Sundays are for family dinner
[4.6K]
pairing(s): steve harrington x fem!reader
summary: Steve met you at the lowest point of his life and it still surprises him sometimes how quickly you see through him and seem to have the exact right words for everything
warnings: 18+ , MDNI, tiny bit smutty, mentions of trauma, mentions of death, mentions of weight loss, mentions of scars, swearing, brief stancy, lmk if i missed anything!!
Part 2
A/N: unbelievable how many times you can stop yorurself from witing "soft". i'm so strong. but truly, i love soft!steve so much, it makes me weirdly emotional. i literally wrote the whole things for that last scene.
Everytime you and Steve had the kids over it was mayhem. Familiar, lovely, lively but mayhem nonetheless.
âDustin, youâre turning 23, I should not be the one still telling you to not run with a knife, dude!â you hear Steveâs voice from behind you while putting out some snacks at the kitchen counter.
âSorry, dad!â
âJesus Christ.â He murmurs in an exaspereted voice and you can practically see the way he pinches the bridge of his nose.
âSome peopleâs kids, huh?â you murmur with a smirk.
âItâs dangerous! One of these days heâll slip on the tiles and cut himself if he keeps doing that.â
âYou should be careful, you sound more and more like an old man with every passing day H.â
Heâs always hit by a little wave of nostalgia when you call him that. Walking into his life, all cocky and snappy at a point when he thought he was over this. Over the all-consuming crushes and thinking someone is the love of your life.
After defeating the Upside down, after the dust settled, after burying their dead they stuck together. Losing Jonathan did a number on everyone. Everyone thought they shouldâve done more. Will felt guilt and sadness, so Mike was devastated, Dustin seemed inconsolable, Nancy was weighed down with all the unsaid words, with the final memories of distance and uncertainty. And he was left to pick up the pieces once again. He was lonely. Robin was leaving for college soon, and he knew she had to go, there were no two ways about it but it did make him anxious and very sad and he didnât show it. In the midst of all of that he was desperate for some familiarity, something to comfort, something that felt safe. So, they briefly found their way back to each other, for exactly that. Warmth, ease, uncomplicated. But itâs never that, is it? Uncomplicated, that is. They quickly figured out that it was not gonna work. It wasnât dramatic, or loud or anything like that. It was a quiet understanding, slow, shared tears, âIâm sorryâsâ whispered into the dark, although they both knew it wasnât anybodyâs fault. It just was what it was.
He walked into a bar in Indiana while visiting Robin not too long after that. She had to study, he was feeling particularly sorry for himself. You were pouring beer and laughing with someone who seemed to be a regular. Wearing a band T-shirt with the sleeves cut off in a way that your bra was peaking out the sides as you moved, hair tied into a bun with no care, chipped black nail polish, a dangerous smile and something even more dangerous glinting in your eyes as you threw your head back giggling. Not his type but still very much his type. He was at rock bottom and he knew you were trouble but he still couldnât stop himself from walking over to the bar. Like a moth to the flame. Iâm so fucking pathetic - he thought to himself.
As he sat down at the bar your eyes flicked at him. You knew that look. Being a bartender you see a guy like him at least three times a night. Six on the weekends. Theyâre sad, they lost something, or they never found it. Whatever it is, you smile, you listen if needed, flirt a little and they tip nice. This wasnât even the first time you thought you could kiss it better, fix him, as it were.
âHey, what can I get you?â
âUh, hi, just a beer please.â
âJust a beer coming up.â
You were pouring the beer from the tap and you couldnât help but stare a little. The dark circles and bags under his eyes, little scruff, he obviously hasnât shaved in at least in a couple of days, cheeks a little too bony. He lost weight, you thought, heâs not sleeping. Wonderful material for your unshakeable need to save everyone. You were quick to learn that thatâs something you shared.
âYou new in town?â you asked.
âUhm, yes and no.â
âOh, mysterious.â
Were you flirting with him?
âNot that mysterious.â You almost missed the tiniest little upturn in the corner of his lips. âMy best friend goes to college here, just visiting. First time in town though.â
âWell, youâre at the right place thenâ you said, continuing in that slightly teasing tone that started to raise a little bit of heat at the back of his neck. The first time you made him feel something he thought he couldnât anymore. âMost good stories and bad decisions start right here.â
Before he could answer a guy came up beside him.
âHey, sweetheart.â There was something about the nickname and the way he said it that made him pull a cringing frown, which didnât go unnoticed by you.
Oh, boy.
