Hey to clarify with your post about the autonomous zone, are you saying the zone is a good thing / is helping? Or it's bad and theyre unwelcome and violent?
Iām going to use this ask as a springboard for a followup post I wanted to write -- to be clear, the rest of this post is not so much a response to your ask as stuff I wanted to say at some point anyway.Ā TheĀ āyouā below is a general you,Ā āthe reader.ā
This turned out to be super long and kind of rambling, so be ready for that.
I was definitely saying thereās less violence in the neighborhood since the cops left, which was also whenĀ āthe Zoneā started.
But, like . . . I also want to communicate thatĀ āCHAZā is way, way less of a big deal one way or the other than the national media appear to believe it is.Ā If you donāt live in Seattle and youāve only heard about it from the national media, your view of the situation is almost certainly very skewed.Ā Not politically skewed, necessarily, but skewed in terms of magnifying tiny things and overlooking huge ones.
This is just an information problem.Ā Ā If you were to go and binge-read the last two weeks of Seattle local news, local journalistsā blogs and twitter feeds, etc., youād come out the other side a few hours later, ready to laugh with the rest of us about how goofy the national āversionā of this story is.Ā But thatās easier said than done, so . . .
Letās forget about the Zone for a moment: this is a city whose municipal politics are in a state of chaotic upheaval.Ā The mayor and police chief have come under withering scrutiny for their role in the pre-Zone situation.Ā Hereās just some of the stuff thatās been happening lately, at the same Trump and everyone else is freaking out about ~the Zone~:
⢠Three of nine city council members are openly calling for the mayor to resign (see also this this article, this one)
⢠This is the tip of the iceberg --Ā ā#ResignDurkanā is the hot new slogan, aĀ petition saying Durkan must resign has been signed by enough local politcos (mostly people involved in the local Democratic party org) that their names fill around 5 pages of a Google docĀ as of this writing, etc. etc.
⢠The city council is so on board with defunding the police that theyāve spent no time arguing over whether it should be done -- theyāve immediately jumped into the details of the police budget and the question of which parts specifically to cutĀ (see also this article, again, and this post)
⢠Even the most right-leaning city council member, Alex Pedersen, is on board with defundingĀ and (admittedly way back on June 1 -- I havenāt been following him too closely) was saying stuff likeĀ āI stand in partnership with my council colleagues on all of this. I pledge to be a genuine allyā
⢠One city council member, whoās been a prominent speaker at the protests,Ā used her key to city hall on Tuesday to let the protestors in so they could demonstrate there
[... I promise weāll get around to ~the Zone~ eventually, bear with me]
So clearly the city council is really pissed off at the mayor and police chief.Ā Much of their ire is about what I talked about last time, the tear gas and stuff.Ā Thereās also the thing with mourning bands, which I wonāt go into detail about here, see hereĀ or Google it.
But also.Ā Itās not just that Durkan (mayor) and Best (police chief) are the local authority figures who happen to be nominally responsible for bad police behavior.Ā They have also, in their daily public statements, been creating the most incoherent, least reassuring narrative possible, displaying the opposite of strong leadership.
Durkan, ridiculously, has been trying to frame herself as vaguely āwokeā on twitter.Ā This at a time when many of her municipal peers are calling on her to resign because, among other things, sheās refused to take clear responsibility for tear gassing BLM protesters and those in their vicinity.Ā I imagine that (say) a transparent, consistent position on riot control methods would go a lot further with everyone -- protesters or not -- than any number of preening tweets about āwhite menā possibly could.
Durkan and Best, who often make public statements at the same meetings, have also established a pattern of making assertions and proclamations that are themselves often mysterious, then contradicting them almost immediately, as a confused populace tries to understand WTF is going on.
I already talked about themĀ ābanning CS gasā and then using it again within 2 days.Ā The next bullet point is another example.
⢠On Sunday 6/7, the mayor claimed the barricades by the East Precinct -- thatās where the nightly cop/protestor standoff was happening -- could not be removed, because they were protecting the building and those surrounding from some unspecifiedĀ ācredible threatā of property destruction which the FBI had passed along.Ā The relevant quote from her speech:
Since last Saturday, Chief Best and I have talked multiple times a day about reducing the tension, de-escalating and de-militarizing the posture, and removing the barriers Downtown and on Capitol Hill.Ā [...]
