In the Changing Light
Author: dknc3
Ship: Ned/Catelyn
Trigger Warnings: none
Brief summary: Modern AU Ned Stark escapes his fatherâs big corporate party to stand outside and watch the sunset, but on this particular evening it seems that the sky is not the only thing on the cusp of dramatic change.
Ned Stark could still hear the music clearly from where he stood well outside the clubhouse. He didnât mind. The jazz band his father had hired to play tonight was excellent even if Brandon had objected. Heâd protested that since the party was for him, he should get to select the music. Rickard Stark had merely glared at his eldest son and informed him that the party was for the principal shareholders of Stark Capital Holdings, and as the President and CEO of Stark Capital, the music selection was his to make. The announcement of Brandonâs appointment to CFO was only one item on the eveningâs celebratory agenda.
Ned had been tempted to laugh at his brotherâs expression then. Leave it to Brandon to make everything about him. Brandon had been working his tail off for the company for the past three years, and he deserved this promotion. He truly did, and Ned didnât begrudge it. But he didnât enjoy the inevitable swelling of Brandonâs already overlarge ego that came with it.
Ned leaned back against the broad trunk of an enormous oak and looked westward past the eighteenth fairway to where the sun hung low over the fields adjacent to the exclusive country club. Heâd always liked this view best of all of those from the clubhouse. In all other directions you could see exquisitely manicured fairways and greens, the tennis courts, or the pool. Only on this side did the land remain flat enough to see far beyond the clubâs borders, and he found he preferred the wildness of those largely untouched fields with scattered trees in random places and an abundance of wild bushes and mismatched grasses of varying lengths.
The band was playing a very lively tune now, and he knew that even more people had likely risen to dance. Thatâs what had driven him out here. He enjoyed the music, but he was a terrible dancer, and it was even more difficult to hide that fact when attempting to dance to jazz tunes than to the typical pop stuff a DJ would play. Rather than be rude to anyone who asked him to dance or make himself miserable by actually attempting it, he decided to come out and enjoy the sunset. It was a nice evening, after all.
âWant some company?â
Startled, he turned to see Catelyn Tully standing behind him. As always, his heart took a small jump when he saw her. He wished that were not the case, but heâd given up thinking he could stop it. âWhereâs Brandon?â he asked in response, intentionally invoking his brotherâs name for both their sakes.
The smile that had played about her mouth faded then. âInside. Dancing with the girl from public relations. You know the one. Long, black hair. Long, tan legs.â
Ned nodded. He knew her all right. He knew Brandon had spent every night of the convention theyâd all attended two years ago in Miami in that particular womanâs bed, too. His brother swore it had been a one-time affairâa company fling which both he and the lovely Ms. Dayne had put behind them, but Ned thought he still had a hell of a nerve to dance with her now. Particularly with Catelyn right here.
âOh, cheer up, Ned,â she said when he remained silent and went back to gazing toward the western horizon. She walked over to him and bumped against his arm with her shoulder. âIâm not letting your brother get to me tonight. So you donât, either. I donât need protecting or defending me so you are off duty, Mr. Stark.â
She moved slightly away so that their arms no longer touched and leaned back against the enormous tree herself, sighing as she turned to look westward as well.
âWhy are you out here, Cat?â he asked after a moment.â
âWhy are you out here?â she challenged him.
He turned to face her then and gave her an exasperated look. âYou know perfectly well why Iâm out here,â he said.
She laughed. âAre you really hiding behind this tree simply because you donât like to dance?â
He frowned. âIt isnât a matter of likes or dislikes, really. Itâs a matter of ability.â He smiled ruefully. âOr lack thereof.â
She laughed again. A musical sound. One of his favorite sounds. âYou really are terrible,â she agreed.
âThanks,â he said dryly.
âHey, Iâm just agreeing with you. But I think you have improved a bit in the years since Iâve met you.â
âYou think so, huh?â
âI do,â she said very seriously, but Ned could see mischief in the blue eyes. âThe last time you danced with meâwhen Brandon abandoned me forever to play poker with Robert Baratheon at that club, remember? And you took pity on me?âanyway, when you danced with me then, you only stepped on my toes once that I recall, and I didnât even have bruises the next day!â
She grinned at him, and he couldnât help grinning back. Cat did that to him. She always had, and heâd never figured out how to make it stop. On his best days, he was simply happy that he knew her. That she would be forever present at least on the periphery of his life. On his worst days, he cursed God for having allowed Brandon to meet her first, forever damning Ned to the role of brother in the life of the one woman whose company he enjoyed more every time he shared it. Two and a half years now, he had known Catelyn Tullyâfirst as his brotherâs girlfriend, and for the last year as his fiancĂŠe. Two and a half years, heâd known her, and if he were honest with himself, heâd loved her nearly all that time.