âHi, Vinnie.â All the warmth and playfulness was drained from your voice so fast. He took his beer and took a sip, sending you a thankful look.
âI would love a whisky, neat, with your number on the side.â He was really trying to control himself but this dick was making it very hard. He could see the way you tensed. You knew this guy. You didnât like it.
âWeâve been over this Vinnie. The whisky I can do, nothing else, just drop it bud.â
âOh, come on now sweetheart.â That fucking nickname again. âSmile for me a little, thatâs the least you can do, promise to leave a big tip.
âJesus Christâ He didnât mean to, he really didnât, he didnât want trouble - well maybe a little, in the form of that giggle he heard earlier but nothing else. But it still slipped out, he couldnât help it.
âIs there a problem here buddy?â He knew that tone too. Trouble. Not the good kind.
âEasy does it, Vinnie! Heâs new, donât scare him away.â You send him a wink but he senses the tension. Youâve seen this before. You donât want this. He doesnât need to be a knight in shining armour for you.
âNo problem at all, man. Just drinking my beer. Although, if you keep harassing her, we might have one.â Again, it just slipped out. Old habits and all that.
âHarassing? Jesus, you young people get so easily worked up over nothing. Iâm just flirting a little, no harm.â
âWell, sheâs clearly not into it, so you can just say thank you and we can all drink our beers in silence and peace.â
There are a couple things happening at the same time. You shout something (the bodyguard at the place, he later learns), the chair under Vinnie sliding backwards and his fists grabbing onto his shirt near his collar.
âListen, little boy-â
But he canât finish the sentence, because the guard pulls him off. They canât keep him out, but they can definitely kick him out when he acts up.
He was glad, if he wanted to be honest. He could still pull some punches probably, if need be, but he was nowhere near his prime anymore. There was no way he was gonna win that one. It was a hard pill to swallow but he needed to be smarter about these things. Bloody knuckles werenât that cute anymore, now he was pushing thirty.
âYou make a habit of protecting bartenders?â you asked after the guy was thrown out.
âOnly the ones that wink at me.â
âHuh, I should do it more often then.â
âMaybe you should.â Itâs teasing, the way his voice drops half on octave as he says it. Your lips twitch. Heâs still got some of it left, he thinks to himself, good to know.
âYour next beer is on me then, hero boy.â
âWhat makes you think I want another beer? And Steveâs fine.â
âIf you must know, Steve, I get off in about an hour and thought you might wanna stick around.â
âDo you have a phone back there?â
âGotta let your girlfriend know, youâre not coming home tonight?â
âLike I said, my best friend, no girlfriend. She gets worried easily, thatâs all.â
âWife? A couple kids back home?â
âNo wife, no kidsâ he said, holding his left hand up, wiggling his fingers. âWell, not mine, anyway.â
You furrowed your eyebrows at that and tilted your head to the side, which made your throat stretch in a way that had him thinking some thoughts. Inappropriate, even lewd thoughts. The second time you made him feel something he thought evaporated from him.
âThereâs this group of kids - well, theyâre not even kids anymore really - I used to sort of babysit back in the day. Not my kids, but kinda my kids.â
You hum, narrow your eyes and he feels his stomach drop a little. Youâre looking at him, studying. He didnât really say anything and still you know thereâs something to look for behind it. Youâre reading him, looking for that closed up, hidden place inside of him that has been dormant for so long. And he almost felt like he wanted you to find it. Shit.
âThe phoneâs on the wall to the right.â you said eventually when you saw someone walk up to the bar.
By the time youâre clocking out, heâs a little tipsy, leaning against the wall of the divebar.
âYou waited.â
âYou got me a free beer, only fair.â
âYou have some more time to spare? Maybe you could extend your protector hours a little, walk me home?â
It was the game, he knew it. Why else would you have suggested he stay, if you didnât want to take him home? But itâs a game he loves, heâs a little rusty, thatâs a given but he does love it and is happy to play along. Itâs like flexing a sore muscle. Itâs not exactly comfortable just yet, but it does feel good.
âUh, you see, that might just cost you another beer.â
âYouâll have to come back for that, pretty boy.â
âWas planning on it anyway, free beer or no free beer.â
âThatâs a good answer.â
âLead the way.â
The conversation is a little fractured. A question here and there, where are you from and what do you do, have you ever been to this place, you must try that. He told you how he found a new calling in being the town handyman while he helped rebuild it after the earthquakes and shit. You remembered the news, the front pages, how it didnât seem to add up. You tell him you dropped out of college, only recently reapplying, studying to be a counselor during the day, picking up shifts at the library and the bar anytime you could. Itâs nice. It feels easy, despite the fact that you can both feel the yet untold sadness and pain behind those stories. The beer and conversation are loosening him up in a way he hasnât felt with a stranger in a long time. He even made you giggle a couple of times and it warms him even more than the beer.
