William glared at you, as your eyes had widen in shock. You had walked into his office without knocking forgetting that you were suppose to knock and you saw the scar on his face. You weren’t worried about the glare he was giving you but the scar that was on his face. You closed the door and walked closer touching the scar itself. He blinked at the gentle touch you had before he gripped your hand.

“You should knock, I know I told you plenty of times before.”

“I-I’m sorry captain. I forgot, how did you get this scar?” You asked worried disregarding the fact he was upset with you.

“I was born with it.” He grumbled putting his mask on, you frown before reaching for the mask but he slapped your hand away.

“Don’t touch the mask, you weren’t suppose to see my face. Only a handful of people have.”

“Why?” He turned his head to the side sighing, since you already saw his face he might as well tell you.

“I was considered a cursed child, even when I was accepted into a noble family, my adoptive mother abused me. My face is ugly, and I don’t trust people not to leave me once they saw my face. Only people who had seen it was Julius and Yami. Now you...” He said, you frowned before wrapping your arms around him in a tight hug.

“Well I won’t leave you, ever. Hate to break it to you, it will take way more than just some scar for me to leave you.”

“Really?” He looked at you and you slowly removed the mask and you pecked his scar. His face erupted into flames, and you smiled.

“Yes really. Don’t worry the secret is safe with me though... I think you are more handsome without the mask.” You said handing him his mask back, he blushed looking away from you. You couldn’t help but let a giggle out knowing you embarrassed your captain.

“You really think I am handsome with such a face?”

“Yep, my feelings for you have not changed at all.”

“Wait what?” He looked at you in shock, realizing what you said you began laughing nervously.

“Whoops, I gotta go bye~!” You said running out of his office, he stood there in shock. Did you mean that you had feelings for him. The thought made William’s heart beat faster as he put his mask back on. He didn’t think you felt that way about him especially after seeing his face, he stepped in the hallway in time to see you turn the corner.

“Wait~” He yelled before using his magic and soon you felt roots wrap around your legs, causing you to fall forward. You gasped before feeling your back pressed against your captains chest.

“C-Captain.”

“I didn’t say you could leave.” He said, your face was red and you could tell he wanted to continue the conversation more.

“I uhm...have laundry to do..”

“It’s not your day to do laundry.”

“But...”

“Nope, what do you mean your feelings didn’t change?”

“Uhm....like we are still friends?” You asked, and William stared at your face knowing you were lying. You let a sigh out before turning around pressing a kiss to his lips, his eyes widen and he froze in spot once again.

“Okay fine, I like you. Like, Like like you... more than a friend.” You said hanging your head down low. William smiled after coming back to his senses and he leaned in pressing his lips to yours once again, you sighed softly in a kiss before hearing a gasp. You both parted to see Mimosa, Klaus and Yuno staring at you two.

“I-It’s not what it looks like!” You freaked out waving your hands in front of you, Klaus adjusted his glasses as Yuno was looking away.

“Uhm, are you sure about that. We saw you two kissing.” Mimosa said smiling widely.

“It’s exactly what it looks like.” William said, you stared at him wide eyed. He was smiling smugly, as you glared at him.

“She is my girlfriend now.”

“What? You didn’t ask me.”

“Don’t have too, you already confessed your feelings for me, and well I accept those feelings.”

“That’s not how it works I am sure.” Yuno said sweat dropping.

“It’s not...” You said crossing your arms so he sighed before turning to you.

“Will you be my girlfriend (Y/N)?”

“Yes I would love too.” You said with a small blush, still trying to process the fact you two were caught lip lock.

“Congratulations~” Mimosa said hugging you.

“Uh thank you.”

“I can’t believe we walked in on that.” Klaus said and Yuno nodded.

“By the way we have our report for our mission captain.” Klaus said and he nodded.

“Head to my office I will see you in there.” They nodded leaving you alone, William stole another kiss before smiling at you.

“Thank you.” He said and you looked at him confused.

“For what?”

