Thinking of Alastor x Reader but make it Doomed Yaoi
Male Reader who grows closer to Alastor because you both have so many similar tastes, similarities, shared interests. You don't really "do" relationships, essentially celibate, functionally aroace like he is. The two of you start spending more time together, discussing all sorts of things like the goings on in Hell, to music, to even deeper political and intellectual discussions
You become someone whom, maybe Alastor actually cares about your opinion a little bit. You actually DO become this charming young gentleman he considers a friend
... which makes it so much harder... when you start having feelings for him, feelings you've never had for anyone, at least not in a long long long time, feelings that were buried under mountains of sadness and broken trust
So not only are you struggling with the genuine mental anguish of just being SO SO SOOOO positive that Alastor, as this strapping, so self determined, so independent VERY asexual sex-repulsed man, would surely be so repulsed by YOU if he knew your feelings had changed, but ALSO you don't even really KNOW how to navigate a romantic or sexual relationship AT ALL so not only are you terrified of revealing your feelings but you have basically NO experience so you're fucked TWICE. You're like basically an adult virgin who's protected your heart inside of a shell and you're scared of letting anyone in. You feel like you've BETRAYED him by falling in love with him. You feel like you've ruined your friendship and you don't want to lose it. You don't want to be alone. But also... you don't want to lose him... but suddenly you're disgusted by yourself. Why can't you be like him and just... not feel these things? You feel disgusted. You feel weak. And also like.... hello internalized homophobia as you realize of course he'll ALSO never return your feelings because you're both men. Maybe there's an... old old old wound inside of you that gets RIPPED OPEN where you remember like being back in school and liking an older boy and when he and his friends found out they beat the shit out of you and called you slurs and shit. Like you are scaling the entire Doomed YaoI Pyramid of Childhood Abuse > Isolated in School > Internalized Homophobia > Amazing Man Thaws Your Frozen Heart > Oh No he Must Never Find Out About My Feelings > I Will Literally Fucking Kill Myself Before I Lose This Man's Respect Because I Love Love Love Him So Deeply I Will Literally Fucking Hop On A Train And Disappear In The Night So I Can Leave Him With The Good Memories Of Me And Not Tarnish What We Had
Like honey you are fucking YEARNING for this man like something biblical.
Meanwhile Alastor just :) immediately picks up the moment you start acting different :) you start pulling away and putting up distance and he's very up front with waiting until you're alone before appearing from the shadows to........ ask if he's done something to displease you...? Did he offend you somehow? No? Then why are you avoiding him? Oh, you're NOT avoiding him, you say? Then look him in the eyes when you say that. Oh, how odd, you suddenly won't look at his face
Can you imagine if Alastor got tired of you refusing to look at him, part of him just ever so irritated he cant meet your eyes and just, grabbed your chin or used his hand to tilt your face toward him and you just have to almost VIOLENTLY JERK AWAY because your little heart can't take him touching your face like that. Now you're embarrassed to have "freaked out" and you just immediately exit the room.
The next few days pass and Alastor can't find you around the Hotel and he's suddenly very very annoyed and pissy and mean to everyone "for no reason" ;) Alastor who starts actually asking the other Hotel goers, trying to be ever so casual, oh you wouldn't have happened to see 'so and so' have you dear Husker? No? Then what good even ARE you 😡😤
Reader who is a bit of a repressed artist and when Alastor is poking around for clues of where in town he might be able to find you, he finds a little sketchbook and starts flipping through it. It starts off with things like city scenery and different environments, but then it eventually drifts to people, actual detailed scenes, other people at the Hotel. Alastor actually finds a sketch of himself, one with eraser and scratch marks and clearly done over and over trying to get just perfect. And he finds another. And another. And another. And then he can't help but notice all the torn paper in the waste basket. He swears he sees something that looks like a drawing on a shredded piece and, with a little magical knowhow, he's putting everything back together. You erased and tore yourself out of any portrait that had him in it. Alastor finds himself holding a drawing that had been previously torn in half, one side portraying him in such detail and respect, sitting on a bar stool, looking at something across from him with a smile that's all too accurate, his hand on a whiskey, and across from him, the side that had been shredded, was you, looking at him almost peacefully, the full picture clearly the two of you having just a friendly casual conversation, but... an eye trained in the arts can pick up subtle, loving details. The difference in body language, one man sitting tall and confident, the other more withdrawn with his eyes anxiously averted, and between the two of them, hands holding their own drinks, and yet, the shadow cast on the floor below from the overhead lighting almost makes it... look like... your hand is held in his
Like boy you are having FUCKING POETIC GAY YEARNING. Like you are Victorian Era Gay Yearning for this man. You are all about to leave him a handwritten note, "Dearest Alastor, it is with the deepest regret that I can no longer accompany you on this journey together--" like you are gay gay homosexual gay for this man and you "KNOW" that he would "never" like you back and he'd be fucking disgusted by you