Based on the best assessment of Chief Best, in part because of specific information from the FBI about threats to the East Precincts and buildings in Seattle, they concluded that removing the barrier would jeopardize the safety of the public and the community, especially considering there are approximately 500 residents that live in that block.Ā
The very next day, Monday 6/8, they started . . . removing the barricades.Ā Then they announced that the cops would be leaving the East Precinct entirely.Ā To be perfectly clear: they didnāt sayĀ āwe are doing this becauseĀ that credible threat to the safety of 500 people is gone now.āĀ The action they said would constitute an unacceptable threat to public safety on Sunday was just, literally, the action they were conspicuously taking on Monday, no explanations or reassurances given.
In fact, they did the opposite of declaring the threat resolved: at least according to this generally trusted blog, they sent around an ominous message to area businesses that day:
[...] The Seattle Police Department (SPD) will be removing existing crowd barriers in order to support a peaceful protest march. While the protest is expected to be peaceful SPD has credible information about a potential intent to set fire to the East Precinct at the intersection of 12th Avenue and Pine. We donāt believe that this will happen, but out of an abundance of caution, the Seattle Fire Department (SFD) is taking some preventative measures to protect the East Precinct building and the surrounding apartment buildings and businesses. They will be assessing the need to spray a biodegradable foam fire suppressant on the buildings tonight if needed, as well as reaching out to the community. [...]
This was the day on which the protesters gotĀ ācontrolā of the area, if you want to put it that way.
From being glued to twitter and livestreams that evening, nervously wondering whether something horrible would happen, I can tell you the mood at the protests was notĀ āwe won, we threw the pigs out, letās declare autonomy!āĀ It was fear that some other group -- the default hypothesis was Proud Boys -- was going to come in and burn the precinct building, just like the FBI said, the protesters would get blamed, and it would be a Reichstag Fire kind of situation.
The #seattleprotests and #seattleprotestcomms twitter tags that night were full of people talking about staying wary, reporting groups they thought might be Proud Boys, discussing how best to defend the precinct building against arsonists (!), that sort of thing.Ā You are free to relive that twitter experienceĀ for yourself, if you like.
Maybe Iām missing something, but the whole FBI thing is still pretty confusing to me!Ā A credible threat of arson, close to where I live, potentially affecting the homes of ~500 people, is a scary thing.Ā No matter what your perspective, I think we can agree that āwe think someone may burn down our police station, and weāre leaving the station behind and letting protesters deal with itā is a bizarre and unsettling thing for a person in a municipal leadership role to say.
Thankfully, no one burned down anything.Ā When asked by a journalist later why this threat seemedĀ ācredible,ā the assistant police chief apparently said
I consider them incredibly credible in that there were incendiary devices usedĀ [against] some of the officers that were on the line in earlier protests, when you look at the fact that we had businesses downtown looted and set on fire, I think they were very credible.
Yes: this FBI tip abut arson, which me and plenty of other people (incl. the protesters) took seriously and were pretty scared about Monday night, was so ācredibleā because some people had committed arson elsewhere in the city recently, and some people threw some things that were on fire.Ā All of which was widespread public knowledge at the time.Ā Where thereās fire, thereās fire, I guess (????)
⢠I donāt have the time here to go into the whole candle thing but there was that too.
⢠Oh, and the curfews! Ā Ah, the curfews! Ā One of Mayor Durkanās first notable moves in this whole thing -- to be clear, back at the end of May, in the one weekend where the protests really did involve lots of looting, burning cars, etc -- was to announce a 5PM curfew . . . on 4:46 PM the same day.
14 minutes is enough time to get out of downtown during a chaotic event, right? Ā This surely wonāt piss people off and further escalate things, right? Ā (Ha ha ha.) Ā And thatās if you happen to be tuned in to twitter for some reason at said event. Ā IIRC, I got the official emergency system alert well after 5 that day, though I happened to be already home at the time. Ā For a week after that, the curfews turned on and off in a seemingly random fashion, with little warning.
⢠Letās share one last moment of unintentional Seattle Police Department comedy before we move into the main event.
Have you heard the thing about ~the Zone~ extorting local businesses?Ā That thing that one right-wing clickbait guy picked up and ran with, which made its way from there to otherĀ culture war clickbait peddlers like Rod DreherĀ and evenĀ newspapers with reputations?
I was originally going to quote the various reporters whoād tried to find these extorted businesses and come up empty-handed -- remember, theĀ āCHAZā is tiny, there just arenāt many businesses in there -- but while I was writing this post, the Seattle Times has come out with the following, which Iāll just quote in full here:
Police walk back report that Capitol Hill protesters extorted businesses
The Seattle Police Department walked back its claim, widely repeated in the news media, that denizens of the Capitol Hill Autonomous Zone are extorting businesses.