âYou think youâre funny, donât you?â he asked her.
âA little,â she said. She swallowed, and looked back to where the sun had almost disappeared now. âNot very,â she said softly.
âCat?â he asked, concerned about her. âWhy did you come out here?â
âTo find you,â she said without hesitating. She kept her eyes focused on the horizon as she continued. âThatâs what I do when Iâm troubled, Ned. I find you. Havenât you noticed?â
Heâd noticed. He wasnât officially her brother yet. She and Brandon hadnât even set a wedding date, but she came to him as she would a brother. When she needed cheering up. When she was frightened. Hell, sheâd even called him when sheâd driven her car off the road in a snowstorm and couldnât get it unstuck  Brandon wouldnât pick up his phone that day, but heâd gone to get her, of course. Together, theyâd managed to get her car back on the road, laughing at the situation and each other, both covered in snow. Then sheâd insisted on buying him coffee to thank him. That had been last winter. He still had the fucking Starbuckâs cup on which sheâd had the barista write the title âMy Heroâ in place of his name. Iâm an idiot, he thought. A fucking, pathetic idiot.
âI will take your silence to mean that you have noticed,â she said, and he realized heâd been silent too long, lost in the memory of snowflakes in fiery hair and laughing blue eyes and a clear voice calling out proudly, âHeâs right here with me!â when that barista had held up the cup, rolled her eyes, and announced, âMy hero.â
âYou said Brandon hadnât upset you tonight,â he said carefully. He found himself saying Brandonâs name a lot when he was with Catelyn. He needed to remember it, and sometimes he thought that she did, too. Sometimes, he could almost convince himself that the smiles she gave him were not sisterly at all.
âBrandon hasnât done anything to upset me,â she said. âHeâs simply being Brandon. And Iâve decided that Iâm not going to allow that to upset me anymore. Iâve done that for far too long. It isnât fair to make him responsible for my happiness, Ned. I need to be responsible for that myself.â Sheâd turned to look at him as she told him that, but now she looked back at the sky. âWow,â she said softly. âWould you look at that?â
He turned to see that the sun had disappeared but the sky was lit up in a blaze of color just above the fields. Pinks and purples and a thin band of bright red that called to mind the hair of the woman beside him. âBeautiful,â he whispered, turning back to look at her.
She turned to look at him, and he had the feeling she knew damn well he hadnât been referring to the sunset. âIâm not marrying Brandon,â she said suddenly.
âYouâre not ⌠what?â He looked at her, frowning at the words that didnât make quite make sense. Of course she would marry Brandon. Everyone knew it. They were a beautiful pair and complimented each other in any number of ways. Everyone could see it. Of course, Ned saw more than most. He knew how often Catelyn was unhappy. But he had no right to ⌠âWhy?â he finally asked when she simply stood there looking at him.
âYou know why,â she said evenly, never taking her eyes from his, and he began shaking his head slowly back and forth.
âNo. Cat ⌠no. I never âŚâ
âI donât mean because of you, Ned. This isnât your fault.â
At once, he felt both relieved and somehow disappointed. And the disappointment made him feel guilty.
