I don’t believe that anyone was asking for this, but here it is ~ !
Who said “I love you” first: Troy. It naturally slipped out, one morning, while he caught a glimpse of the sunlight streaming through the kitchen window of their apartment haloing Kelsi and playing on the curls of her hair, and became transfixed by it. Blushing up a storm and heart pounding, he meant to retract it, especially seeing Kelsi's surprise. But, Kelsi found herself easily able to return the sentiment, eyes shining and a soft, adoring smile spreading across her face.
Who would have the other’s picture as their phone background: They both have each other's pictures as their homescreen backgrounds.
Who leaves notes written in fog on the bathroom mirror: Troy initially starts the trend and Kelsi, amused, quickly picks it up, as well. The notes can be sappy, sentimental, corny, or even profound and encouraging. Either way, it's another special facet of their relationship.
Who buys the other cheesy gifts: Are you kidding me? It's Troy. He is Mr. Diehard Romantic, Bought His Ex-Girlfriend A Necklace With A Pendant Bearing The First Letter of His Name And Brought Her A Picnic Basket Full of Her Favorite Foods. Spoiling his partner with overly cheesy, gooey sentimental gifts is written into his DNA.
Who initiated the first kiss: Kelsi. Swept up by the excitement of one of her compositions being selected for a professional production and practically bouncing on her feet, she grabbed hold of the lapels of Troy's blazer, arched onto her toes, and--
It was a chaste peck, and she stumbled over herself to apologize for it, but Troy recovered from his surprise and softly said her name. Once her eyes were on his, once more, he trailed a hand down her cheek, took hold of her chin, and gently guided her lips back to his.
Who kisses the other awake in the morning: They alternate; planting playful, sloppy pecks on cheeks and temples, and brushing kisses on each other's noses.
Who asks who if they can join the other in the shower: Troy shyly, timidly asks to join Kelsi in the shower. It's the first time after Gabriella that he's able to make such a bold move. Astonished, Kelsi quietly, then with more confidence, extends an invitation and Troy takes a place behind her, only barely able to work up the courage to wash her hair. Slowly, bit by bit, he works up the courage to kiss the back of her neck, and rub the lather of body wash onto the curves of her shoulder blades. Kelsi returns the gesture, massaging shampoo into Troy's scalp and every strand of his hair and cupping water into her hands to tenderly rinse suds off of his chest and stomach.
Who surprises the other in the middle of the day at work with lunch: Troy. Once he comes back into his own and regains his footing, he'll sneak up behind her, and slide his arms around her shoulders, presenting her with one of his specialty peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, or a salad, or any flavor of Asian takeout, or tacos from a taco cart, or a burger, fries, and a butterscotch milkshake.
Who was nervous and shy on the first date: Both of them- Troy significantly discouraged by the way his relationship with Gabriella self-destructed, and Kelsi equally wary to dip her toes back into the romantic pond after Jason left her for Martha, and her crush on Ryan inevitably lead to them being nothing more than best friends.
Who kills/takes out the spiders: Troy takes out the spiders. He can't bring himself to hurt them, so he captures them under a cup, slips a piece of paper beneath the cup, and deposits the spider outside, where he watches it scuttle a safe distance away.
Who loudly proclaims their love when they’re drunk: Troy. Though drinking, especially to get drunk, isn't something they do often. Troy is… haunted, and falls easily into a depression when intoxicated.