âYou wanna come in?â You ask when reaching the door. Thereâs no bashfulness, no shyness lingering there. Heâs kinda known, more hoped, this would happen but the lack of those things still catches him a little off guard. You keep surprising him, tilting the axis of the world around him a little and he finds that he likes it. And heâs really glad, he sobered up on the walk home.
He nods with a lazy, crooked smile and it makes you huff out a little laugh as you open the door.
After you switch on the fairy lights, heâs studying your place, making your insecurities rise a little. It was small, a little messy, you werenât expecting anyone. Books scattered on the small table and the couch, a highlighter, a few empty mugs and a soup bowl, a couple plants, a throw blanket crumpled up - the fairy lights make everything look warm, cozy. Just like you - he thinks.
âYou have a nice place.â
âThank you.â Your voice comes from closer behind him than he anticipated, it makes him flinch a little.
âSorryâ you murmur, even closer now, your breath hitting him through his shirt. âDidnât mean to scare you.â You place a barely there kiss on his shoulder, your gentle hand coming up on the opposite shoulder with a reassuring, light squeeze. Those two things alone are enough to send his head into a tailspin and make him want to cry at how sweet you are. How receptive you were to his sudden⌠shyness. Tenseness? He didnât really know what was going on with him.
âItâs okay, sorry for being jumpy,â he said, bringing a hand up to yours that was now snaked around his chest, a little too close to his heart.
âSorry for the mess. Wasnât really planning on having company.â
He shook his head with a tiny, breathy laugh.
âItâs okay.â He turned around, keeping your hand in his, brushing your knuckles a little.
Your were silent, looking up to him with wide eyes, the fairy lights and that dangerous something twinkling in them in a way that made him fear he was already well and truly fucked.
You could both feel the air shift, tension getting thick, and he was really glad you took charge, tangling your fingers into his hair at the nape of his neck, brushing the apples of his cheek with your thumb, gently pushing him into the direction of the couch, slowly but deliberately, giving him time to stop but making clear what you want. You pushed him down softly, questioning look in your eyes, before he nodded and you lowered yourself onto his lap.
âHiâ you breathed when you were nose to nose again.
âHiâ he breathed back.
âYou nervous pretty boy?â
âI-â his breath hitched a little when you pressed into him with a little more intent. âYeah, shit, yeah, a little. Been a while.â
âWe can stop, if you want.â
He shook his head, placing his hands on either side of your hips. Not grabbing yet, just anchoring himself maybe.
âI need you to say it, pretty boy.â You whispered. Your thumb brushed over his eyebrow and it took every single scrap of self control left in him to not let out a whine.
âNo.â It came out croaked, like he had to clear his throat. âNo, I donât wanna stop. Iâve been wondering what you taste like all night. Just, maybe go slow?â
âI can do slow. Donât have anywhere to be.â You kept caressing his face with sincere finger tips, brushing away his fears one stroke at a time.
When you finally leaned in to kiss him he thought he might pass out. Your lips were so fucking soft, your every movement tender and affectionate and he had to try really hard to not let the thought about how heâs undeserving, unworthy of these things seep into the forefront of his mind. Lucky, you kind of occupied every single one of his senses. You smelled like deodorant and detergent, a little worn out from your shift at the bar. He didnât mind. It made you feel real. When your hand dipped beneath his shirt you felt him tense up, so you paused. He squeezed his eyes shut when you looked up at him, eyes all doey, questioning, a little worried.
âIâm sorryâ he whispered. He let his forehead fall against your shoulder.
âCan you look at me, please?â You were trying to coax him out of whatever this state was with soft and steady touches âPlease, baby.â
And how the fuck do you say no to that? It was almost unbearable, the honesty, the concern in your eyes.
âDo you want me to stop?â
âNo.â
âWant me to turn off the lights?â
âNo. Wanna see you.â
The grin you give him makes his heart skip.