âI donât love him,â she said flatly. âHow can I marry someone I donât love?â
âBut you ⌠Catelyn, youâve always loved Brandon,â he said. âOf course, you love him.â
âNo,â she said slowly. âIâve loved many things about him. And there have been many wonderful times when Iâve loved being his girl. But Iâm honestly not sure I ever loved him. And if I did, I know I donât anymore.â
âI ⌠I donât know what to say.â
She gave a little breathy laugh. It sounded unsure and almost frightened, but somehow relieved as well. âWell ⌠now that Iâve told you ⌠can we still be friends?â she asked, and she bit her lip. âI donât want to lose you, Ned.â
âYou canât lose me, Catelyn. I promise. But are you certain this is what you want?â
She sighed. âWhat I want? I donât know what I want, Ned. Not really. But I know what I donât want. I donât want to marry a man who will never be faithful to me. And donât you dare protest! I know heâs been better since we got engaged. He doesnât go out with girls around here anymore at least. But you and I both know that heâll be traveling even more with this promotion than the two of you travel already. You know him, Ned. You and I probably know him better than anyone else in the world does. And when heâs in some hotel, far away from me, and some pretty girl smiles at him and invites him to her room ⌠he isnât going to say no. And you know that as well as I do.â
Her voice trembled slightly, but her eyes were dry. He wanted to defend his brother, but dammit, he wouldnât lie to her. He couldnât lie to Cat. She was right, and he did know it. âIt isnât because he doesnât love you,â he said instead, and she laughedâa weary, bitter note souring the music of that laugh.
âOh, I know,â she said. âDo you think I havenât heard it? I love you, Cat. No one else means anything to me. It was only sex. I promise she meant nothing. Youâre the only one I want.â She sighed deeply. âIt doesnât even hurt me anymore to hear him say that, Ned. Thatâs one reason I know I donât love him anymore.â
Ned stared at her. Heâd heard nearly those exact same words from Brandon over the past two years, every time theyâd fought over his brothers infidelities to the woman he claimed to love. Heâd had no idea Brandon had attempted to justify his behavior to her with those same meaningless phrases, and he found himself wanting very much to hit his brother in the face.
âQuit clenching your fist. I donât want you to hit him.â
Ned flinched at her words and uncoiled the fingers he hadnât realized heâd curled so tightly. âI wonât hit him,â he muttered. âBut I should. That he would say such stupid things to you âŚâ
âIt isnât only that, Ned,â she said quickly. âNo, I donât think I could be married to a man who is perpetually unfaithful, but even if he could changeâeven if he never looked at another womanâI just donât feel for him what I should, Ned. And if I marry him without loving him wholeheartedly, without knowing that I want him forever, thatâs being as unfair to him as heâs ever been to me.â
Ned nodded. âYouâre right. And Iâve never known you to be unfair. But, Catelyn. Are you certain? Do you intend to tell Brandon this now?â
She bit her lip again and walked away from the tree so that her slim form was silhouetted against the western sky that had lost its fire, but still glowed a soft purple-pink. âNot tonight,â she whispered. âItâs his big triumph tonight, and I canât ⌠I canât ruin it. But, I canât ⌠I canât go home with him, either, Ned.â She turned around and looked at him. âNow that Iâve come to this decision, I canât ⌠I wouldnât feel right about âŚâ
Sleeping with him. She wouldnât feel right about sleeping with him. That was what she couldnât say. âI understand,â he said. âDo you want me to take you home?â
âIâm going to tell him tomorrow,â she said. âI owe him that. I canât have you knowing and him not for days and days. That isnât right. I intend to tell him Iâm not feeling well, but that he should stay and enjoy his night. When I tell him tomorrow that weâre over, heâll know thatâs why I left early. If you take me home, heâll likely be angry at you as well.â
She was right, of course. Brandon would be furious. He did care about Catelyn. Loved her even, in his own way. Even more, he didnât like losing, and he would see this as losing something heâd thought was his. It would bring out both his possessive streak and his temper, neither of which were the most attractive aspects of Brandonâs personality.
He didnât forgive easily, either. For a man who so blithely asked for forgiveness, he was terribly slow to give it. âIf you do this, Cat,â Ned said slowly, walking over to join her, âYou will not be able to take it back. Even if you reconciled, Brandon would âŚâ
âHold it over my head every time I got upset with something he did. I know. But we wonât be reconciling, Ned. Iâve known I needed to do this for some time. I just had to find the courage.â She gave him a small smile. âAnd I needed to talk to the person I trust most.â
Ned wondered how much sheâd trust him if she knew how badly he wanted to hold her in his arms, kiss her breathless, and tell her that everything would be fine. That he would make it fine. But that wasnât what she needed now. And he didnât date his brotherâs exes. There simply wasnât a way to make that a good situation. Not with Brandon being who he was. But he wasnât going to let her do this alone.
