HEC: Acquisition of Leadership Skills in Crisis Situations
by Thomas Kwon
October 16, 2014
Speakers:
Xavier Boute, Affiliate Professor of HEC Paris, Academic Dean Saint-Cyr Military Academy
Colonel Cyril Barth, CEO of Saint-Cyr Military Academy Foundation
What do corporate and military leadership have in common? According to Colonel Cyril Barth, CEO of Saint-Cyr Military Academy Foundation, and Xavier Boute, affiliate professor at HEC Paris and academic dean at Saint-Cyr, the overlap is clear. Speaking at the 2014 World Knowledge Forum, Mr. Barth said, “Leadership matters. The way we are leading our teammates is exactly the same. We’ve got to trust others and give them the chance to challenge everything.”
In considering the role of a leader, Mr. Boute posed the question, “What is the relationship between master and servant? Are you a member of the team?”
According to both speakers, there is a disconnect between book learning and practical application. To fill the gap, their academy puts current and future business leaders through a crash course in crisis management involving various simulated missions, such as building bridges, rescuing wounded squad members, and escaping confined rooms.
At first glance, the activities of Saint-Cyr may not seem directly linked to corporate leadership, but to Mr. Barth, this is precisely the point. He explained that for people to properly handle the unknown, they must practice outside of their comfort zone, regardless of context.
“There is a kind of pedagogical approach we have to deal with. If you are just teaching things, if you are just explaining in a room, you won’t be as understood as you can be if you let people do things on their own," he said.
Mr. Boute drove this idea home with a story about a civilian corporate trainee who approached him after what she called a “life-changing” session. After accomplishing an extremely challenging feat during a physically and mentally draining military exercise, she could not explain how she had completed the task. The key, Mr. Boute said, is that she was able to perform in the stressful environment, gaining valuable experience for future situations.
For Mr. Barth, the transformation and adaptation to uncertain circumstances is critical to leadership. He boiled the process down to three key aspects: decision-making, behavior, and empathy.
“If you don’t know what you want to do, if you don’t know where you want to attack, if you don’t know what market you want to win, you can’t ask people to work for you,” he said.
He continued, “If you’re telling what is right and wrong, if you’re explaining things clearly…it will be very, very nice for people. And if you’re not, well, they won’t get a word of what you’re saying.”
Adding to his colleague’s perspective, Mr. Boute shared his own thoughts on the necessary characteristics for leadership, strongly reiterating the themes of trust and teamwork.
“As an officer, I think a good leader has to love the members of their team. Then maybe it will make them work, it will make them work harder,” he said.
For their final point, the gentlemen stressed that leadership is about continuous learning and achieving tasks once thought of as impossible – or not thought of at all.
In spite of the numerous commonalities shared by corporations and armies, Mr. Barth made certain to distinguish the stakes.
“Time is money in a company. Time is life in the army.”









