racism has its complexity, as the whites pit minorities against each other, then their views cause division. Cameronâs uses this example of the U.S. government in this case.
Relevant to this book, in the contemporary period gendered oppression people experience now is present mostly everywhere, taking in the âtraditionalâ role of women being the caretakers and men as the breadwinners is visible. As Bornstein describes in Naming all the Parts, that society has put categories on gender, based on which role application merges. Women in the workplace today are paid less than men; an example from Emily Baxterâs article gave the statistics of such a gap. Baxter says just in the last two years full time working women have on average have made only 78 cents for every dollar that full time men have earned. Therefore being a Native American it must be hard to find success in the white dominated world, no wondered many do not leave the reservation and the ones who do never find the sense of home anywhere else.
Cameron says due to all the oppression of the past and now makes her a political activist and it is her responsibility to point out even the gay community that does not respond to its racist assessments of  âlesbians of color.â This is significant to feminism and intersectional feminism in particular because not every female feels the same towards the causes that feminism represents. In Cameron piece the gay community or the Third World Gays do not address the importance to her as a Native American, as it excludes them based on stereotypes.
These topics are relevant to our contemporary period and the gendered oppression people have now because people still go through these problems. Some people are still oppressed just because of how they look. People still have that conflict within them wondering if they should be open how who they are, or keep to themselves because they know how their family would react just from growing up with them. These are current problems that people have and it can be so hard that some people take their own life, because they feel that the way they are isnât right because someone keeps telling them that they are wrong. These topics are what feminism is fighting to end. There shouldnât be a fight between dark skin and light skin, or a division between women when they are all still perceived inferior to men. These topics shed light on what needs to be fixed in society. These readings are personal stories of what women went through and the issue is that these stories happened in the past. However, even in this day and age, women are still experiencing these issues and people donât care.
Internalization/Invisibility
Another topic in this section is internalization. As described in the reading when something is unknown, mysterious or dangerous it is often referred to as dark or associated with negative characteristics of women (Moraga 58). Moraga describes that after living with negative images of gay women all around her (Moraga, 59.), she began to hate herself for being a lesbian and her partner for loving her all because society taught her that it was wrong.
When people are grown up in a society that is saturated with negative images of people like them, they begin to believe what they are told. They began to think badly of themselves because they were brought up taking in information that tells them they are wrong, incorrect, a mistake. Women in the 50âs were told it was there job to just be a good wife. They internalized this and when it no longer fulfilled them, the blamed themselves and sought questionable medical advice. Internalization is a scary and demoralizing thing because it means one no longer needs to be told, they already believe that the problem is with them and you canât separate yourself as easily as you can from others who may have negative things to say.
The problem with internalization in the feminist movement is that society never seems to be short on negative or stereotypical imagery to send the message to women that they are thought to be second class citizens. When a negative message becomes internalized it can sap the motivation out of someone because they no longer believe that the problem is something they are able to change because it is their own fault. In intersectional feminism, women may make comments that may propagate the negative emotions and cause one to internalize it. Yamada explains that she overheard on several occasions making racist remarks (Yamada, 61). When women pass along or ignore these messages that are negative in terms of another group, different classes or races or such, they weaken the women in those spheres and thus weaken feminism as a whole. Â
Part of this internalization or a society that propagates stereotypes is a feeling of invisibility. It is explained that sometimes people are invisible to society until they decide to make a stand to be included such as the Asian Americans (Yamada 62). People will stay quiet in a society that is full of racist or sexist remarks, thinking that they canât change them or that if they try they will be discriminated against more harshly. Then, when they finally decide to stand up or ask to be included, society did not even know they were upset (Yamada 62).
These topics are relevant to our contemporary period in feminism because with a society that so often portrays negative images of women it easy for women to begin to internalize that feeling and those falsehoods making them feel as though they are the problem. Internalization hampers the feminist movement by sapping the will of women to fight to change or to even see the problem and instead begins to make them see themselves as the problem. Since it is these negative images that feminists try to stop, internalization causes a back and forth struggle between women and society.
