Silver Keys - Ch. 6
JJ Maybank x OC x Topper Thorton Soulmate AU
warnings: none :) Lmk if there are ever any
notes: I can't even apologize for the lack of updates, this is what we're rolling with lately. comments and reblogs are encouraged and appreciated!!!
silver keys masterlist
JJ never realizes how much of a mess everything is until June is gone for more than a day. Without her, Kie gets too annoyed at the rest of them (mainly John B and him) and there’s no one to settle the arguments between the four pogues. It’s like something shifts with the universe. And that is why the last two days have been a mess.
June left for her recital Thursday night all set to perform on Friday. There were two rounds of competition, from what JJ understood. The main event is on Friday and the second round is on Saturday. So it was up in the air when she would be back.
As for the rest of them, John B said some stupid shit to Kie and she stormed off. She texted in the group later only to say she wasn’t coming to the boneyard for the party Saturday night.
Which left John B, JJ, and Pope to their own devices. Which went pretty much just how JJ expected it to: he was high and slightly tipsy and JB was doing that weird thing where he pretends he hasn’t drunk that much but is totally gone. Pope was probably hating his life, wishing he hadn’t pulled the shortest straw (or in their case the shortest pasta noodle) and gotten stuck as DD. JJ did feel slightly bad about that, but no one wanted him to drive anyway.
Now, it was about halfway through the party and JJ couldn’t find any of his friends let alone people he liked enough to talk to. He had quit beer pong when a member of the opposing team threw up on her shoes. Pretty much the whole scene shut down after that. He noticed a few groups sectioned off in foldout chairs, some around various bonfires.
JJ wasn’t sure how much time had passed after that. Probably enough that Pope was ready to go home. So, he stumbled his way through the small circles of people, laughing and dancing in a gentle sort of way. It was almost melodic, the way everyone navigated through the sand. JJ had stopped when he saw Topper and Kelce leaning against a tree arguing.
It was more than obvious that JJ didn’t like Topper. He was a rich, stuck-up kook. He didn’t give a shit about anyone else and JJ didn’t understand how June had been with him for so long and it was frustrating that he couldn’t give her better. But she was happy, the happiest he had seen her in a while. He could be civil with Topper, hell he’d even be nice because JJ would do anything to make sure June was happy.
“You don’t think this has gone a little too far?” JJ heard Kelce say.
“No, dude. And what’s the harm anyway? It’s not like June is ever going to know I’m not her real soulmate. She believes me.” topper replied.
JJ felt his stomach drop. It took him a few seconds to process what he was hearing, but when he did the rage took over his body instantly.
“Well, I don’t know. She very obviously has a soulmate. Real songs are getting stuck in her head. You’re just lying and saying that they’re yours.”
“I’m not lying!” Topper yelled, his voice getting harsher the closer he got to Kelce, “I don’t have one, okay? I don’t fucking hear anything. And it’s not fair. So why can’t I just pick someone?”
Without a second thought, JJ rushed forward, slamming topper to the ground.
“What the hell did you just say?” He yells, looking down at Topper. He didn’t care if he was causing a scene, he didn’t care about anything. He could only picture June’s face when she inevitably found out and that was enough to make his blood boil.
“This is none of your business, pogue.”
Topper pulled himself up from the sand and swung at him, catching JJ’s cheek. He couldn’t help himself, he launched himself at Topper. He punched his nose, fast and hard. He looks down at his own hands, already bruising and covered in someone else’s blood.
“Tell her.” he spits at him “or I fucking will.” He kicks at the sand and turns away. JJ isn’t sure why he’s letting him off like this. Maybe, in the long run, this will hurt less for June.
June. That’s all that matters. Not topper and not some stupid soulmate. And if not kicking Topper’s teeth in and letting him save face will help her then that’s what he’ll do.
He took a deep breath and knocked on her window. He wasn’t sure what he was going to say, he wasn’t sure if he was going to say anything. If she asked why he was there, he wouldn’t have an answer.
JJ heard some rustling and moments later was met with June opening the window and pulling him inside.
“J, what the hell? You scared me.”
“S-sorry, I didn’t mean to.” She looked tired but happy and his heart hurt a little.
“You could’ve come to the front door. My parents would have let you in.”
“I just. I couldn’t-” He didn’t know what to say. He could hear Topper’s confession ringing in his ears.
June grabbed his chin and turned his head to look at her, “God, what happened to your face? Please tell m-”
“It’s nothing, I just. I have to lay low for a little, okay?”
“Are you-” she pressed.
“June, please”
“Okay, but you have to tell me what happened.”
He hesitated, “It was some kook okay? It’s over, done-zo”
“who” He hesitated again. She searched his eyes and it took everything in him not to tell her. He tried to get her to stop.
“You didn’t catch his name? Ya know before he gave you a black eye”
“We didn’t swap phone numbers, fuck, June”
“You don’t just punch people for no reason JJ. You can’t just”
“June” he pleaded
“Okay, fine… I just want to make sure it wasn’t your-”
“It wasn’t. okay?”
“I just wanna make sure you’re okay. Don’t be an asshole about it”
He did feel like an asshole. She was only trying to make sure his dad didn’t show back up at the chateau and he was yelling at her.
“I’m going to get you ice,” June said without looking back.
When she returned she tossed him a frozen bag of peas and told him to ice.
“This isn’t my first black eye, Moto”
“Yeah, yeah, Maybank,” She sighs, “I know.”
“Hey,” he says softly, “I’m fine, I promise. Just a little black eye. You should see the other guy.” He joked.
She didn’t say anything, just looked at him anxiously. When she finally did speak it came out a whisper, “I just worry about you, idiot.”
He nods, “I know, I’m sorry.”
JJ lays back to rest his back against her wall and stretches his legs. June is sitting across from him, leaning against her bed.
“Tell me about the recital, I wanna hear about how you kicked ass.”
“That’s not how it works, J.”
“C’mon,” he pleaded.
She sighed and her face relaxed, “it was really good. Like, the environment and everyone there. I played really well, too. I don’t think I missed a single note.”
“Play it for me,”
“No, no. It’s okay.”
“C’mon JuJu,” he nudged her foot with his.
She sighed again, moving towards her keyboard.
“Don’t look at me.”
“What?” JJ laughed.
“Turn around,” she urged.
“Fine.”
He did as he was told, turning around so that their backs were practically touching. He could hear June crack her knuckles and take a deep breath before beginning to play. He listened as she began softly, telling a story through the music. It sounded familiar, something he’d probably heard her hum before. But there was more to it than that. It was the feeling of waking up from a nightmare and realizing that you were at home, safe in your bed.
“I like when you play,” he was looking at her now, his full attention on the way her hands glided over the keys and her curled up when she was focusing. He noticed the freckles on her nose and her chipped nail polish like he was looking at her for the first time.
She smiled when he said this and JJ felt the familiar comforting feeling June often brings. She played for a few more moments before stopping, her eyes closed, concentrated.
“Keep going,” JJ urged.
“That’s it.” She said with a sad shrug, “my mom used to play it for us when we couldn’t sleep at night. She wrote it in college I guess. But, she never finished it. So… that’s it.”
“Beautiful,” he whispered.
She met his eyes, “yeah it is isn’t it?”
He nodded sincerely, looking from her eyes to her lips, “yeah.”
They stayed like that for a moment, concentrating on only each other. JJ knew he was falling, knew he had been falling for some time now and he was desperate to know if his best friend was falling for him too.










