i know i talk about how much i hate the dub a lot, like i know thatās kinda my thing, i know youāre all sick of it, but would you believe there are actually like, few things on my list the dub does that actually make me downright upset? for the most part my relationship with it is like, me regarding an annoying co worker iād rather avoid.
but this one thing, this tiny detail, it has such BIG ripples on my autistic heart, and iāve been stewing in rage over it for a while.
guys, i really love the fortune hunters. that episode where james pranced around in a fursuit for the entire second half? that ha ha funny joke episode? i love it. it means a lot to me.Ā
james is one of my favourite characters, heās been my biggest comfort character for almost two decades now. for most of my life. and heās a dude who is timid and cowardly and runs from most of his problems, with occasional bouts of bravery. even at his bravest, itās easy to overlook his more bold traits next to his partners, who are far more volatile in their boldness. iām not saying heās nothing but a doormat, but he is the more peaceful pure heart of the TRio, rivaled in his calm waters only by wobbuffet.
fortune hunters was a big deal because james just did that. on his own. it was all him. someone put the right thought in his head--that he was a glorious flame of a person who was destined to take charge, to thrive, to never back down--and it was all he needed to become that. he wasted no time at all embracing his best self, wasted no time at all transforming into what heād been lead to believe he was. all because a little horoscope told him he was more than he ever could have known. it took a single shred of positive reinforcement and james became legendary.
predictably, i am emotional about this. about what he could have been if he were not a boy from an abusive family, beat down and beat down and beat down again.Ā
some background for dub watchers: gen 1 pokemon have pretty funny names in japanese. most of them are just english words, in the same way my sister named her catĀ ānekoā cause it sounded cool to an american teenager. krabby is... crab. drowzee is... sleep. sandshrew is... sand. haunter is... ghost. legendaries arenāt exempt, and in japanese, moltres is simply calledĀ āfire.ā in the original episode, kojirou runs around calling himselfĀ āfire kojirouā and screamingĀ āFIRE!ā at the top of his lungs like a pokemon would. itās adorable, yes.
so what iām getting at here, is... this episode from sun and moon, sm063, it takes place some time later. 845 episodes later, in fact. when presented the opportunity to don a disguise in front of half the alola region, james chooses to invoke that image again. he still hasnāt forgotten about it. he still carries moltres within him, even after he was told that wasnāt who he is, and to me that speaks volumes just... about him as a person, as a character, about the way his mind works.
is it probably just a cute callback? yeah. but iām the queen of interpreting things as far deeper than theyāre meant to go, and authorial intent is fake anyways.
i feel like every bolt of courage and every moment of leadership is james invoking moltres, and as such thatās why i feel like he chose it for the role of an MC--bright and charismatic and someone who draws all eyes and hypes up the crowd. and his team went along with it, cause hey, why not?
anyways, that brings me back to the dub. either theyāre dense as hell and didnāt realize thatĀ āfireā was moltres (and thatĀ āthunderā was zapdos, and thatĀ āfreezerā was articuno... doubtful) or they just didnāt think the callback was worth making. in the dub, james literally just calls himselfĀ āfire jamesā rather than what the english equivalent would have been--james, the mighty moltres.
it hurts, cause unless dub watchers... really pay attention, really read into it, a lot of them might not ever know--that heās held onto that flame for this long, that itās still a part of him. and i think that takes away so much. itās such a small thing, but man, if i were a dub watcher, iād be so angry to find out this was hidden from me, idk.Ā
sm has, historically, been a season of given attention where previously it seemed rather forgotten. this especially applies to team rocket. maybe iām reading too much into it, yeah. but i canāt help but think itās just a shame that the real weight of this simple disguise was never localized properly.