Division between different groups
Part of this section involves Moraga questioning her right to be able to participate in the writing of third world women. Though she is Chicana, she is light skinned and is able to pass as if she were white and because of this she wonders if other arenât more qualified, unable to pass as white, to assist in the collection of writings (Moraga, 59-60). She explains that white middle class women hold womenâs groups for the discussion of topic and yet no women of color attend. She describes that even though they may claim that the meetings are open to all, they refuse to acknowledge any discrimination (Moraga, 59). They do not seem to mind that the meetings are all white, middle class women. These are not womenâs groups. They are white middle class womenâs groups and it is this division and internal separation that hinders the strength of the movement.
One of the most important things she explains is that there are different kinds of poverty. Being black, female, gay and poor are all poverties and in the end, it doesnât matter what their different struggles are. They all get beat (55). She acknowledges that no matter what the specific struggle or what type of poverty one has, they are all connected because they are all oppressed by the powers at the top. Though some may want to try and step over one another to try and be at the top and be closer to white straight rich men. Rather than hold each other down for scraps, people should unify to try and end the oppression of all types once and for all but in order to end this oppression, they must acknowledge, identify and target the specific oppression. Only when people know what it means to suffer from oppression can they understand and truly feel compelled to fight oppression.
Women are not just some group of individuals that can rally together for a cause at the drop of a hat. They are diverse, different in as many ways as there are to divide the human race: Color of skin, language, heritage, education, economic class and many others. Even though women are similar in many ways, they are each affected differently by similar factors and may sometimes view themselves as totally independent from other women. Women of upper classes would likely have different views on certain topics than women of lower class. Today different spheres of women fight for similar goals yet they do it primarily on their own and do not often branch. These groups struggle for the same goals, but their separation minimizes their potential effect.
The effect of this division is that the feminist movement loses so much potential power by struggling separately rather than together. Though different women face different struggles, if they stand in solidarity then they can help each other achieve their own goals. The other factor is that with so many groups segregated with some groups dominating others in certain criteria such as economics and class or education, some groups get left behind. Though women may gain equality with men, there will still be division among lower, middle, and upper classes and races. This solidifies the point that until the culture of domination of one group over another is changed, feminism cannot achieve its ultimate goal.
Sexism is often considered to be brought on by man. However according to Aurora, her grandmother and granddaughters taught her to be afraid of men and feel inferior and submissive. On one hand, they all explained that men are all âdisgusting and dirtyâ (p.53), and all men only care about sex. On the other hand, they push her to find a boyfriend. In their view, women have to use their body, since it is the only thing they have to offer. Ultimately, romance and love do not exist, marriage is misery and sex has to be bore. Aurora thinks a lot about the phrase âin the third generation the daughters are freeâ (p.56). According to Aurora, the relationship between mother and daughter has to be healed to fight not only sexism but also racism. From pages 41-45, Valerio gives a detailed description of her thoughts and feelings of growing up as a Native American and reflecting on her culture as an adult and as an open lesbian. In the beginning, she brings up an example of sexism explaining how in her culture, a woman is only considered âholyâ if she has only been with one man. It illustrates how a woman is a âgood little piece of property (pg.41)â and isnât looked at as a person, but this is a cultured value that many women in their tribe are brought up with and taught that as a correct idea.Â
The author also brings up how religion has manipulated values from over time and people think they know the difference, when really they donât. The topic of religion or cultural values express gender oppressed values, promoting the idea to accept the stereotypes they create as normal, taking away individuality. From pages 43-48, Naomi Littlebear explains how often, the overall threat of violence is normal to women. Public beatings, sexual abuse, and familial abuse are things that have been a part of life. The author is punished by her own grandmother for getting beaten. Our culture teaches us to blame women for violence against them such as rape. And again, not only men but also women question other women. Our culture supports victim-blaming by not expecting the man to control himself instead of fighting sexism. The man is always provoked-like an animal and is not held accountable for his actions. This then starts the never ending cycle of gender abuse.
