Toby is A.D or has a strong connection with them!
It’s been floating in my head for a while that Toby is A.D. He is pure dodge and has a motive. In season 4/5, I can’t remember the season,but Mr Hastings told Toby not to sue Radley for his mother, however, I think that there is more to this. Considering that we now know that Peter has known about Mary and her radley antics. Moving on in the 7x10 episode we see that Toby and Yvonne have a crash because of a deer (rolls eyes). But I’ve been thinking that maybe his alibi isn’t as smooth as it seems. A.D captures Jenna and drags her out of the blind school. 1. Who would know about the school that Jenna went to? 2. We don’t know how many people were in the blind school While Jenna gets placed in the van, A.D takes off the mask and she feels the mask and finds out that it is A.D. Who else’s face has Jenna touched? TOBY’s! She would’ve known A.D was Toby if she had felt his face and therefore giving the game away! Toby isn’t stupid. He knows that the girls killed Dr Rollins and set up this game. He wants to get revenge on Alison for all the rubbish she’s put him through. All cops in rosewood are corrupt - but in this case especially Toby. Mary and Marion Cavanaughs names are really close and similar maybe radley mixed them up on occassions. (I think someone should make a theory on this) Mrs Dilaurentis didn’t tell anyone about her sister but what if Marion knew everything- but knew too much. Toby mentioned that she was getting better. Getting better also means that she was soon to be released. But if she was, so would all the things she found out in Radley I.e. Mary, Charles and Bethany. There is no doubt that she knew all of this, and so I think Mrs D or Mary pushed Marion to hold her secrets. What is Toby’s alibi for the night Charlotte was killed? Dr Palmer told Toby and presumably Marion Cavanaugh to ‘Stay away from the blonde girl’ the blonde girl was Charlotte! Charlotte was the one that was sending Toby clues as to what really happened to Mary because she was in Radley also. In 4x09 Toby and Spencer visit Dr Palmer and while there Spencer plays the song A/ CeCe sent to Toby. The song is ‘Any Time’. Marlene said the Pasty Cline was a huge clue. 'Anytime’ is also a song of Pasty Clines. The reason as to why we get so many Patsy Cline songs is because Toby’s mother loved her songs and played and sang them. To wrap this up I believe that after Toby picked up Jenna from the blind school and dropped her off somewhere, maybe his cabin? Picked up Yvonne and was ready to 'out of rosewood’. It would’ve been the perfect motive. How can you suspect someone that was moving out of town with their fiancé? It also gives him the perfect opportunity to be out of town but spy on the girls and never be a suspect. Also maybe the Artucus Graphic Novel was when Cece introduced Toby to the game… It’s probably one of the reasons why Spencer and Toby won’t be together at the end of the show. I’m just saying y'all the clues are there or maybe I’m blowing this far left. But we’ll see. Please like and share!