âSmooth.â
âStill have some moves left, it turns out.â
âLet me guess: high school heartthrob?â
âI donât know how to answer that without sounding like a jackass.â
âSo, yes.â
âYou wanna keep being a smartass or you wanna use your pretty mouth for something else, maybe?â
âOh, look at that! Here I am, trying to make you relax and you go straight to suggesting I suck your dick.â
âWhat?! No, wait thatâs n-â
He couldnât finish the sentence because you stopped his rambling with a kiss. Little more force in it now. Youâre holding his face like he is something precious and he thinks he might want to believe that he is someday. He kissed back with more fervor, his hands started moving up your back and you could feel him relax again a little bit against your touch. Coming up for a little air, you looked at him.
âWanna go to the bedroom?â
âYes.â It was eager, hungry even and it made you chuckle.
âCome on, pretty boy.â
You led him into the bedroom where you realized why he was so tense. He took his shirt off with a sigh, and thatâs when you saw the scars. Healed and scabbed, probably a couple years old.
He thinks back to that night often when things get tough. The way you traced them with delicate fingers, the way you kissed along them. It was the first time he felt remotely like a normal person in years. Like someone who can have nice things. Like someone who deserved this. He was on the verge of tears but he wanted it so bad. And so he kept himself together, kissed you like he meant it, kissed down your body, spent his sweet time with his head between your thighs, until they shook, until tears were prickling in the corner of eyes, which he also kissed away. He was nervous, about being scrawny, about the bones showing, poking his skin, about the scars but you didnât bet an eye. He only saw hunger, want, felt it in the way you tangled your fingers in his hair. And you made it look easy. Wanting him looked easy when you did it and it made him a little crazy. You made him relax, laughing with him when he fumbled with the condom packet and again when you hit your head on the headboard at a particularly hard thrust. You wore each other out that night, he also remembers that. You fell asleep tracing patterns onto his chest and while he struggled a little, like most nights, he also fell into a deep slumber next to you and didnât wake until the early afternoon. He almost started to panic when he didnât see you next to him in the bed but that quickly calmed down when he heard your humming from outside and something cluttering in the kitchen. He got dressed and quietly joined you.
âHeyâ you greeted him with a smile and he thought that maybe he likes this even more than the band t-shirt. You were still a little sleep mussed but you clearly had a shower, flowery smell lingering on you now. Hair now let down, wearing nothing but an oversized shirt and panties, making breakfast. He could get used to this, he thinks, immediately followed by the thought that maybe he should pace himself. Maybe it was just sex. You didnât seem like that but he has been wrong before.
âHi.â
âYour timing is great, Iâm almost ready with breakfast.â
âHm, that sounds amazing but I have to go. Robin is probably freaking out already and I promised weâd go out for lunch today, which Iâm also kind of already late for.â
âWell, Iâm sad now, but I understand. Do you want a cup of coffee at least?'
âYeah, coffee would be greatâ he says with a smile.
You made him coffee, you put your feet in his lap at the table, you caressed his cheeks, you whispered so, last night was fun, in a cheeky, flirty tone. And he knew he wanted more of this, more of you. So, he asked for a pen and paper, jotted his number down and said you should do it again, you still owe him a beer after all. You gave him your number as well, just in case.
âSteve H., huh? I donât get a full last name?â
âCall me and maybe Iâll tell you.â
He left and he called you that same day. Robin was elated when she found out her best friend âfucking finally got laidâ. Which he took some offence to. He just wanted you to know that he meant it, that he wanted to see you again, and he was really really close to thanking you but he controlled himself.
That was three years ago now and he still had days when he woke up and couldn't believe how lucky he was. You fit into his life so perfectly. The kids loved you, everyone loved you, it was easy. You kept your apartment in the city but moved in with him not too long after that first time. You wanted to be close, all the time and it made his heart sore because he didnât have to feel shame for being clingy, you were just the same.
Thatâs also how Sundays became a time for what you called family dinners. Sometimes your friends, sometimes his, sometimes both, always some good food, some chaos and a lot of life.
The first time you suggested was before the anniversary of Jonathanâs death. You made an unbearable day almost nice and he felt like he never could thank you for that.
âH, huh? I donât even get a full last name?â He asked as he came up behind you in the kitchen.
âHmm, help get these out and Iâll think about it.â
âYou drive a hard bargain. Youâre lucky, youâre pretty.â
âAlright lover boy, you can show me later, how about that?â
âCanât wait.â
The conversation was lively, everyone talking over each other in the living room that was a little too small for that many people but no one ever cared about that.
âHey, I meant to ask,â Robin started âhave you heard that Mr. Reynolds is retiring?â
âThe old basketball coach?â Lucas inquired, looking for an answer you were as well.
âUh-huh. Says his knees are giving out.â Nancy chimed in.