Women not only internalize menâs behavior but also what they are taught by other women and by society. So long as women teach girls that they have no power and that their body is all they have to âbring on the marketâ, sexism and inequality and violence is being passed on. Especially in some parts of the world, girls are still taught that their virginity and body is the only thing they have to offer, that they are born to suffer and serve man. Â At the same time, men should be taught to respect and value women for other things than her body and caretaking. One of my friends was not allowed to have a boy in her room because her mother claimed she would be worthless if she gave in to any sexual interactions with him and would not find someone to get married too as a consequence. The value of a person should be separated of their sexual activity or virginity. Ultimately, sexism or anti- gay movements also create distance within communities and families.
What society teaches men and women about the opposite and same gender is essential to fight sexism and fight for feminism. Â Women need to support each other and know that they should have a choice, that oppression is not the only option and that men can be different. Likewise, men have to be taught that they are not dominant over women. Internalization of those negative opinions and values are truly holding back feminism and also intersexual feminism since women themselves internalize that they are worth less than men. To truly end sexism, everyone has to work together no matter the skin color, gender, sexual orientation or class.
Separation from oneâs own culture
Mary Hope Leeâs poem describes the pain that comes from not being like everyone else from your environment, family, or race. A light skinned girl is not welcomed among her peers in school, and picked on and made to think that sheâs not equal to others. She had to leave to a different school, dealing with the issue of her different skin color kept her out of the group. Moreover, as an adult she married a man who thought she was the ânext best to white,â and not for who she was. Â The light skinned girl was never a part of the two worlds as she was stuck in between, neither black nor white. It only made her a stranger from both cultures, leaving her envious of others around her who fit in. This is an example how society separates people and there is a distance; the issues of race, (gender, and religion) does not unify everyone as a whole.Â
Aurora Levins Morales grew up in Puerto Rico whereas her mother was born in New York. Hence, Aurora presented the generation of return to Puerto Rico(p.53). She had to fight there to be considered Latina or else she would be called âAmericanitaâ (p.53). In a way, she fought racism, even though she was a Latina in Puerto Rico. In addition, she says that she had to find allies in Angelo women due to the fact that she was faced with racism and backstabbing by her Latina friends. In Puerto Rico, her light-skinned grandmother pretended to be Italian to find an apartment in Puerto Rican-free neighborhoods. Aurora, after having read the book âdown these mean streetsâ, felt like the only factors separating her from gang fights, prison and poverty was circumstantial luck, her motherâs marital relationship with a professor and fine English. But in the end, she feels separated from her own culture and environment. Moreover, Aurora writes about the separation of Latino women. From her experience, she got support from white middle class women to fight feminism and consequently turned her back on the Latino movement. Women are all different, even if they speak the same language. Everyone has a different fight and strives to find allies in various places. Lee didnât find allied among her people either, being an outsider.
Women are separated by so many factors, even within their own culture and heritage. Class, education, skin color, sexual orientation and many other factors can cause distance within a family, culture or society. Some women choose to act oblivious to the feminism movement like Aurora experienced in Puerto Rico. The division among women is understandable due to all the latter factors, however they pose a huge setback to feminism. United in what we teach our children and how we help other women, feminism could have much more potential if united. Women are not just some group of individuals that can rally together for a cause at the drop of a hat. They are diverse, different in as many ways as there are to divide the human race: Color of skin, language, heritage, education, economic class and many others. Even though women are similar in many ways, they are each affected differently by similar factors and may sometimes view themselves as totally independent from other women. Women of upper classes would likely have different views on certain topics than women of lower class. Today different spheres of women fight for similar goals yet they do it primarily on their own and do not often branch. These groups struggle for the same goals, but their separation minimizes their potential effect. Â
The effect of this division is that the feminist movement loses so much potential power by struggling separately rather than together. Though different women face different struggles, if they stand in solidarity then they can help each other achieve their own goals. The other factor is that with so many groups segregated with some groups dominating others in certain criteria such as economics and class or education, some groups are left behind. Though women may gain equality with men, there will still be division among lower, middle, and upper classes and races. This solidifies the point that until the culture of domination of one group over another is diverted, feminism cannot achieve its ultimate goal.