"That has not happened affirmatively," Seattle Police Chief Carmen Best in a news conference Thursday afternoon, adding that the police department had based earlier claims on anecdotal reports, including in the news and on social media. "We haven't had any formal reports of this occurring."
That contradicts earlier statements from the police.
In a news conference Wednesday, Assistant Seattle Police Chief Deanna Nollette said police have heard from Capitol Hill community members that some protesters have asked business owners to pay a fee to operate in a roughly six-block area around the precinct. Best repeated the claim in a video address to officers Thursday morning.
The police narrative rang false to many in the Capitol Hill business community. Restaurant owners said they hadn't heard any reports of extortion in the Autonomous Zone. On the contrary: Sales are strong and the increase in walk-up business is cutting down on delivery costs.
"This protest has not hurt us at all," said Bok a Bok Chicken co-owner Brian O'Connor. When he came to the Autonomous Zone Wednesday, rather than extortion, he said he was met with an offer of a free bagel-and-cheese sandwich.
The claim seems to have gained traction after it was published in conservative blog The Post Millennial, in an article written by former Seattle City Council candidate Ari Hoffman. The article quoted unnamed police officers who alleged protesters were extorting businesses for protection money. Hoffman said his sources were "rock solid" and that he had first heard of the alleged extortion on conservative talk radio station AM 770 KTTH.
The claim was later repeated by a commenter under the name "Marcus S." on the Capitol Hill Seattle blog, and in a tweet by Andy Ngo, editor-at-large of The Post Millennial.
Apart from those sources, Christina Arrington, who heads the Capitol Hill branch of the Greater Seattle Business Association, said she has had "no other indications that this is taking place." The GSBA "found no evidence of this occurring," the group tweeted, based on conversations with area business.
The Seattle Times, among other local news outlets, repeated Nollette's claims that the police had received reports of extortion from community members.
But enough of all that boring shit, am I right?Ā I know what youāre here for.Ā You want to know about the marvel and the terror, the secessionist enclave of armed intersectional warlords and/or the next Paris Commune.Ā You want to hear about...
I walked around there for half an hour earlier tonight!Ā By āthereā I meanĀ āthe neighborhood,ā itās literally just a small part of the neighborhood I live in, nothing especially wild has been done to it.
Uhh... any of you guys ever been to a hippie festival?Ā A Phish concert?Ā It was like a relatively restrained version of that type of thing.
Cal Anderson is a lovely little park.Ā I used to walk through it every weekday, before the pandemic.Ā Cal Anderson as the epicenter of āCHAZā basically looks like Cal Anderson would look in the past, at times when an unusually large number of cheerful but otherwise sedate people were hanging out there.Ā If you donāt haveĀ ārelatively sedate hippie festivalā available as a mental point of comparison, imagine a public park on the 4th of July where a bunch of people are milling about and thereās a generally cheerful vibe.
Wasnāt subjected to anyĀ ācheckpoints.āĀ I donāt know how to emphasize this enough: I walked through much of ~the Zone~ and it was literally just the experience I have whenever I walk through the same stretch of streets on a nice day, except this time with a lot more people.Ā If I had encountered the same thing on my walk home in 2019, I would have thoughtĀ āhuh! wonder whatās going on, I guess thereās a political rally or something?āĀ Wouldnāt even have registered as mildly abnormal for the area.
If this Raz guy is keeping the area under an iron fist (lol), he sure doesnāt seem to be scaring anyone away.Ā Tons of people there, mostly white (looked demographically typical of the area), milling through a park and some adjoining streets.Ā A genial street musician playing Pachabelās Canon.Ā Some really cool chalk art on the ground.Ā Stands where people are soliciting signatures for the #ResignDurkan petition.Ā Somewhat heavier weed smoke than usual for Seattle gatherings.
This tweet captures the amused, weary tone I think youāll hear from anyone who actually lives nearby, re: Trump and other national commentators:
Or see this post,Ā āAn Exceedingly Chill Day at the Capitol Hill Autonomous Zoneā
Last week, the constant background soundtrack of the neighborhood was a police helicopter.Ā The standard nightly experience, if you were housed and not working or protesting or something, was being kept up by flashbangs, thinkingĀ āthat was a flashbang, right? that was a flashbang and not a gunshot? right?ā over and over again, and saying to your spouse/housemate/whoeverĀ āoh, did you remember to pre-emptively close all the windows? The sun is going down, weāre nearing the tear gas time of night.ā
This was apparently the price we had to pay for . . . I honestly donāt know?Ā The cops backed down and now we can walk in the neighborhood again without thinking about the omnipresent helicopters, the prospect of a randomly created curfew effective immediately, and the question of exactly which flavors of tear gas are consistent with being a woke progressive mayor and whether the answer has changed in the last 12-24 hours.Ā Now itās just back to normal.