“You made me happier than ever, I thought I would end up dying alone. But I know that I can be loved, just by the right person.” He said nudging your nose with his before making his way to his office.

“I will talk to you later, I do have duties to do.” He said and you smiled.

“Okay see you later William~!” You said before going into your room squealing slightly.

“And my plan worked. Yes!” You said fist pumping the air, and dancing around your room.

You always stayed far away from William, it was something about the Golden Dawn’s captain that made your blood run cold. Whenever William tried to hold a conversation with you, you would come up with an excuse to leave. William noticed that you didn’t want to be anywhere near him. It sort of broke his heart since he was so in love with you. He even tried to go on missions with you, but you stayed silent and far away from unless you stopped an attack from him. He had realized that you were close to everyone and joked around with everyone, even Nozel. Yet he couldn’t even get you to say one word to him.

He decided he would talk to you about it since he wondered if he did something to upset you. He couldn’t think of what he did, so he grew worried. After he requested for you he began to tap his pen against his desk awaiting your arrival. You walked to his office quite nervous and you bit your lip as you knocked on the door. You heard a soft ‘come in’, and you walked in before closing the door behind you. You stayed by the door looking at William. He had a faint frown on his lips, you didn’t even want to in the same room with him.

“You can have a seat (Y/N).”

“It’s fine captain... I have been sitting all day.” You said William nodded his head slightly before it fell silent again. It was until after a few moments before William broke the silence.

“The reason why I wanted to talk to you was that... I need to know do you hate me?”

“What?”

“I noticed that you stay far away from me, every time I try and talk with you and have a normal conversation you come up with an excuse to get away from me. You get along with all the other captains and members of the squad except me...”

“Really? Do I?”

“Yes, even when we are on missions together...”

“Oh...”

“Why don’t you like me? Did I do something to offend you?”

“Uhm, no you haven’t exactly.” You admitted, William got up from his chair and made his way to you. You backed up slightly but your back had hit the wall.

“Then what is it? I have been trying to get close to you. Everyone has been able to befriend you, but me.” He said now standing right in front of you. You blinked falling quiet, you began to get more nervous, but William wanted to know.

“Do you really want me to answer honestly?”

“Yes, please.” You stayed quiet for a few moments looking off to the side.

“Every time I am around you, you make my blood run cold. I get an eerie feeling when I am around you. I want to trust you, yet deep down I feel like it’s a bad idea.”

“You don’t trust me?”

“Sorry but no. No one I met has ever been so friendly, and so calm. You are like a combination of Jack, Yuno and a pinch of Mimosa’s personality. It’s...weird. Your mask doesn’t help, leaving you to be a complete and utter mystery.” You admitted, still trying to find a way to remove yourself from between William and the wall. William fell silent it broke his heart a bit knowing the real reason why you stayed clear of him, but knowing the reason now made him determined to change the way you see him. Even if it meant that he had to show you one of his biggest secrets he hid in his life.

William gently took your hands into his, your blood began to run cold a shiver ran down your spine. He felt your shaking hands and gave them a firm yet gentle squeeze. He placed both of your hands on his mask and you looked at him confused.

“Go ahead, remove the mask. You will learn one of my greatest secrets and why I wear this mask.” William said dropping his hands to his sides, your hands were still shaking and you continued to stare at him. He met your (e/c) orbs with his purple ones, he shifted nervously at the fact his face would now be exposed to the one person he truly loved.

“Is this suppose to make me trust you?”

“Is it not a start?” He asked, you sighed and did as you were told. You slowly removed the mask, you felt his eyes staring at your every movement. Once his mask was completely off, you looked at his face completely shocked dropping it to the floor. You covered your mouth and you were shaking, you never expected to a scar that covered half of his face. He felt a blush cover his cheeks as he was completely vulnerable, you were his world and he loved you. Now that you knew what he looked like you could break him in so many ways. He grew self-conscious as you continued to stare at the scar.

You reached your hand out touching the scar, William met your eyes. You looked concerned, worried, and curious.

“H-How did you get that?”