âYeah, so now theyâre looking for a new one to coach for the team.â
âHuh, wonder whoâll take over.â
Max and Dustin rolled their eyes, the latter murmured something that sounded like I swear to god, which was surprisingly mild for him.
âCoach Harrington has a nice ring to it.â Will chimed in.
You smiled down into your glass. âIt doesâ You offered while squeezing his thigh under the table.
âHe would have to get back into shape first.â Dustin quipped and you knew heâd hit a nerve. You had to buy a new shirt for him last week, a size up, and it was already messing with his head.
âHey! What is that supposed to mean?!â Steve exclaimed.
âIâm just saying, youâre not exactly in athlete shape, no shame in that!â
âI think you look great.â El said quietly and Mike frowned.
âAlright children, everyone settle down!â you geared into mom-mode, which was required sometimes. âHow about everyone shutting up and I bring out some dessert?'
You gave Steveâs shoulder a little squeeze before leaving for the kitchen.
***
The kids left later and you had to admit, it was nice to just have the two of you. But you can see that Steveâs still upset. You can see that heâs in his head, he barely said a word, his touches, kisses being on autopilot. You were doing the dishes, you washing, him drying, a domestic, familiar routine.
âAre you just not going to talk to me anymore?â
âHm?â
âCome on, I can tell youâre still upset about what Dustin said, baby.â
âWha- Of course Iâm upset about it! I used to be the top athlete and now Iâm turning into-â
âStop that! Right now!â You raise your pointer finger in warning. âFirst of all, weâre not in high school anymore. Iâm not in love with you because youâre captain of the football team.â
âBasketball and swim team actually.â He corrected you quietly with a somewhat guilty look on his face.
âI knowâ you glare at him with a deadpan look. âI was trying to make a point about how much I donât care. I donât love you because of how many pushups you can do or homeruns you hitâ he knows that at this point youâre doing it on purpose but he still winces a little. âI love you because youâre kind and you take care of the people you love.â You take a step closer to him. Heâs still staring at the counter, arms crossed in front of his chest. âSecond of all, it's happy-weight.â you smirk at him.
âWhat?â
âHappy-weight. People who are happy and feel safe in their relationships, tend to put on some weight.â
âReally?â He canât help but smile at that a little.
âReally. I gained a couple of pounds too since weâve been together.â
âNo, you didnâtâ he seems sincere enough but you still have your suspicions that maybe heâs just saying it in case itâs a trap.
âI absolutely did! I havenât been able to go out for dinner without having to unbutton my jeans at the end in months.â He finally chuckles at that. âHave you noticed?â
âThis feels like a trapâ You snort out a laugh.
âItâs not a trap, I absolutely did! Do you care?â
âOf course I donât! I havenât even noticed, I swear!â
âWell, then there you go! Then why do you think I would care?â
He shrugs.
âAnd thirdâ you take another step, bigger this time, reaching out for his jaw, lifting his head so you can look him in the eyes. âI like you softerâ you say quietly and he swears he melts under your touch and gaze. âSofter means no more getting beat upâ you say as you trace his forehead, watching as his eyes close for a second. âSofter means no more running away from creatures from another dimension that want to kill you.â
âNo more trying to save someoneâs life because they were stupid enough to risk it so they can save usâ he says.
A pang of hurt goes straight to your heart. You know he still feels guilty about that sometimes.
âSteve Harrington, I would risk my life for you any day of the week, but yes, no more of that either. I will love you with a little tummy because we eat so much good food, and I will love you with wrinkles in the corner of your eyes because we laugh so much and I will love when you start to have gray hairs because you worry about me all the time. Itâs just life, and itâs good.â
Steveâs eyes start to well up and he doesnât know what to say. He probably couldnât say anything at this point, because holy shit, how on earth did he get so lucky? So, he doesnât say anything, he just starts kissing you all over your face, and then your lips and continues down you jawline and neck and hopes to god you canât feel the rogue teardrops that manage to escape. You do, but you donât say anything. You canât say it out loud but you can feel it. You can feel the weight of being loved so much, so openly, because itâs the exact same way you feel, when you notice that every time you catch his eyes on the other side of the room, heâs already staring at you.
Itâs been a long road and it hasnât always been easy. You both had to peel back so many layers of hurt, of pain, of fear and in the beginning you both had your own attempts to run.
But heâs so glad that neither of you were successful because this was the best thing he ever had. And he finally believed that heâs good enough for it. Basketball coach or not.


