Angel being the one to find you because you're so upset and confused and just lonely that you force yourself into a gay bar that's just way too uh, crazy for someone like you. Angel is shocked to see someone so "modest and conservative" as you in a place like this but you're CLEARLY going through something and you've been drinking so the two of you start talking and you with these big boohoo tears in your eyes are just "I'm a big fucking ugly stupid disgusting pervert and I'm 🥺 I'm in love with the Radio Demon"
I dont know what would be juicier from there :) if Vox happened to be spying on you and plays that footage for Alastor just like deadass broadcasts your love confession in an extremely humiliating way, ORRRRR Angel happened to text Husker who just so happened to be with Alastor and before you know it the Radio Demon is strolling into this seedy club to see you having a moment of Heartbroken Repressed Homosexual Drama where you've let a man pull you into his lap and you're having really sloppy inexperienced makeouts and Alastor just so happens to see you the moment this guy is like sucking your soul straight out of your mouth and even biting your neck as his hands start going under your shirt and reaching for your belt--
Cue just like :) sudden shadow tendril very gently but QUICKLY racing forward to :) politely gently sweetly scoop you up and move you like maybe 5 or 10 feet back and just BAM another tendril is wrapped so tightly around this guy he's about to be fucking popped like a zit. Alastor's walking up saying in detail how horribly he's going to torture like TORTURE this guy meanwhile you're just like incredibly ashamed and embarrassed and your entire face is covered in tears because oh wow now he knows you like men and it isn't even in a confession to him, he must think you're so disgusting now, he must think you're some kind of slut, how could you ever let another man that wasn't him touch you and--
and all he's concerned about is making sure you haven't been hurt, laughing off and basically ignoring how he just found you with a man's tongue down your throat to say something about how late it's getting and that the two of you should be getting back to the Hotel, and you've been drinking a little bit so you're a little heavy on your feet, but that's okay :) you can :) take his arm and lean on him :) let him walk you back to the Hotel :) and your fragile little heart just melts because you're telling yourself you might as well enjoy this touch while it lasts because surely everything between you and him is different for the worse now. And yet... Alastor doesn't seem to be acting that way. He starts chatting with you the same as usual, even seeming oddly chipper (because maybe just maybe he's happy to be talking to you again)
Alastor escorts you all the way back to the Hotel... and also up the stairs... and also to your room... and also maybe just maybe starts undressing you into your pajamas. Gets some cotton and peroxide for those chomp marks on you "because there's no telling where that disgusting cretin has been and it would be terribly regrettable if you were to get some sort of infection" (for those bite marks that MAYBE :) you asked for because in your moment of heartbreak and lust you noticed that douche had sharp teeth just like Alastor's and you maybe just maaaaaaybe had been pretending it was the Radio Demon biting and licking all over your jaw and neck and collarbones)
You're laying down tipsy and cozy and warm and he's literally helping tuck you in and in your head you're still like "oh my god it's over" *Alastor fluffs the pillows before you lie down* "oh my god surely he thinks I'm disgusting" *Alastor pulls the thick comforter up your body* "oh my god he's never going to look at me the same way again" *Alastor dabs sweat/dirt off your face with a wet washcloth* "oh my god I fucking ruined everything he's going to hate me forever" *Alastor hands you some chamomile lemongrass tea* "oh my god it's over it's over im worthless" *Alastor summons a recliner and opens a book to read by candlelight as he dims the lighting so you can sleep, very clearly obviously remaining by your side*
and you're slowly falling asleep but you're still drunk and emotional and you say something like "I'm so sorry... I promise I'll leave the Hotel... I won't-I won't get in your way or--" and Alastor just takes your hand, holds it in his own. He's quiet but he rubs his thumb over your skin. He reaches up and wipes a tear off your face. It's ..... it's basically his way of saying he cares for you, but he's never voiced those sorts of feelings before, so--
You both realize you're the same. And you care for each other. And maybe right now it's complicated to put some sort of label on what your relationship is, but... neither of you want to be apart. More specifically, Alastor is absolutely genuinely 100% positive that watching that brute put his disgusting hands all over you is something he never wants to happen again. He wants to have you and he wants no one else to have you. In fact now that he sits and thinks about it, he's suddenly realizing that he was ALWAYS feeling a little possessive of you, scanning the room while the pair of you are out together, watching his friends ever so closely as he introduces them and grinding his teeth when someone drunkenly flirted with you
Well. Perhaps it's Alastor's job to take the reins since he IS the oldest... he'll have to do some... research into the more.... physically intimate manner of things, but... surely it wouldn't be too soon for him to start referring to you as his fiance would it? :) his adorable little easily flustered future husband? :) Alastor has enough confidence and determination to spare, so... he'll just have to start making some of these decisions on your behalf! After all, he already knows what size suit you'll need, what your favorite foods are, what music you like, the relative average of how many breaths you'll take in an hour sleeping beside him and how often your heart beats in the depths of slumber as he stares at you unblinking in the dark, you know, just little itty bitty teeny details--