“I was born with it. Only Julius knew about the scar, he was the one who made the mask for me so I would join the magic knights.”

“Does it hurt?”

“No, not at all.” He said leaning into your hand as you began to stroke his cheek with your thumb. He placed his hand on top of yours holding your hand to his face and pressed a small kiss to the palm, that made you let a small gasp out. You began to feel bad for judging him based on how you felt without truly getting to know the guy. He took your free hand into his and stepped closer to you as your eyes were fixated on his scar, he brought your free hand to his lips and began to kiss each and every knuckle. You blushed at the intimate action he had done to your hand making you nervous.

He continued to lean into your hand, his heart began to beat faster. Your touches were so gentle and he grew so addicted to being so close to you.

“(Y/N), please learn to trust me. I want you to learn to trust me and not avoid me. I love you, so much. I have always loved you, that’s why I wanted to talk to you and find out why you avoid me.” Your eyes widen in shock, and your hand fell from his face. He grabbed your hand again and placed it on his cheek again. He continued to kiss your palm looking into your eyes, you felt a blush cover your cheeks.

“C-Captain...” You stuttered out, William saw the blush on your cheeks and he gave you a gentle smile.

“Let me love you.”

“I-I...”

“(Y/N)...” William brought his face to yours, he didn’t move closer and stayed a few centimeters away from your face. He didn’t want you to be even more uncomfortable so he had to keep his feelings in check.

“Why? I don’t understand. I practically called you creepy, I judged you based on my own feelings, and I avoided you. I don’t understand how you can love me.”

“Even so, you have always had my heart. When Julius said he was moving you to my squad, I thought maybe with us being in the same squad we could become closer. I thought maybe you just never had time when I tried talking to you, so I was going to use this to my advantage to get to know you. In the process, my feelings only got stronger.” He moved your hand off of his cheek and grabbed your or arm and wrapped them around his neck. You were not completely pressed against him, and his arms wrapped around your waist.

Your blush covered your cheeks, and your heart began to pound into your chest. You had never been this close to a guy, and the way he was so close to your face you had a feeling he wanted to kiss you. You never had your first kiss.

“Is it okay if I kiss you?”

“If you do, you will be my first kiss. Plus you are my captain.” You said, and you were suddenly more flustered. William couldn’t help the smile that spread across his lips.

“I don’t mind being your first kiss, after all, you would be my first kiss too. As for me being a captain, I don’t care about that. I just want to be near you and love you with every ounce of my being.” Listening to his words relaxed you a bit, you never knew he had such strong feelings for you and your heart began to pound harder. You slowly took a deep breath before nodding your head and saying the words that made him happy.

“O-Okay. Y-You can kiss me.” He smiled and leaned in the rest of the way pressing his lips to yours. He held you close to his chest as if you were fragile and were going to break at any moment. The way he kissed you was so sweet and gentle, that you felt all of the worries, nervousness, and every negative thing you felt towards him disappear. He licked your bottom lip gently asking for entrance, you shyly parted your lips giving him the access. You let a soft gasp out feeling his tongue against yours, but you began to grow addicted to the kiss. You began to wonder why you ever doubted William and felt silly for being nervous around him. William parted from the kiss after giving your lips a gentle nibble and smiled as he leaned his forehead against yours.

“I love you so much (Y/N)...” He said stroking your hair out of your face, your face was so flustered you could muster out a sentence. The kiss was so intoxicating and sweet you wanted more of it. You blushed at the thought meeting his eyes, and he gave you another smile.

“Don’t worry (Y/N). I won’t force my feelings onto you any more than I already have. I just originally only meant to confess to you. I don’t know why I became so desperate to kiss you.” He said.

“I-It’s okay, it was a nice first kiss.” You said looking down at the ground, he tilted your chin up slightly and pressed his lips to yours in a quick and chaste kiss. He parted once again but you wanted to feel the kiss again, but he placed his finger against your lips.

“Wait until you actually gain feelings for me, until you don’t feel uneasy around me.” He said gently, you blushed and nodded your head.