âIâll take you home,â he said firmly. âI donât want you to be alone right now. Youâre shaking.â
âI am not.â
He reached out and took her hands in his. âYou are,â he said. âI can feel it. Donât be afraid, Catelyn. This wonât be easy. But you are right. You shouldnât marry a man you donât love. Brandon will understand that in time.â
âMaybe,â she said doubtfully. âBut I canât control whether or not he understands.â She then surprised Ned by leaning forward until their foreheads touched. âIâm just glad you do,â she whispered. âI was terrified of losing you, Ned.â
His heart raced. He thought about moving away from her. Thatâs what he should do. He wanted to grab her to him and never let him go. He wanted to hear her say that again. I was terrified of losing you, Ned. He wanted to believe what heâd heard in her voice when sheâd said it.
Unable to do anything else, he just stood there, head tilted down to keep his forehead against hers. âThat will never happen,â he whispered finally. âYou will never lose me.â
She took a deep breath and straightened up. âWhoâs shaking now?â she asked him with an attempt at a smile.
He did pull his hands away from her then. âCat ⌠I would never âŚâ
âYou would never hurt me,â she finished for him. âWhatever else I know or donât know, I do know that.â She hesitated. âI ⌠I think you know that I care about you, Ned. Probably more than I should. Iâm not asking you for anything, and Iâm not ⌠Iâm not ready to ⌠I have to deal with this thing between Brandon and me. I canât let myself think about anything else. Whatever I feel. And I know you understand that.â She smiled up at him, and for the first time her eyes did tear up. âBecause youâre my hero, remember? I had it put in writing.â
âIâm a sorry excuse for a hero. Havenât even got a cape.â It was a poor attempt at a joke, but she tried to smile at him anyway. âWhatever else I am, though, I am your friend, Catelyn Tully, and that will never change. I promise.â
She nodded. âI need to go in and tell Brandon Iâm leaving,â she said. âAre you certain your father wonât mind your leaving early?â
âMy father wonât even notice Iâm gone. All the official wining and dining is over. Itâs pretty much down to the dancing, and everyone is used to my disappearing for that.â
âAll right. I would like a bit of company, I think. Maybe coffee before you drop me at my apartment. I really donât think I should ask you to come up and sit with me at home given the circumstances.â
âNo,â Ned agreed quickly. âBut if you find yourself getting anxious about tomorrow, you can always call me.â
âWhat did I do before I met you, Ned Stark?â she asked him, and he watched tears threaten her eyes again. It wouldnât do to have her crying when she went in to make her excuses to Brandon. His brother could be self-absorbed and insensitive, but he wasnât blind.
âYou had fewer bruised toes,â he said glibly. He grabbed one of her hands and raised her arm high, making her spin in front of him. âThere,â he said with a grin, when she was facing him again. âIâve danced tonight.â
âYou didnât even move,â she laughed.
âExactly,â he said with satisfaction. âIâve discovered how to dance with you without stepping on your feet. I simply donât step at all.â
She laughed harder, throwing her head back. âNed, look!â she said, suddenly pointing upward.
The last vestiges of color had not quite disappeared from the far western sky, but above them the sky was dark enough that the stars had begun to appear.
âIâve never danced beneath the stars before,â he said with a smile. âOne more dance before we go, Cat?â
âMy pleasure,â she said, giving him her hand once more. This time, knowing what he was about, she spun around several times when he raised her arm and staggered a couple steps dizzily when she stopped.
âPerfect,â she said, almost giggling. âNow Brandon will think Iâve had too much to drink which will explain why I donât feel well and why you feel compelled to drive me home.â
âDo you want me to come in and talk to him with you?â he asked her.
She shook her head. âI think I want to do all of this on my own. Including telling Brandon goodbye for the last time when he doesnât hate me.â She bit her lip hard, but then squared her shoulders and walked toward the clubhouse. She turned back after a few steps. âThank you, Ned. For everything.â
âYouâre welcome, Cat. For everything.â
He watched her walk all the way back to the clubhouse before turning his face back to the western sky. It was as dark as the rest of the sky now, but all of it was lit by a thousand points of light. It looked entirely different than it had when heâd first come outside. Everything looked different now, and he feared there was a lot of dark ahead. But as he looked up at the stars, he was hopeful that he and Catelyn could both find the light in the darkness. He even allowed himself the tiniest bit of hope that they might someday find that light together.