Iām seeing tons and tons of articles about ~the Zone~ whenever I go to Google News.Ā Itās apparently captivated the imagination of politicians, chin-stroking Op-Ed writers, and others in the same rarefied echelon in a way none of the preceding could.
The national conversation doesnāt care as much, it seems, about city governments having crises of authority, about justified loss of public trust in established authority, about those governments sitting down and saying āokay we are definitely defunding the police, the question is which lines in the budget to start cutting first,ā about cops tear gassing protesters and bystanders when they explicitly said they were no longer permitted to do that (see underĀ ājustified loss of public trust in established authorityā) . . .Ā
. . . they donāt care as much about that as they do about some crunchy left-libertarians deciding that, well, if the cops have suddenly left an area unilaterally and without warning as a big dramatic flourish, you might as well make a meme out of it and start calling the area an āautonomous zone.ā
The atmosphere in the neighborhood jumped straight toĀ āwarzoneā out of nowhere, and when the cops left it jumped back fromĀ āwarzoneā toĀ āpicnic,ā and lots of people who didnāt know or care before are now going into fractal self-stimulating bullshit loops, inventing dystopias or utopias extrapolated from badly sourced rumors about the picnic, arguing with each othersā extrapolations.Ā Itās a picnic.Ā In a park you can walk across in three minutes, and thatās the long side.
Meanwhile, Iād guess the CHAZ people are happy they can finally relax, just like the rest of us, and also happy that theyāre winning at least the local hearts and minds -- although, given opponents so perversely talented at seeming both evil and buffoonish, it world be pretty hard to loseĀ the local hearts and minds.
This is a weird kind ofĀ ābona fidesā to cite, in this or any context, but Iām not an activist, and Iām not usually someone who engages with local politics to the extent Iām doing here.Ā If all of the above sounds extreme and even cartoonish, that isnāt because I have an agenda to push, and would push it anywhere, and just happen to be pushing it here.Ā
Itās because this situation is just like that.Ā I cite a ton of sources in this post, and of course thatās mostly because I want you to know the information contained in them.Ā But I also want to convey to you that, yeah, this really is what reading Seattle news is like these days.Ā If it seems one-sided and cartoonish and blackly comic, thatās because the news and the stuff you experience day to day is one-sided and cartoonish and blackly comic.Ā Not all situations are like that, but this one is, and it would take a contrarianĀ read on the news to tell any other kind of story.
The concept of ~the Zone~ appeared in the context of this fast-moving situation.Ā It only makes sense if you know basic things likeĀ āthe cops suddenly decided to leave, without warning, one day as the next step in their sequence of erratic moves.ā
Once you know that, you can understand how crowing about the space they left as anĀ āautonomous zoneā could be a funny and cool move, if not necessarily a radical or even important move.Ā If the police are reacting to you by dramatically storming away from a precinct, and your whole deal is that you think communities can police themselves on their own, you might as well sayĀ āyeah, itās ours now, time to show we can do without you.ā
This was clearly not where they expected this to go, and itās arguably even a distraction from the broader issue of police brutality, which exists all over the place for all kinds of reasons that are not nearly as fun to talk about as ~the Zone~.Ā I donāt know where itās going to go.Ā Maybe it will become less of a goofy LARP strapped onto an existing protest movement and more like an actual independent āzoneā with its own rules and ways, I dunno, anything could happen.
Meanwhile, George Floyd is still dead, no one knows what the Seattle Police Department is thinking, the mayor may well resign or get recalled, the police are definitelyĀ getting defunded and the only question is what exactly that means, and Seattle as a whole is definitelyĀ going to change as a result -- remember, Seattle is ~4 million people, not six city blocks, and includes numerous huge businesses including one calledĀ āAmazonā which you may have heard of.Ā The mayor and cops have just made a stirring case against themselves, in a self-destructive performance which would seem like amateurish satire if it had appeared in fiction.
Big stuff is happening, and itās going to keep happening, and if we have to keep shooing people away from āthe supply level of the food cart that people are wheeling around a tiny park and whether it speaks to the horrors of the Hobbesian State of Nature,ā and toward shit that anyone -- including the people wheeling around the food truck -- actually cares about, over and over again, itās going to get old fast.Ā But we donāt have to do that, and I have hope that we wonāt.