“O-Okay captain.”

“Just call me William when it’s the two of us...” He said and you nodded with a soft smile on your lips.

~ a Few months later~

You and William had become extremely close, the very person you didn’t trust at first ended up being the one you trusted the most. You began to talk with him more, and laugh, everyone in the squad and squad captains noticed the difference between you two. They knew of William’s feelings for you but they realized you began to reciprocate those feelings.

William kept his words, and never forced his feelings on you. He didn’t kiss you, hug you or hold your hand, one day everyone was having a get together in one of the bars in the Capital and you gave William a hug. It shocked William and everyone else, except Julius. What people didn’t know was Julius knew what he was doing when he put you on William’s team. He wanted to see his OTP become a couple, and so he decided to meddle in your’s and William’s at the time nonexistent relationship.

You had every intention of confessing to William, you knew he felt the same way. Yet you still got shy and nervous and would chicken out coming up with a different excuse to see him. Today though was going to be the day he knew your feelings, you woke up with all the confidence in the world and you got to work on your plan before you could chicken out. You made a chocolate cake, with chocolate icing and strawberries decorated the top. In three bright red iced letters read the words that William had been longing to hear escape your lips.

Once you were done with the cake you covered it up and rushed to William’s office before your confidence level escaped you. The closer you got to the office the slower you walked, until you were standing in front of his door. You took a deep breath and knocked before hearing William told you to come in.

You walked in closing the door behind you, William looked up from his paperwork and tilted his head. He saw the cake in your hand and looked at you confused. You walked to his desk and set the cake on the table at this point you were slightly shaking and your face was extremely red.

“It’s for you, uncover it...” You said quietly. You watched as he uncovered the cake when he read it a smiled covered his face.

“Really?” He looked at you, seeing his reaction made you smile and you walked around his desk removing his mask. He looked at you until you pressed your lips to his deeply, he was shocked by the sudden boldness. He pulled you into his lap and you both began to make out for a good five minutes before you parted. YOu were panting before feeling something sticky on the tip of your nose. You gasped giving him a ‘how dare you’ look.

“I know you did not just put the homemade icing that I busted my butt to make on my face...” William laughed softly and licked the icing off before pecking your lips repeatedly.

“It tastes good.”

“I made it, I would hope so.” You said crossing your arms, and he smiled.

“I love you too (Y/N) but you already know that?” He said and you turned to face him nodding your head.

“Yeah, I do. I really do love you.”

“I am glad you were able to learn to love me, trust me, despite your original feelings, and after you saw my face,” William said, and you ran your finger along the scar.

“You are really handsome William...” You said, and he chuckled leaning into your hand.

“As you are really beautiful. Will you make me even happier and be my girlfriend?”

“Of course William...” You said and he leaned in kissing your lips once again before cutting you both a piece of cake and feeding you his slice and you fed him your slice.

~Meanwhile~

“I did it again...” Julius said peeking into William’s office and seeing the new couple. He was somewhere inside the office and the new couple couldn’t sense his or the other captain’s mana as they were hiding in a closet.

“You really did all of that to get your newest couple together?”

“Of course, next may just be Asta and Noelle...” Julius said planning to get the two young ones to date.

“I will kill you. He is not dating Noelle.” Nozel stated glaring holes into Julius.

“Then Yami and Charollette.”

“What???” Both said and looked at each other. Julius didn’t realize it but he was slowly starting to become the target to be killed by the captains.

“Fuegoleon and Sol...”

“Leo and Charmy...”

“....Lightening dragon Roar~!” The captains and Julius were all bickering before being blasted by your magic, they then realized they couldn’t move because of William’s spell.

“Uh... hey?” They all said and Nozel a Fuegoleon were glaring daggers into their Wizard King’s head.

‘He is dead...’ everyone yelled in their heads before realizing they were in trouble since you tended to have a bad temper.

“You are all dead.” You said cracking your fingers, luckily all the noises made it where William was able to put his mask back on but he was sure they already saw there face.